During his time spent in Southern California in the late 1910s and early 1920s, Frank Lloyd Wright accelerated the search for L.A.'s authentic architecture that was suitable to the city's culture and landscape. Writer/Director Chris Hawthorne, architecture critic for the Los Angeles Times, explores the houses the legendary architect built in Los Angeles. The documentary also delves into the critic's provocative theory that these homes were also a means of artistic catharsis for Wright, who was recovering from a violent tragic episode in his life.
I've been an architecture critic in Los Angeles for nearly 15 years and in all
that time I don't think I've ever come across a building quite as inscrutable,
as strikingly mysterious, as this one. It's the Alice Millard House by Frank
Lloyd Wright in Pasadena, one of five remarkable houses Wright designed and
built in Southern California in the early 1920s. My curiosity about the house deepened
when its owner asked me a few years ago if I wanted to see the inside. It was just sitting
there empty, said the owner, a man who collected famous houses the way other people collect
Picassos or Diebenkorns. I could even spend the night if I wanted, he'd just lend me the key.
It was thrilling and a bit eerie to spend 24 hours alone in that house. What I remember more
than anything is how much of a temple it seemed, inside and out, with its rows of pre-Columbian
ornament, even how crypt-like. I mean, look at the place. It's not exactly warm, welcoming,
or especially domestic in any typical sense of that word. It's something else, opaque and tough
to read, tight-lipped. I started to wonder, why does the house look this way? Why did LA elicit
this kind of work from Wright? I remembered a line by Brendan Gill, one of the architect's
most perceptive biographers, who wrote that Wright's LA houses are better suited to sheltering
a Mayan god than an American family. Was he right about that? And why a Mayan god? What was it about
pre-Columbian architecture specifically that made it so attractive to Wright in those years?
What you're about to see is the story of my attempt to find answers to those questions. As
it turns out, the answers make up a story more fascinating and more complicated than I ever
would have guessed. A story that even a novelist might complain was melodramatic and overstuffed,
one involving a midlife crisis of epic proportion, a love affair, and a brutal mass murder. A story
starring an architect who tried to reinvent himself, as so many other Americans have done,
in Southern California, a place Wright would later describe as that far corner of the United States.
The first thing to do in learning exactly how Frank Lloyd Wright wound up in Southern
California seemed obvious. I had to go back to the beginning, to Oak Park, the suburb just west
of Chicago, where Wright opened an office in 1893 after working with the acclaimed architect,
Louis Sullivan. Wright and his wife, Catherine, known as Kitty, would soon have six children. I
also hoped to sit down with some experts on Wright's work from that period. I began with a
architecture critic. It's fascinating to watch his trajectory. I mean, he begins with a shingle
style house, the Holman Studio in Oak Park, and uses that as a kind of laboratory, a way to break
out of the Victorian box. Wright's Holman Studio, featuring a playroom with vaulted ceiling for his
growing family, was really a declaration of war on traditional hidebound Victorian architecture.
In the designs that followed, Wright produced a markedly new kind of house, the Prairie House,
that hugged the ground with a horizontal momentum perfectly suited to the Midwest.
In a series of houses just after 1900, Wright brought this type nearer and nearer to perfection.
You see that culminate, really, in the Robie House, this kind of great statement, which is,
you know, seemingly both grounded in the earth of the Midwest and flying forward like a ship with
its cantilevered roofs. It's a tremendous statement of a house that seems both rooted and static,
but also incredibly dynamic. My next stop was to talk with a former architecture critic, Lee Bay,
who now works at Chicago's DuSable Museum of African American History.
So in 1909, it provides interesting break in his career because up until then,
particularly the last few years, he's really had an incredible creative outburst.
In these years, Wright was beginning to move beyond residential architecture
to larger projects. If his career were to stop there, he'd be a legend. But as we know,
he goes on beyond that. Despite this professional success, Wright began to feel stifled in Oak Park.
He was reaching middle age, and he had pushed the prairie style just about as far as it would go.
One of the most striking of the prairie houses, just a half mile from his own,
was designed for a couple named Edwin and Maima Chaney. Maima Borthwick Chaney was an intellectual,
a translator, and a feminist, a woman who could more than hold her own in debates with Wright.
The architect and his wife began socializing with the Chaneys, and before long, according
to Tim Samuelson, Chicago's cultural historian, people began to talk.
There were certainly whispers about the idea of a relationship between Frank Lloyd Wright and Maima
Borthwick Chaney. It's not unusual for things like that to go on, but Wright was a pretty
unconventional figure. He looked different, he acted differently, and so this is something that
would catch people's curiosity. Wright's relationship with Maima Chaney seemed to
give him a new taste for adventure. This is somebody who challenged Wright, who could be
unequal with him, who I think you can say in all confidence was the love of his life. In the fall
of 1909, Wright abruptly shuttered his office, left his wife and children behind, and sailed to
Once he leaves, then the journalists take over. It becomes sensationalistic.
