By nearly every measure, our children’s mental health is worse than that of previous generations. Investigative journalist Abigail Shrier is the author of Bad Therapy: Why the Kids Aren't Growing Up. Abigail and PragerU CEO Marissa Streit discuss how the mental health industry has put an entire generation of young people in distress by convincing them they have unresolved emotional trauma and need therapy and medication. She explains what parents should be aware of when they send their kids to school—or even the pediatrician.
I saw a generation that is in profound distress.
One out of four young Americans identify as a different gender.
They were treating every child as emotionally damaged.
They'll say anything from climate change, police tactics, being born black.
We've convinced an entire generation they're mentally ill.
It is so important what you just said.
Step number one shouldn't be therapy and medication.
Some kids will need it.
The problem is we are creating mental disorder.
Abigail Schreier, anybody that doesn't know who you are, is probably living under a rock.
So I'm not sure we need to give an introduction.
You have been one of the most important figures, I would say, in America and the West over
the last few years because you have reported on discoveries of things that are so significant
to young American families.
So I can't wait to have an in-depth discussion about your books and everything that you've
been doing.
Can you share a little bit about your work?
Sure.
Thank you so much for having me here.
The last book I wrote, my first book, was called Irreversible Damage, The Transgender
Craze Seducing Our Daughters.
And it was about the social contagion of the trans epidemic, teenage girls suddenly deciding
with their girlfriends that they were transgender, they were really boys, and pushing for hormones
and surgeries and getting them.
And when I wrote the book, it came out in 2020.
It was the first book to sort of name this phenomenon and explain the risks and what
was happening.
And it really shocked a lot of people who I think didn't know it was certainly a nationwide
phenomenon.
It turned out to be an entirely Western phenomenon.
So the book's been translated into 10 languages because America has actually exported the
transgender epidemic among teen girls throughout the West.
When you came out with this book, I remember we called you up, we did a five-minute video,
and I remember people saying to me, this issue is so fringe, okay, it's not even possible
that so many young girls or even boys would really be in danger.
And we got a lot of pushback against it.
And I remember that you also went on Joe Rogan, and I was actually wondering whether Joe Rogan
would ever allow you to go back because that episode got censored, but he stood by you.
He did.
That was really amazing.
Did you experience a similar kind of pushback that when you released the second book?
So no, my second book, of course, is Bad Therapy, Why the Kids Aren't Growing Up, and it's
about all the ways the mental health industry has actually hurt the mental health of the
rising generation.
And I think that, you know, I was very early with the first book, so people didn't realize,
and they really wanted to stamp out my counter-narrative.
When I wrote the book in 2020, there was no mainstream book that had shown the risks of
the harms and that it was a social contagion for these girls.
So it was a real threat to the prevailing narrative, and the left had really done nothing
but made cultural gains for basically unimpeded for seven years or so.
So with this book, I think people have actually already started to notice, wait a second,
why does every teenager I know say they have anxiety?
Why does every kid who talks about, you know, having a bad experience in middle school describe
it as PTSD?
Where did they get the idea, and why are so many of them on psych meds?
Why are they on several psych meds at once?
So they have this sense that the kids are swimming in therapy, and so what I did was
I tried to bring out the psychological research to show not only are they swimming in therapy,
they're swimming in what we know to be bad therapy.
The gender-affirming care, I don't even know what to call it, phenomena, evil, is so massive.
I want to focus on it further because my question is, when you came out with this book, were
there already a lot of girls and boys that were transitioning and simply, we didn't know
that much about it, there was just poor journalism and poor reporting, or have we been seeing
a surge of additional young girls and boys because it's so culturally dominant right
now in our schools and TikTok, and there are actually more girls and boys that are transitioning?
I read somewhere, and correct me if I'm wrong, that one out of four young Americans identify
as a different gender right now, where it may not be transgender, but bi or mixed or
something like that.
So is there an actual growth in the number of kids that are identifying as trans, or
was it just underreported in the past?
So the reason I wrote the book was because I already knew it was a much bigger phenomenon
that had been reported.
I don't write about things people already know.
So you'll see in my new book, I don't use the word woke.
I'm not here to make people feel comfortable in what they have already heard about.
As a journalist, I try to uncover stuff that parents might not know.
And with the last book, the reason I knew it was a major phenomenon was because a number
of parents brought it to me, I did some research, and then I wrote an article for the Wall Street
Journal about it.
And they got nearly 1,000 comments from parents saying, yes, 20% of my girl's seventh grade
is identifying as trans.
And then something interesting happens.
The New York Times was very upset with me, and their transgender columnist posted a response
to my article, and her article got almost 1,000 comments, and most of them were backing
me up.
So then I knew I had a much bigger phenomenon to work with, and there were a lot of parents
eager to tell me their story.
So that, yes, I think it was both an underreported phenomenon, nobody wanted to touch the topic.
I tried to give it to another reporter.
Nobody wanted to touch it.
Because many are talking about now.
People are talking about, and so is it, I mean, do I say thank you?
I mean, thank you, right?
This is amazing.
