Is Death Scarier for an Atheist? | Fireside Chat

PragerU
799 followers
Mar 23, 2025
Why would an atheist be scared of dying? Dennis offers this listener some perspective.
📲 Download the FREE PragerU app: https://prageru.onelink.me/3bas/vgyxvm79
Follow PragerU on social media!
Instagram ➡️ (https://www.instagram.com/prageru/)
Twitter ➡️ (https://twitter.com/prageru)
Facebook ➡️ (https://www.facebook.com/prageru/)
Nate, 26 years old, Minnesota.
Hello Dennis, I'm one of what may be very few atheist listeners, because you defend
your ideas well in spite of our disagreements.
Let me just say this, Nate, it's to your credit, whenever people who differ with me write to
me or call my show, I always note it is to your credit.
Many people do not want to hear anything with which they differ.
So, I give you a lot of credit.
I'm wondering what advice you would give to someone who is scared of dying and cannot
bring himself to believe in heaven.
I expect death to be an endless sleep, a return to wherever I was before I was born.
It is a remarkably scary prospect.
Well, first of all, it's interesting that at 26 you're thinking of death.
That's to your credit, too.
You're obviously a thinker, because built into youth is, not intellectually, but psychologically,
one doesn't think they'll die when they're very young.
And by the way, it's a gift.
You should know it.
It's very important to know, because it can help shape a meaningful life if you know you're
not here forever.
But let me deal specifically with what you raised.
So first of all, to be precise, you're not returning to what you were prior to being
born.
You are on an unconscious level.
You'll be as unconscious about anything after you die, if indeed there is nothing afterwards,
as you were before you were born.
But the difference is, you were eventually born.
So it wasn't endless.
Whereas if there is no God, which is what you believe as an atheist, it is endless,
which is hard to believe that it's oblivion forever, the fate of all of us if there is
no God.
Where I do part ways emotionally, because it's an emotion you're talking about, scared
is an emotion, I don't understand why that's scary.
Were you unhappy before you were born, to use your correct analogy?
No.
So you won't be unhappy after you die.
If there's nothing, it's not something to be scared of.
I can understand being scared of punishment, of there being a hell and that you think you
deserve a hell.
That's one thing.
But oblivion is not scary, it's depressing.
There's a big difference.
When I think about dying, and I'm much closer presumably than you are, I'm not scared in
the least, because either there's a heaven and hell, and I don't think I have merited
hell, maybe I'll be wrong, but I've tried to lead a pretty good life, and I think I've
done a lot of good, and I've tried to from a very early age.
So either there's something good following my death, or there's nothing.
Nothing is not scary, because I'm unaware of what is happening.
It's like, if you ever went under with an anesthetic for surgery, were you unhappy during
the surgery?
No.
Well, you won't be unhappy after death.
It's the equivalent, in effect.
But I am sad.
The prospect of dying makes me sad, because I love life, and I love people in my life,
I love what I do, I love every day, and it's the thought of not having it, it does sadden
me.
It doesn't depress me, but it is sad, leaving all these loved ones and leaving just such
an enjoyable life.
Even putting all my loved ones aside, I just enjoy life immensely.
I always have.
I'm very blessed in that way.
So yes, it's sad, but it's not scary.
So it's something for you to think about, since you're obviously a thinker.
You might also want to rethink your atheism.
See, if you said you're agnostic, I get that.
But an atheist seems to be more or less certain that there is no God.
And I think on a purely rational level, the idea that everything came about on its own
is way more irrational than the idea that there is a creator, on purely rational grounds.
