Who will pay for the costs of climate change?: John Kerry and an Aspen Ideas Festival panel discuss

Political Greats
5 followers
#ClimateChange #AspenIdeas #JohnKerry Costs related to climate change are expected to reach $38 trillion annually by 2050, but who will pay for the adaptation and mitigation projects needed to combat the extreme weather? NBC News' Stephanie Ruhle moderates a panel with former U.S. climate envoy and Secretary of State John Kerry, Anne Finucane of the TPG Rise Climate Fund and Chair of Rubicon Carbon, and Vijay V. Vaitheeswaran, a energy and climate editor at The Economist. NBCUniversal News Group is the media partner of Aspen Ideas Festival.
It doesn't cost more to deal with climate change.
It costs more to ignore it.
It's clear from the stock take that countries have not had ambitious enough nationally determined
contributions.
So we're way off course where we should be.
For too long, finance has not been available, accessible, or affordable.
So that music sounded like we were watching the intro to Succession.
So we're going to all start this panel completely panicked.
Thank you all for participating.
I just want to – I believe that our audience are not experts on the topic, so consider
us educated, engaged, and enthused.
Secretary Kerry, I want to start with you in that just give us the lay of the land,
where things stand globally in terms of climate change and our ability or where we stand in
fighting it.
Well, thanks, Stephanie.
It's great to be here with Anne, an old, old friend of mine.
And BJ, thank you very much.
Great to be with everybody.
Where are we?
We're facing a challenge unlike any challenge that human beings have ever been asked to
respond to.
The fact is that this is not a challenge which requires us to divine a new algorithm or find
a breakthrough rocket science answer to our questions.
This is very, very simple in some ways, but made complex by just lack of global willingness
to move and address facts and to deal with reality.
It's part of the fever that has seized countries around the world – I mean, France, Germany,
Bulgaria.
I mean, you can run around and you all know exactly what's happening here, which is
very, very disturbing.
So, Stephanie, this crisis, which is a challenge to life itself on the planet – and that's
not some liberal lefty sort of qualification about what's going on – it's reality,
and I'll get into that in a moment.
There's one principal cause of what is happening to this planet.
It's very simple.
It's us.
It's the way we choose to light our homes, to heat our homes, factories, to transmove
from one place to another, whether it's airplane, automobile, or truck, or whatever.
We burn fossil fuel without capturing the emissions.
And therein is the entire challenge.
Eighty percent of the emissions that are clogging the atmosphere that contain the heat that
then goes into the ocean, 90 percent of the heating of the earth goes into the ocean,
and then the moisture rises from the ocean, travels around the planet, and falls in these
massive pop-up rainstorms.
I was trying to get some insurance the other day on something, and the insurance agent
said, you know, I like what you've been doing, but we're losing $100 billion a year
now just to these pop-up storms.
That's not even losing to all the other challenges of food production and water and
other things.
So we're really looking at a situation where, globally, the world came together, starting
in 1988 when Jim Hansen testified about climate warming happening, Al Gore, myself, Tim Wirth,
Frank Lautenberg, a bunch of senators whom you recall, we were all part of that.
And in 1992, we went to Rio, and even George H.W. Bush came to Rio, signed an agreement
which was voluntary that we were going to respond to climate.
Problem?
We haven't really fully responded the way we need to.
Now, that said, folks, our clock is really ticking.
This is not something where we have the freedom to be able to just sort of play out like a
lot of political issues.
You know, I've dealt with China, I've dealt with Russia, we've dealt with Ukraine,
with ISIS, with Iran, and so forth.
I believe, despite all of those other challenges, we can manage China, we can manage Russia,
we will ultimately be able to work through those things.
What we can't do is be indifferent about what we need to do to deal with climate because
there is no capacity to come back.
We are seeing the Arctic melt four times faster than the rest of the planet, the Antarctic.
It was 70 degrees above normal last summer in the Arctic.
It was 100 degrees Fahrenheit above normal in the Antarctic.
And if you go there, you will see what the impact is to the naked eye.
You can see the beginning of the fracture of the West Antarctic ice sheet, which if
it were to break off and crumble, which is now currently is on track to do, you're talking
about feet and meters of sea level rise.
So for all these people who sit there, and I hear them and you hear them, and they say,
oh, you know, you guys are hyping this, or it's like, yeah, we've had this in the past.
No, no, we didn't have this in the past.
5,000 years ago, we didn't have human beings doing what they're doing today.
And now we are doing things that are accelerating this transition.
The last 12 months, folks, each month, hotter than the one preceding, the hottest year in
human history that we've measured.
And likewise, I mean, you can run down the list, 50 degrees almost.
Almost 50 degrees centigrade in India a few weeks ago.
A thousand pilgrims died at the Hajj the other day just because of the heat.
I mean, what is wrong with people that they can see these things happening, and yet they're
unwilling to do what we need to do?
