You NEED to know how Democrats are planning to spend YOUR MONEY | Fix Washington S02 EP09

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
You need to know how Democrats are planning to spend your money.
Rep. Travis Couture, the House Republican budget lead, joins the Fix Washington podcast to break down the new budget proposals from House and Senate Democrats in Olympia.
#fixwashington #waleg #traviscouture #taxes #wahouserepublicans #seattle #olympia
[Music]
fix Washington Now from the state
capital here's Hannah Scott Welcome to
the Fix Washington podcast Thanks so
much for being here 35th District
Representative Travis Couture uh ranking
member on the appropriations committee
Kind of a big week for you Yeah it's uh
it's been a big week but a long week We
had the rollouts of the uh House and
Senate um Democrat budget and tax
proposals the taxes that go along with
the spending in the budget And uh uh
news flash they're both terrible Um
record spending uh massive increases to
taxes that would harm
Washingtonians And so um now we're
fighting back We're fighting back in
committee and then later we'll be
fighting back on the House floor uh with
amendments that make sense for the
people of Washington And we starting
heading into the session we obviously
all knew that there was a budget
shortfall that we were dealing with Can
you talk a little bit about how that
even came to be we had a surplus right
just a few years ago Yeah I mean just a
handful of years ago we had something
like a $15 billion surplus And in just a
handful of years now we're facing a you
know roughly a10 billion deficit And the
majority party has uh invested money we
never had by booking new programs
especially with one-time funds like
COVID relief funds Uh and now all the
bills are coming due and that's a big
piece of our uh budget deficit that we
face this year including a lot of other
budget gimmicks and balance balance
sheet manipulations around revenue
assumptions and all sorts of different
kind of trickery that uh state
government's doing in our state budget
But at the end of the day what's
important to know is that we had a lot
of money and we blew it and now we have
this big deficit and uh we're not in a
recession We're not an emergency Um but
right now we're facing the largest set
of tax increases in state history Uh
taxes on our businesses on working
families on the middle class Things uh
that are devastating like a a 3xing of
property taxes that would absolutely
harm uh almost every Washingtonian in
one way shape or form Um but what's
happening is they're taxing uh they're
they're they're introducing this large
set of tax increases uh
to to cover for their budgeting
negligence They're using taxpayers as a
bailout fund uh for their failures to
properly budget And that's just
absolutely wrong Uh we're in one of the
most unaffordable states to live in
right now here in Washington state the
cost of gas groceries housing rent
energy utilities you name it Uh even
your insurance I mean everything is
skyrocketing here Uh it's it's
incredibly hard to find child care
that's affordable It's almost impossible
actually And uh people want some relief
Um and this is going the opposite
direction when we never had to be here
in the first place Uh and so we're
fighting back against all of those
massive tax increases The state of
Washington Olympia the government needs
to learn how to live within its means Uh
we have an enormous budget with record
historic levels amounts of spending and
revenue Uh we have to make sure that the
dollars that we spend are accountable
and that uh they're actually helping the
people they're supposed to be helping
and doing the things they're supposed to
be doing but we spend billions of
dollars on so many things like housing
and homelessness and it just keeps
getting worse Uh people want results for
the dollars they invest and I know in
we've got differing budget proposals to
some degree between the Senate and the
House which will obviously all have to
be worked out because we'll end up with
just one in the end But uh I think of
both what we hear about is the wealth
tax and I think that's a lot of what
we've seen reported and some of the
messaging about these tax proposals that
they only hit the wealthy Is that is
that the deal is that what's happening
yeah I mean that's what they say is that
the wealth tax is only going to be on
the the richest 4,300
Washingtonians Uh I think the devil's in
the details with that Uh um when you
have a quote unquote a wealth tax like
that well one the the the bill itself
the proposal itself has numerous
problems One it's unconstitutional
because it's technically another
property tax uh because they haven't
actually sold any of the assets stocks
and bonds yet So it's just assets in a
portfolio They don't actually have the
money for it yet And so enable in in
order for them to tax it they tax the
value of those assets on any one given
day And if you don't have um if the
market crashes a year later or a month
later or whatever it could be you don't
get the money back uh as a result of
what you paid in taxes So it it
functionally operates like a property
tax but the state constitution is
absolutely clear that all property taxes
in Washington must be uniform And the
