The Middle East Conflict Part 1 (Marathon) | Video Marathons

PragerU
799 followers
There is a lot to learn about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict—and that's why we have DOZENS of 5-Minute Videos devoted to the topic. We've split this playlist into two parts, and here is the first.
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
#isreal #palestine #middleeast
when I did my Graduate Studies at the
Middle East Institute at Columbia
University's School of International
Affairs I took many courses on the
question of the Middle East conflict
semester after semester we studied the
Middle East conflict as if it was the
most complex conflict in the world when
in fact it is probably the easiest
conflict in the world to explain it may
be the hardest to solve but it is the
easiest to explain in a n shell it's
this one side wants the other side dead
Israel wants to exist as a Jewish State
and to live in peace Israel also
recognizes the right of Palestinians to
have their own State and to live in
peace the problem however is that most
Palestinians and many other Muslims and
Arabs do not recognize the right of the
Jewish state of Israel to exist this has
been true since
1947 when the United Nations voted to
divide the land land called Palestine
into a Jewish State and an Arab State
the Jews accepted the United Nations
partition but no Arab or any other
Muslim country accepted it when British
rule ended on May 15th
1948 the armies of all the neighboring
Arab states Lebanon Syria Iraq trans
Jordan and Egypt attacked the one-day
old state of Israel in order to destroy
it but to the world's surprise the
little Jewish State
survived then it happened again in 1967
the dictator of Egypt Gamal Abdul Nasser
announced his plan in his words to
destroy Israel he placed Egyptian troops
on Israel's border and armies of
surrounding Arab countries were also
mobilized to
attack however Israel preemptively
attacked Egypt and Syria Israel did not
attack Jordan and beged Jordan's King
not to join the war
but he did and only because of that did
Israel take control of Jordanian land
specifically the West Bank of the Jordan
River shortly after the war the Arab
states went to carum Sudan and announced
their famous three NOS no recognition no
peace and no
negotiations what was Israel supposed to
do well one thing Israel did a little
more than a decade later in 19 78 was to
give the entire Sinai Peninsula an area
of land bigger than Israel itself and
with oil back to Egypt because Egypt
under new leadership signed a peace
agreement with Israel so Israel gave
land for the promise of peace with Egypt
and it has always been willing to do the
same thing with the
Palestinians all the Palestinians have
ever had to do is recognize Israel as a
Jewish state and promised to live in
peace with it but when Israel has
proposed trading land for peace as it
did in 2000 when it agreed to give the
Palestinians a sovereign state in more
than 95% of the West Bank and all of
Gaza the Palestinian leadership rejected
the offer and instead responded by
sending waves of suicide terrorists into
Israel meanwhile Palestinian radio
television and school curricula remain
filled with glorification of terrorists
demonization of Jews and the daily
repeated message that Israel should
cease to exist so it's not hard to
explain the Middle East dispute one side
wants the other dead the motto of Hamas
the Palestinian rulers of Gaza is we
love death as much as the Jews love life
there are 22 Arab states in the world
stretching from the Atlantic Ocean to
the Indian Ocean there is one Jewish
state in the world and it is about the
size of New Jersey in fact tiny El
Salvador is larger than Israel finally
think about these two questions if
tomorrow Israel laid down its arms and
announced we will fight no more what
would happen and if the Arab countries
around Israel laid down their arms and
announced we will fight no more what
would happen
in the first case there would be an
immediate destruction of the state of
Israel and mass murder of its Jewish
population in the second case there
would be peace the next
day as I said at the outset it is a
simple problem to describe one side
wants the other dead and if it didn't
there would be
peace please remember this there has
never been a state in the geographic
area known as Palestine that was not
Jewish Israel is the third Jewish state
to exist in that area there was never an
Arab State never a Palestinian State
never a Muslim or any other state that's
the issue why can't the one Jewish State
the size of El Salvador be allowed to
exist that is the Middle East problem
I'm Dennis
Prager
if Israel just allowed the Palestinians
to have a state of their own there would
be peace in the Middle East right that's
what you hear from un ambassadors
European diplomats and most college
professors but what if I told you that
Israel has already offered the
Palestinians a state of their own and
not just once but on five separate
occasions don't believe me let's review
the
record after the breakup of the Ottoman
Empire following World War I Britain
took control of most of the Middle East
including the area that constitutes
modern Israel 17 years later in
1936 the Arabs rebelled against the
British and against their Jewish
neighbors the British formed a task
force the peel commission to study the
cause of the
Rebellion the commission concluded that
the reason for the violence was that two
peoples Jews and Arabs wanted to govern
the same land
land the answer the appeal commission
concluded would be to create two
independent states one for the Jews and
one for the Arabs a two-state
solution the suggested split was heavily
in favor of the Arabs the British
offered them 80% of the disputed
territory the Jews the remaining 20% yet
despite the tiny size of their proposed
state the Jews voted to accept this
offer but the Arabs rejected it and