Now what we need to do, Stephanie, and Ann will talk about this, and we've all been working
on it, this transition is now building up.
At the last COP 28 in Dubai, we succeeded in the hardest diplomacy there is, which is
multiple nations, 200 nations in this case, came together.
And we wound up with language even China signing on, even India signing on, saying that we
must transition, this is a quote, away from fossil fuel, accelerating in this decade so
as to achieve net zero by 2050 according to the science.
And the words according to the science mean holding the Earth's temperature rise to 1.5
degrees centigrade.
Right now, folks, as we sit here today in beautiful Aspen, we're heading to 2.5 degrees
centigrade.
Now, there's a glass half full, glass half empty component to that.
We are looking at the fact that when I came into this job at President Biden's request,
and by the way, obviously, when I was running for president and telling people I was going
to wind up in the White House, I clearly meant as climate envoy to President Biden.
But, you know, I worked hard for the U.S. presidential envoy, special presidential
envoy for climate.
I just wanted two words out of that sentence, president, U.S. president.
Anyway, didn't want him that bad.
And special too, I'm sure.
Yeah, special for sure.
But what we're looking at now, folks, is the ability to be able to move.
And that's what is exciting.
I'm actually optimistic.
Despite all the negatives in what you can say about the human factor of being unwilling
to really commit and make a difference and do the things we need to do, a lot of people
are doing the things we need to do.
And we have moved.
I was saying when I came into this job for President Biden on the inauguration day, we
were headed to 3.7 to 4 degrees.
Now the IAEA, the International Energy Agency, tells us that we're heading towards 2.5.
But here's what's exciting.
If we were to do all the things that we put on the table and promised to do in Glasgow
and two years later, and a year later in Sharm El Sheikh and a year later in Dubai, if we did
all the things, we now have 155 countries have taken a methane pledge to reduce methane,
which is 80 to 100 times more destructive than CO2.
We have 100 of the biggest corporations in the world have joined something called the
First Movers Coalition.
So we have Google, Apple, Microsoft, Salesforce, Volvo, Mercedes, Ford, General Motors.
A host of big companies have committed to do things to send a demand signal to the marketplace.
So they're buying green now.
We have green cement, green steel coming our way.
The problem is just not coming big enough and fast enough at scale.
But even batteries for storage, which are critical to the full value of solar, are coming
through slowly.
There are things we could do to speed this up.
So, Stephanie, I would say this, that we are on the cusp of a transition that I promise
you will happen.
We will get to a low-carbon, no-carbon economy.
It makes a difference who's president, huge difference.
But even if you know what happens, the fact is the marketplace has made a decision to
move in this direction.
The CEO of those major automobile companies, they're not suddenly, with the election of
one individual, going to say, oh, gosh, different person.
Let's go back and make internal combustion engine cars again.
That's not happening.
Last year, for the first time in history, a trillion dollars more went into renewable,
alternative, clean energy than into fossil fuel.
So this is happening.
We have about $2 trillion of venture capital now moving into this space.
Not yet enough, not big enough, not at scale, but believe me, it's making a difference.
And what the IEA has told us, here's the reason for hope, and I'll shut up after that.
The reason for hope is that the IEA tells us that if we were to perform all the promises
made in Glasgow, we could hold the Earth's temperature by 2050 to 1.8 degrees rise.
If we did all the things piled on afterwards at Sharm el-Sheikh, we could reach 1.7 degrees.
And we haven't yet had the calculation that shows what we could achieve, but it clearly
will be more, closer even to 1.5 than where we are now.
So it's a question now of political will, of business leadership, of people standing
up and demanding that we do the things we know how to do, provide the finance, which
Anne is a specialist at, and begin to break down the barriers to moving at the pace that
we humans need to move.
And I believe we can do it, but I'm not yet convinced that we're going to do it,
and be able to avoid those worst consequences of the climate crisis.
Vijay, we keep setting these goals, and then we miss them, and then we set new goals.
If we keep missing the mark, where are we headed?
First of all, thank you for having me here, Stephanie, and Tasman Ideas.
I think we're here to talk about the most important question, I think, of our generation,
perhaps of our century.
And I think Secretary Kerry set the frame right, that is a call to arms.
I think that's a way to think about this.
I've followed the UN process in climate change more than 25 years, and it is frustrating,
but it's a process of ratcheting up ambition over time.
We have seen progress.
The way I would frame the challenge, because we were asking the question, where is this
$38 trillion going to be coming from, right?
That's sort of the damage that are expected.
And I would say, look, we start with empathy, raise ambition, and that gets to your question
and what Secretary Kerry has been working on at the international level, at the governmental
level, that that's how you unlock incentives for capital, where the money will come from,
ultimately unleash innovation.
I think that's the trajectory we need to think about.
I'll tell you what I mean very briefly.
The ambition has to come from government and getting together as governments at these
international gatherings, but also domestically, as we've done with the Inflation Reduction
Act, the infrastructure law, and we can talk about the domestic side, but increased ambition
on policy, because government will never have enough money.