Wright is a tabloid newspaper editor's dream. I mean, he's right out of central casting in
terms of how he looks, his braggadocio. He's a guy who manipulates the media, who has a love-hate
relationship with the media. The media helps make him, and it also helps tear him apart.
Frank and Maima settled in Italy's Tuscan countryside. Wright also traveled widely,
seeing the newest landmarks of European modernism, and spent significant time in Berlin.
He is engaged to produce the plates for a publication of his work in Europe for the
great German publishing house of Wasmuth. His leaving was one of astounding professional
growth as well. He comes back to America a different architect than he did when he left it.
On his return in 1910, Wright tried to re-establish his architectural practice in Oak Park,
but it soon became clear that the scandal had hardly dissipated while he was away.
When I sat down inside the Roby House with the Chicago architect Eric Lasher,
he told me that Wright had other priorities than quieting the tabloids.
He was someone driven by artistic impulses above all others. Obviously, social propriety and other
obligations were less important than his mission as an artist and as a creative thinker.
That may sound in the abstract like boilerplate praise, the kind of thing you'd hear from a tour
guide, but I think this point is a key one. What I was beginning to learn was that Wright,
when faced with a choice between producing architecture that he knew was popular,
and architecture that might push his work in new directions, almost always took the riskier path.
It was a kind of compulsion for him, this instinct. As one writer put it,
Wright seemed uncomfortable as soon as his life reached any sort of equilibrium.
As he had the year before, Wright decided he needed to get away.
He returns to what was part of his roots, the hillside of Wisconsin, the family land
of the Lloyd-Joneses, and this would be his mother's family.
As a refuge for himself and Maima, Wright built a remarkably ambitious house and studio.
The materials he found on the site are close by, with sand from the Wisconsin River
used to make stucco the same ochre color as the river's banks.
And in a sense, he's home, right? He's Welsh by extraction, and he names it
Taliesin, shining brown, a Welsh word, so it's him returning to
something, and something deeper, and something rooted.
Walking through Taliesin, I was reminded that it's without any doubt one of the supreme
achievements of Wright's career. It was symbolic for him of two things, his break with conventional
society in Oak Park, and his interest in creating an architecture that seemed not only to grow from
the landscape, but to be almost continuous with it. But Wright didn't cut ties with Chicago
altogether. He maintained a Chicago office where he could meet clients, and there were
some big projects, some were dream projects. For example, the Midway Gardens in Chicago,
which was made for Wright because it was something that was made to appeal to all the senses.
It was while Wright was working at the Midway Gardens site one afternoon in August of 1914
that he received the news that would radically change his life.
Word reaches him of a unfolding tragedy at Taliesin, something that was totally unimaginable.
A servant of Taliesin had murdered not only members of the staff, but murdered
brutally the love and passion of his life, Mamah Borthwick Chaney.
The killer was a cook and handyman named Julian Carlton. His motive remains unclear,
although his wife told police he'd been growing increasingly paranoid in the weeks before the
crime. After serving lunch to Mamah and her two children, he attacked and killed all three
of them with a hatchet. Then he lit the Taliesin studio on fire and killed several members of
Wright's staff in the same gruesome fashion. With seven dead, it was, and remains to this day,
the largest mass murder in Wisconsin history. Just down the hill from Taliesin, I visited
the grounds of the chapel where Wright buried Mamah in a plain pine coffin. This was an intensely
personal spot for Wright. The chapel itself was the first building he ever helped design
as a teenager, and his mother's family, the Lloyd-Joneses, all worshipped there and would
eventually be buried there. It took me a while to find Mamah's grave. Unlike those of Wright's
blood relatives, which are quite prominent, it's hidden away at the base of a tree.
In despair after the murders, Wright broke out Job-like in boils and thought he was going blind.
Ultimately, though, Mamah's death would leave a mark far more psychological than physical.
As Wright looked on the ruins of Taliesin, he began to see himself.
The gaping black hole left by fire in the beautiful hillside, he wrote, was no less empty,
charred, and ugly in my own life. It was in that shaky state of mind that Wright made a trip to
Southern California in January of 1915, less than six months after the murders. Back in Los Angeles,
I sat down with the Western historian William Deverell to ask him what kind of city Wright
found here. Los Angeles comes out of the 19th century brash, so the population growth in
Southern California is prodigious from the first three decades of the 20th century.
