China's May Economic Data Shows ‘Zombie Economy’; China Tops Global Wealth Exodus

China Truths
61 followers
"China's May Economic Data Not Optimistic, Experts: It's Already a Zombie Economy
China Leads the World in Loss of Wealthy Individuals, Severely Impacting Its Economy
Multiple Chinese Banks to Suspend Online Interbank Transfer Services Due to System Maintenance
Video Captures Chinese Officials' Power Abuse in Parking Dispute, Sparks Outrage
Latest Chinese Data Lack Impetus as Political Uncertainty Looms
#china #chinatruths #chinanews"
China's May economic data not optimistic, experts.
It's already a zombie economy.
China leads the world in loss of wealthy individuals,
severely impacting its economy.
Multiple Chinese banks to suspend online interbank transfer services
due to system maintenance.
Video captures Chinese officials' power abuse in parking dispute sparks outrage.
Latest Chinese data lack impetus as political uncertainty looms.
It's all covered in today's China Truths.
China's May economic data not optimistic, experts.
It's already a zombie economy.
The National Bureau of Statistics of China recently released
the national economic data for May,
describing it as showing a trend toward improvement.
However, experts analyzed that the mainland economy has become a zombie economy.
Between January and May, the total retail sales of consumer goods increased year over year,
but at less than half the rate seen before the pandemic.
Despite a reported 3.7% increase in May,
which is higher than the previous month and marked the first rise since December last year,
experts suggest the increase is not as promising as it appears.
Senior Taiwanese political and economic scholar Wu Jialong
attributes the rise to seasonal factors,
indicating that holiday spending does not predict sustained consumer activity.
Following the release of China's economic data for May by the National Bureau of Statistics,
spokesperson Liu Weihua reported signs of recovery and improvement in the economy,
with increased policy support and accelerated investments from the central budget and special bonds.
However, Mr. Wang Guichen,
a research assistant at the China Economic Research Institute,
offered a starkly different view,
describing mainland China's economy as a zombie economy.
He explained that in a zombie economy,
any movement or activity is solely driven by government intervention.
When the government injects funds,
the economy briefly reacts,
but it stagnates as soon as the government pulls back.
Zombie economics is characterized by a financially insecure and crisis-prone future,
primarily caused by an imbalanced economic structure.
Wang noted that the Manufacturing Purchasing Managers Index,
PMI, remains unstable, hovering around 50.
The PMI only improves when the government increases spending and declines when it does not.
The economy, therefore, fluctuates based on government spending without sustainable momentum.
Mr. Wang emphasized that these fluctuations are due to the government's direct involvement.
Without such intervention,
the economy would likely worsen,
a reality the government might prefer to avoid disclosing.
Additionally, economic scholar Wu Jialong mentioned that the manufacturing and investment
sectors aren't doing too well,
showing that there's a steady economic downturn going on,
which is really tied to some deep-seated issues in China's economy.
He also said that the government has pretty much tried everything they could think of
to stop this economic slide,
but nothing's really worked so far.
Mr. Wu argued that the current government measures are more focused on maintaining stability
and managing potential social unrest
rather than genuinely rescuing the economy from its ongoing struggles.
China leads the world in loss of wealthy individuals,
severely impacting its economy.
On June 18, the international investment immigration consulting firm Henley and Partners
released the 2024 Henley Private Wealth Migration Report,
detailing the latest net inflows and outflows of millionaires.
The report estimates that 15,200 wealthy Chinese will leave in 2024,
up from 13,800 in 2023,
representing a record level of wealth outflow for China.
Professor Xie Tian from the Aiken Business School at the University of South Carolina
stated,
these wealthy individuals are leaving,
capital is fleeing,
and industrial chains are shifting.
They are also joining the major shift in international industrial chains,
with their own companies also fleeing,
which represents a significant hemorrhage for the Chinese economy.
The phenomenon of capital flight from China has existed for many years.
In recent years,
the Chinese government has strictly controlled the transfer of funds overseas,
but in 2023,
wealthy Chinese still transferred hundreds of billions of dollars out of the country.
He explained that the ongoing migration of China's wealthy individuals
is largely due to the CCP increased suppression of private and privately owned enterprises.
Favoring state-owned enterprises,
the CCP views private entrepreneurs and wealthy individuals with suspicion,
often treating them as outsiders.
