In this episode, we dive into President Donald Trump’s multi-pronged strategy to revitalize America’s economy, from aggressive reciprocal tariffs to massive DOGE cuts, and a large-scale deregulation effort to promote business growth.
The Code of Federal Regulations is now over 190,000 pages long. A 2017 Auburn University study found that each federal regulator effectively “costs the U.S. economy the equivalent of 138 private sector jobs per year.” The researchers said that equated to a $11 million annual loss for the U.S. economy for every additional regulator.
What will be the impacts of the Trump administration’s policies? Will they usher in economic prosperity or will America have to head into a recession first?
CHAPTER TITLES 0:00:00 - The Regulatory State and Crony Capitalism 0:00:54 - Precedents for Economic Transitions 0:04:14 - Balancing Regulation and Deregulation 0:07:26 - Challenges of Reforming Large Organizations 0:12:00 - Assessing the Current Economic Landscape 0:18:49 - The Role of Tariffs in Trade Negotiations
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
there are hundreds of thousands of
federal regulations the vast majority of
them they're crony they're bought by
lobbyists and the main goal of them is
either to get bailouts to offload some
of their costs onto the public or to ban
the competition in this episode we sit
down with Economist Peter sa an a my's
Institute fellow we dive deep into
Trump's strategy to revitalize the
American economy and what roadblocks May
lie ahead what Trump is doing doing is
that he is very good at spotting the
details of a negotiation okay of
understanding who holds which cards and
when he looks at Europe you know the
Striking thing about really every one of
our trade Partners is that they need us
a heck of a lot more than we need them
is America headed into a recession what
are the precedents we've actually been
through this before so if you look at
the end of World War II so 1946 we
demobilized 11 million soldiers GDP
dropped by
11.2% yes it was a brutal recession in
1946 immediately followed by one of the
Golden Ages leading up through the
1950s into the mid1 1960s this is
American thought leaders and I'm Yan
Kell Peter St an such a pleasure to have
you on American thought leaders thank
you for having me on so of course I've
been following your work quite a bit and
you're very prolific on X on on social
media and you wrote something the other
week that frankly was quite shocking um
for every single federal regulator
that's kept on the job there's
138 private sector jobs that get
destroyed it's hard to Fathom how this
could be the case the reason is because
Federal
Regulations one of the great myths of
government is that
regulations uh exist because there's
some public need and you know people
organize and they they stand up in their
local community centers and they they
bake cookies and somehow you know they
power through against the man and in
reality regulations are bought they're
bought by lobbyists and this has been
true since the beginning of Regulation
they are generally bought by large
incumbents uh for instance Wall Street
Bankers they have big budgets they use
those budgets to put Senators on speed
dial and then when they need a
regulation written they call up the
Senators the people who actually write
the regulations tend to be employed by
those big companies and the main goal of
them is either to get bailouts some sort
of to to offload some of their costs
onto the public or to ban the
competition you look at 2008 for example
that's a really nice example of this so
2008 was a disgrace Wall Street made
billions of dollars and that and by
basically taking huge risks taking
gambles hiding the gambl they were
taking and then when they went against
them they handed it all uh to taxpayers
and what was cute is that of course the
public was angry they were angry on the
left you had Occupy Wall Street they
hanger on the right you had the tea
party and the response was that Wall
Street said we've been naughty we need
you to regulate us and they wrote the
regulations of course because who else
is going to write regulations Wall
Street knows how the financial system
works right the people doing the bake
sales aren't going to write competent
regulations uh they are going to get
hustled so now when you look at it's
kind of a fun chart when you look at the
number of banks that were started in the
US it's very very hard to start Banks
because there a lot of regulations that
are bought by Wall Street they make it
almost impossible so they screwed up
they got something like $800 billion
worth of bailout and in return their
Penance was that they re wrote the
financial rules to Outlaw Competition
and to keep it all for themselves to
monopolize uh Finance into an oligopoly
so the end result is that the
regulations chase out our own job
creators Peter forgive me uh this feels
to me like a very extreme position about
regulations because obviously without
any
regulations
uh Corporate America would run a mock
right like having zero regul ation isn't
cannot be the right answer even if let's
say the preponderance of Regulation is
indeed exactly as you describe so so
where does this actual needed and
valuable regulation come in or is your
position that it simply doesn't
exist uh it doesn't exist with a caveat
so we can ask what happened before we
had the regulatory State and the federal
government was of was of course much
much smaller but how did did you deal
with companies Behaving Badly back in
the N like the
1800s and that was dealt with by the Tor