resumed their violent Rebellion
rejection number one 10 years later in
1947 the British asked the United
Nations to find a new solution to the
continuing tensions like the appeal
commission the UN decided that the best
way to resolve the conflict was to
divide the land in November
1947 the UN voted to create two states
again the Jews accepted the offer and
again the Arabs rejected it only this
time they did so by launching an all-out
War rejection number two Jordan Egypt
Iraq Lebanon and Syria joined the
conflict but they failed Israel won the
war and got on with the business of
building a new
nation most of the land set aside by the
UN for an Arab State the West Bank and
East Jerusalem became occupied territory
occupied not by Israel but by Jordan 20
years later in 1967 the Arabs LED This
Time by Egypt and joined by Syria and
Jordan once again sought to destroy the
Jewish State the 1967 conflict known as
the sixth day war ended in a stunning
victory for Israel Jerusalem and the
West Bank as well as the area known as
the Gaza Strip fell into Israel's hands
the government split over what to do
with this new
territory half wanted to return the West
Bank to Jordan and Gaza to Egypt in
exchange for peace the other wanted to
give it to the Region's Arabs who had
begun referring to themselves as the
Palestinians in the hope that they would
ultimately build their own State there
neither initiative got very far a few
months later the Arab League met in
Sudan and issued its Infamous three NOS
no peace with Israel no recognition of
Israel no negotiations with Israel again
a two-state solution was dismissed by
the Arabs making this rejection number
three
in 2000 Israeli Prime Minister Ehud
Barack met at Camp David with
Palestinian Liberation Organization
chairman yaser Arafat to conclude a new
two-state plan Barack offered Arafat a
Palestinian state in all of Gaza and 94%
of the West Bank with East Jerusalem as
its capital but the Palestinian leader
rejected the offer in the words of US
President Bill Clinton Arafat was here
14 days and said no to everything
instead the Palestinians launched a
bloody wave of suicide bombings that
killed over 1,000 Israelis and maimed
thousands more on buses in wedding halls
and in pizza parlors rejection number
four in 2008 Israel tried yet again
prime minister Ehud ommer went even
further than Ehud Barack had expanding
the peace offer to include additional
land to sweeten the deal like his
predecessor the new Palestinian leader
Mahmud abas turned the deal down
rejection number five in between these
last two Israeli offers Israel
unilaterally left Gaza giving the
Palestinians complete control there
instead of developing this territory for
the good of its citizens the
Palestinians turn Gaza into a terrorist
base from which they have fired
thousands of rockets into
Israel each time Israel has agreed to a
Palestinian State the Palestinians have
rejected the offer often
violently so if you're interested in
peace in the Middle East maybe the
answer is not to pressure Israel to make
yet another offer of estate to the
Palestinians maybe the answer is to
pressure the Palestinians to finally
accept the existence of a Jewish state
I'm David brog executive director of the
makabe task force for Prager
University to my Palestinian brothers
and sisters and to anyone who supports
the Palestinian people I implore you
please do not let Hamas brainwash you
into thinking it has achieved anything
on our behalf it hasn't not in the Gaza
Wars of 2021 2014 2012 or 2008 each one
of these pointless conflicts has been a
catastrophe costing us dearly in lives
and treasure Hamas is not a social
justice movement and it certainly does
not care about the Palestinian people it
is a criminal gang that only cares about
increasing its own power Israel is not
the main cause of your suffering Hamas
is the main cause Israel is not your
Jailer Hamas is it was Hamas that led
you into this most recent disaster they
told you that the isra
were ecting innocent Palestinians from
their homes in the Sheik jarah area of
East Jerusalem it is a Lie the people
living in those homes weren't tenants
they were squatters they hadn't PA rent
for decades they told you that the
Israelis plan to destroy the alaka
mosque this too is a Lie the mosque is
still there it will be there tomorrow
say what you want about the Israelis
they are not stupid they know that if
they actually attempt to destroy alaka
it would lead to war with every Muslim
country yes Hamas take actions and thus
look strong next to its rival the
corrupt fat party but the only action it
takes is to lead us into chaos Hamas has
no ability and in fact no desire to
govern the water isn't safe to drink
drink the power goes out for hours at a
time rage washes up on your beaches the
Israelis are not responsible for these
dismal failures Hamas is and everybody
in Gaza knows it it is Hamas that steal
the imported cement meant to build
houses for you and uses it instead to
build a massive network of tunnels from
which its hopes to terrorize Israelis it
is Hamas that makes sure humanitarian
Aid meant for you is diverted to its
favored Elites who then sell it for a
profit on the black market and it is
Hamas that uses you as a human shield
stationing rocket launchers and missile
arsenals in your apartments Office
Buildings schools and even hospitals
Israel uses Rockets to defend its people
Hamas uses bble to defend its Rockets as
for its war strategy Hamas doesn't have
one it fires missiles at the most highly
populated regions of Israel with no
specific Target yet I know from my
sources in Gaza that as much as 25% of
all rockets launched by Hamas in May
20121 crashed within Gaza 50 Gaza
civilians were killed by the these
Rockets their deaths fely blamed on
Israel are you aware of the fact that
some of the Hamas missiles that Israeli
Defense Forces failed to intercept ended
