what is the key to making great Korean
movies and can we unlock the secret I'm
here with an Asian film expert Samuel
jamier thanks for having me Andrew I'm
very excited to be here Sam you are the
director or the president of the New
York Asian film festival you're also a
filmmaker yourself and you're also
adopted Korean but to France and not
America so that I mean you you have an
interesting background some people think
it's interesting yeah uh basically uh I
was born in Korea I grew up in France I
lived in Japan I lived in Korea I lived
in the UK and uh I've been in film for a
while and I've been running the festival
for about half of his existence now
about 13 years and you speak some
Japanese and Korean correct yeah I speak
Japanese I speak bad Korean but enough
to get into fights I guess all right
well speaking of fights uh I want to
talk about the key to making good Korean
movies because this theory was brought
to me by another film friend of and I
want to talk about it with you and uh it
helps if you obviously of our Korean
background possibly you can deny or
confirm some of these things but um I
think the thesis to and the key to
making great Korean films and why the
Korean film industry is so incredibly
developed it's so great right now
they're killing it all the from the
dramas to The Thrillers to the zombie
movies there's a key element in all this
MH and it's
krage is your friend
Korean he's in film uh but this is
something that uh and we're gonna talk
about K rage in this video about where
it might come from but obviously it's a
concept that a lot of people are
familiar with but maybe they haven't
delved this deep into but that I think a
lot of the anger and pain comes out in
the emotions and that's a lot of the
driving force for a lot of the great
stories coming out of Korea whether it
be snow piercer old boy
parasite even the beef Series in America
Netflix's beef a lot of heavy like anger
and I think that's what sets Koreans
apart from some of the other Asian films
namely I can just say Chinese films I
think is like this anger emotion I guess
that's my initial Theory what do you
think uh I think there's a good Insight
in there uh it's a bit of an outside
perspective I think I I think maybe you
you would make some Koreans angry by
saying that I might entice some K raage
with this uh well I mean so more serious
seriously speaking from a from a
business perspective uh the Korean film
industry is quite developed it's a it's
a it's a very established system there
has a a star system it's it's not recent
so it's not like it happened overnight
it seems to have happened overnight but
it took it took place over the course of
many years so just so there the business
aspect of it it's very well
structured uh and you know there's a
still a few developing Industries in in
Asia like Vietnam and so on and this
this is a very established system so
that's that but what you're talking
about is the emotional intensity uh
that's a result of the storytelling and
I mean it's true there's a lot of
emotional intensity of k k rage if you I
maybe maybe it's not exactly K rage but
there's a emotional intensity I think is
maybe a more proper way to put it you
know I'm I'm making a general ation and
you know trying to get views on this
video but we can talk about like I think
even comparing it to I guess like
Japanese because I think that most
comparable Korea is to Japan as far as
like in pop culture media right there's
a lot of mirrors it's heavily inspired
by but also the histories are heavily
interlined especially recent histories
so I guess like in my opinion I guess
like everyday Japanese life right now is
depicted or PE the narrative is that
Japanese life especially in Japan is
very Serene now that maybe at a time
during World War II obviously the Army
was going crazy and doing all these
crazy things but Japan itself and maybe
you know the joke is that I don't know
if it's a joke but that the after the
bombing you know they all kind of
tightened up and became Hello Kitty and
stuff like that oh wow okay that's the
joke I'm saying that's the joke I'm not
there's you know probably some link but
whether or not you know that's the real
reason but I guess what I mean is that
Southeast Asians like Thai people
Vietnam uh Indonesia I think Southeast
Asians generally have a lot of emotional
intensity as well but their movie
Industries aren't as developed and they
haven't been able to make as many movies
that have spread to the rest of the
world Korea is that Powerhouse okay so I
think the reason why Korean narratives
are so popular whether it's film or or
drama is uh the accessibility it's easy
to understand the emotions put on
display you you see this guy he's happy
he's angry it doesn't always have to be
about anger but anger is probably the
most uh intense emotion so you you can
inst you instantly understand what's
going on do you think anger is an easier
emotion to relate to for like let's say
a non-asian someone who's not used to
watching a lot of Asian faces but that
seeing an angry Asian go through things
is even more relatable possibly than
them going through love is there an
argument there that this is my argument
that I think more non-asians or non
Koreans relate to Koreans being angry
than they would even Koreans being in
love yeah because I think we live in an
age of of great anger political anger
cultural anger that's the word we use
all the time fear and anger so that that
makes uh Korean stories particularly
