GDP Downgrades Have Begun, The Fed is in BIG Trouble

Financial Freedom
10 followers
The parade of economic and GDP downgrades has begun and it's just getting started.
From the Atlanta Fed to a rash of Wall Street banks, the rush is on to downgrade economic
expectations. And given that, you have to think as the Federal Reserve meets today that it is
feeling trapped. After all, we've got central banks around the rest of the world that are
rapidly decreasing their rates, which means the Fed has to be feeling the heat.
We're starting to see people like Mohamed El-Erian, who's one of the most establishment
thinkers there is, think that the Fed needs to begin leaning toward the rest of the world,
which is well underway toward this race to the bottom. Where El-Erian is increasingly worried
that really is the underlying case for the real economy. He's been joined by a number of banks
and brokers all beginning to worry the economic trajectory is indeed at high risk. Even after
the complete mess over the first quarter for GDP Now, which is the Atlanta Fed's GDP tracker,
it's still basically zero growth from the fourth quarter, meaning that it's picking up big-time
weakness on the tracker, even if the tracker has trouble keeping track of gold flows. And
we'll cover what that means here today. And speaking of gold, it continues to hit record
highs as this, quote, uncertainty is unrelenting. Only it isn't uncertainty. On the contrary,
it's becoming more, not less certain. Gold is rising because of those fundamentals,
and those fundamentals are not inflation. We know that from what just happened in Canada
with its CPI and bond markets, a preview of what we should expect from the tariffs. Remember,
central bank policies aren't stimulus or aid. They're a reflection of economic circumstances
and how central bankers perceive them. Lowering rates simply means getting out of the way the
market by agreeing with the market in the way that it has been pricing those fundamentals.
The Fed is not going to say anything today. Officials there are waiting for confirmation
from macroeconomic data. They're going to continue to talk about uncertainty even as
things become more and more certain, including the fact that central banks around the rest of
the world have cut rates a lot more than people appreciate, gone a lot farther. They're well into
this race to the bottom. And so the next step getting the Fed to join the rest of the world's
central banks is to have people around the Fed, such as Wall Street economists, begin talking
in the same way as we see at central banks around the rest of the world, that is to downgrade
economic growth expectations and begin talking more confidently and forcefully about the prospects
for weaker economic growth and even maybe the dreaded R word. And that's exactly what we're
getting. As we've seen just recently, we've got downgrades from Wall Street banks up and down
the street, starting with Morgan Stanley. The bank's U.S. economist, led by Michael Gapin,
on Friday lowered the 2025 GDP growth call to 1.5 percent from 1.9 percent, which is measured
on a fourth quarter versus fourth quarter basis. So they're talking about the entire full year GDP
down to 1.5 percent, which is consistent with a lot of significant weakness in the first part
of this year. And there's more. Quote, while our baseline outlook is that the economy avoids a
recession, we acknowledge that the accelerated policy implementation and front-loaded policy
uncertainty push recession risk higher. They're blaming this on tariffs when it's really the
fundamentals that we got to, that we have before we even got to 2025. We think that the trigger for
downturn would most likely come from a downdraft in equity markets, which is not how the economy
works. Instead, as I keep pointing out, the equity markets pick up on these signals where the
recession conditions are developing, and so the equity markets go down. That doesn't create the
recession. It's a reflection of it. But from the perspective of an economist, what's the difference
to them? Goldman Sachs. Larger tariffs are, quote, likely to hit GDP harder through their tax-like
effect on disposable income and consumer spending and their effect on financial conditions and
uncertainty for businesses. The bank took its 2025 forecast down to 1.7 percent from 2.2 percent,
again, fourth quarter on fourth quarter, seeing significant weakness. And again, they're blaming
tariffs, but at least looking at them in the right way. As prices for tariffs go up or prices go up
because of tariffs, that's going to destroy demand. It makes it harder for consumers and businesses,
too, to spend on other things. You're taking money from one place in order to give it to another in
the most unproductive fashion. So as we see in the non-economic oil price spikes over the last
couple of years, the end result is not more inflation. It's more economic weakness. At least
Goldman Sachs gets that part right. And so we have raised our 12-month recession probability
slightly from 15 to 20 percent. That's only a limited amount of change for now because the
White House still has the option to pull back if the downside risks begin to look more serious.
However, if the administration remains committed, even in the face of much worse data,
the recession risk would rise even further. They're looking at tariffs as the ultimate shock
or the proximate shock to cause a recession. That's how economists believe recessions develop,
traditional-style recessions. You have an economy that's operating, whether it's under or near
capacity, then a shock happens which sends it off into a full-blown contraction. So that's what the
economists are looking for. And what they're really saying here is that given tariffs and
really the uncertainty around the rest of the economy, they're seeing a higher and higher
chances of a traditional-style recession. And these are economists who talk the same language
and think the same way as those at the Federal Reserve. So as these economists are speaking
publicly about what they're seeing in their econometric models, it's the same econometric
models that the FOMC is looking at right now as we speak. The most pessimistic of them has to
be the Atlanta Fed's GDP Now GDP tracker. Now that had been around 2.3 percent growth, the initial
estimates from the GDP tracker actually a little bit higher. So 2.3 percent around the end of
February, they're thinking for first quarter GDP, after the fourth quarter was in the same range.