up exploding in places like japa abuos
and lud where Arab Israelis live
Palestinians living in Israel are as
likely to be killed as Israelis
themselves Hamas couldn't care less and
what was gained Palestinians living in
these four buildings in Sheik jar will
still eventually be eved a fact that has
been known to those families since they
sold away the title to those buildings
think about the even greater number of
Palestinians who are now homeless in
Gaza because Hamas choose to hide
weapons in residential buildings and
when naive American and European noos
offer Millions to rebuild Gaza who do
you think will get that money it won't
be you the people who really deserve it
and need it it will be the leaders of
the Hamas gang and their friends who
will add new rooms to their fancy Villas
rather than rebuild homes purchase
Corona virus vaccines or provide Social
Services for their people and the Beast
you so deserve the Beast which could
have been possible when Israel withdrew
entirely from the Gaza Strip in 2005
will be even further Out Of Reach Hamas
rubbed you of that chance when it set up
its military gang then it's robbing you
of the same chance now no matter how
many Jews it managed to kill Hamas will
never be satisfied it will never stop
lying but you can stop believing it lies
I am basm Eid for Brar
University the mission was
straightforward rescue comets going
under heavy anti-tank fire but now the
sun was up and our cover was blown we
were totally
exposed I felt a heavy wish of air then
I felt
nothing just a ringing in my ears I was
on the ground I could see through my
thigh even even worse I couldn't see my
foot it was
gone when I woke in the hospital it took
every ounce of carriage I had to look
down my Lake somehow some way my foot
was there the doctors have managed to
reattach it we have the best
surgeons Unfortunately they get a lot of
practice at this sort of thing that's
life in Israel that's life as an Israeli
soldier and death that's what I am I am
also an
Arab sometimes people say to me youf how
could you fight for the IDF I say it's
simple it's not the Jewish Defense
Forces it's the Israeli Defense Forces
and I am an
Israeli are you surprised if so I don't
blame you you probably get your news
about Israel from well the media they
amplify extremist and sell conflicts
because conflict sells conciliation
doesn't stereotypes make for simple
stories too simple so let's examine some
let's take the simplest that there are
Israelis and that there are Palestinians
and that each site defines itself
against other turns out the fundamental
division is false according to a poll in
2020 only 7% of Arabs living in Israel
self-identify as
Palestinian by contrast 74% consider
themselves either Israeli Arab or just
plain Israeli this is typical so much of
what you've heard about Israel is
distorted the story doesn't match the
facts so here are a few in America given
their numbers Jews are
disproportionately represented in the
medical professions no surprise but did
you know this in Israel Arabs are
disproportionately represented in the
medical professions Arab compris 20% of
Israel population
but 30% of its Physicians and 35% of its
pharmacists you've probably heard the
styp that Jews are Bankers this suggests
that they control things behind the
scenes so you may be surprised to learn
that the head of the biggest bank in
Israel is an Arab wor than the
stereotypes are the lies the worst lie
is this Israel is an apartheid state in
an apartheid state some can vote and
some cannot
but in Israel Arabs don't just vot they
sometimes call the shots in 2021 as an
article in El monitor put it for the
first time in Israel's 73e history Arab
Parliament members will likely have the
final say on whatever a government is
formed and even who will hit such a
government in an apoide State some get
an education and some don't but in
Israel Arab enrollment in higher
education is exploding more than
doubling between 2008 and
2018 and Israeli Arab Christians
actually outpace Israeli Jews in higher
education degrees relative to population
you probably don't know these facts
because the media prefers to demonize
Israel rather than report about it
fairly that may never change but whether
or not they report it Israel is
experiencing an important generational
shift our parents and grandparents
Generations witnessed major Wars in 1948
1967 and
1973 my generation and the generation
after me haven't seen such conflicts but
we have all grown up under the shadow of
terrorist violence from suicide bombers
to Hamas rocket attacks and terrorists
don't discriminate between Jews and
Arabs when you come face to face with
this reality when you have face to face
conversations you realize that everyone
within the borders of Israel confronts
the same threats and then you can begin
to understand that the real story isn't
two groups Jews and Arabs locked in an
eternal conflict but two parts of a
Nation coming together in a process I
call Israel isation a silent but evergo
majority of citizens simply want to live
in peace with their neighbors the ones
across the street and the ones on the
other side of national borders like I
said extremist voices get Amplified the
media likes it that way it generates
clicks sells papers and boosts TV
ratings unfortunately stories of good
people living and working side by side
without Strife don't do any of those
things but that doesn't make those story
less true all those people any less real
the real peace process happens one
person at a time with each passing year
I see that process expanding it won't be
smooth because nothing in this part of
the world goes smoothly but no one is
going going to stop it just like no one
is going to stop me from defending my
country
Israel I'm YF Hadad founder of together
voucher each other for prer
University I am an Arab I am a Muslim
and I love my country in fact I'm
prepared to die for it which is why I