So the new issue that you've taken on is something that I relate to very much, and that is this
issue that everybody needs therapy, right?
And that everybody is mentally broken, and the only way they can be fixed is by going
to therapists and possibly taking pills, and really festering, is that the word, over this
issue of their mental space.
So what led you to write this book?
Did you see something in the way that you saw?
Something with the transgender groups?
I did.
I saw a generation that is in profound distress.
We know that less than half of the rising generation, so-called Gen Z, believes that
its mental health is good.
But that's surprising, because they've also gotten the most wellness tips, the most anti-bullying
tips, the most emotional regulation in schools.
They've had social-emotional learning now for 15 years.
They should be the picture of mental health.
But when I wrote my book proposal, I still didn't think it was because of therapy, because
after all, only less than half of the kids, about 40%, still the most, have been in therapy.
But it still wasn't even half.
But then I wrote the book with a different thesis originally.
I pitched it to a publisher and sold it, and the thesis was it had something to do with
the way they were being raised.
Maybe they were being raised differently.
And then I attended a three-day conference put on by the public school system in California
devoted to mental health, and I thought, well, gosh, I want to find out what the schools
are doing for mental health.
And what I learned there was that it wasn't just the kids who were on the couch.
That therapy, or what I call bad therapy, had gone airborne.
And in fact, the largest patient pool in the country was in public schools.
How?
What did you see that led you to realize that?
I saw that the mandate of schools was now trauma-informed care.
These are people who believe that every child is traumatized, that their bodies are holding
on to intergenerational trauma.
By the way, a lot of this is nonsense, as I write about in the book.
But they were teaching kids this.
They were treating every child as emotionally damaged.
And not only was there no discipline anymore, but the whole program was one of social-emotional
learning, which was a kind of group therapy.
And instead of ever punishing, the kids were always for bad behavior.
They were sent to the counselor now.
And what does the counselor do?
The counselor gets you out of requirements.
They help you avoid hard things in school, like timed tests.
That is their big lever that they use.
Now, let me just say, I'm not against therapy.
I'm not even against psych meds.
And even for kids, sometimes they need them.
There are kids in profound distress who are profoundly suffering, but that's not how these
things were given out.
They were given out across the board.
Many of the recommendations, by the way, for ADHD medications come from the teacher now.
And these are stimulants.
These are really powerful stimulants.
So the school was very much working as sort of a mental health ward in our country.
It's like SCL is like a feeder into the mental health industry.
That's right.
And they were doing the most, as I learned while writing this book, and I should say,
I didn't know when I started any of this, but I interviewed a lot of academic researchers
in the field of psychology.
And what I learned is a few things.
One, getting kids to focus on their emotions and think about their emotions all the time
and track their emotions is the way to make them dysregulated.
It's also the way to make them unhappy.
Ruminating on a painful experience.
That's what they're asking kids to do in public school.
Tell us about a time when you were in pain.
Think about a time when you were rejected.
Think about a time when you failed.
How did that make you feel?
That is the number one symptom of depression.
It's ruminating on a past pain, not letting it go and rehearsing it over and over.
And that's what we were inducing in school children.
I just go back to my years of getting my master's in education.
And I remember being encouraged as a teacher, whether it's through social emotional learning,
SCL, now I think of it as the Trojan horse.
But I remember being given the mandate to actually sit with my students and have everybody
share their emotions and create a safe space for everyone so that we can unite together.
And so you're saying that something struck you when you were attending these conferences
and you said, this doesn't make sense.
Why are we doing group therapy with a teacher who's clearly not equipped to do any therapy,
let alone therapy in front of 40 other kids?
That's right.
I mean, one of the things I learned by talking to these researchers in the field of psychology
was that it sounds innocuous.
Ask a bunch of kids, how are they feeling?
Well, what could be wrong with that, right?
They could say, I'm feeling great.
The problem is their mandate is teaching social emotional learning, teaching emotional regulation.
Well, if you say, great, I feel great, there's nothing to teach.
So it always heads in the direction.
Now think of a time when you were in pain.
Now think of a time when you felt bullied, when you felt left out.
And then there's a second part.
So that in itself increases dysregulation.
By the way, it makes it harder for kids to achieve any tasks.
We know this.
Focusing on yourself makes it harder to achieve any hard task at all.
I totally relate to this because I think that when I'm in a bad place,
if I'm constantly thinking about poor me, poor me, poor me,
what is the hardest thing I've gone through recently, right?
I actually become weaker and less efficient.
I can't even focus, right?
Because I'm just focusing on how hard things are.
And I'm an adult, right?
So I can possibly better regulate myself.
But for a child to just take them down this direction of like,
poor me, what is the worst thing I could think about right now?
And then, okay, now let's go to math class.
Right, exactly.
And here's the thing I want parents to know.
It's different with adults.
So as bad as that is for adults, it's worse with kids.
And here's why.
Because you're sitting around with your school counselor or a teacher
talking about your trauma.
So now you've told a whole group of kids they've been traumatized.
Is that the word trauma, by the way, used in school?
