Lecture 5 focuses on the female gaze -- with women as both patrons and artists -- during the age of Marie Antoinette, primarily. Another underlying theme in the video is the chronological progression of Neoclassicism during the 1770s. The video starts with the artistic choices of Madame du Barry (King Louis XV's mistress) as patron; discusses Marie Antoinette's arrival in France and accession to the throne as wife of Louis XVI; further brings Marie-Antoinette to life through a look at her portraits, her role as "fashion icon," and her patronage of newly conceived outdoor spaces (at Trianon and the Queen's Hamlet, particularly); and finally, touches on new ideas about breastfeeding. The female artists who have the spotlight in this lecture -- and who fulfilled commissions for both Du Barry and Marie-Anoinette -- include Vigée-Lebrun and Labille-Guiard.
Content of Video 00:00 - Intro 02:19 - Madame du Barry 04:35 - Zamor 06:56 - Louveciennes Pavillion and Fragonard's Progress of Love 12:50 - Louis XVI and Serious History Painting 14:14 - Angelica Kauffmann and 'Zeuxis Choosing' Models (the beau idéal) 18:35 - Marie Antoinette - Intro & Reputation 25:36 - Pouf Hairdo 29:11 - Vigée-Lebrun, Court Painter 35:36 - Rose Bertin, Fashion Designer 37:17 - Petit Trianon and the Queen's Hamlet 43:13 - Furniture & Interior Design 44:30 - Motherhood & Breastfeeding 49:21 - Vigée-Lebrun's Portrait of Marie-Antoinette with Her Children 51:08 - Vigée-Lebrun's Self-Portraits 52:07 - Labille-Guiard
This is the fifth lecture in the course Styling Identity and Ideology in an Age of Riches and
Revolution, Rococo and Neoclassical Art in France and its Caribbean Colonies, 1748 to 1815.
The subject of lecture five is the female gaze, women at the easel, women at the court.
I have noted that 18th century France has been called the century of women,
and we have spent a lot of time looking at influential figures like Madame de Pompadour.
Today's lecture on the female gaze further considers women in the role of patrons and
influencers of art and fashion, as well as women in the role of painters. For a change,
we will be looking at the world almost exclusively through their eyes in this lecture,
which puts the spotlight on Madame du Barry, Marie-Antoinette, Vigée Lebrun, and L'habit
I will begin with Madame du Barry, but to best understand some of her contributions,
I must intersperse elements on the larger development of neoclassicism,
whose origins we covered in depth in the previous lecture. The acceptance of early neoclassicism as
a style preferential to the predominant Rococo created a push and pull among people of taste.
You may remember that there was a call for, and artistic aspiration towards,
serious grand manner painting. However, when the superintendent of the king's buildings,
the Marquis de Marigny, had ordered a series of history paintings on the subject of ancient Roman
imperial benevolence during the refurbishing of the royal Château de Choisy, Louis XV rejected them,
including Vianne's Marcus Aurelius. Even critics thought the works exhibited at the 1765 Salon
were a failure, but that's not the end of the story. Let's take a look at how, in a later turn
of events, Madame du Barry rejected Fragonard's Rococo artwork for her Pavillon de Louisienne
and replaced it with Vianne's neoclassical approach. As the influential mistress of Louis XV,
Madame du Barry was one of those figurative queens that Vigée Le Prince quote referred to.
Born Jeanne Bécu, she came from a humbler background than Madame de Pompadour, being the
illegitimate daughter of a seamstress. She received a convent education thanks to her mother's employer.
Incidentally, she met the future painter Adélaïde Labille while working in the Labille haberdashery
shop. Eventually, she became the mistress of a casino owner named du Barry who, rather than
being jealous and proprietary, fostered her career as a courtesan. She began seeing the king while
also satisfying those in the highest circles at the court. Their relationship had no need for
exclusivity. The king was himself being satisfied by plenty of other women since his sexual relations
with Madame de Pompadour ended, although he had yet to give any of these passing young women the
title of royal mistress. Jeanne married her lover du Barry's brother, a count, in order to get or
really to falsify a noble title, which made her eligible to become the official mistress of the
king, as she did in 1768. Madame du Barry was extravagant, triumphant at the court, and influential
in art and politics. Her portrait here, dated to 1770, is by François Hubert Drouet, himself son
of a painter and in turn father to the better-known painter and people of David, Jean Germain Drouet,
whom we shall encounter later. There's not anything like a real neoclassical aesthetic here,
except perhaps in the plain background. Madame du Barry would have a contentious relationship with
who married into the royal family in 1770. Four years later, when Louis XV died of smallpox,
du Barry was exiled from both Versailles and Louveciennes, although she was eventually permitted
to return to a fairly luxurious life there. She had a Bengali slave, an unusual extravagance even
at Versailles, named Zamor. He was captured at the age of 11 in what is the current nation of
Bangladesh in 1773. Despite the illegality of slavery on French soil, British slave traders
trafficked him into France and sold him to the French king, who gave the adolescent to his
official mistress. This anonymous portrait on the left has been identified as possibly representing
Zamor. However, for a long time, the unidentified boy we see here on the right, through the eyes of
the female painter, Marie-Victoire Lemoine, was presumed to be Zamor. But this doesn't quite look
like the 23-year-old young man he would have been in 1785. Moreover, the sitter has African rather
than Southeast Asian features, although the possibility remains that Zamor belonged to the
To quote the website of the Kummer Museum where the work is housed,
it is clear that Lemoine created a vivid likeness of this youth, whose elegant satin attire and
embroidered vest indicate his connection with a noble family. One can easily imagine that Zamor
looked quite similar shortly after his arrival in France. In any case, the adolescent Zamor was
educated by Dubachy, who treated him as something of a foster son, despite looking down on him as
an inferior. He developed a taste for Rousseau, which certainly fed his natural inclination towards
independence, and later, his support of the revolution and his Jacobin affiliation.
