Rep. Adam Niemerg - Education Policy Testimony

IL House GOP
33 followers
Mar 20, 2025
Education Policy Testimony
so I just have a few questions on the
education
portfolio Just to elaborate a little bit
more home Representative Swanson a
regional office of education or
immediate service center or Chicago
public schools may request that a
homeschooler administrator provide an
education portfolio as evidence that the
homeschool administrator's homeschool
program provides a satisfactory course
of instruction that is at least
commensurate with the standards
prescribed for public schools My first
question is that's on page 9
uh section 25 C It appears that this is
open-ended What is the intent of this
i I can speak to that So the what is
required of of public schools and as
well as schools that register is they
need to attest that they are providing
instruction in English language and in
the areas of language arts mathematics
biological and physical science social
science fine arts and physical
development and health We do not put any
specificity beyond that Okay And as far
as section 25 C it looks like this is a
standalone um that the ROE may at any
time decide they're going to come into
folks home and say "Hey we we want to
see your your education portfolio and to
make sure that it is within the
standards prescribed for public
schools." Is that accurate or not
accurate uh that is contained under
section 25 this failure to submit for
truency of the education portfolio So
that is part of the truency clauses of
this bill for legislative intent if it's
before you know a judge down the road Is
that the intent because it appears here
that C would begin another subsection
that would constitute this May from the
roe as for any reason whatsoever
The legislative intent is that the
educational portfolio is for truency
investigation Thank you Thank you And
then
secondly commensate with standards
prescribed for public
schools You had kind of gone over that a
little bit Does that include mandates
that come down from the state of
Illinois and curriculum mandates that
religious uh freedom that the folks in
this room would want to practice what
does that include uh it would include
the things that I listed before and
nothing more Okay Could you please
restate those yeah of course It's uh
language arts mathematics biological and
physical science social science fine
arts physical development and health
Okay And is it the ROE that would be
making that determination if this
education portfolio is satisfactory
i don't believe the bill says anything
about satisfactory Okay Well who who
then it says program provides a
satisfactory course it's in it's in the
language Who makes that determination
that it provides a satisfactory course
uh that would just need to be under
those individual titles and how they
meet those would be up to the individual
programs that the homeschoolers are
providing that information on Who makes
the decision of whether or not they're
complying with the statute It would be I
believe it would be the roe but I would
uh leave that up to the legislature
legislator to explain It is up to the
individual um roes and how they assess
that information It would be a case by
case basis but then that is what the
flexibility is intended to do is so that
just those freedoms that you were
describing as long as they fall within
the um current statute of the subjects
that's the intent So when doesby have
any rule making ability have any you
know because it says in here also that
is provides the student records or
information may be released transferred
disclosed or otherwise disseminated to
the state board uh of education So does
the state board of education have any
rulemaking ability to supersede the
ROE's decision uh we have broad
rulemaking authority for the entirety of
the school code Uh but no we would not
do that Okay So you would not be
involved in rulemaking ability on the
ROE's decision if this education
portfolio meets the satisfactory
requirements That would be up to the ROE
to make that determination And what
would pre So we're kind of leaving a lot
of authority with individual ROEs Is
there any concern about maybe a a
particular ROE
that sees things differently or doesn't
agree with the religious freedoms of the
individuals in this room
no that is the intent is so that it is
um up to each regional office education
and how they want to do that I I believe
that if the ROE wanted to escalate an
investigation of authentic truency they
would have to take it in front of the
state's attorney and it would go in
front of a court system The ROE would
not have unilateral authority to
determine that your portfolio was
inadequate and in any way mandate that
you return your child to public
education Just to make that clear
Correct And um that is why there are
additional layers of review of how
somebody can a truency investigation
actually occurs and what occurs Um in in
speaking to various states attorneys um
in preparing for this bill I wanted to
know how many cases that were actually
filed versus referred And it's not as
many as as anybody expects So again your
local states attorney is would be
reviewing any truency um potential
invest I'm sorry any truency cases that
would be um civily uh in court that the
state's attorney to make that
determination Okay Thank you And Isby
you had said that the reason for the
form and what we're doing here today is
that you want to know where our students
are Is that correct
we will know by based off those forms
and their their their declaration or
registration Yes Okay So you want to
know where where our students are is
what you stated previously Yeah All
students in the state of Illinois uh
deserve an education Okay Well I just
make something very clear They're not
Isby's kids They're not the government's
kids There are these parents in this
room that are standing up for their you
know religious freedoms parental rights
They're their kids and they're their
students Um and to insinuate you know
that we don't care about a child that is
that had was victim of a horrible crime
is an insult to the 47,000 witness slips
an insult to the moms that are looking
at me right now in this room and to
everybody in the state of Illinois that
has opposed this bill So thank you
