In the thought-provoking video "Conventional Economics Is A Form of Brain Damage," narrated by renowned environmentalist David Suzuki, the critical flaws of conventional economic thinking are laid bare. Suzuki challenges the fundamental principles of modern economics, highlighting its disconnection from the real world and its destructive impact on the environment. The video begins with a powerful critique of the way conventional economics values short-term profit over long-term sustainability, exemplified by practices like clear-cutting forests for immediate financial gain, regardless of the environmental cost.
Suzuki argues that conventional economics is not a science but a system of values cloaked in mathematical equations, failing to account for essential elements such as the ozone layer, underground aquifers, topsoil, and biodiversity. He points out the absurdity of labeling these critical components of our planet as "externalities," showing how this approach is fundamentally disconnected from the realities of our world. The video emphasizes that nature provides invaluable services – from water filtration and soil creation to plant fertilization – services that are ignored or undervalued in economic calculations.
Concluding with a powerful message, Suzuki urges a reevaluation of what constitutes the true "bottom line." He envisions a future where humanity recognizes the real value of the natural world, understanding that economic systems should serve not just short-term human needs but the long-term health of the planet. This video serves as a wake-up call, challenging viewers to reconsider our current economic paradigms and to envision a world where the economy exists in harmony with nature's intricate and vital systems.
The economists say, if you clear-cut the forest,
take the money and put it in the bank, you can make 6 or 7%.
If you clear-cut the forest, put it into Malaysia or Papua New Guinea,
you can make 30 or 40%.
So who cares whether you keep the forest? Cut it down.
Put the money somewhere else.
When those forests are gone, put it in fish.
When the fish are gone, put it in computers.
Money doesn't stand for anything.
And money now grows faster than the real world.
Conventional economics is a form of brain damage.
Economics is so fundamentally disconnected from the real world,
it is destructive.
If you take an introductory course in economics,
the professor in the first lecture will show a slide of the economy.
And it looks very impressive, you know, raw materials,
extraction, process, manufacture, wholesale, retail,
with arrows going back and forth.
And they try to impress you because they think
that they know it damn well.
Economics is not a science,
but they're trying to fool us into thinking that it's a real science.
It's not.
Economics is a set of values that they then try to use,
mathematical equations and all that stuff,
and pretend that it's a science.
But if you ask the economist,
in that equation, where do you put the ozone layer?
Where do you put the deep underground aquifers of fossil water?
Where do you put topsoil or biodiversity?
Their answer is, oh, those are externalities.
Well, then you might as well be on Mars.
That economy is not based in anything like the real world.
It's life, the web of life that filters water in the hydrologic cycle.
It's microorganisms in the soil
that create the soil that we can grow our food in.
Nature performs all kinds of services.
Insects fertilize all of the flowering plants.
These services are vital to the health of the planet.
Economists call these externalities.
That's nuts!
We're told over and over the economy is the bottom line.
I don't think so.
What kind of a world would I like to see our species generations from now?
I hope it will be a creature that understands what the real bottom line is.