The L.A. of that era was almost perfectly suited to distracting a grieving architect
with the prospect of new work and new clients. Southern California and California generally
had, since the era of the gold rush, been seen as a place for reinvention. So it has that
rehabilitative feel to it. It also has a recuperative feel to it. So people come out
here in the late 19th and early 20th century because they want to get better. They want to
get well. They want to convalesce. One of Wright's most important stops on that trip to California
was a visit to the Panama-California Exposition in San Diego. There, he came face to face with
a rich variety of building models and drawings showing pre-Columbian designs, artifacts of the
Maya and other cultures that rose to prominence more than a thousand years ago, in the centuries
before the arrival of the Spanish. According to Megan O'Neill and Jesse Lerner, the experts in
pre-Columbian culture I spoke with next, the San Diego Expo celebrated Maya designs as part of a
regional architecture indigenous to the Americas. The 1915 exposition in San Diego, the exterior of
the California building was Spanish colonial. And then the interior was this sort of Maya fantasy
world, let's say, that was partially very archaeological, I think, but then also about
this fantasy imagination of ruins, etc. All the visitors to the San Diego Exhibition would have
had a chance to see very accurate reproductions of Maya sculpture and some more fanciful
representations of Maya cities at their prime. In addition, the Expo may well have cemented in
Wright's mind a link between this architecture and death. Pre-Columbian temples were sometimes
not only the settings for human sacrifice, but also part of complexes where important figures
were buried, places where the living could commune with and remember the dead. With Wright's mind,
he sees it all, he takes it all in, it becomes part of his toolbox for future use.
Wright had seen pre-Columbian architecture before. He'd seen it at the 1893 World's
Columbian Exposition in Chicago. And according to the UCLA architectural historian Thomas Hines,
there were also memories from his childhood. His parents, his mother, had given him books
with pictures of the buildings from Central America, Mexico and the Yucatan. Those images
stayed in his mind most of his life. In the 1840s, there are four books, a series of two volumes
called Incidents of Travel in Yucatan and Incidents of Travel in Central America, Chiapas and Yucatan,
that were very successful. They went through many reprintings, and they are really the principal
source of U.S. awareness of the ruins of the ancient Maya. The author of these four books
is John Lloyd Steffens, and he traveled with and collaborated with a photographer,
illustrator called Frederick Catherwood. Shortly after the publication of those four books,
you start to see all kinds of references to the ancient Maya and to Mayan ruins in popular culture.
Those references included this pair of siblings that P.T. Barnum put in his freak shows,
though he called them Aztec, not Mayan. And incredibly, these floats, at least one with
a fake dead body draped across it, designed by architect Sumner Hunt. They were part of
the La Fiesta Parade in 1895 through the streets of L.A. So let's pause here to consider the evidence
we've collected so far and what it means for the direction of Wright's work after the murders at
Taliesin. What do you get when you add up Wright's interest in pre-Columbian architecture, the role
of death in that architecture, and the murder of Maima Borthwick? You get this, one of the first
major buildings Wright designed after returning to the Midwest from his trip to California. It's a
warehouse commissioned by a wholesale grocer named A.D. German for a site in Wright's birthplace, the
sleepy Wisconsin town of Richland Center. I got a tour from a couple of local residents who are
working to bring the building back to life. To put it mildly, it does not look like a traditional
warehouse or a Frank Lloyd Wright design or the kind of building you'd expect to find in small
town Wisconsin. It looks like a temple, like something straight out of a Catherwood drawing.
If you put that side by side with the so-called nunnery structure at Uxmal, one of the buildings
that he would have seen reproduced both at the Chicago Columbian Exposition and photographs of
in San Diego, you can see a real sort of dialogue at the very least. It's clear that Wright was using
the Richland Center commission to test out the Mayan and other pre-Columbian motifs that he'd
just seen in San Diego and that would soon form the basis of his residential work in Los Angeles.
And though he was in a new relationship by now, a tempestuous one with a woman named Miriam Noel,
whom he would later marry and then quickly divorce, he was also still struggling to
recover emotionally from the murders and increasingly desperate to work anywhere but the Midwest.
Luckily for Wright, he found two commissions that helped him accelerate his escape.
He was asked to design the giant Imperial Hotel in Tokyo and in California he began work on a
project that would ultimately be dubbed Hollyhock House for a wealthy, ambitious, and inconstant new
client named Aline Barnstall. Wright was in need of escape and help. Part of it he found in Japan,
the Imperial Hotel commission, and here in the Barnstall commission, those two great rather
exotic commissions in exotic places from his Midwestern standpoint, and those were important
sources of healing really for him. According to Jeffrey Herr, who now oversees Hollyhock House,
Aline Barnstall hoped to build not just a residence but a performing arts complex.