serve in its Army I don't have to do
this I want to do this because my
country is a special place unlike other
free diverse vibrant yet other countries
countries not so free not so diverse
call for my country's complete
destruction the moment my country lets
its guard down it will be destroyed my
country is
Israel I go up and still live in a small
village named after my family bent Arab
tribe our Ro and this land run deep in
1948 when Arab armies invaded the new
state of Israel my family thought of
leaving our village some of them did but
when the Jews leaders heard that they
implored us to remain this is our
country for both Arabs and Jews they
said stay and we will work together to
build it my family stayed my parents
were born here made their lives here
start their own family here in Israel
in 2002 I was a teenager it was a
violent time Palestinian suicide bombers
were blowing up Israeli civilians a
danger to Arabs and Jews alike Israeli
troops entered the West Bank to stop
them at their source as a result many
Palestinian were killed I was stor who
side was I on Israelis or the
Palestinians is it possible to be an
Arab and an Israeli the question became
even more difficult when I saw men from
my own village wearing the uniform of
the Israeli Army only Jews are required
to serve in the military no one forced
this Arab men to join they chose it why
I asked them our home is here in Israel
they say our home is under attack our
neighbors in this home are Jews they are
being attacked We Fight Together still I
struggled I went to high school in
Nazareth there unlike the village where
I grow up most of the Arab students
identified as Palestinian even though
they are citizens of Israel some of the
students my friends hated Israel they
couldn't understand me you're a
Palestinian they said so you must hate
Israel when I said that I didn't that we
had far more freedom under opportunity
than Arabs anywhere in the Middle East
they called me a tror After High School
I I want to study electrical engineering
at thatne a leading Israeli University
during my first semester heav fire from
Gaza forced Israel to launch a
Counterattack not long after the War
Began I witnessed a group of Arab
Israeli students expressing their solid
with Hamas the palestin organization
that controls Gaza and is committed to
Israel's violent destruction did the
students not understand that those
Rockets could just as easily be aimed at
them Hamas didn't care who they killed
as long as they landed inside the
borders of Israel had my fellow Arab
students forgotten that Israel had left
Gaza a few years before that there
wasn't single Israeli living there that
day I dropped out of school to join the
Israeli Army in the IDF a few months
later I was a soldier in the Israeli Air
Force after months of training I was
assigned to the search and rescue o
helicopter unit our job was to save
lives we never concerned oursel with the
identity of the people who needed our
help We rescued Syrian civilians wounded
in their country Civil War Palestinian
children from Gaza requiring urgent
medical care and countless Israelis of
every religious and ethnic background a
life whether it is Muslim or Jewish
Palestina or Israeli is a life on a base
of 6,000 soldiers
I was the only bedwin but it didn't
matter the only thing that mattered was
keeping Israel our home safe we came
from all parts of the country and from
many parts of the world we wear every
shade of skin color our Shir go created
a deep bond today I am a student at H
University half of the students are Arab
more than once I have seen the
Palestinian flag being with weed at
Rally or protest on campus in Israel you
can't do this because whether you are a
Jew or an Arab you are free what more do
you need to know I am Muhammad kabia for
braer
University why do we spend so much money
on Israel Over My Decades of military
service as the deputy commander of
United States European command and now
as a security adviser I've often heard
people make make this
complaint the truth is we don't spend
enough we should spend more and for
purely selfish reasons every dollar we
spend on Israel is a dollar spent in
effect in our own defense as a value
proposition it's all in America's favor
let me explain but before I do let me
just say this I can easily defend why
America supports Israel on moral grounds
alone I've been there on numerous
occasions it's a good and decent country
given the neighborhood it lives in I
find that both remarkable and admirable
but I will make this argument solely on
the basis of America's security our
partnership with Israel is unique unlike
most of our current treaty alliances say
with South Korea our ties with Jerusalem
are not premised on American troops
serving as trip wires on Israel's front
lines this because Israel takes care of
itself America for good reason remains
wary of any further military engagement
in the Middle East
and this only strengthens the casee for
giving Israel the tools it needs to
defend its borders here are three things
we can do again all in our own
self-interest first the United States
should frontload its Financial
commitment to Israel we have agreed to
provide Israel 38 billion in defense
assistance over 10 years that's a big
number but it's also a great deal for
America in addition to giving Israel the
financial wherewithal to purchase the
weapons it needs it also benefits the
American economy under the agreement
Israel must spend these funds on us
products and it's happy to do so without
adding a cent to the total the United
States should frontload this assistance
to reflect the changing strategic
situation in the Middle East
specifically the rising danger presented
by Iran and its proxies Hezbollah and
Hamas an accelerated timetable would
allow Israel to acquire critical
capabilities like more F-35 attack
squadrons more refueling tankers and