Or the teachers are using this term trauma?
Sure, their mandate is trauma-informed care.
We need to accept that most kids have been traumatized.
That's what they say.
Traumatized by what?
Well, they'll say, they list, it's based on a study,
but it's a study that's been terribly abused.
So they exaggerate the causes,
but they'll say anything from climate change can cause trauma
to police tactics can cause trauma.
Being born black can cause trauma.
I talked to a wonderful teacher in public schools who was black
and she finds it extraordinarily offensive
that kids are told being born black in America
means you've been traumatized and you have an inherited trauma.
But the thing I want parents to know is
if kids are sitting around and doing this with their counselor or teacher,
well, who was supposed to keep them safe from trauma?
The parents.
So very naturally, it always leads to a criticism
or very naturally, it will lead to a criticism of the family, of the parents.
Because of course, the next question is, where was your mom?
Where was your dad when this was happening?
Oh, she didn't have time to help me.
Abigail, why do you think the system is doing this?
Is it just a thing that is snowballing out of control
because people are just losing right for wrong,
the ability to discern what's the right thing to do for children?
Or is there a nefarious industry that is trying to break the family,
over-medicate children, empower the government?
What's your hunch on that?
It's a great question.
It's an important question.
Is this on purpose?
Is this as people acting together?
Here's what I'll say.
As a journalist, I try not to speculate on things that I don't have proof of.
And here's what I have proof of.
If you wanted to break kids down emotionally,
if you wanted to break them down,
there would be no better program than the program now in schools
that goes under the headline mental health.
It almost doesn't matter really who is orchestrating it.
What matters is that we have to save our kids.
So part of me wants to say, that's it.
I'm never going to send my children or any child I love
to a mental health clinic or to a therapist
because now they're potentially going to be in danger.
And then part of me says, okay, well, we have to live in the real world, right?
And as parents, we're afraid.
We're afraid to not serve them in the best way possible.
We're afraid that if they're dealing with anxiety
or serious mental health issues,
if we don't provide them with an expert to help them,
then are they going to be broken?
Are they going to commit suicide, right?
It's very, very scary to raise our children alone
and then say no to all the experts and then see a child suffering
and hear that the experts are saying, well, here's a solution
and say, no, I don't want this solution.
And so how do we navigate through that?
How do we find a balance between figuring out
when to send a child to the therapist
and when to say this is completely unnecessary?
Is there a line that you have realized that we can draw?
Yes, and it's easy.
Does your child have a serious problem
that you can't otherwise fix by changing their environment,
by making changes in that environment, okay?
If you cannot stabilize your child, if they have a problem,
anorexia, obsessive compulsive disorder,
you know, they can't get out of bed, they're so depressed.
There are so many problems that face kids today.
Now, look, if you can make changes in their environment
and it helps, by all means, start there.
But if you can't stabilize them,
then you may need to take them to a therapist
and then you need to research the therapist
like you would any surgeon.
Would you send your child to sit with a therapist
without you in the room?
It's a good question.
It depends what the problem is.
But here's what I want to say.
I want to reset the default settings, okay?
I'm not here to tell people what to do with their kids.
But here's what I know.
Step number one shouldn't be therapy and medication
because therapy is not a neutral act.
Giving a kid a diagnosis,
telling them they have a brain problem,
which is what that does,
that can change a child's self-concept.
It can limit what they think they can do on their own.
Now, I'm not saying, there's a time and place for that.
Some kids will need it and they should get it.
The problem is we are over-treating every child.
We are taking every child and treating them as disordered.
And so we are creating mental disorder.
So I have this crazy theory.
I call it kiss your calluses.
And one of my friends says,
nobody emerges from hell empty-handed.
That's her way of phrasing it.
But the point that I make is I actually think
that hardship is good for you.
I think that some of the most impressive people that I know
have gone through hard times.
And it's possible that our kids
have not gone through such hard times.
And when they go through something,
not even that hard,
they're told that they're victims of their environment.
So there are certain kinds of adversity
that is no doubt really good for kids.
But here's the most important part of it.
We need to tell them the truth.
And this is the truth.
Resilience is the story of the human condition.
Most kids, even who go through really hard things,
even different forms of abuse,
most kids will emerge resilient.
They will recover.
And we have to assume for most of them,
that will be the case.
Now, of course, you give help to the kid
who is really suffering.
There's no question.
But they need to be told the truth
that their grandparents went through hard things,
that their great-grandparents went through hard things.
It's the only proof they have
that they can get through hard things too.
Mm-hmm.
Well, and then meanwhile,
we're kind of erasing history
and not even bothering to teach history.
We mostly teach victimhood.
And we don't even teach them their own history.
See, we need to connect them to their grandparents,
to their cousins.
We need to tell them what the family went through.
So when they hear you have inherited trauma,
they'll say, no, I don't.
You know what I have?
I have the toughest grandparents and great-grandparents
and great-great-grandparents around
because they will face adversity in their lives.
There's no getting around that.
We need to tell them you can get through it too
because the majority, the vast majority of them will.