She was educated in Europe and became interested in theater, specifically avant-garde theater.
While Wright was off in Tokyo, she found a 36-acre hilltop site on the eastern edge of Hollywood,
a spot called Olive Hill. With Aline Barnstall's money, her inherited fortune
from her father who had been an oil baron, there were limitless possibilities.
And while her dreams of building a theater were never realized,
the house Wright produced for her is plenty theatrical on its own.
When Wright designed Hollyhock House, he not only conceded to Aline Barnstall's idea that this house
would be named Hollyhock House because it's her favorite flower, but he went 10 steps further
designing an amazing abstraction of the plant and then riffing on that with innumerable
adaptations of that design. There is a range of styles in Hollyhock House including Viennese
modern and Japanese architecture, but it is above all a Maya temple. If you look at the west facade,
you have this monumental sort of temple-style building. It has ornamentation that is
certainly reminiscent of Mayan or pre-Columbian ruins. In the final analysis, despite its
unorthodox power and moments of real brilliance, Hollyhock House was an imperfect LA debut for
Wright. It never came close to fulfilling Barnstall's ambitions, that's for sure.
And in a foreshadowing of Wright's LA houses to come, it never succeeded as a residence,
a domestic setting. Barnstall started thinking about donating it to the city of Los Angeles
before it was even a year old, and she would make the gift official in 1927. It's probably difficult
for us to realize now just how idiosyncratic a house designed to resemble a Maya temple
would have seemed in the Los Angeles of that time. By the teens and certainly by the 1920s,
the elite architectural clients have more or less chosen that the article of faith is the
Spanish colonial style. Wright was full of disdain for this architecture and its suitability for Los
Angeles. He called it fraudulent and complained that the red tile roofs of Spanish colonial and
style buildings here give back the sunshine stained pink. When I went to see Catherine
Smith among the leading authorities in LA on Wright's work, she explained something important,
that Wright's dislike for the Spanish colonial was part of his broader impatience with the idea
that American architects should look to Europe for their cultural inspiration.
Frank Lloyd Wright wanted to create a genuine original American architecture.
So even from the 1890s to the 1900s, he rejected Victorian architecture, Greek architecture,
Roman revival, Romanesque revival. Wright was always something of a cultural nationalist
determined to find the roots of an American culture. Wright was arguing in effect that
pre-Columbian architecture was more American than the Spanish colonial, and that Los Angeles had
more in common in terms of climate, landscape, and culture with pre-Columbian Mexico than with
New York or Spain. This point of view was in certain ways deeply naive. Wright never visited
any pre-Columbian ruins in person. As he would later do with Native American designs, Wright
tended to rather indiscriminately mix together Maya culture with Aztec or Inca. I mean there is
something peculiar about looking to indigenous architectures of North and Central America and
appropriating them when in fact you're the descendant of, you know, white settlers that actually
pushed these indigenous cultures aside. And yet there was also something genuine in Wright's use
of pre-Columbian forms. What he was expressing was a kind of heartfelt, if scattershot, Pan-American
pride. We can't learn anything from Europe, he said. They have to learn from us.
By early 1923, despite the fact that the barnstall job hadn't worked out the way he'd hoped, Wright
decided he wanted to settle in Los Angeles for good. His son, Frank Lloyd Wright Jr., known as
Lloyd Wright, and an architect like his father, had preceded him to LA. Frank Lloyd Wright found a
Fortunately for him, there was someone here who knew him, and this was a woman named Alice Millard.
She and her husband had commissioned him for a house in Chicago.
Millard had moved to California after her husband died and asked Wright to design a house for a
piece of land she'd found in Pasadena. It was a commission that would propel his work in a
dramatic new direction. Wright wanted to offer an answer to the lean, machine-made modernism that
was gaining traction in Europe, but he wanted to do it in a way that would not only seem
indigenous to Southern California, but that might be democratic, affordable on a mass scale.
So Wright devised a brand new modular system made, surprisingly enough, of concrete blocks,
created with a recipe that used soil from the building site itself.
Concrete blocks that could be cheaply produced and then stacked quickly by hand.
You have concrete, which is a natural material that is of the earth itself. Its materials are
part of the earth, bound together by the natural sands and the crushed granites that are put
together by concrete into blocks and formed. Concrete also appealed to Wright because he
could easily stamp the blocks with the Maya patterns he'd grown so fond of.
The material of the house and the decoration on the house would be one and the same.