This has led those who can to leave the country.
The situation has been exacerbated by the imprisonment of several businessmen
closely associated with the CCP,
such as Xiao Jianhua, Wu Xiaowei, and Renjie Qiang,
along with temporary disappearances or severe legal actions
against other entrepreneurs like Jack Ma and Su Jiayin.
These incidents have driven many wealthy Chinese to silently flee the country.
Professor Xia highlights the growing challenges wealthy Chinese face
in escaping the country,
liquidating their assets,
or converting them into foreign currency.
This exodus is driven by a pessimistic view of China's declining economy
and limited investment opportunities.
Additionally,
the threat of higher tariffs from Europe and the USA makes investing in China less appealing
as it limits the exportability of Chinese-made products.
Consequently,
many investors are relocating their capital and operations to avoid these tariffs.
Popular destinations for these migrating millionaires include Singapore,
the USA, Canada, and Japan,
with Southeast Asia becoming a significant option.
Many have relocated their family businesses to Singapore
or moved their production to Vietnam to sidestep trade sanctions.
Mr. Xia, a Malaysian-Chinese businessman,
noted that many of his business contacts have migrated,
with some only realizing the necessity after the pandemic
increased the financial burden of migration.
He recounted advising his friends early on to consider moving abroad,
but many were initially skeptical.
The economic downturn post-pandemic and ongoing trade wars
have since persuaded many to leave,
leading to job losses and business closures within China.
He said that many are now opting for decentralized virtual currencies
to bypass national and banking restrictions,
converting RMB into such currencies for easier liquidation abroad,
free from the oversight of the People's Bank of China.
Reflecting on the broader implications,
Mr. Xia concluded that many wealthy Chinese have recognized
the CCP's hostile stance towards them
and are now doing everything possible to relocate themselves and their assets abroad,
even if full escape is not possible.
Multiple Chinese banks to suspend online interbank transfer services
due to system maintenance
Several banks, including China Everbright Bank,
Industrial Bank, Ningbo Bank,
and Harbin Bank have recently issued announcements
regarding the suspension of certain services
due to system maintenance of the People's Bank of China.
The service suspension scheduled during the period
from midnight to six o'clock on June 23.
These banks will suspend services,
such as electronic channel interbank transfers,
for individuals during this period.
On June 18, China Everbright Bank announced
that the People's Bank of China will conduct a maintenance window
from midnight to six o'clock on June 23, 2024,
affecting the small payment system
and the online payment interbank clearing system.
This will cause a temporary halt in transactions during this period.
Consequently, China Everbright Bank will suspend several services,
including interbank remittances,
interbank connectivity,
and transactions related to commercial bills,
both in corporate and private online and mobile banking.
Services such as transfers to other bank accounts,
signing interbank agreements,
and real-time receipts from other banks will also be unavailable.
Similarly, other banks like Ningbo Bank,
Industrial Bank,
and Harbin Bank have announced comparable suspensions
for the same reasons,
though the specific services affected vary.
Ningbo Bank will also undergo a system upgrade later in June,
impacting certain services further.
Industrial Bank will suspend RMB interbank transfer services
across multiple banking channels,
though ATM services for interbank personal transfers
under 50,000 yuan, about $6,900, will remain active.
Harbin Bank will suspend its small payment
and interbank clearing system operations,
affecting related interbank transfer services.
Regarding the reason for this service suspension,
the banks have only stated system maintenance
and have not disclosed further details
on the direct cause of these decisions,
though there is speculation
that a system vulnerability may have been discovered.
Video captures Chinese officials' power abuse
in parking dispute sparks outrage.
On June 16, an account named Derun Media on X released a video
showing footage posted by a Beijing netizen.
In the video, he encounters a black sedan
with a diplomatic license plate
parked in the middle of the road, causing a traffic jam.
As he approached to negotiate, the woman in the car yelled,
if you keep filming me, I'll tell you, I'll call the police.
Do you know what a diplomatic car is?
Do you understand?
Get lost.
The video shows the black car blocking the right-hand lane,
preventing vehicles from passing,
forcing a white car to turn around.
The netizen confronted her, asking,
just because it's a diplomatic car, it can park anywhere?
Blocking people's doors, right?
No one can pass, right?