You know, it's incredible as you describe this.
I think about my mother-in-law
who her mother barely escaped concentration camps
in Nazi Germany.
And she went and hid.
And my mother-in-law was actually raised
in a displaced person camp.
And she today is one of the happiest people I've ever met.
I mean, just everything makes her happy.
Like a chocolate bar makes her happy.
It's that perspective of,
I can't think of a worse childhood
than what Holocaust survivors had gone through.
But it's pretty amazing how we have these generations
of people who've survived the Great Depression.
And they had this ability to discern.
They have this ability to find happiness.
And they were just mentally so strong.
That's right.
And then we look at today's young generation.
And so many of them are depressed.
And so many of them are committing suicide.
And they're on medication.
It's actually, when I read your book
and I think about what you talk about,
it's actually pretty alarming and obvious at the same time.
Yeah, well, I mean, just think about
if your mother-in-law had gone through school today.
So she would have been told by a school counselor,
oh, wow, that you have gone through serious trauma.
We need to meet regularly and talk about it
because this is not something we can just get beyond
unless we talk about it, okay?
Your mother would have had an entirely different trajectory.
Yeah.
But nobody meddled with her in that way.
Because actually, humanity, we have incredible resources.
These kids, Archie, their feelings
are always front and center.
Parents do this too.
They apply the therapeutic methods to kids.
And they tell them their feelings
are the most important thing in the world.
How are you feeling today?
How are you feeling now?
So these kids are being crushed
under the weight of their own feelings
and they're being tyrannized by the weight of each other's.
I see that actually also in hiring.
So I speak to different entrepreneurship groups
and obviously we have 150 employees here.
Every single person that works for PragerU
is absolutely perfect
and there's no issues whatsoever with them ever, ever.
But let me just say that oftentimes when I interview,
I come across employees as CEO,
the word trauma PTSD is used on a regular basis
for things that are just simply
somewhat lightly challenging, right?
It's like, I'll give somebody a task
that's too hard for them.
And they'll say, oh my gosh, it's traumatizing.
That's right.
Or a long day at work is traumatizing.
Or even if they're reprimanded by HR or their supervisor,
they're gonna have PTSD
from being told that their work is not good enough, right?
It is this stuff that starts at childhood
from my perspective as an employer
is seeping into the human capital workforce
of America and possibly the West.
Yeah, that's absolutely right.
And let me tell you,
there's a brand new piece of research that came out
that showed that adults
who were believed they were traumatized as children
are more likely to have adult psychopathology.
They're more likely to be,
you know, have physical, mental and mental health problems
than adults who went through the same things as children,
whether it's abuse, neglect, whatever it is.
If they don't believe they were traumatized as children,
they're less likely to have adult psychopathology.
They do better.
Wow.
Because being told and believing
you went through trauma is debilitating.
I know that the majority of your focus is on children
and what is happening within,
you know, the mental health.
It's an industry, right?
It's an industry.
It's obviously a money-making industry as well.
But the industry actually progresses
into the HR industry in businesses across America, right?
You have an HR industry
that is constantly worried
about traumatizing employees as well.
How dare we say something
that is gonna make them slightly uncomfortable, right?
And we have just weakened the entire American spirit
rather than telling everybody,
you know what?
If somebody actually pushes you up the ladder,
that means they believe in you.
That means they think that you can even do more.
That means that they don't think
that you need to be a victim.
So imagine re-centering the entire thing
around this perseverance,
this concept of perseverance.
And if we started that at kindergarten,
what kind of workforce we would see in America right now?
What kind of military would see in America?
What kind of leadership we would see in America, right?
I imagine anybody that listens to this,
whether they have children, employees,
or friends in their lives,
none of us want people walking around
feeling offended and traumatized all the time.
Right, and that's why they're not showing up for work.
They're demanding mental health days off of work, right?
They don't feel up to the challenge of adulthood.
That's a huge problem.
They've been debilitated by the lie we've given them
that they all have a mental health condition
and it's limiting them.
I want people to know that.
There are people who have mental health struggles,
but unfortunately we've convinced an entire generation
that they're mentally ill or mentally weak
and it makes them weak.
And we need to give them the opposite message.
And here's the best news for parents.
It's so easy and it doesn't cost anything, okay?
Kids need authority.
We know this.
This is really good psychological research.
They need authority in the home.
They need community, people they love
and love them back like extended family.
Really love them.
Not the expert mom hired to watch you.
The ones who really love you.
Even grandma who gives them the wrong foods.
That's really important.
They need to hear what their own families went through.
And this is gonna be the hardest part for parents.
They need independence with actual important
and sometimes dangerous things
like walking home from school by themselves,
you know, using knives.
We have to give them skills and trust them to use them.
Now, I'm not talking about social media.
We didn't evolve to handle social media.
We didn't evolve so that strangers could prey
on our children on social media.
That's not something we evolved to handle.
But navigating your neighborhood by yourself,
being trusted to, you know, walk home from school,
being trusted to go into the store by yourself
and picking up some things for the family.
Cook dinner.