Perhaps thinking back to Taliesin, Wright told Alice Millard that one virtue of the
blocks was that they were fireproof. When I went to see UCLA's Michael Osmond, an expert in the
materials of modern architecture, he told me that there were some basic contradictions inherent
in Wright's new system. When I think about what an architect is doing when they try and make a
seems to me to be against the grain of that material, which in a certain way lends itself
to being more of a mass and less of a unit. So with wood, because it grows in a tree
and you take the tree down, you're already given a unit, the log, and there's a lot of
investigation into what the log can deliver in terms of lumber. But when it comes to an
aggregate made up of sand, cement, gravel, and reinforcement bars, it's a Frankenstein body
in a way. So to make it into a unit is a kind of counter-intuitive thing, even though people
now, we take it for granted that concrete comes in modular units. Concrete was far from a high
design material in those days. Wright called it the cheapest and ugliest thing in the building
world. And in fact, this was part of the challenge for him. As he put it, why not see what could be
done with that gutter rat? Concrete was a gutter rat in certain circles. For sure, with John Ruskin
in The Seven Lamps of Architecture, the lamp of truth is never use concrete, there's a footnote,
never use concrete because it has no character. It doesn't come from nature, and therefore it
only takes on the character of either what you cover it with or the formwork that it's poured
into. For Wright, this quality was central to concrete's appeal. He saw the material as a
shapeshifter, capable of solving several architectural problems at once. So with this
one element, the square block, Frank Lloyd Wright created something that was structural,
modular, material, and a poetic connection to the site itself.
Once Wright had an approach in mind for Alice Millard's property, he decided to put the house
not in the perfectly flat middle of the lot, as pretty much any other architect would have done,
but down in a ravine along one edge. Though this made the house susceptible to flooding from day
one, it's also what gives the design, veiled by trees, such an otherworldly look.
The result which Wright nicknamed La Miniatura is a singularly brilliant work of L.A. architecture,
one that seems to grow almost inexorably from its site, while also closing itself off from the world
at large. Flat-roofed like a work of a European modernist, but altogether more mysterious, closed
off, and dramatic. A small temple and a eucalyptus grove. Remember Brendan Gill's Mayan God? He might
have felt very much at home here. When I saw the designs on the Millard house with that cross, I
thought, well, could that be a reference to this Mesoamerican understanding of the shape of the
universe? The Mesoamerican universe, of which the Maya were a part, shared with the Maya, Aztecs,
Mixtec, Zapotecs, all these cultures, the cardinal directions and intercardinal directions were
absolutely important to establishing the universe. So you get stories of gods or heroes who measure
out the sides of the universe. So when you see this cross, let's say equidistant, it is showing,
it's pointing to those cardinal directions, establishing or showing the shape of your universe.
But that specific design is also the symbol for gold for the Aztecs, and I have no idea if
Frank Lloyd Wright knew that, but it's pretty neat to see the Millard house with all of these designs for
golds. It's sort of this sort of changing of materials, where you get concrete turning into
golds, this sort of transubstantiation or something like that. By this point, I'd spoken to a number
of experts on Wright's work, both in the Midwest and in Los Angeles. What I hadn't done is speak
to anybody who lives in one of these houses. And while that was impossible in a literal sense,
none of Wright's LA houses is now used as a full-time residence,
I found the next best thing via my eight-year-old daughter.
Beautiful.
She takes piano lessons in the studio attached to the Millard house,
which Wright's son Lloyd added in 1926. Her teacher, Cindy Lamb, acts as a caretaker for the main house.
Notes were correct. I did think it was strange looking. When I first saw pictures of this place,
I thought, really, like, who makes a concrete house? That's just, like, so ugly. Who does that?
I didn't really see the darkness. I think I saw this place, really, it represented strength
and beauty to me. I had a breakup with this, with a boyfriend, and we were breaking, in the process
of breaking up, and he was saying all these things to me that were, you know, less than desirable.
I just remember there was, like, a moment, like, this light bulb went off, and I thought,
this is my fortress. You don't get to be in here. Like, you need to leave now.
This house really emboldens people. I've found people in the yard. I have a sign out front that
says that there are no tours, but if you feel entitled to one, then you can leave a bottle of
wine, and we can talk about it. And so far, no wine. I think people get a little bit shamed
by that message, and they go their own way. The next house Wright designed in Los Angeles,
after Millard, has always been something of an enigma, and so is the man it's named for,
a doctor from Wisconsin named John Storer. We don't know a lot about his biography,
but through the drawings and some correspondence, it has come to light
that this was probably a spec house, something that Storer was building for resale.
Though the current owner turned down our request to film there, we got a peek inside thanks to
Martha Stewart, who featured the house on her television show nearly 20 years ago. The footage
suggests a good deal of continuity with the Millard house, with a strong Maya influence,
stacked concrete blocks, a redwood ceiling, and a rather standoffish relationship to the street.