That $38 trillion isn't going to come from government pockets, let's be honest.
But government has the ability to provide catalytic capital, along with the World Bank
and development agencies, to be more innovative in providing blended finance and setting the
rules of the road for carbon trading or for carbon pricing, for promoting clean energy,
ending subsidies for dirty energy, which continue in the trillions at the moment.
And so, if governments get the rules of the road right, with more ambition, what happens
is you unlock that pool of financial capital, that there's no shortage of capital in the
world, and Anne can attest to this.
Enormous amount of capital, but you need the right rules, you need the right incentives,
so that they see opportunity.
And I would put to you, especially given the climate revolution that's beginning to happen,
we're seeing this, an extraordinary time for a range of climate technologies that are
now getting ready for prime time to be scaled up.
I think we're on the cusp of a decade where we're going to see dramatic changes that are
possible to scale up, as well as deployment of things we already have.
That's the challenge today, is how do we unlock and unleash that capital so that the
technologies can be scaled up.
And we saw a small marker, which Secretary Kerry alluded to, according to official figures
from the International Energy Agency, last year we saw nearly $2 trillion invested in
things that could be considered clean energy, green molecules, that energy transition, almost
double that that was invested in fossil fuels or dirty energy.
For the first time, dramatic transformation in the direction of travel.
Now, the amounts we need are much more than that, right?
By the end of the decade, we're going to need $5 trillion per year globally.
Most of it in the developing world is not going there yet.
But this is how we begin to change.
We get the flywheel going with raised ambition and unlocking the capital and creating incentives
for private capital to come through.
And what is the ultimate price tag to transition to greener, renewable energy?
Who pays for these projects?
And ultimately, if we don't do it, who pays that price?
That's an existential question.
But I mean, the estimates are anywhere from $6 to $9 trillion a year.
So that gives you a sense of the magnitude of the problem.
But I wouldn't really quite look at it that way.
First of all, I have a more sanguine view, not because I don't think it's an emergency.
I think it's an emergency.
And I think it's a chronic problem.
We don't usually have an emergency and a chronic problem at the same time.
But we do here.
So when we're in emergency, and I'm going to use America as an example, like a pandemic,
the pharmaceutical companies that were developing vaccines suddenly come to the fore,
and they're able to give them out in the billions.
Now, there's controversy around them, but they saved a lot of lives.
John and I were talking last night at a dinner.
And in World War II, you changed the automotive factories to munitions factories,
and we won a war.
So we have the ability to do these things.
Right now, we're distracted, I think, globally.
There are two wars going on.
There's inflation in most parts of the world.
There are about 60% of the world is going through some sort of election.
Most of that's going to the right, with the exception of the UK.
So, and we hope here.
So, you know, it's a confusing time.
And distractions tend to take us off course.
But if I could just use a little bit of sort of plain vanilla history,
the Highway Act, very poor, 1956, the Highway Act happens,
and the automotive business takes off.
The building business takes off.
Suburbs take off.
Industrial parks take off.
More ports become apparent from a Highway Act.
But that didn't happen in the first few years.
Space program begot chips and computer chips, which begot Silicon Valley.
Takes a while to do.
I think the IRA and the Infrastructure Act and Chips Act,
not one of them particularly well understood by the American public.
And not all the rules are written or they're being sort of managed a little bit.
I think once they take off, they will be the fire starters in the same way
the Highway Act was and the space program.
And then I would just add to that, that the financial firms are pretty much in.
So in 2021, while you were the special envoy,
John Kerry got the six largest banks in America to commit to net zero.
Well, the secret there is if six banks commit to net zero,
they just committed all their clients to net zero.
Because the way it works is you fix your own operations,
then you fix electricity or energy you buy.
And the third piece of that called scope three is
you take care of your entire value chain.
Everybody has sort of made that transition.
It's huge work.
I don't know if it happens by 2050, but it gives you a sense of,
talk about a flywheel, that's flywheel on an industrial level.
Secretary, the United States,
do we have a special responsibility in terms of the world, right?
We're the biggest emitter of carbon dioxide.
We're now the biggest oil producer.
Do we have a greater responsibility than others
in helping specifically developing countries
when it comes to transitioning to greener energy?
Well, I'm one of those who believes very strongly that, yes,
we do have that responsibility.
And generally speaking, Republican presidents and
Democrats alike have understood that responsibility and
tried to put it in play in their policies.
It is only in recent times that we have once again
turned as inwards as we appear to be.
And I can tell you as a former Secretary of State,
while every person who is elected to office
always puts their district and their state and their country first.
Generally speaking, it's not the best diplomacy to run around
telling everybody America first doesn't sit very well.
But that's where we are.
Well, of course.
But but you don't have to say it.
I mean, it's like it's like the Boston Celtics.
They don't have to say it anymore.
I know L.A., I got it.
