What is Baroque Painting? Italian Edition

Baroque Art
20 followers
12 Video Views·Mar 26, 2025
Highlights of Selected Masterpieces in "Flesh and Blood: Italian Masterpieces from the Capodimonte Museum"
In this episode of ART Minded, curator of European art, Guillaume Kientz discusses the origins of the Baroque art movement in Italy, the cultural and political context that helped to shape patronage, and the influence of important painters such as Caravaggio, Carracci, and Ribera. This program highlights paintings featured in the special exhibition Flesh and Blood: Italian Masterpieces from the Capodimonte Museum, moderated by education manager Connie Barganier.
Hello and welcome to Art-Minded, the Kimbell's podcast where we discuss the works in our
collection, special exhibitions, and offer insight into the world of art. I'm Connie
Bargainier, Education Manager at the Kimbell. This episode is part of the series focusing
on the special exhibition, Flesh and Blood Italian Masterpieces from the Capodimonte Museum.
We'll take a closer look at Italian painting from the Baroque period in conversation with Guillaume
Keats, Curator of European Art here at the Kimbell, and also the curator for the exhibition.
Hi Guillaume, how are you? Hello, I'm fine, thank you, how are you? I'm doing great. This is such a
wonderful opportunity for us to explore what made the Baroque period so vibrant and dynamic,
so I thought maybe you would start off our conversation with the actual term Baroque
and tell us what it means. Absolutely, it's a fascinating story. Actually the word Baroque
comes from the Latin barocco, and originally it described an irregularly shaped shell,
and then it became synonymous of bizarre or complicated or sophisticated, and later on
the word got applied to art and architecture of the 17th and 18th century, for they had
abandoned the symmetrical clarity and the classical simplicity of the style, and so that's the origin
of the word. It's kind of fascinating and, well, very casual as a story. The art historian,
the Swiss art historian Heinrich Wolflin, in the late 19th century tried to define a bit what is
the Baroque art, and he said that, well, I think he made a list of several criteria that can be
applied to Baroque art, and one was a composition that is diagonally arranged. Another criteria was
if the painting, for instance, is immediately engaging with the viewers by emphasizing movement
with one main effect, this thing of one main effect is especially good. Another one was that
it had to be framed, a composition or a narrative that visually goes beyond the limits of the
picture, so all those criteria are a way to define or to explain or to recognize about a painting.
And we'll see some wonderful examples of what you've just explained in the exhibition.
The exhibition also has paintings from the Renaissance, and it's important to understand
how the Baroque period relates to the periods that preceded it, including the Renaissance.
Would you give us some examples from the show? Well, actually, what I'd like to do is to explain
a bit, well, the sequence from the Renaissance to the Baroque. Basically, we call Renaissance
the development of the arts during the 15th and 16th centuries. It follows, therefore,
the medieval period and coincides with rediscovery of ancient art, especially Roman and Greek,
architecture and structure. And that was very important because at the time it was a shock
both for the artists and patrons, because it was all about the perfection of human anatomy,
the perfect balance of composition. And this is the human anatomy, the human body,
the perfect human body became the only rule for any kind of proportions in art, in architecture,
in sculpture, in painting. And therefore, the Renaissance style sought perfection, idealized
proportion, perfect balance, composition, and universal harmony. That being said, after the
death of the great masters of this first Renaissance, Titian, Raphael, all present in
the current show at the Kimbell, after their death, the new generation of artists began to feel like
they were in crisis, and that they would never be able to do as good as their predecessors did.
And so they decided to emulate them, and they based their work, their art, not much on nature,
on observation of nature any longer, but on quotations of the style and inventions of their
predecessors. So they created quite an artificial style, very referential, and this created a
separation from nature, a divorce from the natural world and the current appearances,
the actual appearances of being. And actually, they thought that they could escape the crisis
doing that, but actually they created another crisis. I mean, they went into an impasse,
and the only way to go out of the impasse was to break with this artistically referential
art. And that's exactly what Baroque art is. Baroque art is coming back to reality,
coming back to real, coming back to order, coming back to verisimilitude. That's what it is.
And so the show, the Flesh and Blood show at the Kimbell is very interesting, because
it's a journey from the early Renaissance to mannerism and then to Baroque art. So you can
absolutely follow three centuries of artistic development in Italy in a few rooms, and that's
fantastic. That's quite remarkable. Just a few rooms, you do, as you say, walk through the history
of Italian painting. Well, will you set the stage for us now in terms of Baroque Italy? What are
some of the things that were happening at that time, important cultural influences that would
have impacted artists and patrons of the day? Well, first and foremost, one has to remember
that the most important patron at the time was the Church, was the Catholic Church, not only in
Italy, but actually in a large part of Europe. And after the Church came the kings, the princes,
the aristocrats, and wealthy collectors. The thing is that, in terms of context,
the Baroque period coincides with the Counter-Reformation. We call the Counter-Reformation
a propagandistic campaign led by the Catholic Church to oppose the rise of Protestantism
in Europe. So for the Church, the point was, with the art, to convince about the veracity
and the legitimacy of its holy origin and of the holiness of its message. And it was, therefore,
high importance to have plausible representations to support these messages. And relays and
Christian theoreticians condemned the excesses of mannerism we just described and called for
more realistic approach in art. And that's the context in which Baroque happened.