system so negligence rules so if a
company was poisoning your soup then you
had a case you could take them to court
and then you would get compensation for
that and that was the main deterrent
against companies what happened is
during the Progressive Era so this is
about 1900 to about 1915 or so that was
really the Heyday of the era of course
it's continued but during that era the
regulatory State rose up
uh that was sort of the creation one of
the main creations of the Progressive
Era but something else they did was
capture the legal system by specifically
by trial lawyer
associations they have essentially
weaponized legal system against regular
people so if you changed it today it
would be an absolute disaster companies
would indeed poison you because you
wouldn't be able to do anything about it
they would just outbid you in the legal
process they would have lawyers to run
you around circles for the rest of your
life take away your house in the
meantime so you really you know 95% of
the regulatory State you could get rid
of without any consequences that last
little nugget of 5% that is doing
something it's very corrupt but it is
doing something at that point you know
when and if we get to that point then we
can have a conversation about pairing
that last bit of Regulation together
with legal reform tort reform but until
then you know I think the main point uh
given what we're working with is that
you know there are hundreds of thousands
of federal regulations the vast majority
of them they're crony you can get rid of
them with very little consequences very
little negative consequences and a lot
of positive consequences in terms of new
entrance being able to come into the
industry and create jobs and create
Prosperity fascinating and you know so
let's let's talk about Doge very briefly
right one of the arguments that's been
leveled against Doge there's a lot of
you know I I've heard a of positive
arguments certainly uh uh but one of the
arguments that's been leveled against
doge is that it seems too arbitrary
right there's too much being taken out
it's unclear I'm thinking about these
regulations right if you're saying
there's five 5% that are doing something
95 that aren't if you get rid of the
wrong five you could create a mess for
exactly the reasons you just described
is it possible this is the situation
with
Doge yeah it's always tricky if you're
reforming a large organization so the
the US government employs about 2.4
million civilian workers uh they have
budgets of course about 6 trillion that
they spend it is by far the L largest
organization on Earth uh well outside of
China anyway it's a very very large
organization and so if you're trying to
shrink it if you're talking about a
private company you can just go in there
and and you know look through what's
efficient what's inefficient and then
cut the fat with the federal government
it's very very tricky because they've
inserted sort of all these trip wires
and traps and fake doors and and so they
have to go after what they're able to go
after initially so to give an example
when you join the federal government the
first year you are a probationary worker
it's much easier to fire you you don't
yet have all of those government Union
rules now what they're currently doing
is targeting those probationary workers
because they're the loow hanging fruit
in a perfect world they would not do
that right instead they would you know
look at all of the employees and they
would say I don't care how long you've
been here are you good at your job are
you not now they've made a couple of
mistakes I think they laid off there
were some nuclear inspectors or
something where they rehire them within
like 12 hours uh Elon has said that
that's that's going to happen you know
you're when you throw in the postal
workers in the military you're talking
close to five million people if you're
trying to trim a five million person
completely dysfunctional organization
yes you're going to make mistakes in
both directions what do you think of how
Doge has been conducted thus far I think
it's it's been incredible uh it's
something that both parties have been
trying for decades this is not a
republican issue uh both uh Bill Clinton
even Obama they tried to rationalize
government to make it more efficient we
know big government does not have all
the answers we know there's not a
program for every
problem we know and we have worked to
give the American people a smaller less
bureaucratic government in
Washington and we have to give the
American people one that lives within
its
[Applause]
means the era of big government is
over Al Gore famously uh you know he was
going to make the government more
proficient uh he was carrying around an
ashtray it was like an $800 ashtray from
the Pentagon or something this has been
a longstanding issue that has been
recognized by both parties and it's
actually interesting Doge itself was
created by Barack Obama it was called
the US digital service usds and he
created that in the aftermath of the
Obamacare website Fiasco so that was
very embarrassing and they said okay the
federal government is dysfunctional
we're going to create this agency who
whose job is to go through and find
efficiencies over or above all technical
efficiencies so this notion that doge is
some outside creation no it was created
by Obama and it was created because
there's a longstanding need recognized
by all parties to rationalize the
federal government to make it more
efficient it's just that when it's Trump
doing it the Democrats go nuts when it