uniformity clause means that what is
good for one person is good for another
That means you can't separate it by
classes by middle class lower class and
and and the wealthy So I think that um
in in anyone's um court that that is
unconstitutional and we would be the
first state in the nation to have done
this um successfully if it was done
successfully And uh uh uh and it just
leads you to think that um this is not a
sustainable way to uh budget because uh
you're relying on revenue that may never
actually come And another problem with
it is our new governor Bob Ferguson has
said he doesn't like this wealth tax
idea Even Mr capital gains tax himself
Nick Hanower a progressive stalwart of
our current capital gains tax uh said
that this was a boneheaded idea when
Governor Eninsley first proposed it Now
progressives here in Olympia have been
pushing for a wealth tax for a long time
because they want progressive revenues
Um but it's a false promise because even
if it passed all of the challenges that
it faces and it is and implemented um if
just five people at the tippy top of the
4,300 taxpayers who are by the way the
most sophisticated taxpayers in our
entire society who have the ability to
move who have the ability to shelter
their funds and hire attorneys and all
sorts of different things that the rest
of us maybe don't have the ability or
the resources to do if just five of them
people like Bill Gates if they move on
or shelter their money somewhere else
the whole tax falls apart um and
conversely if a couple thousand at the
bottom move out uh then it's a problem
And so a lot of people may have heard
the term capital flight Uh and a good
way to point this out is when you saw
Jeff Bezos after our original capital
gains tax was implemented moved all of
his money and and assets and moved to
Florida um to shelter it from that
capital gains tax So now we would not
not just have the capital gains tax we
have now which is um a tax on your
capital income an excise tax of a
certain percentage above a certain
amount when you sell a stock or bond But
now even if you haven't sold the stock
or bond uh whatever the assessed value
is kind of like your property taxes uh
you would have to pay uh that amount and
and so I think it's unconstitutional
It's got a lot of hurdles Uh but right
now our budget is like a house of carts
Um if we don't have the billions of
dollars that they assume that tax will
pull in which I because of the capital
flight I doubt it will actually be as
much as they assume Um the whole budget
falls apart And that is a super super
risky and unsustainable way It's
irresponsible It's reckless Uh nobody in
their family budget would assume a lot
of money off of income they may never
get uh and then base all of their year
spending in their family budget based
upon that It's crazy So and so that
would be the wealthy the wealth tax
affecting the you know the wealthiest
4,000 or some odd people like you
mentioned But then again circling back
to the property tax is I think probably
what perks most Washingtonians ears up
right that's that's not the rich that's
that will impact everybody And again um
you know the the the unrealized capital
gains tax or the wealth tax I mean the
another one of the false promises with
it is that if those folks those wealthy
folks move they're they're moving their
their their large sums of money which is
used for capital investments and it's
used for philanthropy and and so many
other different things Um and if they
move completely out of the state and
move their money well that's less
revenue for the state and in other forms
as well including the properties that
they own and the property tax And so uh
right now people are suffering at home
as it stands with property taxes The
assessments are really high Uh schools
uh you know take a lot of money in local
um property taxes so the fire districts
and everything else And it seems like we
keep paying more and more and more and
more and nothing ever gets solved Uh we
have the 51 out of 50 per capita in the
nation for police Uh you know our fire
districts are struggling with the
resources that they have And our schools
although um we've never funded our
schools at a higher amount in in
Washington state history than we do
right now Three times that of inflation
record historic funding levels We have
the lowest outcomes ever Um but yet
we're asked to pay more and it looks
like on the surface level that our
schools are absolutely broke Yeah Um and
so schools individually school districts
are going into the red And you kind of
ask yourself well what's happening we're
giving a lot of money here It's it's
more money than other states would ever
give But how are school districts broke
and so there's problems with the policy
and how uh the funding formulas work and
everything else and and the and the
actual outcomes the educational outcomes
we're getting um for u the money that
we're investing from the state and also
the unfunded mandates on our schools and
many other different things So right now
uh House and Senate Democrats both are
asking for this massive property tax
increase and right now it looks like a
little bit but over time the compounding
effect of those property this new
property tax proposal makes it the