Increasing in his hatred for his employer, he denounced her to the police and was dismissed
from her service. He continued to seek her takedown, and eventually she was permanently
arrested and put on trial in 1793. Perhaps tragically, her cupidity led the 50-year-old
former mistress of the king to return to France from one of several stays in England
and try to secure her landed goods, at a time when the revolution was clearly becoming radical.
Sentenced to death, Dubachy would lose her head under the blade of the guillotine the same year
Let's return to happier times at Louveciennes. The chateau is about 20 miles outside Paris,
similar to Versailles. Louis XV offered it as a gift to Madame Dubachy.
What interests us is not the chateau, although it was expanded and redecorated by
Ange Jacques Gabriel for Madame Dubachy, but the music, or reception pavilion,
consisting of just four rooms, which was itself constructed by Claude Nicolas Ledoux from 1770-71.
So how would you describe Ledoux's garden façade? Quite neoclassical. Ledoux was, in fact,
one of the earliest and best exponents of the neoclassical style and architecture.
The columns are in the Ionic style, one of the three canonic orders of classical architecture,
though it may seem above reproach to us, Ledoux's Ionic peristyle was actually criticized by less
innovative royal architects. Louis XV was moderate in his praise, merely remarking,
not bad, when he saw the peristyle. On the interior, in the game room,
you can also appreciate the pared-down classicizing decorations, with relief panels in a neat
simple style, and pilasters with gilded capitals. Fragonard was commissioned to paint a series of
canvases with the theme of the four moments of love, and known as the progress of love in the
heart of a young woman. Fragonard executed these four large paintings, measuring over 10 feet high
each, between 1771 and 73. The series depicts four episodes in the courtship of a couple in a stately
garden setting. These include the pursuit, the surprise, or the meeting, shown at right, the lover
crowned, and the love letter. Several smaller pictures, including overdoors, were later added
to the ensemble. The meeting has an almost bursting visual energy to it, in the tense moment where the
lover climbs into this walled garden setting, causing the alarmed young lady to look back and
make sure his presence will not be discovered. The love letter has a more subdued, intimate, quiet,
and truly tender energy. The sculpture on the far right is based on Pajoux's statue of Madame
du Barry, called Fidelity, and the dog who appears in this scene is a common symbol of fidelity.
There is an incredible feeling of space, with the foliage once again providing an important
compositional element and adding to the symbolic meaning of the work, since we might discern the
shape of a heart. In fact, all the vegetation seems to enclose the couple in a gentle embrace.
Despite the great beauty of Fragonard's works, and the fact that he was paid for them, they were
rejected by Madame du Barry and returned to the artist. Although the precise reason cannot be known,
what we do know is that the replacement commission went to Vien, thus transferring
the privileging of a rococo idiom to a neoclassical one. Vien's series, executed in 1773, explored the
same theme and included its own image of a lover crowning his mistress. Other individual panels
differed slightly and included such titles as Greek maidens decorating sleeping Cupid with flowers.
Today, they seem insipid and uninspired by comparison to Fragonard's, although the use of
antique dress, rather than the pastoralizing 18th century fashion of Fragonard's work,
anticipates a new vogue while ushering out an old one. We will remember that, despite the earlier
criticism of his Marcus Aurelius, Vien had achieved success at the Salon with works in an
already pictorially neoclassical idiom that, nonetheless, largely preserved rococo themes.
Meanwhile, Fragonard was no longer exhibiting at the Salon. His last one was in 1767, where he
showed only two small pictures just after making a sensation with a large history painting at the
previous Salon in 1765. Diderot was highly critical, calling a pink and yellow canvas
of Cupid's wheeling in the sky an omelet of children. Ouch! In any case, as we have seen
and will continue to see, Fragonard was far better suited to intimate private commissions than to
history paintings worthy of the Salon anyway. Let's turn to some history and continue our
story about the neoclassical development so we have a better context for our ladies.
Louis XVI, or Louis XVI, succeeded his grandfather in 1774 and ruled until the
French Revolution brought an end to his life, as well as his reign. Although I'm sure you're eager
to get to his more famous wife, Marie Antoinette, let's view a couple of changes that further shift
the style away from rococo. First of all, Don Givillet was named superintendent of the king's
buildings at the accession of Louis XVI in 1774 and held the position for 15 years until 1789.
He followed Marigny's ideas of elevating history painting. Don Givillet announced that he and the
king intended to systematize the commissioning of history painting. Each year, artists would
be assigned four or five history pictures illustrating both ancient and French history,
ultimately comprising a series of, quote, actions and deeds honorable to the French nation.