But with all due respect, it's not just saying it.
If President Trump wins, right, this isn't just talk.
He pulled out of the Paris Climate Accord.
It's not just what will we do to fight climate change?
You don't have lots of people, including that candidate,
who doesn't acknowledge climate change.
We're all going to work really hard.
And the Europeans are going right.
Yes, and exactly.
Think about the elections that are taking place in Europe in the last few weeks.
Listen, I've followed them extremely closely.
There's a tangible reason why the world is in crisis today.
This is not, again, not rocket science.
It's pretty basic life and politics.
A large number of people in the world feel as if globalization didn't serve them one bit,
in fact, hurt them.
And they have not profited.
People are struggling.
Even in America, we see our own fellow citizens struggling to make ends meet.
And they don't feel as if the brass ring is available to them anymore.
So when you have a divide growing, as we do, between wealth and poverty or hard times,
you're breeding insurrection.
You're breeding a lack of confidence in governance.
And that's what we're living with, folks.
Government has not delivered in many respects.
Now, there are certain people who have adopted that as a matter of strategy to not let it work,
because the matter you make, people, the more they move off into this
place of supporting the extreme kind of view of how you can do things.
I got news for you.
The United States Senate is not not working because the rules of the Senate have been changed.
It's not working because the people there don't make it work.
And they may be elected.
And when I was there, we went out to dinner with and talked with and enjoyed conversation
with our colleagues from the other side of the aisle, and we got things done.
That doesn't happen today.
And that is breaking the back of our nation.
Right now, it's we who are our own worst problem.
We can deal with China.
I kept a dialogue going with China all last three and a half years.
And we got China to step up and join us in accelerating our efforts to deal with the
climate crisis.
But if we don't talk to people and we just assert our way and the highway for the rest of you,
we are begging for a world that is much less functional and much more divided and impossible.
Now, with respect to this particular issue, the climate issue, I just want to emphasize
that we're looking at – we're not talking about spending money.
We're talking about investing money for the most part.
Do we need to have some concessionary funding that will actually excite and act catalytically
to bring private sector to the table?
Because then you have a more bankable deal.
You need bankable deals for this money to deploy.
And it's been hard to get to them.
The international financial institutions, particularly the World Bank and some of the
have not been able to deliver what we need to be able to attract that capital.
But we're now learning – we know how to now.
It's beginning to happen, and we've reformed somewhat what the World Bank was doing.
Ajay Banga has taken over and is very much committed to moving this capital into the
marketplace.
We are staring at the largest market the world has ever known, the energy market.
There are about a billion people who have no electricity at all today.
And there are plenty of people who – and since it's something you pay for and you
pay in many places for water and you pay for transportation, those – that revenue is
the revenue that can support this transition.
So it's not as if we don't have the money to do this.
When the global banking group GFANS came together for Glasgow, people felt, okay, we've got
$131 trillion of assets that need to be deployed that are at the table.
But they haven't deployed.
Why haven't they deployed?
Because they don't think they can make money.
Now, Anne and I were talking yesterday.
Anne informed me that ESG, which now is being assaulted and attacked, which doesn't make
a lot of sense, but actually delivered profits of 24.4 percent.
So it's money-making, folks, to be in the business of this transition.
And it's only going to grow in its need.
I'll tell you, we're going to have tens of millions of refugees, particularly from a
place like Africa or some other countries where food production craters, where water
disappears, and these people can't live.
And just as we saw a wave of immigration in the wake of Syria and Turkey and the war in
Iraq, we will see a wave of desperate migration as people find or try to find a place to live
on this planet.
SINGHALAIKIS That last point addresses your earlier question, who will pay the $38 trillion.
The sad truth is part of it will be paid in human suffering, right?
If we don't raise ambition, if we don't make this transformation work, it will be paid,
particularly in the lives of those who need to leave where they are, or droughts in the
developing world where they have less resilient infrastructure, where they have less financial
markets that are developed or access to clean energy.
That's the sad truth.
That's an argument to increase our ambition, not to give up.
You had also asked about what happens with the election.
Obviously, we're in election season.
Here it is.
For those who care about climate, climate finance, the energy transition, I assume you're
all in this tent this morning for that reason, because you do care about what happens with
our planet and the future for our children and grandchildren.
There's bad news and there's good news.
The bad news is this is a challenging time, right?
Interest rates are high.
That makes it harder for clean energy like wind or solar, which tends to be capital-intensive
free fuel later, right?
So capex-intensive industries, it's harder to invest when the interest rates are high.
Supply chains are gummed up.
So there's some financial challenges that Ann can, I'm sure, illuminate us on.
There are also some challenges if we were to see a Trump victory, there's no doubt we
would see a slowdown in ambition.
Outside analysis suggests that maybe a trillion dollars might be wiped out from the energy
transition over the next 30 years if the set of policies that are likely to be implemented,
not those that are claimed on the campaign trail, but likely to be implemented by a Trump
administration were to come into force.
