Justice Sonia Sotomayor Says Courts Should Remain 'Fearlessly Independent'

Pure News
844 followers
2.2K Video Views·Mar 29, 2025
I'm going to quote Rosie, and this was her response to me when I asked her what should
courts do to protect it.
She said, quote, they need to remain fearlessly independent, protective of rights, and ensure
that the state is respectful of both.
I couldn't think of a better answer than that.
That is really at the end what judges should do, but it's in the end of whatever citizens
should do, which is ensure that the courts are fearlessly independent, that we understand
that our obligation is to protect the rights given to us under the Constitution.
These are not just made-up rights.
The Constitution is the structure of the norms that bind us as a society in America.
But we also have to demand that all others respect both of these principles.
That's what our function is.
More than ever, we have to get up and explain and repeat and explain again why judicial
independence is critical to everyone's freedom.
Because arbitrary power is just that, and it means that anyone is going to be subject
to unfairness at someone else's will.
And so the fact that you may like the use of arbitrary power against someone else at
the moment, and you can target whomever you want at any moment, you have to be worried
about the day that will turn on you.
That's why we have the rule of law, which is to give a set of expectations to people
that they can rely upon.
One of the things that's troubling so many right now is many of the standards that are
being changed right now were norms that governed officials into what was right and wrong.
Once norms are broken, then you're shaking some of the foundation of the rule of law.
Is there any way to re-establish norms after they're broken?
Well, I mean, in the end, I think some of my colleagues, like Neil Gorsuch, who talks
about democracy being messy, we're going to have to go back to reminding people what
the fundamentals of their obligation as citizens is, and their obligation to monitor their
public representatives.
