Native Culture Arts: Traditional Comanche Arrow Making

Tradition Keepers
9 followers
Mar 25, 2025
Join Willie Pekah, a master of traditional Comanche craftsmanship, as he shares his deep knowledge and skill in making authentic Comanche arrows. With years of experience passed down through generations, Willie walks us through the sacred process of crafting arrows that are not only tools but symbols of the Comanche people's history, resilience, and cultural pride.
Gain insight into the art of arrow-making, from selecting the right materials to the intricate techniques that have been honed over centuries.
My name is Willie Pica. I'm from the Comanche Nation. I'm a traditional bow and arrow maker.
I've been doing this since about nine years old, so now that took me about 61 years.
Today we're going to talk about making a traditional Comanche arrow. The process going
from getting it cut in the creek, what to look for when you cut the dogwood, down to getting it
processed, making it look like an arrow shaft. I'll talk about everything. I'll do the knob,
put the feathers on, the points, talk to you about how Comanches made them
hundreds of years ago to make them traditional. Now when I go into the creek to cut all the shaft,
this is what it looks like in the creek. This is a dogwood. I did research it for Oklahoma. There's
about 17 varieties of dogwood. The best place to find them is along the creek or inside a
boggy area. I like to go inside a boggy area where there's a lot of trees. That way when the shaft
grows, they grow to the sun. They get a lot straighter. If you get them outside the edge of the
creek, they're too much bent. They sway around too much. I try to look for different dogwood shafts
and I try to get them close to the arrow that I want to make. You got to allow for the bark to be
taken off. One of the old things that the old guys were telling me is how to find dogwood that
works for you and makes a good arrow. I was told when you're making one, you select it where it's
long enough for your arrow. I make them about 27-28 inches. When you find them in the creek,
they need to be a little bit larger than your regular shaft. That way you take the bark down
and shape them. It comes down to this, which works out nice. But getting back to the point
of where you're selecting the arrows, I was told by the old arrow makers, when you use dogwood,
try to get where you see the limbs here. That's where you want to put the knock of your arrow.
That's where you want to put the knock of the arrow, right here in that. When you've got these
limbs coming out, it's kind of like the burl effect of a tree. The wood is real dense there
and opposed to be down at the bottom where you have straighter grain layers that go this way.
Up here, it kind of intermingles. That's the best place to make the arrow knock.
It's stronger and it doesn't tend to split when you put the string there.
It's the best place for it. I've found out through the years that's where I put my knock.
So, I start here, then I go down to the length that I want. That's how I usually gauge it.
From the knock to where the point goes in the front. What I do is, when I get a piece,
first thing you got to do, once you size it up, or you've got your, you know, limbs are for your
back end, you just have to start working them. What I do is, I start shaving them down and you
just got to work them down. Shave it down, shave it down. It's a lot of work, but that's the way I do
it. If you've got a better way, fine with me, but you got to take that bark off. As I'm shaving it
down, I just rotate the knife and the shaft so it just keeps coming off. When you get to those
knocks, I mean the knots, you got to cut them off just a little bit because you want to eventually
work those down. Okay, so you take those off as you're going and then keep working it, taking it
down. That's the process. It takes a while. It's just something that doesn't happen. When I go cut,
I make so many nowadays, I've got to have about 150 or so of these that last me through the years
because once I get it all cut up, I bundle them together, straighten them as best I can because
it comes crooked in the creek, but you know, they're still green and you can work them.
So I work them and get them straight and then when I get them all settled where they're down,
I like to bundle them. I bundle them in the seventh. That way
you get one in the center and they all go around. Okay, that way when you get them,
they're pulling against each other, you tighten them up where they all stay straight as much as
you can. I bundle them and about a week or so later, I'll unbundle them and keep working it
down with the 9% paper where you do to get those knots off and just keep working them
until you get them to where you want. Okay. Once I do that, then I go ahead and worry about
oh, backing up. When you're sanding these, you've got little spaces where the limbs were.
Okay. And those are usually raised where the limbs were coming out. So when you're sanding them,
I get a block. It doesn't matter. You can make your own. You need to be about six, eight inches.
That way when you sand those down, it sends them flat with the length of the arrow shaft.
So it doesn't dig in if you add a little bit. So just, you know, run them and it gives you a
straight arrow if you sand them down like that. And you finally get a shaft that'll work for you.
And you're going to find out is that when you get them in the creek,
they're full of moisture. They're heavy. As you cure them and dry them out, they get much lighter
and they make a great arrow. They're stronger and they will work better so you don't have to
worry about them and they stay straight. After I put the nock in in the back, what I try to do is
I cut the nock down and you'll see where it kind of shapes in. I cut them down.