But let me pivot to the good news.
The good news is we're talking about a transition.
We talked about tens of trillions of dollars that are involved, right?
So it would slow ambition, but it would not be a U-turn.
Here's why.
I've been talking to a lot of operatives in Washington for a lengthy story I'm writing
for The Economist on this very topic.
Nobody serious believes that the Inflation Reduction Act will be overturned.
It's like Obamacare was, a totem, something to tilt against.
But in fact, too many people benefited, the votes weren't there.
And when you look at who benefits from the Inflation Reduction Act, over two-thirds,
and on some measures 80% of the money goes to congressional districts that are red.
In red states, to Republican congressmen, who often, even though they make a noise about
it in Washington, we all know this, they turn up to take credit for the project, right?
And just to give a small example, more than 80 projects worth over a billion dollars each
having to do with decarbonization of clean energy.
In Louisiana and Texas, deep red states are funded by infrastructure law and IRA money.
That's been counted up by the Rocky Mountain Institute.
Just to give you an idea, those projects aren't going anywhere.
Those are companies that you would know from the oil and gas industry and engineering sectors,
and they're Republican congressmen, they're going to fight for those.
So every lobbyist I've talked to even said,
we're going to go to the wall to protect a lot of aspects of the IRA.
Now, there's some things that are going to be in the crosshairs, electric vehicle credits.
They need to be modified, they're unpopular,
there's some challenges with how they're being implemented, for sure.
And there'll be less ambition.
But broadly speaking, I think the energy transition will continue,
even if there is a Trump victory.
And if you look at what happened during Trump won,
when we did see the US come out of the Paris Accord,
that didn't mean the wheels fell off the bus overseas.
Ambition continued in Europe, for example, and other countries.
We look at China.
Well, where does China fit in all this?
The secretary worked closely with China to bring the Paris Accord
and what came after back on track.
The Chinese are the number one beneficiaries of the clean energy economy, right?
They make most of the solar panels, the electric vehicles, the batteries,
and other related equipment that goes with the clean energy economy.
They want this transition to happen.
In fact, because their own property bubble in the financial sector is slowing down,
they're doubling down on a world that invests more in clean energy.
So, I think we actually have multiple wheels globally
that are going to keep the clean energy transition going
and creating markets and availability.
There's one thing I do worry about.
It is protectionism, that green protectionism,
which is very popular here in Europe, in India, other places.
Tariffs on solar panels, on EVs.
It's very easy to say, you know, America first.
We must build everything right here.
And here's something, frankly, the Biden administration
and the Trump administration share.
And there's a mood now for green protectionism.
I would urge caution saying making the cost of green energy more expensive.
That's the surest way to encourage green backlash in America,
like we saw in Europe a few months ago.
The reason people turned up at the polls was they blamed higher prices
on the environmentalists and the green parties, right?
So, I would argue we need to have more free and open trade in clean energy,
including so that when we get our own innovation mojo going in America,
we can sell our products at a lower price across the world
rather than face tariffs ourselves.
So, I would argue, you know, be careful about what you ask for
with making every small widget that needs to go into a car
or your solar facility here in America.
Globalization is the way to go, but thoughtfully.
You know, not the pattern from the past.
We can do this in a smart way.
So, I see positives as well, including that flywheel continuing to go,
regardless of what happens in the election.
And you're in the risk management business.
So, you just said a moment ago, the financial sector is now on board to do this.
But we read all sorts of headlines that say VC firms are funding new projects.
But when it comes to getting the financing,
our largest financial institutions,
our largest banks are saying these projects still look too risky.
What gets them over the hump?
Well, if I can back up the truck a little bit on that one.
Banks are the last in.
However, I oversaw the idea of investing in green,
if you will, or climate initiatives for 20 years.
And 20 years ago, I was hoping in 20 years,
in 10 years, we could have done $20 billion worth of financing.
I didn't really have any idea how we were going to do it.
I just hoped we could do it.
We had just built the first lead platinum skyscraper
in the United States at One Bryant Park in New York.
We had potable water and cogeneration for our electricity.
And it was 95 in the summer and 50 in the winter.
And the toilets didn't flush.
And six months later, everything was fine.
So part of it is like it's a journey.
And so $20 billion, I couldn't figure out, but we were going to do it.
A few years later, we were blowing through that $300 billion.
I couldn't figure out how we would do that.
But maybe we could do that.
I would just bring you to the present day.
And I would take the top 10 banks in the world
who are easily doing $2 trillion worth of, shall we say, climate business.
That means it's not very risky.
That means it's not...
Banks don't take risks.
They think of everything in terms of risk first, opportunity second.
But if you back up the truck, as I said, you begin with venture.
Venture only looks at opportunity, a lot of investment.
You know, you're always looking for the big payoff
because you'll have many that won't go well.
Then you take in private equity.
They scale.