biggest tax increase in state history
Just imagine that in both scenarios
whether it's the House or the Senate uh
property tax proposal in in roughly 10
maybe 13 years your property tax could
absolutely double maybe even triple
depending upon what your local
governments and where you live and what
they decide to do And they tried to say
"Oh this is this is just the given local
government's options." Well that's where
most of your property taxes come from
And depending on where you live maybe
that saves you a little bit Um but the
state is still collecting an enormous
amount of money just in the first
bianium a billion dollars um for the you
know uh or in the first four years for
property taxes So I know that a lot of
people who are on fixed incomes who are
retirees who saved up they they own
their house outright and they already
have to budget on their fixed income for
property taxes every single year This
puts them out of a hum This will
absolutely if you if your property taxes
triple in growth it could put a lot of
people out on the streets We already
have one of the highest levels of
homelessness and we actually don't even
need to raise the property tax to
balance the budget And that's the crazy
thing Uh and this is an absolutely
irresponsible tax It's it's done on
behalf of of the well-connected and the
elites here in Olympia who who know and
can phone a friend um and and make sure
that their pet projects get funded There
is a lot of waste fraud and abuse in our
state budget of 72 well which would be
78 billion and 8% growth of spending uh
as a result of all of this and people
just can't afford it anymore Uh when you
couple a property tax increase with
other policies like rent control it will
absolutely devastate homeowners and the
housing supply market and it will make
sure that even if you're older and
you're on fixed income or if you're on
low uh low income on fixed income or if
you're just entering the housing market
there will be nowhere to go Uh and this
is absolutely when you compile and uh a
lot of these policies together and
especially if they continue with trying
to ban natural gas uh it spells absolute
disaster in a lot of our communities and
we absolutely have to stop it So in the
weeks ahead the few weeks we have left
here in session it'll be um trying to
get you know fight against the budgets
you're talking about from both the House
and the Senate Everybody has to work
together to get to that one budget House
Republicans did not propose their own
budget but you this week have proposed a
package of structural budget reforms Can
you talk about that yeah I think it's
it's important to note that um you know
Republicans are trying to work as a team
here in Olympia I we're fewer in numbers
and that means fewer in resources so we
got to divide and conquer a little bit
The Senate Republican caucus came out
with a proof of concept budget They came
out with a budget that does not raise
taxes that lives within its means and
does some still fixes some problems uh
that we've had for a very long time here
in Washington state So they've proven
that you can have a responsible
sustainable budget that doesn't
radically in uh radically grow spending
and and most importantly does not raise
taxes and still keeps intact a lot of
the almost all of the critical functions
uh core functions of government the so
we could still take care of the people
who need us the most and our key
functions of government And on the House
side we're essentially saying that look
we can solve today's budget deficit um
in a myriad of
ways You know one way that from the
Democrats is more taxes and more
spending I mean technically it fixes the
deficit but it harms people in order to
do so Uh the Republican way is well more
sustainable budget you know reduce the
reckless and wasteful spending and make
sure that we're actually performing our
core functions and do it with no new
taxes Uh what House Republicans are now
uh and myself are proposing is that
unless we have structural reforms uh to
protect taxpayers uh to have limits on
how much we could spend limits on how
much we can tax and some key
accountability and performance audits of
a lot of the programs we pay for that
are wasteful Make sure we're actually
getting accountability for every dollar
spent That we have priorities of
government um and that we have
anti-corruption type of things to where
you know lawmakers here in Olympia
aren't profiting off of the taxpayers in
kind of shady ways We're saying unless
you do a host of these budget structural
budget reforms then we will just be back
here again someday uh arguing about the
same exact problem You know one of the
problems of why we're in this budget
deficit is because they essentially put
bills on layaway They pass bills that
cost a lot of money and they said "Well
we in like 2021 they'll pass a bill and
then say but it's implemented and we
have to pay for it in 2026." Well now
here we are and the bills are coming due
and we can't pay for them Uh and it's a
lot of the times based upon revenue
assumptions of revenue we never actually
had in the first place And this is how
they continue to grow wasteful programs
and expand and and create new programs
we never had the money for and then they
say "Oh well I guess we need new taxes."