On another front, kings wanted to make clear the absoluteness of their power. And art and
architecture were, therefore, less about refinement and sophistication, that was the renaissance,
and more about making an impressive impact on the viewer. And this is another quality of Baroque
art, an impressive impact, very impactful, and it's one main effect to make the message very
clear. In the case of the Church, it's that the Church is the legitimate Church. In the case of
the King, it's that the King is the legitimate ruler of the country. And actually, the trick
of Baroque art is that Baroque art speaks to the senses more than to the mind. Renaissance art
speaks more to the mind than to the senses. Sometimes it can speak to the senses. Obviously,
if you think of Titian's Dene, for instance, that's quite a painting that directly speaks
to the senses, but that's more the speciality of Baroque art. It operates by stimulating the eyes
and making an impactful use of colors, light effects, dynamic compositions. And this makes
Baroque art something very appealing. And this is what encourages also private art lovers
to build impressive collections, all at the same time, demonstrations of their power, their wealth,
and their taste. And that's new. I mean, collection in the Renaissance was only for
the princes and the kings and the cardinals. It's kind of a bit more democratic in the 17th
century. And think of Gaspar Romer, a very important collector in Naples, the one who
actually commissioned to Vera the incredible drunken slenders that we have in the Flesh and
Blood exhibition. So that was a very important collection for his own gallery, nothing to do
with a public commission for a church or nothing to do with a very prestigious collection for a
prince or a king. It was something else. It's much more private. Great, thank you. So if you would
now talk to us more specifically, I know you've mentioned Ribera, the great Spanish artist who
was working in Naples. Who are some of the other important early masters of the Italian Baroque?
I think the two most important masters to be remembered for the Baroque,
or for the birth of the Baroque at least, are Annibale Carracci and Michelangelo Caravaggio.
At the turn of the 16th and the 17th century, these two major artists would break from the
mannerist style. They didn't choose the same way, though. While Caravaggio brutally broke with the
academic tradition based on drawing and decorum, inventing very bold solutions and creating images
that shocked at the time for their apparent triviality, Annibale Carracci, for his part,
tried to inoculate naturalism with the standouts of classicism. So he didn't give up
with the idol of classicism. He just tried to bring classicism up to date and well.
And in the show, we have the great pleasure to have two great masterpieces from those incredible
artists. One is Caravaggio's Flagellation of Christ, and the other is Annibale Carracci's
Pietà, and they're a great example of their respective revolutionary style.
What they have in common is the chiaroscuro, and by chiaroscuro, I mean the harsh contrast between
light and shadow in the painting. And another thing that they have in common is that there is
one main effect and then secondary effects. One main scene, one main action, and then secondary
action, secondary scenes, secondary details that the viewer noticed just after a while, after he
or she got impacted by this main effect. In the case of the Flagellation of Christ, it's the
incredible body of Jesus lighted by the light. In the case of the Pietà, it's obviously again
the body of Jesus on the knee of the Virgin. So this is the main effect. And then you can notice
in one case the persecutors in the dark, in the other case, the little angels pointing on Jesus'
wounds. So that's Baroque, and that's something that they both understood, and that's something
they both have in common. But if you look carefully at Annibale Carracci's Pietà,
you will notice some kind of idealization, and actually the composition itself is reminiscent
of Michelangelo, the great Renaissance artist, Michelangelo's Pietà, that at the time was in
the Vatican, in St. Peter. It's still in St. Peter, and it is not for nothing that this
painting was painted by Annibale Carracci when in Rome, when he discovered this absolutely
masterpiece. In the case of Caravaggio, it's quite different. You immediately notice quite a raw
realism with theatrical aspects of the scene, like you see actors from the daily life
embodying sacred roles, and Caravaggio plays much more with the boundary between sacred and secular,
between daily life and sacred story. So that's then a difference. Caravaggio was obviously much
more radical and ugly. He was even shocking for his time, while Annibale Carracci was looking for
an acceptable midway. He was someone looking for compromise, for harmony. He was someone
who tried to resurrect the great ideal of the Renaissance, but still having them
speaking loud in the time of Baroque. How do you see that playing out in the next generation,
the artists who are influenced by Caravaggio and the Carracci? I think the first who had
quite a strong influence on all the artists was Caravaggio, because the Carracci kind of
closed a tradition, which was the great tradition of Renaissance, and then they got
rediscovered later on in the 17th century, when artists tried to resurrect the style of Titian.