The reason I do that is that's where the nock is can be for the string to come in.
So I'll put them to a shape like that and then I'll, I get a file to the size that I want for
my string to go and then I just take it down the middle and you just cut your nock in. And remember
that's where those limbs came out on these sides so that's pretty dense right there and it makes
a great knot for it. And that's the way these come out. When I shape them down,
you've got the nock that comes in right here. And I start putting on the feathers and everything.
Okay now to keep it straight and one thing that the elders taught me
is Comanches, they always put, they called it a blood groove. So it's in and there's a groove down
the whole length of the arrow on three sides. Like I said they call it a blood groove so when it goes
in it's still supposed to let the blood come out. I found out later it adds to the strength of the
arrow. It's kind of like I always call the tin horn effect. We got a tin horn. It makes it so
much stronger. Same way with the groove. A groove brings it in and your arrow stays stronger and
it would. You always straighten them but I found out if you put the groove in they last and stay
stronger longer opposed to not having the groove. So it's one thing that Comanches always did
was put the blood grooves. They're a pain to do but it pays off in the long run.
Now how I put the grooves in, this is off a rib bone and they had usually
some kind of point that came through. I use a screw where you got a knot where it goes on your
arrow. Okay and then that little screw is sharpened where it fits on your groove that you're making
and I just work it back and forth, work it back and forth and I get that groove
where I want it and like I said it adds to the strength
of the arrow which you guys call the blood groove. It's a great process. It's just hard to do.
You've got so many things to do just to make a good arrow and that's the way the elders made
them. So I try to reproduce them. I can't cut corners as much as I can but I've adapted to
the new ways and you know like having sandpaper and things like that.
Now to the points, Comanches made several different kinds of points. The progression for
Comanche arrows was when they first started making arrows they didn't know about the points,
how they figured it out. I have no idea but in the beginning they just sharpened the point.
Just a sharp point where it would go in things. Through the years and progression of developing
arrows they went from points, then they learned how to make them out of bone. Bone was the next
one. Now this is a buffalo rib bone that I use and I'll show you how to do those in a minute.
Went from just a straight point to a buffalo point. Then when Americans moved in and the
frontier they would find metal and one of the things in the beginning they liked to use was
that metal that goes around the wagon wheel. They would take that take chunks and shape it into a
point. The problem we had with the wagon wheel is that metal was so heavy that when you shot
the arrow it's called dipping. It goes then it drops okay because it was too heavy in the front
end. Through the years of seeing the frontier they went to a different metal. They found the
old hand saws that some of the carpenters would use and shape that into a metal point. Now these
are so rigid and those old hand saws you can put a razor edge on each one so these can be so sharp
but I don't do that because people you know touch them and they move around and they would do that
but they would take the old hand saw and what they would do is you have the hand saw then you put a
and score your pattern on that hand saw and mark it on that metal hand saw and then you take a cold
chisel along that hand saw on your pattern a cold chisel and just score it. You don't want to break
it all the way through because it's a cold metal so once you make your line all the way through
just get a piece of pliers and break it and it just snaps off. Then you're left with this.
Then you take it now you just take it to a grinder you can take a file and shape it down to the way
you want it and usually I try to come out something like this. Different sizes they would have for the
points everybody had a different way some of them were smaller straighter and some were longer
that's how they would do the the metal points but it's a great they're light and they can really
put an edge on it and that's from an old hand saw. Now the way they would do the bone points
the bone points and I found out through different bone points I would use a buffalo
rib bone a big rib bone that they'd come I would cut sections out of it in the rib bone
and then when I get it cut out then I take a knife on each one and split it and it would come apart
from then I would shave it down right now you could whichever you want to shave it down but I get a
little grinder sander little sander and I grind these down to where I have a flat piece it comes
into this and it makes you know it makes a beautiful little point they look they look
really original but it would come down to from this grinding it down to this then you would go
ahead and get your pattern put it on there and work it mark it then you would take it back to
the sander and work it down to where you need it and this is what I come out with these are the
points that are making for a set of arrows for a guy and they're you know they're pretty nice
they look good so you your options is a straight point which nowadays I use for
target practice you don't need to put a metal tip on it you sharpen because dogwood once you
harden the end what I do is put it in a fire and darken it and shape it a little bit and get a
point and I use those for my target point target points then I'm when I'm making them for traditional
guys I would either use the metal or the bone points or whatever they prefer and that's how you
do it now when uh when you get back to making the metal points what I found out when I make it out
the hand saws that before I put the point on you've got to put that groove into it and I found