relatable I think anger is a mode but
overall there's a degree of uh intensity
and you have these outbursts but there's
a lot of frustration in there and and
Koreans live Korean Society is
extraordinarily uh frustrating it's it's
a very tough Society to live in my other
part to this is that because I I do
factor in how I think non-asians in
general had perceived Asians for the
past 20 15 years like so like they kind
of viewed them they didn't know that
Asians had such emotions and then
Koreans are like hey we get angry and we
got rage and like here's our stories and
there and that anger is well all right
so let me preface this because a lot of
the first Asian movies that people watch
were kung fu movies so they're used to
Asians fighting or defying things or
beating people up they're used to that
in movie Sense and then there is some
dramas that kind of got somewhat popular
but mostly within maybe like a certain
sect of the female drama crowd you know
but really when Korean movies blow up I
think in my opinion is when it's pain
anger krage the Han Korean blood the
kimchi blood you know all that coming
out I guess that's my that's my theory I
think you're right I mean there's an
yeah again it's the uh it's the
Aesthetics of it
shocking it goes beyond uh it's
Universal there's a language to it maybe
it helps us open our eyes on screen like
the I'm just kidding well yeah I don't
know about that but I mean it's an
interesting Society it's quite fractured
it's quite broken there's a lot that
people have internalized and so of
course it comes out in in the films and
the and the TV dramas how would you
describe K Rage or Han blood and where
it comes from do you believe in this
genetic or this deep cultural thing you
know how some things like over
Generations they can kind of stick
within your blood we've heard that
trauma can be passed down through the
blood line to a certain extent do you
believe in Han blood or where does it
stand in Korean Society now having been
to South Korea somewhat
recently okay well well I'm kind of a
product of that you know like there's um
uh I think it's partially true there's a
there's some truth to that otherwise why
would
people uh talk about it and
korean-americans definitely talk about
that a lot the concept of Han you know
you have this gudge this chip on your
shoulder and somehow it ends up defining
you uh but you can also kind of
transcend it by embracing it I think
historically yeah it's kind of true I
mean there the Korean War the separation
in it's naturally natur I mean it's just
a fact Korea is broken into two states
right I mean it's not the case of many
uh many nations so that creates uh yeah
as you say uh inter uh intergenerational
drama is it's passed from one generation
uh to another yeah I mean mostly I agree
way is it prevalent in Korea or is do
you do you find do you find that the
conversation about Han this Korean K
rage being more of a korean-american
thing or in Korea they talk about it
it's a Korean American thing like you go
like very often people tell me well tell
tell us about the Han and Han what is
Han what is Jong and I'm like look it's
kind of [ __ ] okay it's it's it it's
historically defined what Korea was in a
in a sense or is a good way for
korean-americans to find to Anchor the
identity you find this word is you're
like this is what we are you know we
don't we don't have Kung Fu we don't
have I don't know anime and stuff but we
have this incredible anger uh you know
like that's the M uh minin novel
Pachinko starts with that like he
treated his treated us wrong something
like that so it starts with the sense
that you've been wrong you've been
colonized you've had uh OC OCC your
country's been occupied your women have
been uh trafficked you know this is
pretty massively traumatic right so it
gets passed down after that saying
that's all that defines a person a
nation I mean come on you know and
there's plenty of H there's Happy People
Too happiness exists it's not just but
then again I suppose from a crean
perspective you could also argue
happiness is just a moment but uh no I
don't I don't like the idea that it's
entirely defined by by trauma but it's
it's certainly a huge part of it you
live in a state of War I mean you have
the country is split into two it's a
very artificial Bower it's literally a
straight line and not only is it split
into two it's like the two are almost at
war or like there's there's basically
missiles that are already yeah but no
one thinks about that there like again
that's also cliche whenever you hear I
think it PES off and rightfully so it
pisses off a lot of people when you say
oh you're from the North or from the
south look you're not going to meet a
North Korean person like probably ever
like the average individual is very
likely to ever meet a North Korean uh
person you know so do you think uh the
high alcohol consumption might play into
it the I mean Soju being such a cheap
and easy to drink alcohol and obviously
alcohol we all know fuels rage I mean in
every culture uh I guess do you I mean
it's a reasonable Factor yeah Koreans
drink gasoline and it's a lot
of so yeah you drink the gas yeah
exactly oh my gosh uh yeah it's true of
course I mean it's uh especially at this
level but I mean it's it's declining
let's be a little positive there but um
I think the
fundamental uh sort of engine or Source
or origin of the kage let's just call it
that is the economic uh uh inequalities
I mean it's a profoundly unfair Society
you have this massive gap between rich