That's a great one.
That we, they, boy, it gives you a sense of power, efficacy.
I can do things in the world.
These kids don't think they matter
because we've told them they're so unique.
They're so separable for everybody else.
They don't know they're part of a community.
They're part of a world
and they need to contribute to it.
Abigail, I'd imagine people who are listening
are probably saying to themselves,
okay, that's fine.
You know, Marissa and Abigail, you both have families,
you have husbands, you have grandparents,
but there are millions of Americans
who are going to school every single day
who don't have a solid household, right?
They don't have mom and dad in the home all the time,
being able to support them mentally.
That's the answer that I would get
when I would push back against SEL, right?
I would say social emotional learning is a Trojan horse.
Teachers are not therapists.
They should not do therapy in front of 20 or 40 other kids.
It is important that kids have access
to good emotional learning experiences.
But I would say the school is not the place to do it.
And the pushback that I would get,
and I imagine you're getting too,
is not everybody has a healthy household to go to.
And therefore we need to build a system
that provides everybody with the option
of emotional regulations,
health and mental support, et cetera.
Okay, two things.
First of all, what they're doing in schools,
what they call emotional regulation techniques,
that doesn't work for anybody.
That's going to break anybody down.
Telling them, let's focus on your emotions.
Let's focus on your trauma.
Not only is it going to break down the kid who doesn't need it,
it's going to break down the kid who does.
To sit with 40 other kids in their class
and talk about the dad who left them.
You think that's not healthy for a kid.
But here's what I also want to know.
The poor kids are going to suffer the most from this.
Why?
Because they get such low expectations.
No one has high expectations for them, okay?
They need, and the solution is there.
You know who does the best?
Way better than white kids in America, Latinos.
They call this the immigrant paradox
or the Latino paradox sometimes, right?
Sometimes they call them...
Their mental health is better.
No, regardless of socioeconomic level.
Why?
Because they know they're connected to a community.
They know mom's counting on them to help out.
They're impressed to do chores,
all stuff that's great for kids.
And their mom doesn't put a therapist in charge.
So the idea that this is just some sort of,
we have to rush in and help the poor kids.
Let me tell you something.
We've done so much damage to these kids
by breaking them down and telling them they're traumatized.
It's not true for most of them.
And it's not helpful anyway.
When you went into doing this research
on this very important book,
you said that you didn't realize
what you're going to find, right?
You said that the thesis had to change.
You possibly had to talk to, I guess,
the company that you signed with and change things.
What did you find out that really surprised you
that made you realize that you're onto something
different than what you originally thought?
So I realized two things.
One, that these kids were flooded with therapy.
That's why they were never saying they were shy.
They were saying, I have social phobia.
You never hear the word depressed.
It was sad.
You only hear I'm depressed.
You never hear the word worried anymore.
They never say they're worried.
I have anxiety.
They were all speaking the language of psychopathology.
So they were getting flooded with therapy.
And a lot of it was coming from schools
and with their parents.
Tell me about your feelings.
Let's talk about your feelings.
Endlessly soliciting their feelings.
One of the things you write about in your book
is this incident that you had at the pediatrician.
Your child had a stomach ache or something
and you took them to the pediatrician
and then they moved you out of the room
and started asking your child
whether they have suicidal thoughts
or something like that.
That's right.
So these kids are getting so many mental health surveys.
These are not innocuous.
These are profound interventions.
They are bringing up suicide all the time with these kids.
My son, I took him to an urgent care clinic
because he had a stomach ache
that when he got back from summer camp
and after deciding it was just dehydration,
I got up to go and they said,
oh, hold on.
We're going to ask you to leave the room
because we have to do our mental health survey.
And I got up to leave.
And then I thought, wait a second.
I just wrote a whole book about this.
Excuse me.
Can I please see your survey?
And I took a picture of it.
It was put out by the National Institute of Mental Health.
This is their standard protocol now
for kids aged eight and up.
And it asks kids five escalating questions
about whether they might want to kill themselves.
Now here's the problem.
Not only is this terrible for a kid
who wasn't considering suicide,
who might alone in that room answer yes
and then you can't take him home.
They tell you he's suicidal.
Now we need to watch him, right?
But there's something else too.
What about the kid who has suicidal thoughts?
The first thing the National Institute of Mental Health
thought to do was separate him from his parents.
Wow.
I mean, I think it's just the way you phrase it
makes it so alarming, right?
I think people just don't think about it.
We have been conditioned to do this group think
and not think at all
that when you just put the obvious in front of us,
it's just mind boggling.
You and I were at a talk a few days ago
and you mentioned the story
and there was a pediatrician that walked up to us and said,
I don't take the $15.
And I said, what $15?
What are you talking about?
And the pediatrician responded and said,
we are offered to receive $15
essentially from the government
for every survey that a child completes
or a parent allows a child to complete.
I mean, the incentive to separate the parents
from the entire experience
and to have the pediatricians and the schools
all be involved in this bizarre breakdown of the family
is really, it's actually very scary.