His program linked broad moralistic categories, such as an act of unselfishness among the Greeks,
to particular subjects with new commissions from 1776 forward. The first group appeared at the
and included Brené's Caius Furius Cressimus, accused of sorcery, and La Grenée's Fabricius
Lucius, refusing the gifts of Pyrrhus. They are both depictions of ancient Roman virtue
and became popular subjects for neoclassical painters. At this time, not all virtuous history
paintings need come from Greco-Roman antiquity, although the latter did come to predominate.
For example, the same combination of moralizing subject with an intended accuracy of setting and
costume occurred in a medieval scene in Brené's Death and Honors of the Constable Duguesclin.
It represented a hero of the Hundred Years' War who had reconquered much of France from the English
when he died of illness in 1380. Such was his honor that he was buried at Saint-Denis in the
A Swiss painter in Rome, Angelica Kaufmann, would pick up on this moralizing trend of history
painting around the same time David did, and I will discuss her work in that vein in more depth
when we get to Davidian neoclassicism, but since her career began at this time, I'd like to introduce
her here and tell the story of her rather colorful life. Born and raised in Switzerland, Angelica
spent her teenage years and early 20s in Italy. Eventually making her way to Rome, she met
Winckelmann and painted his portrait. After receiving commissions from English painters,
she moved to London in 1765. In 1767, she married a man who was exposed as an imposter and bigamist
a year later and separated from him without divorcing. She became close friends and probably
lovers with Joshua Reynolds, a painter 20 years her senior who was actually a proponent of the
Grand Manor in Britain, as well as the first president of the British Royal Academy. Despite
his importance in English painting, since our focus is on France and the most direct influences
on French neoclassicism, I won't be discussing his work. In 1769, Angelica joined the earliest
members of the Royal Academy, one of two women to hold that position. From that time until 1782,
Kaufmann exhibited annually at the RA, often sending female-centered classical or allegorical
subjects as well as some portraits. When her estranged husband died in 1781, she married
Antonio Zulci, an Italian artist, and then moved back to Rome with him. There, she met Goethe and
painted his portrait in 1787. She died in Rome at the age of 66. This work from 1778 still has a
rather rococo quality, despite the frieze-like disposition of figures from left to right
in virtually one plane, the antique costumes, and of course, the subject matter. I do want to take
a moment to discuss the subject of this painting, Zucs's choosing models for his painting of Helen
of Troy, for it encapsulates the neoclassical theory of the beau ideal. The subject comes from
Pliny, who was writing in the 1st century CE about a Greek painter of the 5th century BC.
Accordingly, I always tell this story in my Greek and Roman art class as well. As the story goes,
Zucs wanted to paint a picture of Helen of Troy, who was renowned as the most beautiful mortal
woman to have lived. While searching for a model for this perfect beauty, he realized he could not
find a woman beautiful enough to pose as Helen, and so instead, he selected the finest features
of five different models to create a composite image of ideal beauty. In essence, this was the
neoclassical approach to figure drawing, and sometimes nature in general. Although nature is
the point of departure for neoclassicism, for a certain sense of correctness or trueness to real-life
experience is necessary for a convincing and pleasing composition, the beau ideal refers to a
type of beauty or excellence that is so ideal that it almost becomes a supernatural beauty.
That's to say, perfection doesn't really exist in nature, but there may be close enough approximations
to it. After all, perfection is an abstract concept and may be considered subjective.
On the other hand, according to Plato's philosophy, for example, the idea itself an ideal is inherent
in all of nature's forms, but none absolutely reaches this ideal. Even so, neoclassical artists
won't typically depict the most realistic men and women, but rather the idea of the perfect man and
woman embodied in the perfect form. At the risk of digressing into an unresolvable theoretical
discussion, let it suffice to say that one of the hallmarks of neoclassicism is its search for
ideal beauty. The next half of our lecture combines depictions of the women of the French court,
most notably Marie Antoinette, with the women painters who painted them. We should start by
reviewing some of the basics of Marie Antoinette's life. She was an Austrian princess with the title
of archduchess from the Habsburg dynasty, which ruled in Austria. So she was actually German by
language and culture. In 1770, when she was 14 years old, she was sent to France to marry Louis,
himself only 15, and Dauphin of France, meaning he was heir to the throne. Meeting for the first
time at their wedding, these two strangers and virginal adolescents were expected to enter
immediately into a conjugal relationship. Young Louis was next in line for the throne of France
since his father had died five years earlier. Luckily, his grandfather seemed to be in good
health in his early 60s when the couple married. However, Louis XV died unexpectedly of smallpox in
1774, thus making young Louis king at the age of 19 and Marie Antoinette queen at age 18. Louis XVI
was a reluctant king. It was a job he didn't expect to get so young and one that he, by his own words,
felt less suited for than his younger brother. Louis XVI inherited a financial crisis that in
the 15 years of his reign before the revolution, he failed to ameliorate. But we can talk more
about that when we cover the French Revolution. Queen Marie Antoinette is seen on the bottom left
and in the detail in the center in her official coronation picture by Gautier d'Agouti in 1775.