Do you park like this?
While filming, the netizen said,
I'm dealing with you today.
Call 122.
I'll show you how to park.
The lady in the black car whispered to the driver
to leave and gestured threateningly to the filmer saying,
are you filming me?
Is that it?
Later, as she got into the car,
she pointed at the filmer saying, get lost.
Keep filming me, I'll call the police.
She made a phone call and then pointing at the filmer said,
wait for the call, just you wait.
The lady seemed arrogant, pointing with her finger while saying,
On June 19, Beijing police reported that on the morning of June 16,
a dispute arose due to a diplomatic license plate vehicle
parked at the intersection of Guangxin Street
and Guangtai East Road in Chaoyang District.
The vehicle registered to an international organization
was improperly parked by Su, a 61-year-old man,
and Yuqi, a 58-year-old woman, an employee of the organization,
who refused to move their car and insulted others,
issuing inappropriate comments.
According to the Beijing News on June 19,
Yuqi, the current secretary-general of the Asia-Pacific Space Cooperation Organization,
APSCO,
apologized for her inappropriate behavior and released an apology video.
Yuqi stated,
I also realized that my actions have negatively impacted
the international organization I belong to,
and I deeply regret this.
I sincerely accept criticism from all parties
and the actions taken by the relevant authorities.
Public records show that Yuqi previously served
as the deputy director of the International Cooperation Department
of the China National Space Administration
and is now the secretary-general of APSCO.
APSCO, founded in 2008 and headquartered in Beijing, China,
is an intergovernmental non-profit international organization
composed of countries in the Asia-Pacific region.
The organization aims to promote multilateral cooperation
among member countries in space science, technology, and applications.
This incident has sparked heated discussions among netizens
both domestically and internationally.
Netizens on mainland Weibo mocked,
times have indeed changed.
Over a hundred years ago,
foreigners used consular jurisdiction to bully Chinese people
and now Chinese people use diplomatic immunity to bully their own.
Another netizen commented,
this scene is truly spectacular.
It encapsulates the arrogance of privilege
and also mocks the hypocrisy of the rule of law.
Latest Chinese data lack impetus as political uncertainty looms.
China's recent economic data presents a concerning picture
as weak domestic demand continues to obstruct recovery efforts
from ongoing issues in the property market.
The situation is further complicated by increasing trade tensions
which analysts believe could significantly slow economic growth.
In May, industrial production fell below expectations
and the slump in the property sector persisted
despite government interventions aimed at stimulating growth.
Although retail sales saw a temporary spike due to a holiday period,
the overall data suggests an uneven and challenging recovery
for the world's second largest economy.
The National Bureau of Statistics, NBS,
reported that industrial production growth decreased to 0.3% in May,
down from 1% in April,
primarily due to declines in property-related industries such as cement.
Automobile production growth also declined sharply.
However, sectors like industrial robots,
solar panels,
and semiconductors experienced significant growth.
Despite a 3.7% increase in retail sales in May aided by a public holiday,
analysts from Berkeley's FICC research are skeptical about the sustainability
of this growth due to weakening labor markets
and financial constraints among households.
Efforts to boost online retail sales began in May rather than June,
with major e-commerce platforms like Alibaba and JD.com
moving their annual sales events earlier.
Additionally, HSBC noted improvements from policies
encouraging consumers to replace older durable goods
with new, energy-efficient models.
Yet, the property market remains a major economic drag.
Despite policy efforts to stabilize this sector,
new home prices in May saw their most significant drop in over nine years.
The real estate sector continues to struggle with a large inventory
of unsold properties and mounting developer debts.
Labor market conditions have not shown improvement,
with employment rates in manufacturing,
services,
and construction all contracting for the fourth consecutive month.
The economic outlook is further threatened by political tensions in Europe and the U.S.,
which have led to higher tariffs and potential trade conflicts.
Barclays predicts a severe slowdown in economic growth to just 0.2%
in the upcoming quarter,
emphasizing that the risks to growth remain high.
Don't forget to comment in the section below
to share your opinions on today's topic with us.
If you find the information helpful,
please share this video with a friend to watch together.
This will be a great source of motivation for our team
to produce more and more quality and reliable videos.
And also don't forget to like and subscribe
to see more interesting topics from China Truths.
Thank you for tuning in.
