History Summarized: The Greek Age of Cities

Hellenic Legacy
8 followers
4 Video Views·Mar 17, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
When the Greek world awoke from its 4th century power nap of the so-called Dark Ages, it did
so under a brand new configuration.
Brushing the metaphorical sand from its eyes and drowsily looking around the Aegean Sea,
we can imagine our personified civilization startling itself to attention, astonished
by the scope of the changes to their ancient abode.
Gone were the great palaces and mighty kings of the Bronze Age, long since dead and buried
under the cataclysmic weight of a civilization-scale collapse, hence that lengthy nap, and here
to replace that was the city, known in Greek as the Polis.
The turn of the 700s BC saw the rise of dozens, and soon hundreds, of these small independent
city-states, comprising an urban center and its surrounding countryside, each of which
had their own laws, government structures, and local customs, but all of whom were inseparably
part of a wider Greek civilization that was coming into full form.
The question we're after today is what did that civilization do?
What did it look like, act like, believe in, aspire to?
What made Ancient Greece Ancient Greece?
Okay, that was several questions, but they all connect, I promise, as we'll see over
the next two-odd centuries, this ascending era of Greek society is defined by a spirit
of collective individuality, and that is represented most vividly in the Polis.
It's the definitive unit of society, and the lens through which Greeks understood themselves
and interacted with each other.
History calls this stretch from the mid-700s down to 500 BC the Archaic Period, to distinguish
it from the lofty Classical Era and Athens' Golden Age, but I see it as Greece's Age
of Cities, the Polis Era.
So, to learn how it shaped every aspect and layer of Greek civilization, let's do some
history.
This arrangement of independent states bound by a common culture is best described by Plato
as frogs around a pond.
In this case, being a frog means speaking a version of the Greek language, worshipping
the Olympian gods, and participating in these civic societies.
Now, we might assume he's describing the OG mainland around the Aegean Sea, but he's
actually reaching from Gibraltar to the far edge of the Black Sea.
As Greeks carved out hundreds of Polis in Sicily and Southern Italy, Anatolia and Cyprus,
the North African coast, and the foothills of the Caucasus Mountains.
That's a big pond with a lot of frogs.
Across this very wide board, every Polis was the unique product of a land, its people,
and their customs.
That meant each wrote its own laws, had a preferred patron deity, and organized their
own government.
Most of the time, this took shape as oligarchies governed by a handful of aristocrats, but
every Polis had different systems of councils, assemblies, and head honchos.
Sparta, famously, had twin dynasties of kings running the state with the help of two additional
councils, and while Athens would later invent a little something called Demokratia in 508,
it was one of countless cities to have a brush with tyranny.
That word conjures up images of vicious autocrats, but the original word tyrannos simply refers
to someone who grobossed their way to supreme power without being elected to it.
It's a purely neutral word, and in practice, many notable tyranni in the archaic period
were law-abiding, benevolent, reformist leaders who left their Polis a lot better than they
found it.
Like the Cypselid dynasty of Corinthian tyranni, who turned the city into a key economic hub
in Greece.
Among the greatest threats a city could face was stasis, the factional discord within a
city ranging from shenanigans in the assembly between rival oligarchs to full-on civil wars.
Cities could get very familiar with bouts of stasis erupting from normal Polis life,
then giving way to a tyrannos who rallied enough support to consolidate power and quiet
everything down before eventually returning to normal.
It wasn't easy, and it certainly wasn't fun, but that was a cost citizens paid time
and time again to preserve their near-sacred civic autonomy.
In a civilization where no single Polis was preeminent above the rest and each fiercely
guarded its independence, competitions between cities were as critical as the internal ones,
and even seemingly simple intercity disputes over land or local resources became essential
conflicts for survival.
When states were this small and this close together, any neighbor behind the mountain
in the next valley over or further down the coast was a rival and a threat, and handling
that threat meant being prepared to cut a fool.
This, of course, is the domain of Ares and Athena, warfare.
Now the precise method of ancient Greek stabby times was once thought by scholars and enthusiasts
alike to be an organized, sport-like affair where two tightly-packed formations of soldiers
pushed against each other's shields in an attempt to break the enemy line, whereupon
it was GG and everyone went home.
More recent scholarship, like last decade and change recent, has convincingly disproven
that model by reinterpreting key evidence and pursuing new and better-supported logic.
This is a fascinating instance where historians are working right now on developing a new
model of polis-age warfare.
The gist is that it was a brawl in bronze, and the big innovations in technique, tactics,
and macro-scale strategy came into form during the later classical era, then were perfected
up in Macedonia by some twink named Alex.
But I'm getting ahead of myself and military history is kinda boring anyway, so what can
it tell us culturally about the Greeks?
Essentially, every core feature of early Greek warfare derived from and reinforced the polis
system.
See, these warriors are best known for their kit and their formation, marching into battle
with a giant hoplon shield massed in a phalanx.