It's personally very scary to me
because I wanna be able to trust the society that I live in
and so many of these things are just becoming glaring examples
of how important it is that we step back in.
Well, the book is entirely looks at the research of,
I went through this from a psychological perspective
because parents were getting so pushed around.
Every time parents thought, this doesn't seem right.
Why are they asking my kids about suicide?
And people said, well, it's for mental health.
These are coping techniques
and your child could be suicidal.
Parents didn't have a response.
Or the gaslighting is real.
The gaslighting is real.
So I went back and looked at the research to see,
well, is this actually good for kids?
And the truth is repetitively bringing up suicide
with kids, valorizing the person who killed themselves.
Do you know anyone?
This sort of thing.
Those things, that is exactly how to spread
a suicide contagion.
Well, that's also what they did
with the gender affirming care, right?
Your first book, are you sure you don't wanna be a boy?
Are you sure you don't wanna be?
Maybe you wanna be a boy.
Maybe you wanna, do you wanna try?
Maybe dress up like a boy?
Maybe, right?
And so eventually you put it in the child's mind
enough times they start questioning.
And when you actually reward them for,
oh, so wonderful that you're now deciding
to change your gender.
Let's all celebrate.
It's so wonderful that you're going to a therapist
on a regular basis
because you're taking care of yourself.
Oh, parent, you're a great parent
for taking your child to therapy three times a week.
So you're actually celebrating the act of victimhood.
That's right.
And I interviewed a woman, a young woman, 16 year old
in the book, I call her Nora.
But basically she told me,
and many, many high school students then said the same thing.
She told me that in high school, it's really weird
if you don't have a mental health diagnosis.
Wow.
And the problem is, look, you can say I was shy
or I was lazy and you can get over those things.
But once you start saying, no, I have anxiety,
you're talking to something,
you're talking yourself into a brain problem.
Well, how do you solve a brain problem?
You need an expert to help you and you need a drug.
If Abigail from her 20s could make it into 2024
and watch you do the work that you're doing today,
what do you think young Abigail,
not that you're not young anymore,
but what do you think young Abigail would say
about the work you're doing today?
It's funny, I've always kind of been a truth teller
and it's certainly gotten me into a lot of trouble socially.
I mean, I was always the one that they,
you know, girls would say to me in high school,
you can't say that, you know,
but here's sort of what I've learned.
And that is that there was this amazing role for me
by telling the truth
because we're living in this time
where the pressures to go along are so extreme
that there was a role for the way I was.
And the reason I bring that up,
you know, I guess the psychological profession
that calls it disagreeable personality is the category.
You know, I'm willing to sort of hurt people's feelings
to say the truth,
but here's the thing that I want people to know,
we're all different.
And just because your child is a little quirky
in this way or that,
it doesn't mean they have a mental disorder.
Don't let someone diagnose them
unless they absolutely have a problem
because if they don't have a problem,
you're gonna change the way that child sees himself.
And if you start a child on medication,
you may be putting them in an emotional snowsuit.
They may not feel the lows anymore,
but they might not get the highs either.
You wanna develop their musculature.
Stop asking all the time,
how do I make my kids happy?
Start asking, how do I make my kids strong?
If we make strong kids, they'll be happy kids.
I completely agree.
So much of what we're falling into
is the language game,
the expert word game
where we're manipulated to think the things
that are really bad for us,
they say are good for us.
We talked a little bit about SEL
and there are many other words like that.
And I wanna empower the people
who are listening to us to understand
how to navigate some of the terminology
that is being thrown our way.
There's both good terminology and bad terminology.
I wrote some of it down.
I just think it's so important
that we just offer as much help as we can.
And I know that's the goal that you have as well.
That was PragerU,
the whole point of this organization
is to empower people.
So let's play a little word game
where maybe you can help clarify
to those who are listening,
some of the things that I have collected
as words that will show up in family everyday life.
Let's start with SEL.
SEL, how should people think about SEL?
Social emotional learning.
It's a program in school.
It means anything they want,
the educators want it to mean.
Sometimes it means straight up Marxism,
but very often it's a psychological program
that is essentially group therapy.
Getting kids to dwell on their pain.
And oftentimes takes the time
of reading, writing, and arithmetic, right?
Something you can't measure.
I'd add that.
Use the term memory poker.
Yeah, so I got that from Elizabeth Loftus,
a wonderful, brilliant psychologist
and one of the greatest living psychologists
of the 20th century.
And she said that when you put people
in a group therapy setting,
you often have this sort of memory poker.
Everyone tries to one up each other with their trauma.
And that's why it leads people
to feel sadder very often.
And that's what we're doing in schools.
We're asking, oh,
and what was a hard thing you've gone through?
Well, you don't want to say something boring
after your friend just talked
about his parents' divorce.
So now you have to come up
with something really traumatic.
The problem is in the process,
you're likely to exaggerate a past memory,
especially a child.
And you're also likely to talk yourself
into the idea that you've been traumatized.
Parentified.
The term parentified.
This is more of the psychopathologization
of human life.
