Sources: Figes, Orlando. Crimea: The Last Crusade. New York, NY: Metropolitan Books/Henry Holt and Co., 2010. Kinglake, Alexander W. Invasion of the Crimea. Hansebooks, 2016. Mackenzie, John. "Battle of Inkerman." BritishBattles.com, www.britishbattles.com/crimean-war/battle-of-inkerman/ Mackenzie, John. "Siege of Sevastopol." BritishBattles.com. https://www.britishbattles.com/crimea... Moon, David. “Russian Peasant Volunteers at the Beginning of the Crimean War.” Slavic Review 51, no. 4 (1992): 691–704. doi:10.2307/2500132. Ponting, Clive. The Crimean War: The Truth Behind the Myth. Random House, 2011. Radzinskiĭ, Ėdvard. Alexander II: The Last Great Tsar. New York: Free Press, 2006. Small, Hugh. The Crimean War: Europe's Conflict with Russia. Stroud: The History Press, 2018. Troubetzkoy, Alexis S. A Brief History of the Crimean War: The Causes and Consequences of a Medieval Conflict Fought in a Modern Age. London: Robinson, 2006.
Music: Never Complain, Never Explain by Howard Harper-Barnes The Great War by Jon Bjork Symphony of the Cold-Blooded Dawn Without End by Zach Heyde The Armchair Historian Theme by Zach Heyde No Time Left by Jon Bjork No Going Back by Wendel Scherer Chasing Peace by Miles Avida
If you haven't heard already, the Armchair Historian team is working on a free historical
strategy game, Fire & Maneuver. It's a PC game set between the years 1853 to 1871,
meaning players can take command in conflicts like the Franco-Prussian War and even the Crimean War.
You can follow development using our Discord link below, and you can play the game early by
supporting us on Patreon. Learn more about Fire & Maneuver by checking out our Steam page below,
and don't forget to wishlist!
As a fierce battle rages around them, the Light Brigade of the British Cavalry is preparing to
charge. Though their orders were vague at best, shouted over the din of gun and cannon fire,
the men are ready to ride forth. But unfortunately for these brave soldiers,
their charge will not be wholly remembered as a noble and triumphant action. Instead,
it will go down in history as a monument to the chaos and foolishness of the Crimean War.
Hi, I'm Griffin Johnson, the Armchair Historian. In today's video, we will be re-examining a topic
which we covered in one of the first ever videos on this channel, the Crimean War.
One of the largest and bloodiest European conflicts in the 19th century, the war is
primarily remembered for the disastrous incompetence of the commanders on both sides,
and the ultimate futility of the conflict. But while the immediate consequences were insignificant,
the long-term effects of this conflict altered the course of European history,
and set in motion events that would one day lead to the First World War.
Ever since its foundation in the early 1700s, Imperial Russia had sought control over the
warm water ports on the Black Sea, an area traditionally under the influence of the
Ottoman Empire. Although once considered the menace of all Christian Europe, by the 19th century,
the Ottomans were in a rapid decline. A decline which Russia was eager to exploit.
But after the tumultuous shake-up of the Napoleonic Wars, most other great powers of
Europe desperately wanted to avoid any more disruptions to the balance of power,
creating tension between them and the expansionist Russians. This tension finally boiled over in 1853,
sparked by, of all things, a dispute over the rights of Christians in the Ottoman Empire.
In an effort to project power in the Middle East, France declared itself the protector of
all Christians in the Holy Land, and convinced the Ottoman Sultan, Abdul Majid I, to issue a decree
that the Catholic Church had sole authority over all churches, holy sites, and Christian
citizens in Palestine. This irritated the Eastern Orthodox Church in Russia, which had previously
held control over most of these churches. Of course, neither France nor Russia really cared
about the religious rights of Christians in Palestine. Controlling churches meant projecting
power and influence in the Middle East, a strategic goal of both nations. The French Emperor had
challenged Russia to a game of chicken, and the Ottoman Empire was unlucky enough to find itself
right in the middle of it. Not one to back down, the Russian Tsar Nicholas I promptly sent an
ambassador to the Ottomans in hope of changing the Sultan's mind. This effort succeeded, and the
Sultan promptly restored authority over the churches to the Orthodox Church in Russia.
Expectedly, the highly ambitious French Emperor Napoleon III escalated the situation by sending
a warship into the Black Sea as a show of force, which prompted Abdul Majid to flip-flop once again
and proclaim his eternal respect for the authority of the Catholic Church.