You look up at it from Hollywood Boulevard, that little stretch of Hollywood Boulevard,
and it's a real presence there. You're not going to miss it. It does not nestle in.
Wright put the living room on the top floor inside a tall central pavilion
that opens onto a pair of terraces. The house is even more vertical and temple-like than Millard
has seen from the street, because instead of being sunk into a ravine, it starts on a hillside
and goes up from there. The author and Wright expert Robert Sweeney told me that as the Storer
house was under construction, Wright was continuing to experiment with the concrete block system.
He did a design for Aileen Barnstall on Olive Hill called the Little Dipper. It was a kindergarten,
and there are many drawings showing the evolution of the concrete block system.
It was worked out for the Little Dipper. One change from Millard was that the blocks could
be stacked without any mortar, requiring less skilled labor, and then woven together with
vertical and horizontal steel rods. Wright called it a textile block system. Wright went back to
Wisconsin during construction of the Storer house and turned the project over to his son Lloyd.
When he returned to California, Wright was deeply disappointed. Compared to Alice Millard,
Storer was a less involved and dedicated client. On top of that, Wright's block system was proving
tricky to execute, especially on a hillside. Wright told Lloyd that he considered the house a tragedy
and that it was lacking joy. In later years, one resident of the house, even in praising it,
compared the living room to a drama of Sophocles, as if Wright's own family strife
and violent recent past were written into the concrete blocks themselves.
The house, to be fair, hasn't always prompted that sort of reaction. In the 1980s, the film
producer Joel Silver bought it and undertook a complete and enthusiastic restoration. In the
process, he became so obsessed with Wright that he began dropping references to the architect
into his work. In Die Hard, there's a TV news station called KFLW, and the movie's villain,
Hans Gruber, played by Alan Rickman, pauses at one point to admire a bridge design that Wright,
in real life, proposed near the end of his career for San Francisco Bay.
Attention to every conceivable detail. It's beautiful.
The storehouse itself doesn't show up in any of Silver's movies, or any famous movies,
for that matter. But for the next of Wright's Los Angeles houses,
for the couple Charles and Mabel Ennis, it's a completely different story.
I'm Vincent Price, and you're invited to my party in the house on Haunted Hill.
I visited the Ennis house not long after the completion of an immaculate restoration
overseen by its new owner, Ron Burkle. What struck me was that the house is not just the biggest,
but the most imposing of Wright's L.A. designs, one that manages to wring genuine
grandeur from concrete block. Looming over Los Feliz, it's the apotheosis of Wright's
vision of a pre-Columbian temple relocated to Southern California, monumental and impenetrable.
That bulwark, that bastion up there, quite wonderful, quite striking, but not intimate.
Many of the details, the wrought iron decoration and stained glass in particular,
reflect the Ennis' taste more than their architects.
They were an interesting couple. We don't really know a lot about them,
and I don't think it's even pinned down at this moment how they met Frank Lloyd Wright.
I have wrestled for years wondering why they built this enormous house. It's a Maya palace.
They were just clients, and they wanted to have the house that they wanted to have built.
And so there are parts of the Ennis house, major, major elements that pop out to people,
where they turn to the kind of decorative work of the period. It sort of looks like
Norma Desmond's house in Sunset Boulevard. And people wonder about that, but that's because
they wanted to have it carried out and completed to their own wishes.
It's attracted a certain aura about it, which perhaps has been made more so by the number of
films that it's been in. But I think even before that, it was in the Hollywood films because it
communicated this kind of mysterious aura about it.
Oh, Mrs. Esty decided the pool needed a dead horse in it, so we got one.
If the Ennis house was typical of Wright's L.A. work in suggesting dark, even sinister,
overtones and seeming to repel the very idea of normal family life,
the exception came in the architect's fourth concrete block house in the Hollywood Hills.
The clients were a young bohemian couple named Harriet and Samuel Freeman. They'd
scraped together the money to buy a piece of land that offered a view straight down Highland Avenue.
What the Freemans lacked in money, they made up for in enthusiasm for Wright's work.
The architect, in return, produced a house that seemed to fit them like a glove,
with a big open living room where Harriet, a dancer, could hold performances and salons.
They lived there for the rest of their lives, more than 60 years,
and under the stewardship of USC, to which the Freemans donated the house in 1986,
it's been the setting for at least one more successful relationship.
I'm Hank Harris. I'm an actor. My wife...
is Elizabeth Timmy. Yeah, and I'm an architect, and my dad was the dean of the school of
architecture at USC from 1994 to 2005. And we met and fell in love in the Freeman house. And
I had the benefit of being able to stay there while I was a student. Me too. And him too.