For a more personal portrait, though still full-length, she selected a female artist who
was really only at the start of her career. Here are Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun's retrospective words
I did her portrait for the first time when she was in the full brilliance of her youth
and beauty. Marie Antoinette was tall, admirably figured, neither too thin or too plump. Her arms
were superb, her hands small and perfect in form, and her feet charming. She was the woman of France
who walked the best, holding her head up high, with a majesty that made her immediately recognizable
as the queen among her court, but a majesty that did not diminish at all the sweet,
kind aspect of her face. Actually, it's very difficult to give someone who has never met the
queen an idea of so much grace and nobility. From her family, she had inherited the long,
narrow, oval face particular to the Austrian nation. Her eyes were almost blue. But what was
most striking about her face was the brilliance of her complexion. I couldn't render the effect
as I wished. I lacked the colors to paint that freshness, those delicate tones which I've seen
in no other woman. The painter goes on to say that she was immediately intimidated,
but the queen's manner put her at ease. Vigée-Lebrun remained Marie Antoinette's favorite
portraitist. These two works show the pouf hairdo that was fashionable in the 1770s.
Hair would reach astounding heights. Before we talk about her extravagant hairdo further,
maybe we should touch on Marie Antoinette's rather notorious reputation.
Many think of her as the frivolous queen who, in response to the notification that her subjects
were starving on the brink of the revolution, said, let them eat cake. But what is the reality?
The reality is that Marie Antoinette never made that comment. The quote, attributed by Rousseau
to a grand princess, is actually recorded in his confessions written well before his death in 1778
but not published in full until the 1780s, when the public was persecuting the queen in the social
media of their time. She was called l'Autrichienne, a derogatory reference to her Austrian heritage,
and Madame de Ficite, as if her expenditures were responsible for the country's financial crisis.
Columnius' rumors that her extravagance knew no bounds led to her being implicated in the so-called
affair of the diamond necklace, a complex intrigue that speaks more to the will of
her enemies and to the credulity of the public than to reality. Of course, we are far more easily
convinced of a salacious story than we can be persuaded that what we've been told and have
believed to be true is actually a lie. Besides, myths may be more compelling than reality,
especially when you need an excuse to chop off somebody's head. In reality, the extravagance of
Marie Antoinette and Louis' predecessors at Versailles was more extreme than their own.
Certainly, the luxury continued, but it was a bit more restrained under Louis XVI.
Despite his reputation as an inept king, he had an inquisitive and sensible mind,
as well as a responsible and naturally temperate, almost puritanical character.
While it is true that the queen was much more interested in pleasure than Louis,
her frivolousness is somewhat excusable. Given her great youth—she was 19 when she acceded to
the throne—given her lack of sexual pleasure with her husband—apparently, her poor and experienced
young husband was unable to fully consummate their marriage for the first seven years of
their union—and given the temptations of the luxurious court of Versailles all around her.
Waiting to become a mother, she had no function as queen, and thus amused herself with games,
gambling, entertainments, and fashion. The people, especially as their own misery increased,
turned against her for these reasons, and also because she was a foreigner.
Austria was one of France's traditional enemies in Europe. They alternately mocked
Louis or cursed the queen for the couple's inability to produce an heir. By the time
she had a child—a daughter—shortly after Vigée Le Brun's portrait was done in 1778,
the damage was done. Accusations of affairs, orgies, lesbianism, with crude pamphlets,
cartoons, and songs continued unabated. It hurt the queen, but her fatal flaw was perhaps
her pride. Certainly, despite never having suggested that the starving poor eat cake,
she had an insurmountable optics problem. But in 1778, she was still largely carefree,
stepping into her role as a fashion icon. Absolutely fabulous.
The pouf is the brainchild of Léonard, as the queen's favorite hairdresser is generally known.
His career at the court actually began with Madame du Barry, but apparently Marie-Antoinette
didn't hold that against him, since he was styling both the ladies' hair when Louis XV
was still king, and Marie-Antoinette a dauphine. Although the Duchess of Chartres was the first
to showcase Léonard's pouf, Marie-Antoinette, who became queen shortly after this debut,
brought it to its height of popularity, pun intended. As for Léonard, he and the queen's
dressmaker, Rose Bertin, were, quote, like two good sisters, and both worked well with the queen,
as we shall see. He would remain a royalist during the revolutionary era. The pouf was not a fixed
style, but rather a virtual tower of hair that could be ornamented with all sorts of thematic
motifs, and not just jewels, pearls, and plumage, but also mechanical birds with flapping wings,
fruits, floral gardens with little irrigation systems to keep them fresh, and model ships if
the right occasion called for it. There was even a pouf for the occasion of the king's inoculation
against smallpox in 1774. These satirical prints indicate just how involved the elaboration of the
pouf might be, and of course the wigs would be heavily powdered as well. As exaggerated as these
images may seem, there were documented examples of poufs reaching over a meter in height and 11 pounds
in weight. Another anonymous print called At the Café Royal d'Alexandre, The Burning of the Coiffures,
and dating to around 1780, shows a possible hazard of such a towering hairdo in the age of candlelight.
To the amusement of viewers, a great lady's wig has caught fire as it brushed against the candle
holder, and she remains absolutely oblivious as her servants frantically attend to the flames.