Further negotiations proved fruitless, with the British ambassador to the Ottoman Empire
stepping in to support the Sultan against Russian retaliation. Neither side was willing to back down,
and so in May of 1853, two Russian armies crossed the Prut River and invaded the Balkan provinces
of the Ottoman Empire. Left with no other choice, the Ottomans declared war in response
and sent forces to check the Russian advance at the Danube River. Arriving in September,
the Ottoman Empire quickly moved to establish strongholds along the Danube, under the leadership
of the skilled general Omar Pasha. The first battle of the war took place in early November,
when the Ottomans crossed the river and recaptured the occupied town of Oltenitsa in modern-day
Romania. The Russians launched a counter-attack to reclaim the town, resulting in a bloody and
indecisive battle, which ended with both sides withdrawing to their previous positions.
Fighting in the Balkans would continue in much the same way for the rest of 1853,
with neither side managing to gain a decisive advantage. Tsar Nicholas was hoping for an
announcement of support from Austria, his long-term ally, in order to break this stalemate.
But the Austrians were reluctant to get involved. Instead, they hoped to settle things with the
Mighty Pen, and hosted a conference in Vienna with representatives from France, Britain,
and Prussia, with the goal of drafting a treaty to end the war. While these talks were ongoing,
Russian warships chanced upon an Ottoman fleet near the port of Sinop. Hoping to disrupt their
enemy's supply lines, the Russian ships opened fire initiating battle. This engagement saw the
first ever use of explosive shells in naval combat, which completely devastated the wooden
hulls of the Ottoman ships, inflicting over 3,000 casualties and destroying their entire fleet.
The events at Sinop alarmed the other great powers, and the representatives at Vienna quickly
finalized a proposed peace treaty, which they presented to Sultan Abdul Majid and Tsar Nicholas
in December. Nicholas was willing to accept the terms offered, but the Sultan objected,
and diplomatic talks soon completely broke down. Fighting continued, and in February of 1854,
Britain and France presented an ultimatum to Russia. Withdraw from the Balkans, or they would
But now, Russia refused to back down, and the British and French declared their own war
in March of 1854. Having made no further gains, and fearing the intervention of a dubiously neutral
Austria, Nicholas ordered his forces to withdraw from the Balkan provinces in July. Russia at this
time was one of Austria's most important allies, and so by not supporting the Russians, they found
themselves isolated diplomatically all throughout the 19th century. With hostilities temporarily
ceased, the war could have ended there, but Britain and France, spurred on by pro-war public opinion
and eager to put an end to further Russian expansion, chose to continue the fighting,
launching a full invasion of the Crimean Peninsula. Seizing this peninsula would cripple
Russia's naval power in the Black Sea, greatly reducing their influence in the Middle East and
Balkans. The Allied forces landed at a beach north of the city of Sevastopol in September,
and their troubles began almost immediately. The landing of the invasion force was badly mismanaged.
For starters, there was no equipment for the unloading of cargo, forcing the soldiers to
During this piecemeal unloading process, the soldiers were forced to sleep
outside in the rain and heat due to the lack of tents and camping supplies. To make matters even
worse, there was not enough food or water to go around, nor enough medicine to treat the many men
who came down with cholera and other diseases. After four days, the invasion force finally
overcame this comedy of errors and set out for Sevastopol. On the first day of their march,
the Allied forces got their first glimpse of the Russian army, assembled on a hill on the other
side of the Alma River. The next morning, they crossed the river and attacked the Russians,
beginning the Battle of Alma. The defenders were outnumbered, with 37,500 men standing against the
strong invasion force, but the Russians held a strong defensive position on a steep hill.