Here, rich and poorer citizens marched side by side and depended on each other to not
catch a spear to the ribs.
This was not a professional army funded by the state, but a citizen militia where every
hoplite bought their own gear.
They were soldiers one day, back to being a farmer the next, but always a citizen.
And fulfilling their responsibilities in war earned them civic rights in the polis.
The theory of a hoplite revolution links an expanding citizen pool with a growing hoplite
army.
The old aristocrats shared political power with the lower classes in exchange for their
vital contribution to the city's defense.
Ancient Greek politics was a full contact activity.
There was, however, another main venue for competition, one that Greeks took just as
seriously as killing each other, and that was sports.
Yeah, actually that tracks, these are the guys who'll burn down a city over a chariot
race, we can't be that surprised.
Starting in 776 BC, the Sanctuary of Zeus at Olympia held festival games every four
years.
Athletes came from all over the Greek world to prove their excellence in running in chariot
races, throwing stuff, and different styles of fighting, from wrestling to the all out
pankration, which literally means all the power.
That's cool.
That's a cool name.
Set against the collective action of hoplite warfare, these athletic festivals awarded
individual glory, elevating Olympic victors into modern day Homeric heroes, celebrated
in poetry, and lavished with honors by their home city.
In time, those cities began competing with each other vicariously through their star
athletes, but in the polis age, this festival celebrated a purely individual excellence.
The Olympic games were such a central fixture of the culture that the four year Olympiad
was the closest thing to a standard calendar across the Greek world.
Every city had its own means of timekeeping, but say, the start of the classical period
at 500 BC always maps to the first year of the 69th Olympiad.
Nice.
As the games were a religious festival at their heart, the event was protected by a
sacred truce, a month on either side of the festival days allowing athletes and spectators
to make their way to and from Olympia with no threat of shenanigans.
Any ongoing wars between cities couldn't interfere with transhellenic travel out of
respect for the sport and the tacit divine threat against defiling Zeus's big party.
And this all makes it abundantly clear what the Greeks prioritized.
Warfare, politics, and culture coexisted day to day, but when one had to take precedence,
religious observance was it.
The historian Herodotus quotes the poet Pindar to say nomos opandon vasilefs, culture is
king of all.
And yeah, I'd say that's accurate here.
The Olympics were one of four panhellenic games, meaning they were open to and celebrated
by all of the Greeks.
The other three were the Nemean, Ithmian, and Pythian games.
That last one was held at the Sanctuary of Apollo at Delphi, known by myth as the center
of the universe and home to Apollo's divine oracle.
The authoritative voice of the god of prophecy himself, the oracle advised on everything
from personal life to the course of empires, counseling on where to create new settlements,
and in Athens' case, what to do when the Persians were invading, trusting one of the
most consequential policy decisions in their history to Apollo's supposedly hash-blasted
interpreter.
This power was clearly invaluable to the Greeks, so Delphi was undoubtedly the most essential
panhellenic site in the Greek world.
That, of course, earned it some gifts.
First were small offerings left by individual travelers, then valuable gold tripods from
richer patrons, and toward the very end of the Polis Age, the cities themselves got in
on the action, building lavish treasuries on the sacred road to the sanctuary just to
house the gifts from their citizens.
What started as an act of pure piety, where better gifts earned more divine favor, became
a competition for prestige.
Delphi was a truly neutral venue, protected by a sacred truce of several major cities
If each individual polis was a distinct, insular pocket of Greek society, the panhellenic religious
sanctuaries like Delphi and Olympia were the key forms for a collective expression of Greekness.
And that's really the balance here.
For all this aura of competition, everyone was performing the same culture, speaking
the same core language, and creating in the same artistic tradition.
Red and black pottery with stylized figures, naturalistic sculptures, gorgeously proportioned
temples in that quintessentially Greek fashion, here too there's a balance between capturing
the beauties of nature's variety and respecting the underlying mathematical order that governs
the universe.
Ideas that would later come to define Greek philosophy were already being expressed through
artwork.
So in art, religion, athletics, warfare, and civics, we're seeing different iterations
of the relationship between the individual and the collective.
How they contrast, yet how they're deeply intertwined.
People commune in cities.
Those cities then commune as a civilization.
Each polis connects the individual to the whole and simultaneously has elements of both
of them.
Its existence facilitates ancient Greek culture and so ultimately defines it.
That determines what it meant to be Greek in this society.
The original word politiki doesn't just refer to government but describes the affairs
of the polis in all the different venues we've seen.
Politics in ancient Greece is an art of performance and competition, so participating in that
collective individuality through the city is the essence of Greekness.
It's either that or the cool-lookin' helmets, 50-50.
Thank you for watching.
There were multiple points writing this script where I had to stifle a surge of ancestral
monologuing at your collective expense.
As in, the word politics is come from the Greek word politiki, which is mean, uh, politics.
So there you go.
One day, surely, my restraint will fail me, but until then, I'll see you next time.