more precision Munitions it will need
this Hardware to defend itself in
American interest against those
persistent and growing threats second
the United States should enhance our
alliance with Israel it may surprise you
to know that the United States does not
have a defense treaty with this
essential Ally lots of agreements but no
treaty we should why is this important
because it will send a loud strategic
signal to Israel's enemies that if you
mess with Israel you mess with us Israel
is not going to ask us for truth groups
but we should be giving them anything
else they need intelligence weapons
technology and other Vital Information
and we know this is a two-way street
Israel gives a lot in return which leads
me to the third point the United States
and Israel should build on their already
close collaboration in research and
development Israel is one of the most
high-tech economies in the world
American investors understand this more
venture capital is spent per capita in
Israel than in any other country
nine out of the 10 largest companies
have R&D facilities there this is in a
country of just 8 million people when we
sell them military gear they adapted to
their own special needs the American
Military in turn benefits from these
Innovations especially in the area of
desert Warfare indeed President Obama's
defense secretary Ashton Carter made
this point there's no question that
American lives have been saved by
Israeli technology there are many
cuttingedge projects we can work on
together such as directed energy weapons
this new form of Cannon emits highly
focused energy to neutralize targets
such weapons will be needed to counter
the spread of cheap deadly and plentiful
mortars and drones from Iran and other
Bad actors all this explains why I find
it so infuriating to see Americans
especially Young Americans support
anti-israel groups like BDS boycott
devest sanction that want to weaken and
Destroy Israel putting aside the
perverse logic of these groups that we
should punish a free and open democracy
it's self-destructive Israel is on the
front line of Terror they not us are
within Missile Range of Iran Syria
Hezbollah and Hamas to the extent these
enemies of Freedom are held in check
they are held in check by Israel and
they ask from us not one US soldier only
for military aid which they spend on
American defense products to help defend
American interests we should get them
that Aid without reservation sure it
cost us treasure but it saves us blood
our blood it's also the right thing to
do I'm General Chuck Wald United States
Air Force for prayer
University there are two views of the
Israeli military what you hear in most
of the media and the truth I'm going to
tell you the truth I was the commander
of British forces in
Afghanistan I have supporting combat
zones around the world including
Northern Ireland Bosnia Macedonia and
Iraq I was also present throughout the
conflict in Gaza in
2014 based on my experience and on my
observations the Israel Defense Force
the IDF does more to safeguard the
rights of civilians in a combat zone
than any other Army in the history of
warfare why is this so firstly Israel is
a decent country with Western values run
on Democratic principles Israel has no
more interest in war than Belgium does
in fact Israel has never started a war
the only reason it ever goes to war is
to defend itself and it has to defend
itself because unlike Belgium it is
surrounded by countries and armed groups
that want to destroy it secondly Judaism
with its unsurpassed moral standards
remains a major influence on the
citizens of Israel I say this as a
non-jew thirdly the Army is composed
overwhelmingly of Citizen soldiers
Israel is a small country with a small
professional Army to fight a war it
depends on its conscripts and its
reservists these are ordinary citizens
from professors to Plumbers called upon
to defend their homes
they don't want to be fighting and they
don't want to harm
others nowhere was the essential
morality and decency of the IDF more
evident than in the Gaza war of
2014 if ever there was a purely
defensive War this was it the war was
started by Hamas the terror
organization designated as such by the
US state department that runs the Gaza
Street
in the first 6 months of 2014 Hamas
launched hundreds of rockets at Israeli
civilians after repeated warnings from
Israel to stop the Israeli Air Force
finally conducted Precision strikes to
Halt the rocket fire and the IDF
Advanced into Gaza to destroy a network
of Terror tunnels that Hamas had
constructed to attack Israeli
communities near the the Gaza border the
IDF took Extraordinary Measures to give
Gaza civilians notice of targeted areas
dropping millions of leaflets
broadcasting radio messages sending
texts and making tens of thousands of
phone calls let me repeat that the
Israelis called gazans on their cell
phones and told them to leave their
residences and move to safety never in
the history of warfare has an army
phoned its enemy and told them where
they're going to drop their
bombs many IDF missions that could have
taken out Hamas military capabilities
were aborted to prevent civilian
casualties increasing the risk to
Israeli citizens and soldiers despite
all of this of course innocent civilians
were killed every war is chaotic and
confusing and mistakes are frequent but
mistakes are not war
crimes Hamas on the other hand committed
war crimes as official government policy
Hamas deliberately positioned its
military assets among the civilian
population hiding weapons in schools and
hospitals and placing rocket launchers
alongside apartment buildings then
forced those civilians to stay in areas
they knew would be
attacked they also instructed their
people to report the lie that every
Garen killed was a civilian even if they
were actually Fighters and if there were
no civil in deaths Hamas made them up
numerous internet sites show