They held out against three hours of repeated assaults by the Ottomans, British, and French
before withdrawing. However, the Allied forces were unable to pursue them due to their lack of
cavalry. Following the battle, the invading army marched southeast to the coast, encircling
Sevastopol and establishing temporary ports at the towns of Balaklava and Kamysh to bring in
supplies. In October, they began to besiege the city with cannon brought in by sea, although
further widespread outbreaks of cholera weakened the British army, emboldening the defenders to
launch several probing attacks. On October 25th, the Russians attempted a large-scale assault on
the British position at Balaklava, sending 25,000 men to disrupt the Allied supply chain between
their ports and the siege lines. The first line of defenses at the Vorontsov Heights, manned by the
Ottomans, was quickly overwhelmed, and the Russian cavalry then swept down the hill toward the second
defensive line in the valley to the south. There, a combined force of Ottoman and British infantry
managed to hold the line against the enemy cavalry charge, in a defense that would come to
be known as the Thin Red Line. On the northern side of the hill, the British cavalry's Light
Brigade was sent to intercept Russian forces, attempting to withdraw after seizing Ottoman
artillery guns captured on the heights. But this order, relayed verbally through multiple sources
in something like a game of telephone, was ultimately misinterpreted by the Light Brigade's
commanders, who sent the Light Cavalry charging down the valley straight into the teeth of a dug-in
Russian artillery regiment. The resulting charge of the Light Brigade was a complete failure, and
left over a third of the brigade's soldiers killed, wounded, or captured, and over a half of its horses
dead. Shortly thereafter, the Russian forces pulled back to their newly captured defensive positions
at the Vorontsov Heights, and the battle came to an end. While the siege of Sevastopol would continue,
the Russians had won a tactical and morale-boosting victory at Balaklava, in large
part thanks to the disorganization of their enemies. This disorganization and incompetence
at the command level would continue to plague the Allied forces for the rest of the war,
preventing them from gaining significant ground. After the inconclusive battle of Balaklava,
Russian strategists believed that their enemy's supply lines were overextended and vulnerable
to attack. On November 5th, the Russians gathered a force of 42,000 men to assault the British near
the village of Inkerman, with the goal of breaking through their defenses before reinforcements could
arrive. Advancing in the early hours of the morning, the attackers were hidden by a thick fog
as they approached the British defenses at a hill called Home Ridge. The French and British defenders
on and around Home Ridge numbered only around 13,000, less than a third of the size of the
Russian army bearing down on them. Fighting began at dawn, when the Russian general Fedor Soymanov
sent around 15,000 men to assault the ridge, which in the early stages of battle was defended
by just 2,700 men of the British 2nd Division. However, British forward defenses in the valley
did catch sight of the Russians advancing through the fog and opened fire, alerting the men of the
2nd Division to attack. But due to this fog, the defenders on Home Ridge had no idea how outnumbered
they truly were. Emboldened by their ignorance, the acting commander of the 2nd Division,
Major General John Pennyfeather, ordered the entire force to advance down the hill and meet
the Russians head-on. The Russians attempted to soften up the defenders by bombarding Home Ridge
with artillery. However, they didn't realize that the 2nd Division was no longer on the hill. They
didn't become aware of the impending counterattack until the British soldiers emerged from the fog
right in front of them, and fighting began almost immediately. The Russians attempted to break
through on the 2nd Division's left flank but were pushed back, their outdated flintlock muskets
completely outmatched by the British Enfield percussion lock rifles. In the fighting that
followed, Soyminov, the Russian general, was killed and swiftly replaced by another officer
who was then promptly shot and killed too, followed by a third commander who survived
for a few minutes and then was killed too. At this point, the remaining Russian officers were
understandably reluctant to take charge and so promptly withdrew to regroup as British
reinforcements poured in. Once a second column of Russian troops arrived in assistance, the Tsar's
men shifted their focus to the northeast, where the British had set up a defensive wall called
the Barrier. 15,000 men advanced on the Barrier, which was being held by only 300 troops.
Channeling their inner Spartans, these 300 men affixed bayonets and vaulted over the wall to
charge at the Russian army. With the fog still hampering visibility on both sides,
the bayonet charge caused enough confusion among the Russians to halt their advance,
giving enough time for reinforcements to arrive and attack the Russian's flank,
forcing them to withdraw. Still not knowing exactly what was going on, the Imperial Russian
army gathered up for one final push on Home Ridge. The fighting was fierce and hectic,
with the dense haze forcing many units on both sides to act completely on their own initiative,
cut off from their allies, which would eventually earn the Battle of Anchorman the nickname
The Soldier's Battle. Just as the British defenders began to falter, the timely arrival of
French reinforcements allowed them to hold back the Russians and ultimately drive them away from
Home Ridge, bringing the battle to an end. At the end of the day, approximately one-third of the
Allied and Russian soldiers fighting in the battle had been killed, wounded, or captured.
The demoralized survivors retreated back behind the walls of Sevastopol, and the Allied forces
dug in for a long siege. The bitter cold of the ensuing winter coupled with severe supply shortages
among the besiegers soon led to a halt in ground operations. A massive storm in late November
destroyed 30 Allied transport ships, many carrying crucial winter clothing and other supplies,
which led to thousands of deaths of hypothermia and disease. The Russians made one more attempt
to break out of the siege in February of 1855, attacking an Ottoman base at the town of Eupatoria,
north of Sevastopol. Heavy artillery from the Ottomans' well-fortified positions
forced the Russians back, and the attack was called off after just three hours of fighting.
