The genius of America is that it was set up as a representative government, but increasingly, Americans are ruled over by leaders who are unelected, and very powerful. Columbia Law Professor Philip Hamburger unmasks the people who are really ruling our lives. Donate today to PragerU! http://l.prageru.com/2eB2p0h
Join Prager United to get new swag every quarter, exclusive early access to our videos, and an annual TownHall phone call with Dennis Prager! http://l.prageru.com/2c9n6ys
Join PragerU's text list to have these videos, free merchandise giveaways and breaking announcements sent directly to your phone! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru
Do you shop on Amazon? Click https://smile.amazon.com and a percentage of every Amazon purchase will be donated to PragerU. Same great products. Same low price. Shopping made meaningful.
Join Prager United to get new swag every quarter, exclusive early access to our videos, and an annual TownHall phone call with Dennis Prager! http://l.prageru.com/2c9n6ys
Join PragerU's text list to have these videos, free merchandise giveaways and breaking announcements sent directly to your phone! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru
Do you shop on Amazon? Click https://smile.amazon.com and a percentage of every Amazon purchase will be donated to PragerU. Same great products. Same low price. Shopping made meaningful.
If someone suggested to you that Americans should reject representative government and return to the rule of kings, you would laugh.
“This is America,” you would say. “In our revolution, we got rid of monarchy.”
And, of course, you’d be right – but only to a point. Monarchy is making a comeback – though not in the way you think.
Let me explain.
A king is one person. Get rid of him and you might get your freedom back.
But what do you do when the nation has come to be controlled by thousands of little king – almost supreme in their specialized fiefdoms – who have vast power over your life, much as a king might?
Good question, because that’s what we’re up against.
This regime is called the “administrative state.” Its little kings are unelected “bureaucrats,” officially known as “administrators,” “secretaries,” or even “czars.” And, make no mistake, they are very powerful. Their decisions affect us every day. The FDA, the FCC, the SEC, and so on and so on.
Put together almost any three or four random letters and chances are you’ve stumbled on a government agency. These agencies and the people in them shape our lives – often for the worse.
Many farmers in California lost their livelihoods because the Fish and Wildlife Service decided that the delta smelt (a tiny fish) was more important than the farmers’ water supply. That decision may have been right, or it may have been wrong. My point is simply that the decision should have been made by our lawmakers—who are accountable to us at the next election.
Those farmers are among the millions of hard-working people directly hurt by the administrative state. And many more millions have been indirectly hurt – such as all those discouraged from even starting a business by miles of bureaucratic red tape.
This is not an argument against government regulation per se, but against regulation imposed by bureaucrats rather than by our elected lawmakers whom we can hold accountable at the next election.
Here’s the larger danger: As bureaucracy grows, individual freedom diminishes.
How did we get into this mess? And, more importantly, how do we get out of it?
If someone suggested to you that Americans should reject representative government
and return to the rule of kings, you would laugh.
This is America, you would say, in a revolution we got rid of monarchy.
And of course you'd be right, but only to a point.
Monarchy is making a comeback, though not in the way you think.
Let me explain.
A king is one person.
Get rid of him and you might get your freedom back.
But what do you do when the nation has come to be controlled by thousands of little kings,
almost supreme in their specialized fiefdoms,
who have vast power over your life, much as a king might?
Good question, because that's what we're up against.
This regime is called the administrative state.
Its little kings are unelected bureaucrats,
officially known as administrators, secretaries, or even czars.
And make no mistake, they are very powerful.
Their decisions affect us every day.
The FDA, the FCC, the SEC, and so on and so on.
Put together almost any three or four random letters,
and chances are you've stumbled on a government agency.
These agencies and the people in them shape our lives, often for the worse.
Many farmers in California lost their livelihoods because the Fish and Wildlife Service
decided that the delta smelt, a tiny fish, was more important than the farmer's water supply.
That decision may have been right or it may have been wrong.
My point is simply that the decision should have been made by our lawmakers,
who are accountable to us at the next election.
Those farmers are among the millions of hardworking people
directly hurt by the administrative state.
And many more millions have been indirectly hurt,
such as all those discouraged from even starting a business by miles of bureaucratic red tape.
This is not an argument against government regulation per se,
but against regulation imposed by bureaucrats rather than by our elected lawmakers.
Whom we can hold accountable at the next election.
Here's the larger danger.
As bureaucracy grows, individual freedom diminishes.
How do we get into this mess?
And more importantly, how do we get out of it?
America's founders recognized the problem.
They didn't like being told what to do by people they hadn't voted for.
They built all kinds of protections into the U.S. Constitution,
starting with its very first line after the preamble.
All legislative powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States,
which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives.
All legislative powers, not some.
This means only Congress can make the nation's laws.
Congress thus cannot divest itself of that power to a bureaucracy.
And that's how America operated for most of its first hundred years.
This changed when many Americans, such as Woodrow Wilson,
fell in love with centralized bureaucratic power.
Wilson was a university professor before he moved into politics
and eventually became president in 1912.
A self-described progressive reformer, he was impatient for power.
He wasn't interested in persuading the American people to come over to his point of view.
That would take too long.
So instead, he aimed to shift lawmaking power out of Congress
and into the hands of a professional class of government workers, in other words, bureaucrats.
Franklin Roosevelt, who served in Wilson's cabinet,
perfected his mentor's vision when he became president.
For him, as for Wilson, there were few problems that administrative power couldn't solve.
FDR's presidency produced an alphabet soup of new government programs
that vastly expanded the administrative state.
And since then, it has grown even more dramatically.
Congress still passes laws, but it leaves it to the bureaucracy to fill in the gaps.
And these gaps can be enormous.
Consider, for example, the Affordable Care Act of 2009, what came to be known as Obamacare.
The bill itself was over 2,500 pages, but Congress left much unspecified.
So career government officials, elected by no one, went to work.
And by 2013, there were an additional 10,000 pages of regulations.
So how do we rein in these faceless monarchs?
First, Congress should actually do its job and take responsibility for the laws it passes.
Don't hold your breath.
But they at least could do this.
Congress should end legal immunity for bureaucrats who abuse their power.
If they know they can be sued,
they'll be a lot more sober about imposing rules others have to live by.
Second, the courts should do their job.
They must follow the law.
That means protecting our constitutional freedoms,
including our right to representative government.
No more bureaucratic rulemaking.
And finally, we have to do our job.
We must assert our freedom in conversation, on the web, and in the courts.
We don't want to be ruled by a king or thousands of little kings.
As the Founders would have said,
no regulation without representation.
I'm Philip Hamburger, Professor of Law at Columbia Law School
and President of the New Civil Liberties Alliance for Prager University.
Thank you for watching this video.
To help keep PragerU videos free, please consider making a tax-deductible donation.