Palestinians elaborately staging sniper
victims and smashed ambulances among
other phony
Horrors it's so common there's even a
term for it plywood as in Palestinian
Hollywood I ironically it's the leaders
of heras themselves who best understand
the Extraordinary Measures the IDF will
take to protect innocent civilians they
take full advantage of Israel's decency
and adherence to the laws of
war no army takes such risks in order to
protect civilians as the Israeli Army
does I say this as a professional
Soldier I say it because it's true
and people who care about truth should
know
it I'm Colonel Richard Kemp for Prager
University maybe you've heard someone
say that Israel is an aparte state that
Israel has a policy of segregating and
oppressing the minority population
within its borders like South Africa
once did maybe you've been so outraged
by this information that you have
considered joining the BDS movement the
effort to boycott divest and sanction
Israel until it ends its alleged racist
policies I don't blame you aparte is a
great evil and deserves to be fought
wherever we find it but here's the thing
you won't find a parde in the state of
Israel so I'll put it bluntly the BDS
movement is a slick propaganda effort
built on lies I think I have the
credibility to make this claim having
grown up in South Africa and having
spent a fair amount of time in Israel I
know what aparte is and what it is not
my parents were raised under real
apartheid where blacks were by law
separated from whites at every level
from education to drinking fountains
blacks couldn't vote couldn't own land
couldn't live next to or use the same
transportation system as
whites I remember my father telling me
about how my grandfather was kicked and
humiliated in public by a young white
boy all he was permitted to say was
please stop little
boss that was the world my family lived
in that was the world of apar South
Africa but in Israel the law is
colorblind it's Israeli Arabs have the
same rights as Israeli Jews They Ride
the same buses study in the same schools
and are treated in the same hospitals
Arabs are elected to Israel's parliament
serve as judges and fight in the Israeli
military on my first trip to Israel the
group I was with had a Jewish tour guide
and an Arab bus driver imagine our
surprise having heard that Israel is an
aparte State this would have been
inconceivable in AP Pare South Africa
all these things would be self-evident
to anyone who did any kind of actual
research or even better visited Israel
something I encourage everyone to do BDS
doesn't want you to research or visit
Israel it depends on the ignorance of
its audience sadly an American college
campuses BDS has a significant presence
it succeeds by playing on the the good
intentions of good people through
deliberate deception in short they lie
and lies really make me angry because
lies Empower evil lies about blacks
empowered apartheid in South Africa lies
about Jews made the Holocaust possible
and lies about Israel are misleading a
lot of good-hearted young people into
opposing the only country in the entire
Middle East that doesn't segregate and
oppress its minority popul population
just ask the next Egyptian copt or Iraqi
Christian you meet on
campus so the question people should
really be asking is what does the BDS
movement want the answer is simple they
want to destroy Israel they can't do it
militarily so they try to do it through
lies they say that Jews have no historic
claim to Israel lie they say that Israel
treats its Arabs second class citizens
lie they say that Israel doesn't want
peace with its Arab neighbors
lie if you tell lies and you tell them
often enough people who don't know the
truth start to believe them the BDS
movement's leaders barely tried to hide
the charade they will lie and say that
they only want a Palestinian State
living side by side with Israel and then
they say this we oppose a Jewish state
in any part of Palestine ending the
occupation doesn't mean anything if it
doesn't mean upending the Jewish State
itself that's from Omar bouti a founder
of
BDS bouti lives in Israel so you might
expect that he said this from inside an
Israeli prison like Nelson Mandela
during South Africa
apar you would be
wrong bouti is a PhD student at Israel's
Tel Aviv University where he enjoys the
same rights as every Israeli my parents
could only dream of that kind of
freedom is Israel a perfect country no
there are as many perfect countries as
they are perfect people but to call it
an aparte state is not only an insult to
the only democracy in the Middle East
and the only country with equal rights
for all its minorities it's also an
insult to the actual victims of
apartheid like my parents and all those
who suffered under it I'm Olga misher
for praga
University why does the left hate Israel
on the surface it doesn't make sense
Israel is a liberal democracy it extends
full rights to women to gays and to its
many Arab citizens like all countries
which are made up of flawed human beings
Israel is flawed but compared to most
countries not to mention its neighbors
it is a civil rights Paradise so why
does the left hate Israel the reason is
that the left and as I always emphasize
I am talking about the left not about
liberals is not Guided by a moral
compass it is Guided by three other
compasses a power Compass a race compass
and a class Compass let's begin with the
power Compass instead of evaluating
people and Nations on the basis of right
and wrong or good and evil the left
evaluates them on the basis of weak and
strong if you're weak you're good if
you're strong you're bad Israel is
strong therefore it is bad America is
strong therefore it is bad the
Palestinians are regarded as weak
therefore they're good when you're
Guided by a moral compass you don't ask
who's strong and who's weak you ask
who's morally right and who's morally
wrong 50 years ago Israel was not a big