was Clinton doing it Clinton laid off
several hundred thousand federal workers
not a peep you know that was that was
all about efficiency it made a lot of
sense is what New York Times tells us uh
when Trump does it it's literally
destroying democracy we're going to take
a break and then we'll be right
back and we're back with Peter St an
let's actually talk about the economy
we've been hearing about lots of real
structural problems with the economy uh
the the debt the amount of money that's
been printed in the last few years kind
of the the accelerating you know
interest payments on the debt
um at the same time uh basically since
inauguration inflation and I have this
by quite a reputable numbers from the
folks over at triflation that that it's
down like to something like 1.4% if
pretty pretty steady I I don't even
understand how that works given given
the reality of the previous years right
given the amount of money Printing and
so forth so can you give me a picture of
what you think the economic reality for
the US is right now
so that's a big question there's a lot
of parts to
it um here breaking it down okay so
you've got three numbers that I think
people really care about one of them is
inflation one of them is growth and one
of them is
jobs and if we start with
inflation the big story at the moment is
that we've got this overhang from the
Biden Administration the numbers that
we're getting right now are really the
tail end of Biden's numbers and the
reason is that it takes a while to
colate most of these statistics so the
numbers that we've been recently getting
uh have been sort of the final report
card for Biden those have been pretty
bad so Biden's final month inflation
rate was an annualized 5.7% that was his
parting gift to Trump economic growth
GDP growth was about 2.3% that's fairly
good there's a big caveat there however
which is that if we go back through the
Biden Administration about half of
economic growth has just been increases
in government spending right that is not
sustainable that's not that's not
actually creating Prosperity it shows up
as GDP but it's not creating Prosperity
so if you discount for that then we're
probably closer to about
1.2% which is pretty bad because the
population grows about 1.2% other words
that's flat that is stagflation so 5.7%
inflation per capita 0% economic growth
Biden gave Trump stagflation and the
problem is that it takes a while to turn
those around so traditionally for
example when you look at Federal Reserve
interest rate cuts which is the main way
that the FED tries to influence
inflation there's a delay of about 12 to
18 months on those those take quite a
while to work through the economy that
means that if Biden handed Trump
stagflation in theory the first 12 to 18
months of trump could still have all
that inflation it so how do you fix that
how do you bend the curve on it faster
the main way you do that is cutting
government spending you can cut
government spending or you can try to
grow the economy very quickly spending
they've been trying very hard to do that
with Doge Democrats have been fighting
every step of the way some of that has
been through lawfare for example uh you
know trying to force them to hand out us
Aid money things like this on growth
which the other way to do it uh that
also it it usually takes a while right
it takes a while for people to start a
new Factory or or to drill a new hole
for oil so Trump is trying to accelerate
that as quick as possible and so the
question is over the next 6 to nine
months let's say before the new
companies kick in when we still have the
overhang from Biden's tag flation I
think that's really the danger zone
that's what you know when you look at
the stock market for example when it's
somebody called it a kangaroo market
right it's not a bull market it's not a
bare Market it's a kangaroo it's all
over the place a lot of that has to do
with the market trying to figure out
what they think is going to happen in
the next six to nine months under Trump
you mentioned you know the there's two
approaches right one is that you can cut
spending the other one is you can create
Prosperity when you're doing the cutting
spending side of things right you're
actually you know you mentioned that a
significant portion of the jobs growth
for example and the economic growth was
actually that government spending in the
first place you're actually cutting the
economy itself so it's almost seems like
you have to do the other part the
increasing Prosperity otherwise you're
going to uh you know end up in a dark
place or or or correct me if I'm wrong
yeah you're going to end up a recession
right so if you look at Argentina for
example Javier Malay has been a model uh
for what doge is aiming to do and Javier
Malay uh came into an economy that was
going through
hyperinflation the real economic growth
was in freef Fall it was just an
absolute mess in Argentina and what he
did was slashed the federal government
he he campaigned with a chainsaw and
maybe viewers have seen him uh aa aa
throwing out uh Ministries from a from a
whiteboard he cut 6% of GDP in
government spending which in US terms is
like cutting close to $2 trillion in
annual spending massive Cuts so he cut
6% now that means that on paper GDP is
going to go down by 6% because GDP cut
uh includes government now what actually
happened in Argentina is that in that
first year GDP growth only went down by
three and a half per. meaning that the
private sector almost immediately jumped
in and made up for half of all the
government Cuts one year later the