Uh no we don't actually need to do that
You just need to be responsible at the
outset And so um that action of delaying
things into the future and then putting
the bills on layaway and having to pay
for it later that's exactly what House
Dem and Senate Democrats have done with
their budget proposals with many
expensive items Uh their cuts aren't
real cuts They're just delays into the
future and we will have to pay those
bills again someday because there was
actually no reforms done here And that's
what I think is important for people at
home to understand is that we did not
reform the budget process We did not
reform a lot of the malpractice that is
has been happening I mean it is like
shuffling the deck chairs on the Titanic
uh we are playing a massive billiond
dollar shell game and moving things
around and it will will not actually
solve the issue and what people want is
accountability for the dollars tax
dollars that are spent We want it to
actually solve the problems we want it
to solve We want to go to our priorities
of government our courts our schools
whatever it may be And we want those
things to work well Um but one of the
things that's happened in Olympia is
we've spread the peanut butter so thin
that I call I say this about the budget
that it's a little bit for everybody but
not enough for anybody Meaning we don't
fully fund a lot of things And so think
everything suffers when you do that
because you got to know when to say no
and you got to have priorities of
government You got to do things right So
without the structural budget reforms
that I'm proposing all the other budgets
will just be back here again someday And
so people want government efficiency Uh
they want accountability Um and they
want to be able to not be taxed out of
their homes They want to be able to
afford their gas their groceries their
rent Uh and every time a bill is passed
here in Olympia Um even if it doesn't
cost a taxpayer dime it might cause
higher costs somewhere out in the
community And those things compile and
compound and it hurts people And right
now we're eclipsing almost we're neck
andneck with California for one of the
most expensive states in the nation in
almost every measurable category And it
has to end And right now our businesses
are fleeing too And that means jobs Yeah
Uh the BNO tax they put out um is a
jobkilling tax Uh when you when you levy
a 50% essentially tax on all of our
largest employers that might sound good
because hey they're not taxing me I'm
not the largest employer But those are
the people who provide all the family
wage jobs in our state with great
benefits and health care and vision and
dental and and all sorts of different
things with paid paid leave and um great
vacation packages and retirement and
401ks I mean do we really want um Amazon
and Microsoft and and Boeing and you
know many of our big kind of you know
businesses to literally just pack up and
leave our state because of extreme
payroll taxes like Jumpstart or uh that
the Senate proposed or big massive BNO
increases I mean and even if they stayed
those companies uh don't just absorb
those costs They pass it down to the
consumers that they serve Uh just like
any business does when they have higher
expenses they pass those costs down to
the consumer That means everything you
buy which is a lot of people because
they're some of the biggest businesses
in the world everyone's products or
services that the those companies
produce will be more expensive as a
result and they'll have less jobs
available as a result as well And and
usually whenever this happens it's not
the people at the top the upper
management that gets let go It is the
people at the bottom the people who are
laying the bricks uh paving the roads
doing the hard work with their high viz
vest and their hard hat Those are the
first people to let go with taxes like
this
So um what is the best thing for our
viewers to to do if they're concerned
about some of these or any of this as we
go through the budget process in the
next week uh how do they get involved
what do they do i think it's important
to know that uh the the Democrat propos
budget proposals here are just taxing
the joy right out of Washingtonians I
mean we mentioned some of the big ones
but there's a 11% tax on firearms
there's a tax on bottles there's a tax
on uh uh beverages there's a tax on
vacations I mean there's I mean the only
thing I can think of is they haven't tax
you to breathe yet Um and I almost made
a joke the other day they might tax you
to leave but apparently that was almost
on the table as well And it's just it
it's nuts And uh you know you can't tax
your way into prosperity Um so uh you
know people need to stay involved and
and informed and you need to talk to
your neighbors You need to um be open
about these things and and talk to other
people Human beings politics and and
government is a people game Uh you got
to you got to use your voice and you got
to talk to people even maybe if it's
uncomfortable Be civil about it But you
know do you think that it's right to uh
raise property taxes on working families
in order to balance a budget that should
uh never have been in a deficit in the
first place the answer for most people
is no I mean left and right Yeah Um but
at the end of the day
uh you you got to be involved a little
bit even if it takes 5 10 minutes of
your time I know people are really busy
and they don't have time to sit around
like an activist and watch Olympia all
day Um but you know 5 10 minutes of your
day to to check out the news be informed
um follow our caucus uh on X Instagram
Facebook um and you know and and of
course our website uh which hopefully
gets put on the screen at some point
That's how you could find out how out
how to stop bad bills There's a tab at
the top to stop bad bills help us out
there That's functional ways that you
can help us out It's really important
because we're outnumbered but we're not
outclassed here And we absolutely need
your help because only when the people
come in on our side do we win here All
right that's great Thank you so much
Representative Travis Couture 35th
District our House Republican budget
lead Some busy weeks ahead Thanks Fix
Washington with Anna Scott A podcast
from Washington House Republicans Go to
our website
houserepublicans.wa.gov Find us on
Facebook X Instagram and YouTube