Since the cost of wigs could skyrocket to 50,000 pounds, there was another hazard, and that was for
the royal treasurers, namely overspending on the part of the queen, and with it earning public
disapproval. Marie Antoinette maintained a detailed correspondence with her mother Maria
Teresa, the empress of Austria, and you can imagine that given Marie Antoinette's tender age on arriving
in France, her mother still sought to instruct her and admonish her on her faults. To quote the
empress, I can't help touching on a point that many gazettes repeat to me too often, it's the hair
adornment that you sport. They say it's 36 inches high and covered with feathers and ribbons. You
know that I was always of the opinion that one should follow the changing fashions moderately,
but never push them to the extreme. A young and pretty queen full of charms doesn't need such
follies. Au contraire, the simplicity of the hairdo puts you in a better light and is more suitable to
the rank of queen. It is she who must set the tone, and all will rush to follow, even your little faults.
But even when the queen mellowed in her extravagance in her late 20s and early 30s,
as she became a mother, she couldn't catch a break. We'll see how in another set of portraits by
Vigée Lebrun. But first let me talk about the artist herself. Elisabeth Vigée Lebrun was born into a
family of good social status who had all the means to send her to a convent for her education.
There, she discovered her true calling, art, as she found herself drawing endlessly and everywhere.
In fact, she was following in the footsteps of her father, who was a pasteliste and a painter.
Her parents fully supported her endeavor to make a career as an artist, and she passed from studying
to taking commissions very quickly. Sadly, her father died when she was still a teenager, but her
career was taking off, and in her memoirs, she noted that she attracted a lot of attention in society
for her beauty, and implied that this helped her gain commissions. She trained and socialized with
another female, a year older than she was, who gave a painting when she got married, at a young age.
An important side note for what direction a young woman's life might take. But being a woman didn't
seem to impede Elisabeth Vigée at all. Her early success, and the ease with which she earned a
living through portraiture from a young age, contrasts with the poor condition of the artist
who trained her in his home. These portraits show what an excellent painter she was from her teenage
years. She married the painter and art dealer Lebrun at the age of 20, not wanting to, but
responding to pressure from her mother. She mentioned that she did not want to give up her
maiden name, saying that it was already known. Hence, Vigée Lebrun. Her husband's poor reputation
was known to her too late, and she suffered from his habit of carousing with women and losing
prodigious sums of money gambling. This loss of money caused her to open an art school for young
women, but she didn't enjoy it, since it took away from her own artistic practice, and she soon gave
it up. Marie Benoît, whose work we shall see in a later lecture, was one of her outstanding pupils.
She had her first and only child, a daughter, after two years of marriage in 1780, and wrote
that she painted all through her pregnancy. She became a member of the Académie in 1783,
despite objections from Pierre, first painter to the king, solely on account of her sex,
although other women were starting to be admitted as members around this time. This self-portrait
with a straw hat was inspired by a visit to Belgium, and particularly by the work of Rubens.
She reported that it enhanced her reputation when exhibited at the Salon. In fact, it was this and
other works that had prompted Joseph Vernet to propose her as a member of the Académie.
On the other hand, her portraiture was criticized for open-mouthed smiles that showed teeth.
On the grounds that there were no antique precedents. We haven't quite arrived there yet,
but by 1782, David had ushered in a mode of neoclassicism that revered antiquity.
In her memoirs, Vigée Lebrun takes credit for sparking this vogue among women of the court
for sporting straw hats. Thus we see Madame du Barry, two of Marie Antoinette's closest friends,
and the queen's sister-in-law, Elizabeth of France. You'll notice that the pouf is gone.
Well, fashions do come and go. Another feature they all have in common is the creole-style
white cotton dress. And this brings us to the portrait of Marie Antoinette in a muslim dress.
Here, the queen has a completely new look, a new attitude. But it was still a scandal.
Why do you suppose that was the case? Critics believed the look was too informal, too intimate.
They thought it lacked distinction. The queen cannot dress like the other courtiers,
who themselves were dressing in a way approximate to the common people.
It may be the height of irony that Marie Antoinette, who had been decried for bankrupting
the state through her extravagant attire, was now bitterly accused of popularizing inexpensive
clothes and thereby ruining the Lyon silk manufacturers. Moreover, although fully
covered, she was accused of wearing too little, since a simple cotton dress didn't require the
typical layers of undergarments and padding. The reaction to this work was so adverse that
had to be pulled from the salon in order to avoid further scandal. It was replaced by
Marie Antoinette à la rose, which certainly shows the queen in much more regal attire,
certainly in Lyon silk. Vigée Le Brun stated that she preferred to paint the queen, who was the same
age as herself, in the informal way of the muslim dress portrait, rather than in grand pomp.
Madame Vigée Le Brun had a nice long life, and another excerpt from her memoirs suggests a unique
relationship between art, and particularly the art of portraiture in the eye of the artist,
and fashion. Looking back at the pre-revolutionary era, she wrote,
Since I detested the type of clothing women wore at that time, I made all possible effort to make
it a bit more picturesque, and I was delighted when I obtained the confidence of my models to
drape them as I wished. No one was wearing shawls yet, but I would arrange large scarves loosely
wrapped around the body and arms, thereby attempting to imitate the beautiful style of
the draperies of Raphael and Domenichino. What's more, I couldn't stand the use of powder. I
managed to get the lovely Duchess of Cremont-Cadrous to not wear any powder while having herself
painted. Her hair was of an ebony black. I separated it around her forehead, arranging it
in irregular curls. After our sitting, which finished at dinnertime, the Duchess didn't
disturb her hairdo, and went like that to the theater. Such a pretty woman must have set the
tone. This fashion took hold gradually before eventually becoming generally accepted.