and poor people are pissed off you can
be a very uh established filmmaker and
like you know you heard like the guy
director Hong who made squid game he
didn't make a lot of money from the
running the first season is shocking
Netflix made billions of dollars of it
and what did he make not a whole lot he
made less than you know most uh American
filmmakers would make on a show of that
magn ude
so so that's a bit different but overall
that's that's the story of many Koreans
you you you have to struggle and that's
still that's still there and even though
the Korean film industry is now
internationally known Korean dramas
K-pop the music the models the fashion
everything you know Koreans are hot on
all on they killing it yeah okay good
I've said it it is very factually true
okay it is okay I'm ethnically Korean so
have a little it you get to take some
you should take some credit I think I
should yeah I mean I I uh I did an early
career retrospective of bonjo back in
2007 so like yeah hey man so was we a
bit early in the game e Jong the star
squid game I I guess uh to New York in
2015 so yeah a full 10 years I want to
bring up this story though sorry of Leon
hun how sorry how should I say the name
all Le and he obviously we know him he's
he's been in Squid games recently but
before that he was in Terminator and
before that he was obviously a bunch of
Korean F very decorated Korean actor
very good-looking right very handsome
and a beautiful man but when he was in
America there's these famous stories
where he felt like he was getting
disrespected by other actors in uh not
uh American actors in Hollywood where
they wouldn't really even shake his hand
and look him in the face um um and he
did say rather than feel sad I felt
really enraged by it and I was like hey
man you use the word rage uh but but
also to his credit I mean he did get
mistaken for Ken Jong from The Hangover
which I would get upset too which for
for for lean hun to be mistaken for Ken
Jong which you know you can feel however
you want about Ken Jong they they look
like It's oddly enough because like the
hairstyles are similar but they're very
different people right so I think for
him to get mistaken that was his way of
being like yo like and I could see how
that would enrage him because he so uh
he he's getting mistaken for somebody
who is obviously uh almost as polar
opposite as he could be but I guess like
is it it's not a Korean problem it's an
American problem it's American prism
it's not really his reaction is normal
most most Koreans would be like that
that's true I do think Koreans I will
say I think on average have more rage
than like the average average Chinese
person
uh well it's just it's a matter of
expression like everything in Korean
Aesthetics not everything but a lot par
well for film in particular it's so
focused on
expressing entirely expressionist it's
like you're angry you it shows on your
face there's no like even the restraint
like if the guy looks like oh you know
I'm trying to hold it in so everything
is pretty clear it's a little bit like
watching an anime uh if you watch anime
one of the reasons why animation is so
popular you understand right away what's
happening you have this instant sympathy
with it you just go with it when the
story is is Well written uh in
comparison you you watch some of the
Chinese films uh I'm making a huge
generalization here because right China
this this what does that mean also
Chinese cinema right or or Japan you're
like kind of sometimes say like the
typical Chinese film maybe like
a a a drama or you mean maybe like
you're talking like the woan like the
take place in the dynastic time that's
where they're wearing the long wigs yeah
so first of all there's the cultural
context before like oh God what's the
beggar SE what is the the
wuang uh door whatever like they're like
they're confused so there's a lot of
cultural context that also comes in the
way and the the emotions are expressed
differently people are sad but they they
smile so you're a little bit so there's
a lot of mixed signals not to say that
it doesn't exist in Korean Cinema or or
drama but overall uh everything that you
do in the film making is me is meant to
serve one purpose to express an emotion
directly clearly and to just throw it in
your face that's why it gives this
impression of of Rage o overall that's
that's PR reason I don't think careers
are really necessarily angry it's just a
matter of expressing it like also in
Japan for example you have this concept
like gamma you have gamma means like you
endure something so that for a long time
you had this emphasis on on being able
to just you know right like endure it
and not expressing your pain that's a
you have like classic scenes in Yakuza
films gangster films where a guy to show
his toughness is going to like I don't
know break a bottle and like eat the
glass or something like that or cut
himself and not and not react at all so
like it's the exact opposite of
expression you have to to understand his
Spain for its opposite not expressing
stuff uh that's not really a Korean
thing like people when they're really
really sad they're not like this they
cry their [ __ ] eyes out like they're
bowling and crying they collapse on the
floor they pull their hair out it's very
uh even in real life it's bit like that
like you see people when they're happy
they're like they're jumping in their
chair funny I would say korean's also
you know between egyo Kawaii from Japan
but egyo is very uh popular now with