On February 28th, the Census Bureau published estimates on advanced trade, including things
like imports, which imports as we saw soared, absolutely skyrocketed. And as a result,
because imports are a subtraction from GDP, the GDP Now tracker went from plus 2.3 percent all
the way down to minus 1.5 percent. And then on March 3rd, the GDP tracker was dropped even further
to minus 2.8 percent with the advanced indicators on personal spending and personal income, which
I've noted before, the personal income numbers were incredibly weak and the spending figures
weren't all that much better. There was a massive 20 billion dollar or so inflow of gold, mainly
from Switzerland, some from the UK, which was gold trying to beat tariffs with the fear that
import duties will be placed on gold. Gold dealers were importing gold from all over the world,
everywhere they can get their hands on it. And that, of course, showed up in the Census Bureau
estimates. However, the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the government agency responsible
for putting together the GDP figures, does not count imports of non-monetary gold in its GDP
estimates. So for the GDP tracker to get back on track, the Atlanta Fed is going to have to jigger
with its current models and its current assumptions. And they're in the process of
doing that, which supposedly they're going to update their GDP tracker models in the next week
or so. But already there's been a preliminary assessment when they take out gold that got GDP
back to minus 0.4 percent as far as the last data that was released. But still, minus 0.4 percent,
that's negative. And then they raised the estimates a little bit further after the
payroll numbers came in, because the GDP tracker takes some of the data from the
establishment survey and uses that to approximate what GDP components will look like. And so they
got the GDP number for the first quarter back up to 0.4 percent. So it's on the plus side at least.
But 0.4 percent is substantial weakness. And this focus on gold imports obscures the fact that we
have weak spending, weak incomes, weak retail sales, falling consumer confidence, all the things
that you would associate with a plus 0.4 percent GDP quarter or a minus 0.4 percent GDP quarter,
substantial weakness in the real economy that can't just be ignored as a product of gold imports.
So that's what Wall Street's economists are doing, similar to what GDP Now is doing,
trying to come to grips with what's happening in the first quarter, the start of this year,
which is for them unexpected, which is why they keep using the term uncertainty. They were certain
we're going to hit a soft landing. Now they're seeing the evidence suggests maybe not. And
because there's rising risks of weaker economic outcomes, they're looking for reason for it. It
can't be their interpretation of the economy, the soft landing economy before. It has to be
tariffs and trade restrictions. So at the Fed meeting today, by the way, I'm recording this
before the announcement comes out because I don't really think it matters all that much.
What they're going to say is very likely the same thing they said last time, which is we don't
really know where the economy is going. We're worried about economic weakness, so they won't
say that. But we're also concerned about consumer prices because consumer price numbers have been
stronger than expected recently. And their theory of inflation includes tariff impacts on the
consumer price numbers. So basically, they're paralyzed. They're going to play it cool and
say strong and resilient over and over again, but also acknowledge that they'll see the risks on
both sides. There's risks to the downside in the economy, but there's also risks to the upside in
terms not of the economy, but of consumer prices. You've got to keep in mind how these economists
think inflation works, which is not how inflation actually works. Their view of inflation rests on
expectations theory. They think if you and I believe inflation is happening because we see
it in higher consumer price numbers like the CPI, then that will change our behavior as if
inflation is happening, and then the change in our behavior becomes that inflation. So the Fed
thinks that it has to counter that expectation by giving you and me something else to think about,
which is the idea of restrictive interest rates. And so if they're worried about inflation
expectations unanchoring, becoming out of control, then they're going to give you the idea that
interest rates, their policy rates are restrictive. Therefore, that will depress your instinct to do
something about these consumer price worries that you and I supposedly have, and it's all complete
and utter nonsense, which is why eventually the Federal Reserve is going to see reality,
and that reality is going to force them to act in the same way that we see other central banks
acting already, because ultimately that's the thing. As Wall Street banks are picking up on,
as the Atlanta Fed GDP now estimates picking up on, things have shifted in the wrong direction
here in the first quarter, and they're not looking like they're going to get better
as we move on further into 2025. Again, that's what other central banks around the world are
reflecting with their policies. They see the same types of things, and it's only a matter of time
before the Fed is shifted in that direction as well. But this is a key step in moving in that
direction. The economists that talk and think like the Fed are already talking and thinking like
other central banks are already acting. And the global aspects of all of this is something we're
going to talk about on Monday, March 24th at noon. There's a link in the description to sign
up for Urdal University's webinar. What are the latest global trends that we're seeing, including
the central bank race to the bottom that's well underway and much further along than most people
appreciate? Not to mention how a possible traditional recession developing in the U.S.
might affect everyone else around the rest of the world, and what you might be able to do about it.