But fashion had its famous high-end designers in the 18th century, when an early form of haute
couture can be said to have started. Rose Bertin, dressmaker to Marie-Antoinette, is in fact often
credited as the first haute couturière. Bertin's critics derisively called her the minister of
fashion, to mock the importance that fashion took in the royal court. Bertin met Marie-Antoinette
in 1772, and after the latter became queen in 1774, she met with her twice a week to present
the latest fashions. Marie-Antoinette, a great fashion enthusiast, was also discerning and
detail-oriented. And far from being merely a muse, the queen probably deserves some credit for helping
to shape the vision of Bertin. Additionally, she encouraged Rose Bertin and Léonard to revive the
French fashion magazine, the Journal des Dames, by funding the venture. Rose Bertin, having one of the
most famous models to outfit with her creations, became the leading fashion designer for the French
aristocracy at large. In fact, the first fashion plates newly introduced at this time might feature
Marie-Antoinette, even if she never wore the clothes, in order to sell them better. And since this was
also at a time when French fashion predominated in Europe, Bertin's influence had a far reach.
Rose Bertin also enjoyed a close personal relationship with Marie-Antoinette,
who used both dress and hair as a personal vehicle for expression. The queen also had very personal
taste when it came to her preferred ambiance. To flesh out some details of her personality,
it would be useful to know that Antoinette hated the formal etiquette of Versailles.
Though she had been raised as a princess in an imperial court, that court lacked the extreme
protocols, rigid hierarchies, and pompousness of the French court, and she found it all quite
stifling. Her first means of escape was when Louis XVI, newly king, offered her the Petit Trianon,
a seven-roomed pavilion on the vast grounds of Versailles that Louis XV had built for Madame de
Pompadour. A slightly larger and elaborate variation of the classicizing type of facade
we have seen on the Douze pavilion at Louveciennes, whose construction started shortly after it was
finished, the Petit Trianon was designed by Gabrielle. There, said the queen, she could
be herself. She immediately endeavored to spruce up the grounds around the Petit Trianon.
Thus, from 1775 to 78, a so-called Temple of Love, designed by Meek, was erected in a fully
fabricated English-style garden. Designed à l'antique as neoclassicism took greater hold in France,
the open-air temple featured 12 fluted alabaster Corinthian columns and fine decoration.
At the center was placed a copy, by Mouchy, of Bouchardon's 1750 statue, Cupid Fashioning His Bow.
The statue is an interesting choice. Although created for the royal court, it hadn't been well
received there over 25 years earlier. Apparently, there was something disconcerting about the
sculptural rendition of a young adolescent male nude for Cupid. Disapproving courtiers found too
much of the everyday urchin in Bouchardon's over-aged Cupid. They also criticized the
blatantly coy lack of naturalness. By contrast, Falconet's infant admonishing Cupid
couldn't have been more admired. This watercolor, dated to 1786, gives a good sense of the fabricated
English-style garden that originally housed the temple. In 1782, Marie Antoinette started
developing land on the other side of the lake from her Trianon garden for use as a farm.
By 1784, there emerged a whole complex known as L'Amour de la Reine, or the Queen's Hamlet.
It included eight remodeled thatched cottages, a cow barn, stables, a dairy, paddocks, a chicken
coop, and vegetable and fruit gardens. Sheep, goats, cows, and hens animated the terrain. Many have seen
the hamlet as a kind of toy, a sort of theater where the Queen could play the role of a shepherdess,
bringing to life the idyllic pastoral images of spotless peasants that we have seen in paintings
by Boucher. I might even note that Marie Antoinette, like Pompadour before her, actually acted in small
court productions, and in this way she also stepped out of her role as queen for a short time.
At the hamlet, she sometimes gave a hand to feeding the hens, trimming the hedges, or bringing in the milk.
But the biographer Cronin reminds us that the hamlet was not just a playground.