issue for the left why because it was
perceived as weak but after the 1967
6-day war in which Israel achieved a
stunning military Victory it all changed
Israel became strong so Israel became
bad and the Palestinians were weak so
they became good so no matter how much
Terror Palestinians engaged in hijacking
airplanes murdering 11 Israeli athletes
and coaches at the 1972 Munich Olympics
blowing up Israelis in pizza parlors and
at weddings the left's position never
changed Palestinians good Israel bad
because the Palestinians were weak and
Israel was strong that's one of the
three ways the left judges the world you
can test this theory in other ways why
is the United States bad because it's
strong and third world countries that
oppose the United States are good Cuba
for example has been adored by the left
for decades never mind that Cuba's
communist party has ruined Cuba that
Cubans have no civil rights and Cuba is
one of the poorest countries in the
world since Cuba is weak to the left
Cuba is good
the same was true with North Vietnam in
the 1960s it was considered weak so it
was good the US was strong so it was bad
it didn't matter that America was trying
to preserve the freedom of the South
Vietnamese exactly as it had preserved
the freedom of the South Koreans the US
was strong so it was bad which brings us
back to Israel the stronger Israel gets
as it effectively defends itself as its
economy grows
and as its diplomatic position improves
the more the left hates it the second of
the left's compasses the race Compass is
another reason the left hates Israel
just as it substitutes weak and strong
for good and evil the left substitutes
nonwhite and white for good and evil the
left doesn't judge people by their
actions but by their race that's why for
example the left asserts that a black
person cannot be a racist only a white
person can be a racist and that provides
the second reason Israel is labeled evil
Israelis are considered white and
Palestinians are not white never mind
that more than half of Israel's
population is not white the result the
left essentially ignores Palestinian
Terror and loudly condemns Israel's
responses to
Terror now to the left's thirdd compass
the class compass
this is the third way in which the left
replaces traditional Western and
judeo-christian categories of Good and
Evil instead of judging people's actions
by the same moral yard stick that of
Good and Evil the left judges people's
actions based on their economic class
rich people and Rich nations are bad
poor people and poor nations are good
this began with KL Marx who divided the
World by economic class not moral
Behavior to Marx and to Marxism good and
evil is entirely class-based good is
defined as workers evil as
owners and that is the third reason for
the left's hatred of Israel and of
America they are both wealthy as fewer
and fewer people perceive the world in
terms of Good and Evil substituting a
power race or class compass for a moral
compass you will inev ably get more evil
and more hatred of the good beginning
with Israel and America and ending with
Western
Civilization I'm Dennis
Prager when I was the Prime Minister of
Canada I was often asked this question
why do you support Israel my response in
effect was always the same why wouldn't
I support Israel why wouldn't I support
a fellow Democratic Nation where open
elections free speech and religious
tolerance are the everyday Norm why
wouldn't I support a country with a
vibrant Free Press and an independent
Judiciary why wouldn't I support a
valuable trading partner and a
Wellspring of amazing technological
innovation why wouldn't I support our
most critical Ally in the Middle East
and in the international struggle
against
terrorism in a rational World in a world
where simple Common Sense prevailed the
question why do you support Israel would
be like asking why do you support
Australia or Canada but we don't live in
that rational Common Sense world so the
Case for Israel has to be made over and
over I for one am happy to make it let
me start with this every military action
Israel has ever taken has been to
protect itself Israel is not an
aggressor State it's a defensive State
this has been true from its founding to
this day as a the fledgling nation in
1948 Israel was immediately attacked by
its Arab neighbors their goal was not to
contain the tiny new country it was to
annihilate it no Nation came to Israel's
Aid not the United States not my country
Canada not the United Kingdom no one
they all thought Israel would lose but
it didn't lose it won in 1967 Israel's
neighbors again sought to utterly
destroy the Jewish State a nation that
had then existed for two decades again
Israel prevailed and it survived another
allout attack in
1973 those are the big Wars but I'm not
sure there's been a single day in
Israel's entire history when some Act of
Terror has not been waged against it
inside or outside its borders there have
been two bloody waves of Terror
so-called inas in the late 1980s and the
early 2000s when Israelis were blowing
up on buses at pizza parlors and
celebrating weddings there have been
incursions from Terror groups like
Hezbollah in Lebanon there have been
thousands of Rocket attacks from Hamas
in the Gaza Strip even after Israel
completely withdrew from that territory
in
2005 in between the wars in between the
terror Israel has sought peace with its
neighbors and it has achieved peace
treaties with Egypt and Jordan for
others however every Israeli gesture for
peace is met with incitement and
violence I recount this history for one
reason any nation that has endured what
Israel has endured could easily have
become a police state but through it all
Israel has never abandoned its
commitment to the rule of law to
democracy to tolerance one of its
citizens are Muslim they enjoy the same
rights as Jewish citizens they occupy
key positions in the nation's courts