out that if you get a hacksaw and cut your groove the width of the blade is the same as the metal
from the hand saw so once you cut your groove down with the hacksaw it makes a beautiful point
then it then you can just slide it in you got to cut it deep enough to get where you want
where it comes out or it sits in far enough then you would take your
people I used to use the imitation sinew but I make so many nowadays that I use imitation sinew
so once you get your point in put some glue in there tie it down and I just wrap it that's all I
do wrap it tight and it makes a beautiful point okay now back to the original part is the feathers
now what I need to tell you about is cutting the feathers Comanche's feathers were always uh
we made them they were six five six eight inches long the length of the feather
uh I settled on about five and a half inches or so I cut them long and I've cut so many
that I had to develop something to cut them it was all right to have a feather but then you
take a scissors and they're always different so what I developed was I made a pattern
that fit my feather that I needed that I was going to use okay so I got the one that I wanted
and I made a pattern what I do is put it on
the feathers that I'm cutting I put on pieces of uh tape and then you just wrap it around
bump it up to the vein wrap it over and that stays right there where you need it okay
then I would get a piece of masking tape put it on the back
then I would cut this out you want to allow a little bit in the back
to attach it to the arrow so maybe just less than a half an inch you can always cut it as you need
but cut that up here then you would cut it down and around and leave some in the front
that's the easiest way that way when you cut it you don't have feathers flying all over the place
you don't have to find feathers over here so what you do once you cut it and you just take this off
and it's got those feathers that you cut on the tape and you have a pile of tape get your pattern
go to the next one and that's what you come out with to attach to your arrow it's a great process
I was teaching at a class one time one guy was that I made a bustle for my son he said that's
a great idea to you know tie your feathers down a couple things that it does once you attach it
it doesn't let this move at all when you're cutting with scissors see it's tied on a on a
on the masking tape so just cut it out where you want it he said man if I knew that I wouldn't
got in trouble because my wife was complaining I had feathers all over the house but it works
the same process if you're cutting if you want a different pattern for a feather so it's great
so to put the feathers on the Comanches there's only ones that I know of
that do this in the beginning they didn't have glue developed the glue so one thing that
you'll find out that Comanches did is they tied their feathers on the back you can see where
I get a little bent area so it tied on but once you tie it on and it's laid backwards
what Comanche did once you get them off you tie them on like this and you bend them forward
that way you can put more pressure on them pulling down
so you know it makes you tie the arrow if you just laid it flat in the back it would pull
out that way we tied them from the back forward I always had the old guys they always ask me
they'll say son you make those Hollywood style or do you make them Comanche style
Comanche style was where they tied them in the back pull them over then tie them in the front
that's without any glue nowadays I try to glue them down because when people buy them they want
uh the old days when they made them they just re-tied them whenever they needed to but that
was a style that Comanches find out you'll only find that Comanches and I've only found I've been
doing this for 61 years are the only ones that tie it in the back pull it over and that's Comanche
the other thing that we do some of our people uh you'll see in the picture I use a style from
Chief Wild Horse I'm a descendant of Wild Horse we take the plumes and he was uh he was saying that
it was part of his medicine that when he put the feathers on in the front
he would put the plumes on at the front he said it was part of his medicine
so okay not me go above medicine I started putting them on he's one of my ancestors elders so
I would tie the plumes on and then tie the string down wrap it down all the way around
that's where you would get to
the plumes that we have all of my arrows I make them like this you'll find out we use the dark
arrow feathers he did anyway with the plumes on now you can develop that into anything you want
another guy he ordered these he uh his tribal colors red white blue so he wanted red and white
blue feathers and then I put the points on for him he can use these to dance with so
that's a different progression of all the arrows
um I love using dogwood the elders said you know as they travel we uh Comanches travel all the way
from kind of uh Kansas all the way down to Mexico um over to Arkansas to New Mexico
that was our area we'd go north in the summertime following the buffalo we go south
in the winter following the buffalo again because they were everything for us
but as they travel if they couldn't find dogwood they would use anything straight sometimes a
cherry tree had shoots on it and they would make a good arrow shaft they've used
reeds from the creek anything straight they were traveling they need to do these all the time
and I was asking my one elder said okay they were traveling in teepees and trying to make arrows
he said they made arrows all the time because you had to have them to hunt
protect your people so they were always cutting arrow shafts wherever they went and bundle them
I said okay how'd they cure them I was wanting to know how to cure them he said they would bundle
them and hang them up in the top of the teepee where the heat goes up and it would cure them
they would take them down and work them and the process used was just long and tedious but
it made a great arrow I love working dogwood
because like I said once you get it down and cure it it's light but it's strong
makes good thank you for my people