You've probably noticed by now that the Freeman house is in pretty terrible shape.
In part because of its steep lot, and perhaps because the Freemans didn't have the resources
of the Ennises, or even Alice Millard, the house had structural problems from the beginning.
Wright had clearly not perfected his new concrete block system.
These issues were compounded by the 1994 Northridge earthquake.
The textile blocks would absorb rain to a point, and then it would just begin to drip
through constantly. And I remember my dad just coming over with, like, tarp.
Yeah, just plastic everywhere, just to keep the water off the floor. And we'd get up
and squeegee it off every morning. So it felt like a ruin, which was really crazy,
to be inside something that felt very much like Anchorwatt. It just felt very much like
someone else's kind of bizarre Blade Runner fantasy. Our next interviewee, who oversees
the house for USC, understands as well as anybody how difficult these problems are to solve.
We're taking the approach that, you know, this is a very complicated knit sweater.
And we don't want to pull the wrong thread first and unravel the whole thing. It is a combination
of not enough money to do it, and trying to decide with the right approach, and with the
small amount of money we have, what intervention is the most important. We use it now. We take
students up there all the time. And it's in a condition where it actually provides some
really great lessons about how this house was actually built. You can see a lot of the
infrastructure. You can see the systems. They're exposed right now. That's amazing
for architecture students. There are times when it can seem like folly to keep fixing a house
that, in many ways, has proved stubbornly unfixable. And I've thought a lot about the
system because it was experimental. But then, on the other hand, there's no doubt that it was flawed.
At the very beginning, I believed that the textile block system should be held sacrosanct.
But if you go to Japan, you see, if you follow out the idea of building a building
in concert with nature, in concert with nature means that it has a life. And when you carry
forward with a life, at some time, a life ends. In some ways, I know this would be horrific
to an American mentality, but perhaps they should just have been allowed to deteriorate.
And that would have been the logical conclusion of the system.
We always joked that we would, if we got really rich and famous, we would go back
there and paint it gold and then burn it down. Yeah, you can't burn concrete, though.
I know, that's why it's a funny... It's a joke. It's a joke. You can't. We could melt it. Yeah.
Some historians have stressed the differences between this house and the concrete block
designs that preceded it, even seeing in its corner window the seeds of the case study
modern houses of post-war Los Angeles. But more striking is how similar the concrete
block houses are as a group, how consistently dense and introverted. The Freeman House,
as seen from the street, is just as windowless, secretive, and off-putting, just as suggestive
of a crypt as the Millard House, the first of Wright's concrete experiments here.
By the end of 1923, he was feeling there wasn't going to be a big future for him.
And he sort of was at a dead end. And he didn't feel comfortable here. He felt alienated from
the real estate market of Los Angeles. California history is filled with people
who come out to California imagining a future for themselves that never takes place. They never
discover gold. They never get famous. They never star in a film. They never find oil.
So they go home. He was not well received in Southern California.
People were not people willing to take the risk or be experimental enough to build with these
concrete blocks. And I think many people simply didn't like the houses. They are not domestic in
any conventional sense. He was somebody who was impulsive, and he would change. He was perceptive.
And so if it looked like it wasn't going where it wanted to go, that's it. He went back home.
After leaving Los Angeles at the end of 1923, Wright maintained some connections here.
His son Lloyd stayed on in L.A. and even continued the family tradition
of designing houses covered in pre-Columbian ornament.
Visiting this house by Lloyd Wright is telling, though. What Lloyd produced has none of the
gravity, the power of his father's L.A. houses. It feels like a stage set, some corner of
Disneyland. The house is a pastiche in a way Frank Lloyd Wright's L.A. houses are not.
Across L.A., as the 1920s wore on, pre-Columbian architecture became all the rage,
though with more flamboyance and populism than had marked Wright's use of it. Most notably,
a British architect named Robert Stacey Judd came here, fully embraced pre-Columbian culture,
and never looked back. He built the Aztec Hotel in Monrovia. Here he is doing a made-up pre-Columbian
dance in made-up pre-Columbian costume. And here's a dancer performing some of that same
choreography in front of the Ennis House in the late 1920s. Later on, Frank Lloyd Wright would
come back to design the 1939 Sturges House in Brentwood, a cantilevered version of Wright's
small Usonian houses. In the 1950s, he designed this small shopping center on Rodeo Drive in
Beverly Hills. But none of those later designs have the peculiar force or density of the L.A.
houses of the 1920s. Now nearly a century old, these concrete block houses retain their wildly
anomalous character. They stand apart from Wright's work, and apart from the rest of the
The L.A. houses are muscular. They're brutal. They're romantic. They're fantastic.