They take something positive,
giving kids high expectations
and responsibility,
and they tell them,
no, you've been emotionally abused
by your parents.
Can you give any examples
of how you came across this term?
Sure.
Immigrant kids are told,
you were parentified.
Your parents,
sometimes they'll outright say it,
but it's a form of abuse.
Why?
Your parents put too much responsibility on you.
You know what?
Immigrant kids do great for a reason
because they have that responsibility
because their parents exert authority
and they have responsibility
and it serves them well.
So like a family that immigrated here
and the parents don't speak English very well.
And I can think of those examples
where the child has to help the parents
get through filling up forms
and helping them get through life in general.
But because the child doesn't get to be child
for the rest of their lives,
they've been parentified.
Is that the concept?
Exactly.
And you know what?
Giving to the common good,
doing for the common good
is so good for your mental health.
Oh my, it's so enriching.
It's so enriching.
But instead,
you've got these kids
who are running towards adulthood.
These immigrant kids
are running towards adulthood
and you have these American,
native born American kids
who want to stay on their parents' couch
and live at home
when they're 18 to 25.
We've never had so many American kids
choosing to live with mom and dad.
Oh, wow.
What a glaring example.
You talk about the term trauma
and I guess this is a newer thing for me
because when I was an educator,
I didn't hear the word trauma come up so often.
So I think that has been
a very negative evolution of probably SEL.
But how should we think about this term trauma
in conjunction with our kids going to school?
Sure.
So like everything else,
there are traumatic events.
There are people with PTSD.
The problem is that we've convinced everyone
that every bit of hardship,
every bit of heartbreak is trauma
and they might have PTSD.
It's a very bad suggestion for kids.
It's not true.
It's actually nonsense.
Most of them will do just fine
and it gets applied to every hard thing
a kid goes through.
They will say,
oh, your grandmother died.
That was trauma.
In most cases, that won't be.
As sad as it is,
the child will recover fine.
We want, obviously,
grandkids to outlive their grandparents.
I'm going to make a conscious decision
to not use the word trauma and PTSD
because it's become part of our lexicon.
It's like, oh my God,
I had such a traumatizing day.
Right.
And we need to be so careful
with the words we use
because we then rob them of their true meaning.
And here's the thing.
It's not that I don't respect people
who have real PTSD,
who have gone through severe traumatic experience.
It doesn't help them
that we're applying it casually
to a population that didn't go through
anything particularly scary.
When you think about the term experts,
because I feel like that's a term
that's logged at us oftentimes
in order to manipulate us
into making certain decisions.
How do you think about experts?
So obviously, like a lot of Americans,
I think we all sort of lost
a lot of faith we had in experts.
But they're always,
it's this giant shell game going on.
Oh, you have to master the new methods
for child rearing.
Now you have to deal with this parenting expert
or this psychological expert.
Let me tell you something.
Let's start with parenting experts.
To me, the only parenting expert,
the only person you should listen to for advice
is someone who has raised good kids to adulthood.
That is a person worth consulting.
Not this person who mastered
this awkward set of techniques
for talking to a kid
where you never get to meet the kids
that her wonderful techniques have produced.
You know what's amazing?
I think about the books
that have been written by parenting experts
and how many of them don't even have children.
It's pretty glaring.
Go take those parenting expert books
and just put them away
and use your parental instincts
because you love your kids.
And your history and experience.
What did your mom do?
I mean, here's the thing.
You know, not only did they ruin parents' confidence,
but they made them awkward and weird
with their children by professionalizing it.
Parents talk to children now
like they're imitating therapists.
Everyone sounds like an,
oh, are you having big feelings?
I mean, everyone is aping this therapeutic language.
You know, I can see that made you really sad
not to get the red cup instead of the blue cup.
You know, and we've lost the fun
of being with our kids.
And you know what?
It was never supposed to be
a professional relationship.
You needed authority.
You needed a certain amount of hierarchy,
but it was yours.
These are your kids.
Raise them as according to your values
as you think is best.
You know, I think parents want to receive
some sort of manual so that they can be,
you know, get a guarantee
that they're gonna ace that test
because that's what our mindset has been on, right?
We're on this assembly line
where we go through the washer,
which is what I call basically
our left-wing indoctrination centers,
also known as government schools.
And we have to go through a rigorous assembly line
of how to win in life, right?
How to win in finding the careers
that we should be getting
or even raising kids.
And so we have to have the experts
to give us a manual.
And if we read the manual,
and we follow the manual,
then we'll be successful at that.
And forget about our instincts.
Forget about our autonomy.
Let's just make sure that we follow the experts
so that we can be guaranteed to be successful.
And you know what?
Many of us are gonna raise great kids
because we're great people.
And some great people are gonna raise not great kids.
And some not great people will raise great kids.
Not everything can be controlled
or really decided upon by some sort of manual
that has been written by a supposed expert.
I think that's why we're being duped
because we are expected to follow
some sort of assembly line process
in order to win in life.
And we're not following what we know works.
I mean, actually passing on your values to your kids,
that's essential.
