Is This Popular Organic Gardening Method Wasting Your Time?

ORGANIC FARMING
23 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hello and a very warm welcome back to the garden. It is certainly boiling,
there hasn't been any rain for a fair while and there's no rain in the forecast and so just having
to make sure that I'm keeping on top of getting these seedlings developing. This video is about
crop rotation, why I think it's holding back a lot of gardeners because in all honesty I think
there's a lot more important things to consider when growing food and crop rotation isn't exactly
suitable for our smaller spaces so let me explain why. The main thing to understand about crop
rotation is that it was developed for agricultural field scale models and if you've got a allotment
or a vegetable garden it's not a field scale model of growing food and so the reasons for
crop rotation are really important. It's about making sure that there's enough nutrients in the
soil, that you're not allowing a pest and disease build up and these are all very valid points.
It's got popular over years in organic gardening, I understand why, but the practicality of actually
applying it in our gardens I think holds gardeners back more than the benefits that it offers because
it adds complexity especially if your garden isn't a shape that's dividable into four exact areas
and I just think that there's maybe time to re-look at crop rotation and it's something that
I haven't bothered with for the last seven years. Now obviously crop rotation isn't used for things
like perennials like this mint. I'm going to harvest a bunch of this for making a very powerful
mint tea, maybe even turn it into a mint syrup just cutting off the tops. So crop rotation is
for the annual crops and it's actually split usually into four different categories. So you've
got legumes which are your peas and beans, you've got your leaves so those could be like brassicas
or salads, then you've got your fruiting crops like courgettes and tomatoes and then you've got
your roots like potatoes and beetroot. So the actual rotation is that leaves follow legumes,
legumes follow roots, roots follow fruit and fruit follow leaves. That is kind of the
traditional one, the four-year rotation. All it takes is a simple google search about crop rotation
to see that there's actually many different versions of crop rotation. There are sometimes
a three-year rotation, sometimes there are different plant group names or you have allium
separate to roots and there's also ones where it splits up into high feeders, low feeders and kind
of soil nutrient givers. And so it's really hard for a beginner gardener to look at all of this
data and realize what is actually the best system for me but this video is about why for us gardeners
we don't need to use crop rotation as a system so I'm going to explain why. So for smaller spaces
dedicating different areas of the garden for a specific plant group can be quite complex. One of
the main things to remember is that we all have preferences. Maybe you just absolutely adore
potatoes and you just want to grow half the garden as potatoes and if you don't have much space
then that's something that you're going to do. You can't then try and build in crop rotation around
that, it simply isn't practical enough. The other thing about small spaces is that you've got
limited space so you're trying to be as clever as possible with the given space to produce as much.
Here I've got fields, beans, onions, garlic, peas. In front of the peas I'm going to plant a row of
salad. All of these different things happening within about three or four square meters and in
this space I'm breaking the rules. I'm growing leaves with the legumes and roots with other
legumes and it isn't exactly crop rotation. Polytunnels is another growing space where
crop rotation is quite hard because for me I allocate about half of the space just to growing
tomatoes and so a four-year rotation for growing tomatoes in a polytunnel is impossible. Now I'm
going to just quickly talk through the number one reason why I think crop rotation is holding back
or doesn't make sense the context-wise for a lot of gardeners and it's the fact that we spend
a lot of time trying to make sure that we get the most from our space and for the majority of the
annuals that we grow we're actually growing two or three different crops in the same space over
the year. So when I harvest the potatoes I might put in leeks or brassicas and so then you ask
yourself where do you start that crop rotation from? Is it the leaves because of the brassicas
or is it because you had potatoes in to begin with? It starts to make it quite complicated
and so what we're doing as gardeners is that we're constantly adding diversity of plants to
the soil. There is a natural rotation in a sense just because we're planting in different crops
over the year and so in terms of the soil health and soil diversity and disease buildup there isn't
really that possibility because there's always going to be something new growing in that space
and that's the other thing as well with say disease buildup I very often will you know plant
potatoes elsewhere in the garden it will just be a random bed every single year it might not be the
same bed it might be the same bed but also if I feel actually yeah I need to plant potatoes there
two years in a row because I've got excited about field beans then I'm not going to let that stop me
from growing potatoes for two years in a row. I think one of the best examples of this is I
think about nine years ago Charles Dowding started a trial of just not doing any crop rotation and
his results have been fantastic that is kind of all you need to see it it's working in this garden
it's worked really well for Charles Dowding it's working really well for a lot of other gardeners
and I just get really passionate about this because if there's any way that we can make
growing food more simple kind of less limiting not really following the rule book more enjoyable
more free then hopefully more people can produce more food and have a little bit more joy. Of course
in the garden we're going to come across pest and disease issues some are a lot worse than others
rust I don't really care about a lot of pests like black flower I wouldn't care about things like
club root for your brassicas that is something that is a little bit more challenging that is
where I wouldn't perhaps recommend rotation but if you've got club root in one part of your garden
then only grow brassicas in the other part but that doesn't mean rotation that just means choosing
the most suitable site for that particular crop. Now as well if you enjoy crop rotation if you
enjoy the process of it you know in terms of planning as long as you don't want to change a
single thing it's quite easy because every year you just rotate each block but it's only possible
if you have say a number of raised beds or square meters that are dividable by four but that's the
thing as well about gardening I'm trying to say that crop rotation isn't necessary and I think
for about 90% of gardeners it is holding them back it's certainly I'm speaking from experience
where it's held me back but if it's something that you enjoy absolutely do it because that's
what gardening is about gardening is an extension of our personality I say this time and time again
and gardening it's so important to do it in a way that feels best for us and so if you still
you don't want to do crop rotation go for it because the most important thing is growing
food. Whilst the vegetable garden right now feels kind of green it's going to turn into an abundance
of color that's a nice thing about kitchen gardens and allotments is that when you think about
it compared to a field scale they're very rich diverse polyculture this comfrey here is being
amazing for all of the pollinators why I would recommend you do is watch this video here it's
a garden tour video from summer last year it'll show you all of the polyculture all of that
diversity that's a natural way of reducing pest and disease issues in the garden I think
far more effective for us growers than crop rotation.