projections for Argentina's GDP now are
around 8%
growth right so in other words what
happened in Argentina you cut $1 the
private sector immediately grew by 33
cents and then the following year it
grew by like
a150 right so it's incredibly good for
the prosperity of the country you're
can't answer is a strong word but you
are you are losing fat and you're losing
fat fast if you cut 6% it takes time to
build the muscle going by Argentina it
was surprisingly fast but yes in the
meantime you did have that three and a
half% drop now Argentina does not have a
very robust welfare state we have an
overgrown welfare state in this country
uh you're eligible for Medicaid for
welfare for unemployment benefits so you
know if we have something like a 3 and a
half% recession here it's not going to
be nearly as bad as Argentina because we
have that large welfare state now we've
actually been through this before so if
you look at the end of World War II so
1946 we demobilized 11.2 million
soldiers it was an enormous that was
close to 10% of the entire population it
was close to a fifth of the workforce so
we we demobilized them because the war
was over and GDP dropped by 11 I'm sorry
we demobilized 11 million GDP dropped by
11.2% and yes it was a brutal recession
in 1946 immediately followed by one of
the Golden Ages leading up through the
1950s into the mid1 1960s Trump is
surprisingly aware of American economic
history he's talked a lot about the
period before the income tax for example
the 19th century when the government
subsisted almost exclusively on tariffs
there was no income tax there was no
Federal Reserve
he's surprisingly familiar with these
things for a president I think he's far
more intellectually curious than say a
Barack Obama uh certainly than people
give him credit for but yeah I think
he's interested in the 1950s economy and
in many ways demobilizing our
overgrown Federal leviathon I think is
very similar to demobilizing after a war
so you mentioned tariffs instead of
taxes um and this is something that that
I know that the executive branch has
looking into uh I think the president
has has mentioned this specifically um
let let's talk about tariffs you know
how do you view for example right this
big new uh I guess approach that the
president has been touting and we're
about to see how it's going to work or
not is these reciprocal tariffs right in
in situations where there's a you know
significant imbalance in terms of what
sort of tariffs are being levied they're
going to be equalized based on on what
the other side is doing what do you
think is going to
happen yeah so a tariff fundamentally is
a it's similar to a sales tax and it's a
tax on imported goods the trick is that
generally speaking other countries are
putting a lot more tariffs on us than
we've been putting on them now they're
not all sort of tariffs written out on
paper a lot of them are non-tariff
barriers so they'll they'll block our
Imports you know by claiming uh some
environmental or some uh Health rule uh
many of them are are Vats which are a
type of income tax or a type of sales
tax that most countries in the world
impose those hit our Goods if we sell
stuff to France but then France exempts
its own products so there's a variety of
barriers that countries put on us and
for Europe for example they tax us at
roughly
18% more than we tax them what Trump is
doing is that he is very good at
spotting the details of a negotiation
okay of understanding who holds which
cards and then seeing whether he can get
a better deal and when he looks at
Europe you know the Striking thing about
really every one of our trade Partners
is that they need us a heck of a lot
more than we need them so to give a
flavor something like 1 to two% of the
American economy is producing for export
to Canada or to Mexico on the other hand
1th 20% of the Canadian economy is
producing for export to the US onethird
of the Mexican economy is producing for
export to the US that means that we have
massive leverage over these countries
now we could just make them dance to
entertain us but specifically what Trump
is interested in doing is getting them
to lower those barriers and what he's
saying is if you get rid of your
barriers we'll get rid of our barriers
but in the meantime we're going to
calculate how much we think you're
tariffing us with those non-tariff
barriers and the vat tax and all this
and we're going to put the exact same on
you and so because the US economy is so
important right Mexico cannot give up a
third of its economy they'll have riots
they can't do it and so what Trump is
sort of doing is recognizing the
enormous leverage we have over these
countries now that's not even to speak
of the military right so there's a
number of countries in the world that
only exist because the American taxpayer
covers their bills for military it's
true of Europe it's true of Japan Korea
certainly is true of Taiwan it is
outrageous that any of these countries
should have any trade barriers
whatsoever against us given what we give
to them so he is putting countries into
line when they've been abusing the US in
the past well uh Peter St jge uh any
final
thoughts uh no just to say that you know
if you look at what a difference it's
been uh since 2021 the dark days of Co
it's um this is one for the history
books we are living history right now
well Peter St Don it's such a pleasure
to have had you on thank you thank you
for having me on J thank you all for
joining Peter St an and me on this
episode of American thought leaders I'm
your host Yan Kell
[Music]