Ranking Member Warren Floor Speech on Overdraft Rule

Senate Banking Housing & Urban Affairs Committee
27 followers
9 Video Views·Mar 28, 2025
mr President I want to thank the senator
from Connecticut for his work today in
defending the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau and highlighting again
the importance of this work from the
CFPB to help level the playing field
just a little between the billionaire
banks and our hardworking service
members and families that are living
paycheck to paycheck I also want to
thank Senator Booker for coming here and
talking today about how people from New
Jersey have been directly affected by
overdraft fee abuses and appreciate his
work on this President Trump and
Republicans promised the Americans that
they would lower their cost of living
and instead they are now linking arms
with some of the biggest banks in the
country to impose billions of dollars in
fees on working families Today
Republicans are voting to overturn a
CFPB rule that prevents big banks like
Bank of America JP Morgan Chase and
Wells Fargo from saddling customers with
hundreds of dollars in overdraft fees
when a customer overdraws a checking
account by only a few dollars Let's be
clear this rule covers only the biggest
banks those with more than $10 billion
in assets Community banks are completely
exempt from this All this rule does is
ensure that overdraft fees are
reasonable Under the rule banks are
allowed to recoup all of their costs all
of their losses associated with
providing overdraft that is typically
under $5 which is why the CFPB's rule
generally caps overdraft fees at $5 But
if the bank can show that its costs are
harder then they can charge the full
amount of their actual costs and losses
What the banks cannot do is play a game
of gotcha in which the bank manipulates
the customer's account to hit the
customers with hundreds of dollars in
overdraft charges Today a handful of
giant banks are charging about $35 a
bounced payment squeezing families for
far more than what it typically costs to
offer this overdraft And the consumers
carrying the vast majority of these fees
are disproportionately lowincome
Americans with the typical customer who
gets t caught by overdraft fees ending
up paying more than
$400 a year Now $400 can be the cost of
a mortgage payment or rent for someone
with a modest income
$400 can be the difference between their
kids medication or just going without
$400 for some families can be several
weeks worth of groceries This money
matters to millions of families
Altogether the CFPB rule saves American
families up to five billion dollar a
year Republicans claim they care about
lowering costs but overturning this rule
will make big banks richer and
hardworking families poorer The
Republicans are deeply sympathetic
deeply sympathetic to giant banks They
worry about poor little Wells Fargo They
shed a tear for JP Morgan's extra
billion dollars in profits that they
make from overdraft fees on top of the
27 billion they make in their other
banking services Yes the Republicans
worry about those giant banks and that
$5 billion that they would have to
forego if they could only charge $5 for
an overdraft fee Look banks can survive
with limits on overdraft fees How do we
know that because they're already doing
it In fact many banks including Capital
One and City Bank have eliminated
overdraft fees entirely and they are
still making billions of dollars in
profits No these fees are about kicking
hardworking Americans when they are down
My constituent April from Massachusetts
shared this During the years of my life
when money was always tight nothing was
more stressful than overdrafting my
account by $1 only to lose $35 due to
overdraft More than once that additional
$35 loss tangled up my budget for
multiple paychecks or made the
difference between getting groceries or
not
Joan also from Massachusetts talked
about how insidious these fees can be
Quote "Several times when money was tied
and I refilled my account a bit too late
I was charged an overdraft fee that then
itself caused the next check to bounce
causing another fee On top of that there
were daily fees because the overdraft
charges kept me behind even as I added
money to the account
To make matters even worse these abusive
anti-consumer practices often target
service members and military families
Last year the CFPB ordered Navy Federal
Credit Union to refund $80 million in
illegal surprise overdraft fees which
they had charged service members even
when the service members accounts showed
enough money to cover the transactions
Cracking down on abusive overdraft
practices particularly when they harm
service members has bipartisan support A
year ago my then colleague J D Vance and
I launched an investigation into another
credit union that had prayed on service
members with extortionate overdraft fees
And I hope to see the same kind of
bipartisan concern now and support for
the CFPB rule that puts a stop to this
squeeze on military families And look
finally I just want to mention I know
that my colleagues on the other side of
the aisle and on this side of the aisle
are concerned about debanking Now
debanking is something that happens when
a bank closes someone's account without
any real
explanation Overdraft practices have
been the reason for tens of millions of
account closures shutting out far too
many Americans from our banking system
So for everyone who has concerns about
debanking consider that CFPB rule
eliminates one of the main excuses that
banks have used for debanking their
customers Look our job is to lower costs
for American families not boost profits
for giant banks A vote against today's
CRA is a vote to protect those families
and save them five billion dollars a
year I urge my colleagues to vote
no Thank you Mr President and I yield
the floor