The assault on Eupatoria was the last major Russian effort to break the siege,
but the miserable struggle for Sevastopol was far from over. In March, British contractors
completed the construction of the Grand Crimean Central Railway, a rail line built to quickly
bring ammunition and supplies from the ships to the siege lines. The railway allowed the Allies
to intensify their bombardments of the city, but it did little to stave off the waves of disease
running rampant through their camps, killing tens of thousands. The flagging morale of the Allied
forces was bolstered somewhat by the arrival of 18,000 fresh troops from the Kingdom of Sardinia,
whose king hoped to strengthen his alliance with France. The Sardinian troops provided
welcome support, but even so, when Sevastopol finally fell on September 9th, both sides were
utterly exhausted, and no further operations were conducted in Crimea before the next winter
arrived. Further east, the Russians and Ottomans continued battering against each other in the
Caucasus, where small and inconclusive engagements had been fought throughout the war. While a handful
of towns and forts in the region changed hands, neither side was able to make any decisive gains
on that front. This trend was reflected across many other fronts, with inconclusive skirmishes
taking place in the Azov Sea, the Baltic, and even Russia's Pacific coast. By late 1855, after years
of bloody and pointless fighting, both sides were thoroughly sick of the war. The British public
especially, fed up with reports of fiascos like the Charge of the Light Brigade and the staggering
death toll from disease during the Siege of Sevastopol, began to demand an immediate end to
the conflict. New technologies like the telegram and photography were making the truth about the
horrors of war more accessible to the average citizen than ever before, contributing to an
unprecedented public outcry. Although the new British Prime Minister, Lord Palmerston, had great
ambitions of expanding the war and permanently crippling the Russian Empire, pressure from the
and his French allies eventually forced him to agree to peace talks. On the Russian side, the
new Tsar Alexander II felt pressured to make peace after Austria, Prussia, and Sweden began showing
signs that they might be willing to join the war on the Allies' side. Thus, on March 30th, 1856,
the Treaty of Paris was signed and brought the Crimean War to an end. The treaty essentially
amounted to a status quo, restoring orthodox control of the churches in Palestine, forcing
Russia and the Ottomans to return to each other's captured territories, and banning any nation from
maintaining warships or fortified ports in the Black Sea. This clause of the treaty was later
ignored by the Russians in 1871, after the fall of Napoleon III in France caused the French to lose
interest in Eastern geopolitics. Six years later, in 1877, the Russian Empire attacked the Ottomans
again, this time claiming territory in the Caucasus and securing the independence of Bulgaria
and other Balkan states without much outside interference. As Russia simply went back and
took what it had been after in the first place, many in Europe were left wondering what the point
of the Crimean War had been. Ultimately, the only tangible outcome of the Crimean War was a
tremendous loss of life on both sides. Around 165,000 of all Allied troops died, and almost 120,000
of those died of disease. The Russians lost 130,000, 89,000 of which were to disease. In Britain,
the public was outraged by the strategic and logistical failures at all levels of command
during the war, and widespread calls began for sweeping reforms of the army and greater
professionalism in the medical field in particular. The demands for army reforms were ultimately
blocked, but the push for medical reform, spurred on by the famous battlefield nurses Florence
Nightingale and Mary Seacole, were much more successful, leading to the development of
professional nursing in Britain and improving healthcare for all British society. In Russia,
the embarrassment of defeat prompted a major push for modernization across all sectors of society
in order to catch up with the rest of Europe. The wave of reforms in the years following the
Crimean War included the abolishment of serfdom, expansion of rail and telegraph networks,
modernization of medicine, and the reorganization and modernization of the army. The Crimean War
exposed some of the most devastating flaws of the established ways of waging war in Europe,
prompting major efforts to modernize on both sides. This push towards technological dominance
contributed to the rise of nationalism in Russia, an ideology which would profoundly impact the
nation's foreign policy for the rest of the 19th century. Further Russian interference in the
Balkans would later give rise to nationalist sentiments in that volatile region, escalating
tensions that would eventually boil over into the assassination of an Austrian prince in 1914.
In many ways, the Crimean War was the first small domino in the chain leading up to the World Wars.