press and government and they have their
own parties representing them in the
kasset Israel's parliament
to say that Muslims in Israel are the
freest Muslims in the region is an
understatement how about this as a human
rights test prisoners in Israel be they
Jewish or Arab are well treated well fed
and have access to the best possible
Medical Care parents and spouses of
these prisoners know where they are and
that they are safe who else in the
region but Israel can make that
claim through all the wars and all the
terror Israel has survived and
especially in the last 20 years it has
thrived it's known as startup nation and
with good reason key components of your
cell phone and your laptop were designed
in Israel a drug or a medical device
that has saved your life or the life of
a loved one may have been developed in
Israel yet there are leftists
politicians activists artists academics
and college students who devote their
lives to denouncing Israel calling for
boycotts demanding it be cut off from
academic and professional societies
do they denounce the Palestinian
leadership that hasn't held an election
in well over a decade do they denounce
the leadership of Hamas who use women
and children as human Shields to protect
their Fighters no they denounce free
vibrant Democratic Innovative Israel
with all the brutal and violent regimes
not only in the Middle East but around
the world how is one to explain singling
out Israel for
condemnation sadly only only one
explanation fits
anti-Semitism do these haters of Israel
question the legitimacy of any other
Democratic nation of Any Nation for that
matter of course the answer is no
somehow they only manag to oppose the
Jewish one the state of Israel has now
existed for 70 years it is one of the
freest most prosperous most successful
Nations on Earth why do I support Israel
why wouldn't I why wouldn't anyone I'm
Steven Harper 22nd prime minister of
Canada for Prager
University I was born to hate Jews it
was part of my life I never questioned
it I was not born in Iran or Syria I was
born in England my parents moved there
from Pakistan theirs was a typical
immigrant story moved to the West in the
hope of making a better life for
themselves and their children
we were a devout Muslim family but not
extremist or radical in any way we only
wish the best for everyone everyone
except the Jews the Jews we believed
were aliens living in stolen Muslim land
occupiers who were engaged in a genocide
against the Palestinian people our
hatred therefore was justified and
righteous and it made me and my friends
vulnerable to the arguments of radical
extremists if the Jews were as evil as
we had always believed mustn't those who
support them Christians Americans and
others in the west be just as evil
beginning in the 1990s speakers and
teachers at mosques and in schools began
to endlessly repeat this theme we were
not Western we were not British we were
Muslims first and only our loyalty was
to our religion and to our fellow
Muslims we owed nothing to the Western
Nations that welcomed us as westerners
they were our enemies all of this had
its desire to fact at least it did on me
it changed the way that I saw the world
I began to see the suffering of Muslims
including in Britain as the fault of
Western imperialism the West Was at war
with us and the Jews controled the West
my experience at University in Britain
only enhanced my increasingly radical
beliefs hating Israel was a badge of
honor stag in anti-israel Pro
Palestinian rally and you were sure to
draw a large approving crowd
while at University I decided the
protests and propaganda against Israel
were not enough true Jihad demanded
violence so I made plans to join the
real fight I would leave college and
join a terrorist training camp in
Pakistan but fortunately for me fate
intervened in a
bookstore I came across a book called
The Case for Israel by Harvard Law
Professor Alan dtz the Case for Israel
what case could there be the title
itself made me furious and I began to
read the pages almost as an act of
defiance how ill informed how stupid
could this guy be to defend the
indefensible well he was a Jew that had
to be the answer still I read and what I
read challenged all of my dogmas about
Israel and the Jews I read that it
wasn't Israel that created the
Palestinian refugee crisis it was the
Arab countries the United Nations and
the corrupt pal inian leadership I read
that Jews didn't exploit the Holocaust
to create the state of Israel the
movement to create a modern Jewish State
dated back to the 19th century and
ultimately to the beginnings of the
Jewish people almost 4,000 years ago and
I read that Israel is not engaged in
genocide against the Palestinians on the
contrary the Palestinian population has
actually doubled in just 20 years all
this did was make me angrier I needed to
prove DT's wrong to see with my own eyes
how racist and impressive Israel really
was so I bought a plane ticket I would
travel to Israel the home of my
enemy and that's when everything changed
everything what I saw with my own eyes
was even more challenging than what dtz
had written instead of apartheid I saw
Muslims Christians and Jews coexisting
instead of hate I saw acceptance and
even compassion I saw a rockus modern
liberal democracy full of flaws
certainly but fundamentally decent I saw
a country that wanted nothing more than
to live in peace with its neighbors I
saw my hatred melting before my eyes I
knew right then what I had to do too
many people on this planet are consumed
with the same hatred that consumed me
they have been taught to despise the
Jewish State many Muslims by their
religion many others by their college
professors or student groups so here is
my challenge to anyone who feels this
way do what I did seek out the truth for
yourself if the truth could change me it
can change anyone I'm casim haiz for
Prager
University
