How Australia Blew Their Chance to get Stupid Rich

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financenews
Australia has an abundance of natural resources, and rapidly rising commodity prices have been the biggest driver behind Australia's GDP growth in the 21st century. But a massive opportunity was wasted.
Australia has been lucky once again. Their vast territory is unusually rich in natural resources
and the current craze is iron ore. In Western Australia alone lies nearly a third of the world
supply. This resource is critical for making steel. And Australia got lucky because since 2000
China substantially increased world demand. Mining is driving an incredible 20% of Australia's GDP
but a huge opportunity was missed. The mining boom is the largest shock to Australia's economy
in generations. It might not seem like it but this is affecting average wages, the cost of living,
and even how much people are paying for rent, whether employed in mining or elsewhere. This
industry has become so huge that in 2022 more than half of all corporate profits were generated
in mining. While this sector employs just a fraction of Australia's workforce. Now that a
few years have passed we can see more clearly whether Australia took full advantage of this
opportunity with hindsight. Australia holds an abundant number of natural resources. They have
the largest reserves of uranium, nickel, and bauxite which is used to make aluminum. They also
have the third largest reserves of iron ore. This is almost entirely exported to China which comes
with some geopolitical considerations. Because what if they use this against Australia to achieve
political or economic goals? But the part that is most often overlooked is how mining is affecting
the lives of everyday citizens. Mining has the potential to transform a country if its revenues
are well invested. So to understand how well Australia did, let's start at the beginning.
Australia was lucky from the start. In the 1840s silver and lead were found in South Australia
and later they found copper in several other places. This led to a surge of immigration to
Australia and the hype got crazier when in 1850 they also found gold. Almost overnight as much as
40% of the world's gold was produced in Australia and mining now accounted for 30% of their economy.
But by the early 1900s their luck seemed to have run out. The world was starting to industrialize
and countries were thirsty for steel. To make steel you need iron ore which Australia believed
it didn't have. They placed a ban on the export of iron ore to protect its own limited supply.
But boy were they wrong. The story goes that a miner and his wife departed in a small aircraft
to head home to Perth when bad weather forced them to take a detour. They followed a river valley
on a low altitude and as he looked out of the window he noticed these massive red brown outcrops
that were lining the hillsides. He thought to himself that this could be oxidized iron.
And after arriving home he contacted the authorities and some investors to see if they
could help him explore this region. But with the export ban still in place nobody was too keen on
getting involved. He returned several times and followed the iron ore over a distance of 112
kilometers or 70 miles. He knew that this could very well be the largest reserve in the world.
In 1960 the ban was lifted and this kicked off a mining frenzy. The newly discovered iron ore
deposits were now explored and Australia got lucky that at the same time Japan entered its period of
rapid industrialization providing a ready market for its exports. It was a golden time for Australian
miners but nobody saw coming what would happen next. Iron ore prices back to their highest level
in six months. The price of gold is now at its highest level ever. The prices of commodities in
the early 2000s shot through the roof. The price of coal increased more than fivefold. The same for
gold and iron ore prices increased more than sixfold. Australia's mining sector which includes
these commodities and many more became an increasingly important driver of economic growth.
Most mining companies were seeing record profits without even having to increase their production
simply because people were now willing to pay much more than 10 years earlier. But the company's
mining iron ore went all in. 16.6 billion dollars in six months this is a record it smashed all-time
In 2011 the price of iron ore peaked at over 170 Australian dollars and the production of iron ore
increased substantially with these increasing prices. The mining industry continued to boom
for the shareholders and of course the government. This put tens of billions of dollars of extra tax
revenue in the government's coffers and it didn't even end here. In 2020 iron ore became the first
commodity to ever exceed 100 billion dollars in annual export value and the subsequent years were
even crazier. During these record years the export value of iron ore was larger than the entire GDP
of Alaska, Montana or Hawaii and this had far-reaching consequences for the country as a
whole. There's a flip side to having abundant natural resources as many countries in Africa
and South America can tell you. In the short term it makes a lot of money but in the long term it
often leads to countries becoming less wealthy and less democratic. But the opportunity was just
too great to pass on. Mining is an amazing business if you do it well. These are the
profit margins by industry and mining stands out with over 35 percent and such earning potential
helped mining stay at the center of policy focus for much of Australia's history. During the mining
boom the government responded by massively investing in this sector reaching a record
eight percent of Australia's GDP in 2011. This is what some have criticized. While mining has
tremendous profit margins an over-emphasis on mining can hinder growth in other sectors like
technology or health care which are much more resilient to global changes. In the short term
countries that start exporting more of its natural resources generally get more demand
for their currency thus making it stronger. This also happened in Australia. This stronger
Australian dollar makes it cheaper to import goods but for sectors who rely on exports like
agriculture and manufacturing a stronger Australian dollar makes their exports less
competitive. The agricultural sector alone lost 61 billion dollars in export income over
nine years. So mining does not just hinder growth in some sectors it actually causes some sectors
to shrink but it also causes some sectors to grow. The industries that benefited the most
were construction, electricity and distribution services. These sectors service the mining
industry and they benefit from higher domestic demand which is another effect of the mining boom.
It increases purchasing power. The mining sector created more demand in the economy and added so
much in tax revenue that the government could lower overall tax rates. As a result the average
wages grew by six percent and disposable income grew by 13 percent. It also added tens of thousands
of new jobs in the highest paying sector of the Australian economy. The mining boom gave people
more money to spend but more purchasing power also leads to higher prices of consumer goods.