That's our webinar next Monday, March 24th at noon. There's a link in the description to sign
up. I do hope to see you there. We've seen a moderate example of this in Canada just this
week. In fact, just yesterday, the Canadians reported a red-hot, red-hot CPI for the month
of February. It was the biggest monthly jump in the index since May of 2022. So almost three years
going back to the supply shock, the height of the supply shock. It was the highest core year-over-year
rate since August of 2023. The reason for the increase in consumer prices was the Canadian
government ended the tax break on GST and HST taxes in the middle of last month. While everyone
knew the tax breaks were going to expire, the consumer price estimates came in well above
expectations anyway. It's going to continue into next month as the full effect of reinstituting
the taxes will be felt. So you would think, given how the mainstream constructs its narrative about
inflation as well as central bank policy reactions to it, that this sky-high CPI report
for February in Canada, along with the likely next one in March, that's got to get the Bank of Canada
to rethink its rate-cutting plans, right? That's got to at least put them on hold. It puts them
more into a hawkish frame of mind, given how central banks conceive of this and how we're
supposed to think about how these things like tariffs or increases in taxes play into higher
consumer prices and therefore feed into inflation. But that's certainly not how the market reacted
to it. Instead, the downward trend in market interest rates, Canadian bond rates, kept it still
going. There's a little bit of a fluctuation at this moment, but hardly any reaction to the CPI
report at all. If there's any expectation that the Bank of Canada is going to alter its rate-cutting
policy, it's not in the Canadian government bond market at the moment. Because the bond market
knows, as central banks are worried, and they know this too, they just have this flawed
inflation theory, that higher taxes, like higher tariffs, are going to end up being worse for the
economy, not inflationary. That means more demand destruction, combined with other increasingly
negative factors, even before you get to the tariffs, which means eventually central banks
are going to see that weakness and respond to it by further lowering rates. The higher taxes go,
or the higher tariffs go in the short run, the more weakness there will be over the intermediate
and longer term, which means rates are going to go down over the intermediate and longer term, though
many of these places, like Canada, rates are already going lower right now, today. Even Mohammed
El-Erian said as much in his latest TV appearance. Here's how Bloomberg wrote it up. The Federal
Reserve needs to make it clear, at its policy meeting today, that it may have to cut rates if
there are continuing signs that the economy is slowing. But the central banks should communicate
all of this in a way that convinces people that you will have the possibility of rate cuts, not
because inflation is coming down, the so-called good news cuts, but because growth is problematic.
Bad news cuts, he said. So that would put the Fed right back on course to where all these other
central banks already are. If the economy deteriorates even more, then ultra low rates are
going to happen. There's no surprise there. What is a surprise is that the chances of this happening
are rising, and they're already higher than more people really appreciate. That's
what markets are saying, not just the ones in Canada, either. That's the same thing that we're
getting in the gold market, too, with gold hanging at an all-time high yesterday, being above $3,000
per ounce for the first time on Monday. In the gold market, that's not an inflation signal.
I mean, gold lagged in 21 and 22 when consumer price rates were at their absolute highest, and
the gold started to pick up late in 2022 as the global economy started to forget how to grow. So
gold soaring recently is another one on this worsening economic outlook, both here in the
United States as well as abroad. In fact, it's gone up so much, it's almost keeping pace with
copper's surge this year, which means the copper to gold ratio hasn't actually moved that much off
its recent lows. Even though copper is up 25% on a supply squeeze and panic buying in China,
copper to gold is marginally higher than its lows because gold is keeping up on the other side of
it. Contrast that to last year's copper supply squeeze when the copper to gold ratio was sent
much higher, if for other reasons, than the copper to gold ratio normally shows. So gold is saying,
and gold keeping up with copper in a non-economic supply squeeze is saying,
those who are buying gold are afraid that the economic conditions and the financial conditions
this year are materially worse than what was perceived to be just last year too. So you have
more and more markets that are preparing for worsening conditions, and I don't mean worsening
conditions in the forgot how to grow sense of the term either, more the traditional style recession
probabilities. We've got gold, we've got stocks, especially small caps. I talked about credit
spreads yesterday, bond markets, not just in Canada. While the Fed is stuck on its inflation
theory of tariffs and past prices, the rest of the world is seeing the economic risks more clearly,
and they're not aligning in the direction of inflation. So the chances that the Fed is going
to be able to hold out while all the rest of the central banks around the world continue to race
headlong toward the bottom, they diminish with each of these Wall Street downgrades,
with each of these market signals. Uncertainty isn't rising. In fact, uncertainty is falling
with all the other economic and market downgrades. That's why the retail sales report was such a big
one, because of what it said about the consumer angle and all the soft landing uncertainty stuff,
and I went over the details in the video link below. As always, thank you very much for joining
me. I hope you can join me next Monday for our webinar. There's a link in the description.
Huge thank you to your university members and subscribers and until next time, take care.