Parents have thought since the beginning
of truly going back,
I don't know how many thousands of years,
they thought that passing on our values to our kids
is an essential part of parenting.
Raising a strong person,
giving them independence,
teaching them something
and giving them the independence,
which means not monitoring them.
Because you know how psychologists introduce stress
into any experiment?
They add monitoring.
We are stressing out these kids
with our frantic monitoring.
We don't trust them to exercise their judgment
because we never lay down the rules with them.
We try to avoid punishment
so we can't trust their judgment
and then we have to hover endlessly.
And that's what we're doing.
The term caregivers comes to my mind
because I know that is a term
that the schools have been using a lot
instead of parents.
Right.
I mean, it's an offensive term.
It really is.
It reduces parents to service providers.
But it's also an instructive term.
You know, when I saw it in the materials in the schools,
I thought,
this is how the teachers think of
or the educators think of parents.
And it's teaching children.
This is what your parents are.
They're just service providers for you.
They're not particularly important.
And we can sit around discussing
what they did last night,
what your punishment was
or how they behaved with you
and decide if we think it's good.
Wow.
What's your reaction to the term equity?
I think it's just Marxism by another name, right?
It's an idea of redistribution.
It's a big part of the new SEL curriculum across America.
People think that the problems
are only in California and New York,
but I've been scanning through curriculum
all over the country.
It is a fundamental piece of SEL.
There are so many books that are coming out
that even talk about how to teach SEL
through the lens of equity.
And I just would imagine that
for a big segment of the population,
that which you identify as a problem,
which is you are a victim,
the system is set up to basically hurt you
and stifle you.
That is what we're teaching through equity and SEL.
Have you noticed that also through your research?
Absolutely.
They call it transformative SEL.
That's the explicitly Marxist SEL.
But the reason I didn't write about that part
was because I thought,
and I still think,
that's something that parents are generally aware of.
They know to look for the critical race theory.
Chris Rufo and others have done wonderful work
to expose that.
What they might not know
is that the stuff that travels
under the rubric mental health,
that's just as harmful.
It is so important what you just said
because what has happened is
we are laser focused on the words
that we already know are dangerous
and they've already moved on
to doing much bigger things.
And they're just out there laughing at us.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, you go focus,
marinate over equity.
Meanwhile, we're going to take
the whole mental health industry
and dominate it.
Exactly.
Sometimes I think they almost stuck in
some of that transformative,
you know, the critical race theory
almost to confuse people
because the truth is
even the stuff that's supposedly
supposed to teach emotional regulation,
that's doing a fair amount of harm too.
Wow.
Can you just talk a little bit
about student mental health surveys
and student mental health clinics?
I know that they're opening
some of these mental health clinics in schools.
Absolutely, across California,
certainly in the Los Angeles area.
And I believe across California,
we now have these mental health clinics.
I mean, the mandate now
in schools across the country
is increase mental health,
increase mental health.
They did these amazing studies,
two sets of studies
while I was writing the book,
in Australia and in England.
Actually, a set of researchers studied
whether these techniques,
these so-called mental health techniques
were good for kids,
like wellness, emotional regulation,
techniques, coping techniques.
Were they helping kids?
And what they found again and again
was the kids who went through those programs
ended up sadder and more anxious
and more alienated from their parents.
So the stuff that travels
under mental health is not helping.
It really is injurious.
Abigail, final question.
For those who are listening,
I'm sure they have steam
coming out of their ears.
They're probably very upset
about a lot of the stuff.
There are a lot of other things
that are very upsetting
about what's happening
in America right now.
But in order for us
not to get overwhelmed
and also realize that
we can do something,
what are the first steps
that you recommend that we do
in order to get out of this mess?
Right.
So I will-
Give me easy, easy, easy stuff.
Don't say, oh, elect a new,
shut down the Department of Education.
Something we can actually do ourselves.
Okay, what I want you to know
is this is the easiest problem to fix.
Good, I want easy.
This is the easiest problem.
We in America have been
We know how to do this.
It requires parental authority,
which doesn't mean being unloving.
It means being loving.
But ultimately,
parents make the rules
and parents meet out.
Yes, consequences,
if there are consequences,
which means saying no.
Okay, we know this is good for kids.
It means give them people who love them
and they love back over a lifetime.
That's so important.
Cousins, uncles, aunts,
grandma, grandpa,
those people are essential.
Tell them they're connected
to a broader world
and make sure they know
they have to contribute to it.
That means things like chores,
doing something,
giving them a sense of efficacy
in this world.
You can walk home from school.
You can walk home from the school bus.
I can trust you to do that.
Look both ways and go ahead.
Trusting them to develop
their natural resources,
but it also means when they're hurt,
when they're sad,
when someone says something mean to them,
tells them, you know what?
You're going to be just fine.
Keep playing.
I love it.
I'm going to have my kids
cook dinner tonight
and I'm going to add a little sprinkle
of vitamin N, vitamin no.
How about that?
I love it.
Thanks for this great work that you do
and this great discussion.
Really appreciate you.
It's always great talking to you, Marissa.
Thank you.