There is all this wave of neo-Venetianism in Italy that is actually what we call today the
full Baroque, but it was a more discreet and underground movement in the art. The Caravaggism
was much more visible as a movement, because when in Rome Caravaggio achieved to find his personal
style and then invented something really new, he kind of painted out of the box, if you know what
I mean. I mean, some people are thinking out of the box. He was painting out of the box.
As a result, many other artists started to emulate his style, especially the straightforward
approach and the dramatic light, the so-called chiaroscuro. They were soon to be called the
Caravaggisti, even during Caravaggio's lifetime or soon after. The same art enables painters like
Caracciolo, present in the show with the gigantic altarpiece, but also other artists less known,
like Carlo Sellitto or Filippo Vitale, and many others. They were all totally impressed by
Caravaggio, and they all followed his style. Perhaps the more talented among them was the
Spanish-born artist, José Pérez Rivera, very well presented in the show, because we have no fewer
than three paintings by him and three masterpieces by him in the show. José Pérez Rivera had been a
follower of Caravaggio in Rome already, because from Spain he moved to Rome, and in Rome he
discovered the manner of Caravaggio, and then he decided to go to Naples ten years after Caravaggio
had arrived. Caravaggio was dead in the meantime, and he brought his very personal Caravaggism to
Naples, and in Naples, his manner, which was no longer called Caravaggism, but more Tenebrism,
because it was very dark, Tenebroso in Italian, and so he kind of renewed his interest for, let's
call that, Caravaggist painting in Naples, and actually he created a school in Naples for
painters. I mean, in a way, in doing so, he extended the success of chiaroscuro painting
until the end of the 17th century, and someone like Mattia Preti, so present in the show,
or Stormer, a Dutch painter active in Naples at the time, or later at the end of the 17th century,
someone like Luca Giordano, they were all born in this context of Ribera-style Caravaggism.
The final room in the exhibition has some absolutely glorious still lifes,
including one by Ribera, and I was hoping that you would talk to us a little bit about
the Neapolitan school of painting in the Baroque period, sort of following up on what you were just
discussing. One has to keep in mind that Naples at the time was a very rich and very
important city. It was still a harbor, so it's connected with a lot of cities in Europe,
so it's a place of trade. It's a very important place of trade, and being a place of trade,
it's a place of money, and when you have money, you have rich people, and when you have rich people,
you have great patrons for the art. Actually, that's the secret of the flourishing school
of paintings in Naples during the 17th and the 18th century. Following the trend of Caravaggio
and then Ribera, many people decided to become artists because it was a good job. There was a
great market for art, so they dedicated themselves to art. With the wealth, many of the
people did quite well and decided to become collectors, and then also the market changed a
bit. It was not that much about big art pieces because they had been already painted by the
previous generation. It was not that much about a great, how can I say, a very impressive
mythological painting for very impressive Neapolitan galleries because all the aristocrats,
I mean, they served themselves with Ribera, with water, and the taste changed. The taste became
kind of more bourgeois, and you can see that when you see the painting because they're much
nicer to look at. It's not any longer about martyrdom. It can be about martyrdom,
but it's less about martyrdom. It's less about blood. It's more about color, and the effects
are more gracious. The paintings themselves, as objects, they're more decorative. It's something
actually you would enjoy to have at home, and you wouldn't enjoy to have at home, the
Drunken Silenus, which is gigantic and disturbing. You wouldn't enjoy to have at home,
I would, but not many people. The Fledgling of Christ by Caravaggio because it's great.
I mean, you don't want to live with that, but you do want to live with nice still life. You do want
to live with a very nice and sweet depiction of St. Cecilia, the patron of musicians. Because she
is nice, she's playing the organ, and you can see the music, you can feel the music, so that you
like. You can even stand an angel painted by Simone de Beauvoir and stand from Rome to Naples
all the time because, okay, it has something to do with the passion of Christ, and you can see
some traces of blood in the handkerchief that he's holding. But it's very seductive as an image,
so you more pay attention on the color, on the grace, on the features of this young angel.
So actually, life is lighter in the second half of the 17th century, also because, and that's
something that speaks to us right now, they got a plug. They got a very, very deadly plug
in the mid-17th century, and many, many artists died of this. So that's something
that resonates today. And because of that, they needed something lighter after that. They needed
some rejoicing images, and that's what artists are for. They are for a supply with images. And
when we can't stand tough images, that's okay. But we need sweet images. They're there, they're here
to give us sweet images and reassuring images. Thank you. That really speaks to how important
art is today as well as in the 17th century and how it has the power to connect with us.
To make us feel so many different ways, and Baroque painting certainly can do that.
Thank you so much for taking us on this journey through the Italian Baroque, through the
lens of the exhibition. It's been great fun to hear from you. Everyone stay tuned for the next
podcast, which will feature Guillaume again. Thank you, Guillaume. Thank you. See you soon.
Thank you for listening to Art Minded. Please don't forget to connect with us at
kimbellart.org to see the art we've discussed in this episode.
As always, we thank you for your continued support.