One study calculated that food became 20 percent more expensive as a direct result of the mining
boom. Total consumption prices increased by 10 percent and motor vehicles by 30 percent. Perhaps
most urgently the mining boom also contributed to higher rent and home prices. This is particularly
troublesome because it takes more time for the housing stock to keep up with higher demand.
There were many short-term costs and gains from the mining boom in the early 2000s and in recent
years this sector has become even more profitable. It just continued to grow and it's becoming an
increasingly important segment of Australia's economy. But there are real concerns whether this
is a smart long-term strategy. Australia has been dealt a winning hand and if you're this lucky with
the sheer abundance of natural resources it would be illogical not to look for ways to sustainably
mine these resources and to turn them into a force for good. But here's the problem. This is the
economic complexity index. On the top we find highly complex economies like Japan and Switzerland.
If we scroll all the way down we find Australia at place 82 between Kenya and Sri Lanka. This is
the lowest of any developed country and this is primarily credited to their reliance on mineral
exports. The mining boom contributed to Australia's lack of economic diversity and I'll add one more.
The shareholders are primarily foreign. These mines are for 83% foreign-owned. All these
billions of dollars it creates in revenue for a large part isn't even going to Australian
citizens or companies. And the profits that remain in the country are not equitably shared.
If we just look at the 17% that remained in the country, 50% of these profits went to Australians
who made over $250,000 per year and 25% went to those making over a million dollars per year.
A con is that the rich profit the most. But this needs to be seen in context. It's true that the
richest Australians are eating an increasingly large portion of the pie, especially in iron ore
mining. But the middle class and bottom 10% of earners are also seeing their incomes rise faster
than in almost any other developed country. The mining sector likes to emphasize that it raises
overall incomes. Those who campaign against this sector say that the rich profit the most.
Both are true. It leads to more inequality, but everybody is better off in the end.
This is a major opportunity. Mining today is generating insane amounts of revenue,
but they are a very poor taxpayer. The effective corporate tax rate in Australia is 21%,
but mining is paying just 14%. Norway, for example, taxes its oil and gas at 78%.
This helped Norway build the largest sovereign wealth fund in the world and today you can see
a clear correlation between how much this sector generates in revenue and how much their government
makes through all different kinds of taxes. But in Australia, the government seems to be
cutting itself short. While the sector experienced a massive revenue boost,
the Australian government saw its revenues flatline. Just imagine the opportunity that
Australia missed out on if it had adopted a similar strategy as Norway. Australia has such
abundant natural resources, but much of this goes to foreign shareholders and Australia's richest
people. Mining is a poor taxpayer and it's very dependent on foreign demand.
China has suspended indefinitely high-level economic talks with Australia. There's been
an escalation in Australia's trade dispute with China. One of Australia's biggest exports is coal
and its biggest trading partner is China. In 2020, a series of disputes led to China
to cut all Australian coal imports. China has formalized import restrictions on coal,
targeting Australia's 14 billion dollar industry. Months of import delays have left millions of
tons of Australian coal stranded off China's coast. This left dozens of ships collectively
carrying hundreds of millions of tons of coal anchored off China's coasts.
Iron ore is now by far Australia's most important mineral export, and this is almost exclusively
sold to China. Some fear that China could also weaponize this leverage to achieve political
and economic goals. But it also goes the other way around. The world is simply dependent on
natural resources. Australia could increase its geopolitical leverage by producing more.
Take rare earth minerals. China is by far the largest producer, but Australia is also a major
player. Increasing its production would increase Australia's geopolitical leverage. And as Norway
has shown, it can be possible to sustainably invest revenues from these industries to
diversify the economy and to provide for future generations. The earnings potential of mining
is simply unmatched. It also lowers unemployment, creating the highest paying jobs in Australia,
and it stimulates investment, which can be life-changing for people who live in these
remote areas. Australia has been incredibly lucky, and they deserve credit for avoiding some of the
major pitfalls that come with exporting natural resources. But the tens of billions of dollars
that are generated every year are not as equitably shared as they perhaps could have been.
Remember that point that I made earlier that China is producing most of the rare earth elements?
Well, one of the metals that is receiving a lot of attention is tungsten. This is the metal with
the highest melting point in the world. It's nearly as dense as gold, and almost as hard as
diamond. This makes it incredibly useful for military applications. But of course, China is by
far the biggest producer. Australia comes in at place 7, but the United States is nowhere to be
found. They are already the largest importer of tungsten in the world, and 35% of its imports
come from China. And that's where today's sponsor saw an opportunity.
American Tungsten, ticker DEMRF, today's sponsor, seeks to potentially become the first tungsten
producer on US soil. At the moment, China is by far the largest producer of rare earth minerals,
and they control an even larger portion of the world's processing capacity. This creates a
strategic chokehold, especially in the context of the current trade war. China managed to reach
this position by strategically investing in rare earths, and by undercutting competitors with lower
costs. This forced many US mines to shut down. And while there are no tungsten mines currently
on US soil, it once was a thriving industry. All across the American west coast and up to Alaska,
there are literally hundreds of known tungsten deposits. But as long as China controls this
critical metal, the US risks a sudden supply disruption that could cripple US industries,
causing a security crisis of unparalleled magnitude. American Tungsten, US, DEMRF,
wants to avoid this. They are seeking to secure key strategic partnerships and non-dilutive
financing with the US Department of Defense and US Department of Energy for their flagship asset.
A mine that once was the 5th largest operational tungsten mine in the United States.
I personally think that this is an exciting opportunity that could also help the United
States become less dependent on China. And maybe you will be a shareholder.