Koreans and it's very blew up like so
it's very cut like my sassy was very
cute and then you go crazy I guess I
have a question and I I I agree with
what you're saying I mean when we say k
rage it's not unique to Koreans but I do
think that now that those movies and
stories have proven to be successful and
that is kind of like popular culture or
the popular identity now do you think
mhm it is perpetuating in people's lives
like people now maybe some Koreans
whether korean-americans or in
Korea they identify with the K rage and
the Han and they kind
of maybe they don't maybe it's not fake
but they do um they kind of let it you
know let it let it be let it uh flow let
it it out yeah lay it out and and
because they identify with that image
and they're like hey this is what makes
Koreans different or this is what we see
in the movies so now I am more this you
know how like movies can change your
imagery and and perpetuate ideas about
yourself as well so I guess so your
question is you do I think sorry that is
starting to affect Korean society and
individuals in them identifying with the
anger and the krage well I mean the the
films are the result of the society I
mean of course it's a bit of a chicken
and egg thing at some point you see
something and you react to it becoming a
circle now though that it was anger so
you create the films and then the films
for the young kids they they watch the
films and they're like hey Koreans are
angry I'm k no it's a kind of a question
mark in my head but mostly I want to say
not really I mean the films are really
an expression of society they really
reflect who they are like I rather than
the other way around people get shaped
of course by the pop culture the fashion
you see someone but also that person I I
yeah it is kind of a cycle overall when
it comes to the anger I mean these are
real life problems people are poor
there's uh despite you know the K-pop
Star so poor you have these dudes with
sixpacks and it all looks very
successful but it's a society that's
struggling
profoundly their means oh yeah people
live above their means it's it's all
about your appearance the face the
concept of face but no one has the
concept of face I believe
as much as Koreans do it's all about
like you have to walk around with you
access accessories with an airs bag if
you can if you can even if you can't you
have to really try it's very very
competitive so I think these are real
problems that exist people are not going
to get more upset because of watching a
film in fact right now Koreans
domestically they're turning more
towards comedies like feel good stuff
escapism it's it's actually the opposite
Trend right now and it's this well maybe
because uh there's too many struggles in
the everyday life you want that comedy
you want to laugh kind of laugh it off
right yeah for sure I mean also you know
you have the political turmoil life is
not getting better you know it's a lot
of it's a lot of [ __ ] going on like
people are not happy uh fundamentally so
it hence the cage uh thing you're
describing but also uh simultaneously
you have fun comedies you have like you
know silly stuff that anyone could
appreciate but where Koreans are really
good is they make it accessible usually
I can put someone from uh from Ethiopia
uh from the Middle East and they're
going to be like they get it you know
they're not going to be like oh so who's
Captain Marvel VAV Thanos what's the you
get it you're like oh my stepmom she's a
[ __ ] I hate my stepmom you know that
kind of stuff anyone can understand that
I think that explains uh the global
success of uh of Korean films and and
dramas that's a good conversation man
like no I I love that conversation and
uh obviously you know I I like to throw
out these generalizations for kind of
for fun but to get the conversation
going um but yeah I mean I see a lot of
what you're saying and I think I'd like
to invite anybody in the comment section
who's uh you know let me know what you
think about this is
the delivery of the emotional intensity
from Koreans one of the things that
stands out on film I guess that's my
theory I think I think it is compared to
some other Asians but also their film
making is great and their accessibility
is great and their language is uh fun to
speak and fun to learn so I think there
the the faces are good-look everybody's
you know we get it six-pack hot bodies
anger that you get if you got the
six-pack in the in the beautiful body
and then you're angry I don't know maybe
that's a a good some good building
blocks for yeah but it's it's
interesting you're saying that and you
talk you were talking we were chatting
earlier about the pain like the beauty
and all that you know we all know about
the plastic surger phenomenon working
out six hours a day it's it's not easy
so this this thriving the sense that
effort you need to see the effort you
have to go for this so you're saying
that these actors could potentially get
more stressed out and more Angry while
they're training to play these angry
characters that's possible I don't know
all right everybody uh that is Samuel
jamier correct uh check out the links
down below for the New York Asian film
festival you are working on a film as
well right now correct um so yeah I mean
check out his personal links down below
and uh thank for being here and that was
a great talk about Korean Asian film all
right everybody let me know in the
comments down below hit that like button
and uh until next time I'm out peace