He notes that it belongs in the context of the new attempts to improve agriculture, and is a sister
scheme to Louis's raising of merino sheep at Rambouillet. The farm was run on commercial lines,
and the sale of its produce actually brought in some revenue. Following from Cronin's remark, where
good economic sense is interwoven with the basic functioning of nature, we might remember the
enlightenment principles of Rousseau, for whom nature also inspired moral precepts, and Voltaire,
who literally took the advice he ventriloquized through Candide and spent his later years
cultivating his own garden at his chateau. I would also add that the queen's construction of the
hamlet as a kind of personal refuge possibly reflects a broader early romantic current,
whereby the civilized world took solace in nature. This trend would become more pronounced and less
artificial, even in Napoleonic circles in the early 19th century. With that comment, I could
segue back to the painter who helped Mieke with the designs of the hamlet. A good friend of Vigée
Lebrun, who painted the portrait of him shown here, and also a Fragonard with whom he traveled to
Italy, Hubert Robert is sometimes classified as an early romantic for his landscape paintings that
often depict picturesque scenes with ancient ruins in Italy. I'd love to say more about landscape
painting and particularly the way it offers yet another engagement with antiquity, though in ruins
it might be, but I don't want to stray too far off course. I will however add that these influences
for the hamlet's decor also owe much to French countryside paintings that combine landscape and
genre, sometimes in a more realistic vein than Boucher's work did. A brilliant example occurs
in the painting The Farm, dated to 1750 by Oudry. Incidentally, Louis XV's wife, Queen Marie Lachinska,
took a serious interest in painting and created a highly faithful reproduction of the hardly simple
work. I would take one more brief digression however to highlight once again that, like Pompadour,
Marie Antoinette was a patron of great furniture. If she can be called a spendthrift, at least her
purse has contributed to leaving us with some masterpieces of artistic creation. Jacob and
Riesener were exponents of neoclassicism in interior design. Prisner, whose writing table
from Marie Antoinette, 1780-85, is pictured here, was a German immigrant to Paris and actually became
the official furniture maker of the king. His pieces are true works of art and I wanted a chance
to mention more of the big names of the period associated with neoclassicism, even if it is
part of the decorative aspect of neoclassicism. Jacob cornered the market on shares, starting
under Louis XV, continuing under Louis XVI, and even going into the era of Napoleon.
This was also the time when the antique-inspired grotesque decorations I mentioned in the earlier
lecture on developing neoclassicism reached the royal interiors. By the 1780s, a new style was
firmly in place. At the time the Hamlet was built, Marie Antoinette was maturing. She had given birth
to a daughter in 1778 and a son and heir by 1781. Another son and daughter would follow in 1785 and
1786, respectively. I'd like to quote Cronin again, as Antoinette's life became increasingly centered
on her children and a few close friends, so she renounced her early extravagances. She spent less
money on clothes now than Aunt Adelaide, and instead of discarding shoes when slightly soiled,
had them retrimmed. After 1784, she no longer had the books at Trianon bound in blue leather.
She continued to gamble, but only for low stakes. Her main pastime was the inexpensive one of
embroidering roses on white silk. She worked quickly and produced quantities of chair covers.
Unfortunately, her abandonment of her youthful search for pleasure and entertainment did not
prevent her popularity from plummeting in the 1780s. I've already discussed this since it is
such a strong part of her legacy, so instead let's say a bit more about motherhood. One defining and
vital aspect of motherhood is breastfeeding. To ease our way into the topic, I'd like to show you
the famous Breast Bowl, designed by La Grenée and Sèvres Porcelain. It was long rumored to be taken
from a cast of the queen's breast. However, the only connection to Marie Antoinette was that it was
part of the complete porcelain service for the queen's dairy at the experimental farm at Rambouillet.
The bowl could hold fresh cow's milk, and it required a separate tripod holder to maintain it
upright. Rousseau was one of the strong proponents of mothers breastfeeding their own children,
rather than having a wet nurse stand in for them and do it. This aspect of maternity came to be
celebrated in portraits of upper-class women. Apparently, even Marie Antoinette attempted to
breastfeed her first daughter for almost three weeks before her physician advised against it.
Of course, for women of the peasant and proletariat classes, breastfeeding their
own children was as necessary a part of life as carrying those children in their wombs.
If unable to use their own breast milk, and without a willing surrogate in their immediate family,
it was likely that their babies would die. The bared breast had long been a common trope for
rustic motherhood before Rousseau, and breastfeeding served as an allegory for charity, fecundity, or
maternal care, even appearing in images of the Virgin Mary and baby Jesus since the Renaissance.
Even so, Grose gives a pointed tenderness to the moment when a baby has fallen asleep at his
mother's breast in a work painted just a few years after Rousseau published his second discourse,
and a few years before his Émile, in which the virtues of breastfeeding,
in the larger context of honoring nature, are expounded.
Women of means would typically send their infants away to a wet nurse or otherwise spend significant
time apart from them. Rousseau's criticism of this practice manifested in painting in the later part
of the 18th century. For example, Aubrey's Farewell to the Wet Nurse depicts the moment when a baby is
handed back to its mother, whose higher status is embodied by her position above the nurse,
on the horse. That the baby should cry and cling to his wet nurse rather than delight at being
returned to the bosom of his mother suggests an unfortunate inversion of nature for Rousseau and
his like-minded contemporaries. As modernism steamrolled forward in the 19th century, Rousseau's
ideas were largely swept aside. However, after the bottled formula explosion of the 20th century,
Rousseau's impulses have been vindicated as there has been a more recent return to,
and scientific understanding of, the benefits of breastfeeding. Of course, in Rousseau's scheme,
fathers have their duty too. In front of Grose's The Drunken Cobbler, viewers would recoil at the
sight of an inebriated man returning home to his wife and two young children. It is clear that he
has sacrificed their needs to his pleasures. The shoemaker's children are, proverbially,
barefoot. While Grose takes a typical moralizing approach, purely sentimental views of paternity
figured into the repertoire of Grose and other artists of that time, such as Fragonard.
Perhaps there was no better artist to depict the matron queen with her children than another mother,
who truly surpassed herself in this grand format painting measuring 9 feet high.