You know, they're strange. And all these years later, they've settled into an odd place in the
culture, popping up not just in the movies, but in the digital world. It turns out Wright's blocks
work exceptionally well in the game Minecraft, which relies on a similar modular logic.
There's also a composite version of the block houses in a video game starring Buffy the Vampire
Slayer, in which Buffy fights off undead opponents in a series of appropriately dark and moody
Wrightian spaces. To get a final and more personal perspective on Wright's time in L.A.,
I drove out to Malibu one morning to meet Eric Lloyd Wright, Frank's grandson and Lloyd's son,
and an architect in his own right who's worked on restoring several of his grandfather's houses.
Eric Wright lives with his wife Mary in a compound overlooking the Pacific that feels very much like
the end of the road. If Frank Lloyd Wright sought in L.A. that far corner of the U.S.,
his grandson, now 88, seems to have found that far corner of Los Angeles itself.
We met in an unfinished building made, appropriately enough, out of concrete
on the edge of his property. We talked about the textile block system,
his relationship with his grandfather, and about his work on some of the L.A. houses.
I asked him why he thought Wright had come here after Maima's murder, what had drawn him to Los
Angeles. Well, he, of course, had been very upset about the death of his companion and all the
adverse publicity that had come about because of his living with her and being together. So,
he thought that Los Angeles, this was a new town, coming up, he could have a new life.
And then, for me, a key question. When Frank Lloyd Wright began working in Los Angeles,
what was his state of mind? Well, it was one of, I think, sorrow because he had,
they had had a wonderful life. He had had with Mamie Bothwick a wonderful life until her death.
That brings us back to my overnight stay at the Millard House and the question I posed at the
start. Why do the L.A. houses look the way they do? Are they expressions not just of a desire
for privacy and escape, but expressions, to use Eric Wright's word, of sorrow?
Some of the people I interviewed took issue with that idea. Many people have looked at the
California houses, particularly the concrete block houses of 1923, as things that almost seem like
mausoleums or they're heavy, and that this reflects an idea of grief. I can't get into
Wright's head. I don't know that I quite buy that. After a while, it was impossible not to
notice a split. Historians have tended to play down the pre-Columbian aspects of the houses,
and especially their connections to death, and to play up their wide range of other influences.
Artists, filmmakers, Hollywood location scouts, and video game designers, on the other hand,
have all had a simpler and perhaps more instinctive take. They've seen what's right in
front of them, right in front of all of us, that these houses are shadowed by violence and even
death. Over time, I came to agree with this more direct view, even to think of the houses as a
precursor to L.A. noir. And for me, it hardly felt like a leap. If my experience as a critic has
taught me anything, it's that if you spend enough time in a building and listen closely enough to
what it's saying, it will tell you pretty much everything you need to know. And you'd have to
be putting your fingers in your ears not to hear how clearly Wright's Los Angeles houses
are communicating their more funereal aspects. What's more, the vocabulary that has grown up
around the houses, some of it from Wright himself, is consistently dark and even macabre.
Drama of Sophocles. Brutal. Sinister. Tragedy. Lacking joy. Part of what's happening here, I think,
is that scholars are understandably reluctant to embrace the crude caricature of pre-Columbian
culture and its various death cults, especially that of the Aztecs, that was an important part
of the way Americans understood those ruins during Wright's day. Yet there's no doubt that those
caricatures shaped Wright's understanding of pre-Columbian designs and their meaning.
And it's not as though Wright was one to discourage a psychological reading of his
architecture. To the contrary, as the critic Herbert Mouchamp once pointed out,
Wright explicitly offered up his life along with his work for critical appraisal,
insisting that neither could be adequately understood without the other.
His architecture saves him, in a sense. It becomes, you know, it's this mission, this
project that helps him to recover from that, you know, just catastrophic personal tragedy.
In the end, I came down on the side of the idea that Wright's L.A. houses, these strange apparitions,
are not just heavy, but heavy-hearted. There was something in pre-Columbian architecture,
its starkness, its state of ruin, that suggested to Wright a sensibility that
might suit Southern California and his own uncertain frame of mind in the years following
the murders. I don't think it's the case that the houses look off-putting and crypt-like to us
because they're empty, because none of them is now used as a full-time residence. I think the
opposite is true. I think none of them is now used as a full-time residence precisely because
they're off-putting and crypt-like, because they were a means for Wright of finally putting a
troubled period behind him for good. Mama Borthwick is buried in the little graveyard I visited next
by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors through the Los Angeles County Arts Commission,
the City of Los Angeles Department of Cultural Affairs, the California Arts Council, and others.