Private equity scales that great idea that came out of venture
and they scale to the next thing.
And then they together go to the banks and say,
let's take this company public.
I mean, that's what Vijay is talking about in the fly world,
in the very boring world of finance.
That's how we see it.
Venture to private equity to banks.
But if the banks are doing collectively,
and I'm just taking some top banks at $2 trillion,
then when you back up the truck, that's what's going on at other companies.
I'll use the company I know about, TPG Rise Funds.
In 2016, they were hoping to do one fund at $2 billion.
Hard to raise the money.
They got the money and they started investing and made market returns.
Today, 2024, they will close probably at $30 billion.
Six funds, no, five funds, 30 billion.
That's a 15 times multiple in that short period of time.
And they're not doing it for charity and they're not getting concessions.
They're seeing value here.
So what I see is that venture is making their way.
Private equity is doing well and banks are kicking in.
And then you bring in concessionary capital,
which is this MDBs, multilateral development banks,
who are kind of changing their stripes of how they do it.
There's a thing called carbon credits,
which is as you go into your journey of trying to make something happen,
the delta in a company between what they can do and what they need to achieve,
the delta, if they prove they've done all they can,
because the technology isn't there yet.
The cement isn't green.
The steel isn't green.
You can't do everything by solar.
They will buy credits.
Those credits can be part of the concessionary capital.
So that's a product.
And then I'll just try one more thing.
And that is on a history of these kinds of products.
In 2009, the World Bank and the European Investment Bank
tried to stand up something called a green bond.
So it's like a municipal bond, except that if you're doing the bond
and you use a bond to borrow, essentially.
I borrow from...
Stephanie has a company.
She borrows from me.
She wants $30 million and she didn't want to take it on a loan
because she's going to get better economics
because I, the bank, am going to syndicate that out.
So I have laid off the risk for me too.
A green bond, says Stephanie's company,
is also going to commit to putting solar on
or some component that is green.
And she has to prove it at the end of it.
So you can see why World Bank wanted to do this.
But they couldn't get it going.
It took getting the International Capital Markets Association,
which is a consortium of banks, asset managers, lawyers, regulators,
and NGOs weighing in.
And that nascent business in 2009
that they clawed their way to get $2 billion for,
by 2014 was only $30 billion.
Today, it's a $1 trillion business annually.
So it gives you a sense of we're just...
We got to see this for what it is.
Go back to the Highway Act.
Go back to the space program.
The IRA, the Infrastructure Act, the CHIPS Act,
to me, are like the green bond on steroids.
These carbon credits will help with the concessionary capital.
And in between, there have been other products.
This all works, but it's just going to take a little bit of time.
And for the financial world, we sort of work in the world of
can, not should.
But we can do this because we are doing it.
Secretary Kerry, then this takes us back to
these projects in developing countries.
It's important to do them.
Banks are now on board because it's huge money-making opportunities.
But when the private sector are making loans,
are financing deals in developing countries,
that's just going to put these countries deeper in debt.
Yeah.
How do we address that?
Well, you have to structure deals
that aren't going to put them in debt, obviously.
And there's a huge backlash to that.
One of the things that came out of the Dubai meeting
was the UAE's commitment to put $30 billion on the table,
$5 billion of which would be dedicated to efforts within the global south.
And I think, and that's a terrific proposition,
but we have to remember, I mean, we've got to balance this.
You can have 48 sub-Saharan African countries
that equal 0.55% of all the emissions of the world, 48 countries.
There are 20 countries, and we are among them,
as in China and Russia and others.
We are equal to 80% of all the emissions.
You don't solve this problem by rushing to say,
oh, the global south, we got to do this.
We have to do what we have to do in the global south
because it's the right thing to do,
because you cannot have the global south left behind.
You need to develop it.
You need to develop in ways that don't compound the problem.
And there, there are difficulties right now
because there hasn't been money on the table
to be able to afford the new technologies
and the ways to avoid the coal, mostly coal,
but also gas and oil that is not abating the emissions.
I mean, the problem here, folks,
is everything you're hearing from us up here, the three of us,
is not based on any politics at all.
We have a scientifically arrived at challenge.
What we have to do, we have to do some things
that are dictated by mathematics and physics
and some biology and chemistry, but mostly physics, mathematics.
And that is telling us,
if you don't reduce your emissions fast enough
by a certain date in time,
you are inviting the worst consequences
of what we are doing.
That's the challenge here.
And, you know, we can't get lost
in the global south component of it
that when I say get lost, you know,
that is not what is going to solve the problem.
What is going to solve the problem is China,
the United States, between the two of us,
40% of all emissions, and then China being 30 of them.
And then you've got India,
which is coming online with additional coal
that is not sufficiently abated.
And you have Malaysia and Vietnam and Indonesia
and others burning coal, more coal coming online.
And coal is the dirtiest fuel there is.