The royal children include Marie-Thérèse, now almost 10 years old, the baby Louis-Charles,
on her lap, and Louis-Joseph, who holds up the drape of an empty bassinet signifying the recent
death of Marie-Antoinette's fourth child, Sophie, who died just before her first birthday.
Sadly, Louis-Joseph's own fate was to pass away at the age of 7 in 1789, although, as we know,
the family was almost entirely ill-fated given the outbreak of the French Revolution.
Only Marie-Thérèse would live to an advanced age. In any case, the work is a tour de force.
Some have speculated that the image of the queen presented here to the public was calculated to
soften her suffering reputation. If so, Vigée Le Brun delivered with great virtuosity.
The conception, that's to say the subject itself, is probably less original than the deep sensitivity
of the rendering. The pyramidal composition is impeccable, as is the warm but subdued palette,
featuring the queen in a bold but somehow perfectly befitting red dress. Both simple and
stately, she looks flawless, perhaps at her most beautiful, surrounded by her affectionate children
and displaying a slightly fuller face, a serious expression of mature, stately, and somehow more
natural, even melancholic beauty, rather than her youthful portraits. Vigée Le Brun also left us
with some beautiful pictures of a maternal bond in the form of self-portraits with her daughter Julie.
You may notice the surprising antiquarian garb of the portrait on the right, and accordingly,
I will briefly return to this portrait in a later lecture that discusses female portraiture in the
fashion of the 1790s, which was very different from the pouf hairdos and almost architectural
dresses of the Ancien Régime. Finally, I thought I'd finish this section on Vigée Le Brun with a
self-portrait in the act of painting, painting a portrait of the queen as a matter of fact.
She made it in Italy shortly after she fled revolutionary France. We saw her with her palette,
of course, in her straw hat portrait, but I do think there is a particularly strong emphasis
on her vocation as a painter here, befitting its destination in the Uffizi portrait gallery.
I'd like to turn now to another female painter of Vigée Le Brun's generation,
her senior in fact, by just a few years, Adélaïde Labillard. She is pictured here,
painting, and in the role of instructor, for she is accompanied by two of her pupils,
Marie-Gabrielle Capet and Marguerite Caro de Rosemont. Labillard is known for her miniatures,
pastels, and oil portrait paintings. She was accepted as a member of the French Academy in
along with Vigée Le Brun and two other women. She received early patronage from the royal family
and did numerous portraits at the court, including those of Louis' aunts, his sister,
and eventually his brother. During the revolution, although she lost her patrons,
she stayed in France, continued to work as an artist, and advocated for women's rights in
the academy. Among other things, art instruction classes were separated by sex at the academy.
Since, as you may remember, the instructional focus was on drawing from life, and particularly
from the male nude. This would be considered unbefitting for women and for mixed company.
Thomas Eakins would be the first to challenge this prohibition in the U.S., but was forced
to resign after removing the loincloth from a male model in a mixed-sex class. In 1795,
Labille-Guillard would become the first female artist to receive permission to set up a studio
for her students at the Louvre. By that time, as we shall see, the revolutionaries had opened up
the Louvre as a public museum, but artists had already been granted both working spaces
and living spaces in the Louvre for almost two centuries. By 1799, the 50-year-old Labille-Guillard
was already divorced, her first marriage to another painter, Nicolas-Guillard, having occurred 30 years
earlier. As a second spouse, she married her friend Vincent in 1799. This is her pastel portrait of
him from circa 1783. Incidentally, Vincent, like his wife, was a painter of David's generation who
had tended to hold on to somewhat baroque tendencies in the classicizing phase of the 1770s.
His sensibilities were never wholeheartedly neoclassical, and his later work often tends
towards the romantic in both subject and pictorial approach. This is a lovely pastel study of Marie
Gabrielle Capet by Labille-Guillard dating to 1789. Capet became a pupil of Labille-Guillard in 1781,
and herself worked primarily as a portrait painter, notably of miniatures. A close friend
of Labille-Guillard, she moved in with her teacher at the Louvre, continuing to live with her after
Labille-Guillard's marriage to Vincent, and in fact until her death. Labille-Guillard's most important
portrait was probably that of Madame Adélaïde, her namesake. We have seen Adélaïde as a young woman,
mainly in the guise of Diana. She was, of course, the daughter of Louis XV, and by 1787, when this
official portrait of her was made, she was the former king's oldest surviving daughter. She is
depicted with cameo portraits of her beloved father, mother, and brother, with an inscription
that says, their image is still the charm of my life. You may also notice the funerary subject
on the notably classicizing sculptural relief frieze in the background. Here is a more informal
portrait of Madame Adélaïde, done in pastel by Labille-Guillard. It's not impossible that it would
have been done as a preparatory work for the official portrait, as Labille-Guillard would
have worked more quickly on a smaller pastel picture, and moreover, it wouldn't have required
the subject to stand. A model could easily have been used for the body. To end this lecture, and
foreshadow things to come, I'd like to share this portrait by Labille-Guillard of Robespierre,
done in 1790, when he held the position of deputy of the third estate after the outbreak of the
revolution the previous year. Not only is it a rare portrait of Robespierre, but I also thought
the juxtaposition between royalty and revolutionary, rendered by the same artist, was striking.
And that concludes Lecture 5.