And if it's unabated,
it contributes very significantly to the climate crisis,
as does the methane, which is now bubbling up
in permafrost that's thawing around the planet
because of the overall warming.
So this is, you know, this is just a challenge
unlike anything we've ever faced.
And we have to excite.
What Anne is talking about is 100% correct.
She understands this formula of how to do this better
than anybody when it comes to really putting the money
on the table and really creating the project
that will make a difference.
But we're not, nothing on the table to date
is gonna do it at the scale that we need to do
and in the time frame that we need to do.
That's our challenge.
And even when Trump pulled out, for instance,
of the agreement, just to reinforce what Vincent said,
you know, during the time Trump was in office,
75% of the new electricity
in the United States of America came from renewables
because that's economics driving those choices.
And that's what's gonna happen going forward.
Yeah, just to say that I think that I recognize
some of the campaign rhetoric of the Trump campaign.
But it is true that the economics may be very favorable.
And the IRA are tax credits for people.
Infrastructure is fixing bridges and linking grids.
And the CHIPS Act is really kind of, for both parties,
a sort of stiff arm to China.
Well, it is.
But China's cornered the market.
China's producing more renewables now.
And coal plants.
Yes, but they're not bringing the coal plants
online at full capacity.
They're a hedge against brownouts, blackouts,
and cratering of their economy
because they can't provide energy.
So it's a hedge.
China is producing, manufacturing, deploying
right now more renewables
than all of the rest of the world put together, folks.
And that is going to have a profound impact
on China's footprint.
Whereas they have a 2060 date
for achieving net zero 2050.
In fact, because they're deploying
all of this renewable,
they're gonna lower,
they're gonna speed up and probably beat
a lot of other developed countries
in achieving a balance.
So I think the problem-
Just to pick up on that,
we have to be able to keep two competing thoughts
in our heads at one time to understand China.
I was bureau chief there for a number of years,
and that's certainly true, Mr. Secretary.
A comparable point I'd want to make
is if we're looking for where is that 38 trillion,
or at least the trillions in the future
gonna come from, we haven't talked about.
I thought one final provocation
I could give our audience before we go,
and that is, you know, Willie Lohman,
the famous bank robber, was asked,
why do you rob banks?
And he famously said,
that's where the money is.
Well, there's a lot of money
in OPEC and big oil, right?
And I think part of that will come to finance
the clean energy transition,
and we should make sure it does.
And here are a couple of ways
that we can make this happen.
Among other things, as we get off of oil,
the trillions that are sent to the OPEC cartel,
I mean, let's remember, it is a cartel.
They fix prices so that you and I
pay 80 to $100 a barrel
rather than what would probably be
a few dollars a barrel
if it were a market price, right?
As we get off of oil,
we send less money overseas.
That's a start on where that money
stays here at home,
can be invested in clean energy
and infrastructure.
But also, we see some change in behavior
as the big oil companies of the West,
as well as the national oil companies,
the more forward-looking of them.
The one in the United Arab Emirates
was mentioned, Saudi Aramco.
They began to say, hold on a minute,
we want to be around for the long term,
the oil endgame.
They're putting huge amounts of money
through their sovereign wealth funds
or through their own investments
into clean investments,
into private equity companies in the West
that are investing in clean energy
or investing directly into renewables,
carbon capture, hydrogen,
various technologies of the future.
As you don't have to love them,
you don't have to invite them home to dinner.
Exxon is doing much the same
with its projects that I mentioned
in Texas, Louisiana,
the American oil companies.
But they're looking for hedges
and huge amounts of capital.
$30 billion in the case of the United Arab Emirates
putting into clean energy investments.
But we're seeing trillions of dollars
that will come, I predict,
that can be encouraged
or, in our case, withdrawn
from the oil economy
to go towards a clean economy
that's currently being spent
in ways that are leading to emissions.
We don't have to go that way.
So I would say, let's find more ways
to challenge that oil money.
Then, Anne, is one of the biggest problems here
beyond these specific issues
or even these projects,
but a problem that goes far beyond this,
and it plagues business and politics,
and it's short-termism versus long-termism.
Oh, yeah.
That's for sure.
There's something that separates the U.S.
from everybody else.
We always talk about innovation,
but it's really innovation with capitalism.
That's really what makes us different.
We put money, we do the stick, not the carrot.
So right now, you've got the stick in Europe
of all these regulations
around environmental and climate issues
and the carrot with these acts in the U.S.
That's why I think both administrations
will join into that.
I would go back to,
we have seen progress in the United States
that have fire starters
like the acts I talk about later,
and one thing begets another,
and you're slow at first,
and then it goes really fast.
So on climate, if we politicize it,
we'll get nowhere.
Just everyone fights,
and they argue about oil versus solar.
It's just not productive.
If you incent,
and you can get the financial markets
to see both opportunity and risk,
banks are risk,
venture, private equity,
more about opportunity.
They collectively are already there.
They see it.
It's just how big they'll go.
It really is how big they'll go,
and the financial world,
unlike other parts of the economy,
they don't want to fight about fossil fuels.
They want to accelerate the other thing,
and we're accelerating the other thing,
which is renewables.
Those renewables or water desalinization
or those kinds of things,
those kind of innovations
will be applied to the global South.
It's unfortunate that the global South
will still suffer,
and the big thing for me is
they're going to want to
both electrify their homes
and industrialize,
and will they go to coal first,
or can we come up with enough innovation
at a price point that they can do it?
That's both short and long.
Secretary, I don't mean to put you on the spot,
but I'm going to.
But you're going to do it anyway.
You started this conversation where you said,
and this is practical,
this is economic,
this is for the planet,
this is for our future,
and you said,
this isn't sort of liberal, fruity talk,
and you're right.
The three of you have just laid out
in the last 50 minutes
the best possible solutions,
none of them political.
Every day I cover business and politics,
no one has laid out
how the CHIPS Act,
how the Infrastructure Law Act,
how the Inflation Reduction Act
helps the country,
helps the globe
like the three of you just have.
Why not?
THE PRESIDENT Because of politics.
Very simple.
We have resistance
for a lot of different reasons.
How many of you have seen
advertisements for green gas?
I mean, that's happening.
But there isn't green gas.
We have a denial and procrastination
that continues to prevent people
from coalescing and making a decision.
Let me give you another example.
We haven't talked at all
about nuclear here.
The fact is that in Dubai,
we called for a tripling
of the deployment of nuclear
over the course of the next 10 years.
And the fact is that
nuclear is part of the solution.
Every expert will tell you
we cannot get to net zero 2050
without nuclear.
THE VICE PRESIDENT And the U.S.
is currently 20 percent,
the energy is on 20 percent.
THE PRESIDENT Yes,
of our own energy right now
is nuclear.
A lot of people don't realize that.
You know, in Massachusetts,
we get from Seabrook,
which years ago was a site of protest.
Now it's the source of energy.
And we have to realize that,
give another example
of this procrastination.
There's about 2,000 gigawatts
of potential electric power
that's just sitting at FERC,
the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission.
They won't have made the decision.
They won't allow the permitting
to take place.
You have permitting that takes
up to five or 10 years in places.
Litigation gets in the way.
We have to act like
this is the emergency that it is.
No government has enough money,
as I said earlier,
to solve this problem.
The private sector is going
to solve it.
But the private sector can come up
with the technology,
but they can't deploy
the technology.
We lose, all of us.
So the solutions are there.
They're coming at us fast.
Battery storage is getting
better and longer.
We're seeing batteries.
Germany is now up to about
50 percent of its power
for a very industrialized country
coming from renewables.
And their target is to get
to 80 percent.
Most countries are in the single
digits, folks.
So we have not even begun
to tap into the solutions
that are staring us in the face,
and largely because of
the pushback of NIMBY,
not in my backyard,
or other restraints.
We have to behave like we are
in a war.
Anne mentioned it earlier.
The end of World War II,
we produced one B-24 bomber
every hour on the hour.
We had three Liberty ships
being built every two days,
three Liberty ships built.
This is what we need to be doing
with the new technologies.
And if we were serious about it
and put more visible money
and effort into that,
more incentive into that,
as Anne said, she's 100 percent correct.
The tax, the IRA,
powerful tax incentive,
$369 billion is what it was
supposed to be allocated for.
It's over a trillion now
because it's geared not
to an amount of money,
but to people who qualify
for the credit.
And you qualify for the credit,
but doing the things
that we need to do
in order to win this battle.
We have to decide.
Look, people are,
immigration's on the table,
age is, I mean,
all these issues are on the table.
But really,
survival ought to be on the table.
And we ought to be releasing
the entrepreneurial energy
of this country
and the private sector.
And the minute the market,
which is already increasingly
taking over these decisions,
those decisions are made,
we can win this.
That's what we have to understand.
And the IEA has made it clear,
if we fulfill our promises,
we win the battle.
If we continue to play the games
we play today
and we allow the,
you know, misinformation,
disinformation to run rampant,
it's going to be very hard
to win the battle.
But for this to happen,
we need both the left
and the right to come together
on something.
We need a new environmentalism
that builds.
But here's the thing.
There's actually,
I think, a chance here.
It's one of the rare areas
where there's some interest
in Washington bipartisan action,
might be the next,
after the election,
permitting reform.
People, we need to have an America
that builds again.
And we're seeing this
from Silicon Valley.
We're seeing this
from environmental groups
rethinking how they consider
permitting processes,
because you can't get climate action
if you don't build.
And so I think this is the new era
in which we can build
some bipartisanship,
maybe to end on a positive note.
We need to go from a country
of bananas,
build absolutely nothing
anywhere near anybody.
To a country that builds.
I think we're going to end
on bananas.
Thank you all so, so much.
I sincerely appreciate it.
