Private equity has exploded while public markets have shrunk in the US - what does this mean for businesses and investors? At Stanford Graduate School of Business, JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon engaged in a thought-provoking discussion with Interim Dean Peter DeMarzo on the rising influence of private credit, the decline of public companies, and the regulatory landscape shaping financial markets. Dimon raises a fundamental question: Is the shift towards private capital a net positive or a risk for market transparency? He delves into why companies are fleeing public markets, citing litigation, regulation, and governance complexities. He also shares insights on consumer protection, critiquing regulatory approaches while acknowledging the need for safeguards in finance. With his trademark candour, Dimon challenges assumptions about private equity’s stability and the effectiveness of current regulations.
Let me push on that a little bit.
So, you know, we've seen big growth there.
We've seen sort of the Apollos,
the Blackstones getting into private credit.
We've seen the business development companies
serving the mid-market.
Two things, I mean, one is when you look at those institutions,
they are much more equity-funded,
so have more long-term capital backing them.
So in some sense, we don't see that arbitrage,
I think, that you were talking about, right?
They have much more equity-based funding.
No, they don't.
You know, some do and some don't.
So the insurance companies don't.
A private credit fund does.
You know, they might be leveraged, you know,
two to one or something like that.
But what you guys don't see
is there are multiple layers of leverage in there, too.
They borrow against those loans.
They have subscription lines over here.
They pre-fund some of these other investments.
Literally, like, you don't all see
all that stuff that takes place.
But, yeah, in some cases, they're safer.
Like, an insurance company, in fact, does have,
you know, if you're an annuity company,
you may have longer-dated liabilities
and you have better liability matching
than a bank might have.
So, but you have to ask, and that's fine.
So some are, and they're quite good at what they do,
so I'm not criticizing that.
But is that what you wanted?
80% of the mortgage business is outside.
And I'll tell you another consequence,
which I'd love you guys to study.
Who looks at public capital markets here?
Is there a professor who does public capital markets?
We've gone from 8,000 public companies
in, like, the early 90s to 4,000 today.
8,000 should have gone to 16,000, okay?
Private equity's gone from, like, 1,000 to 10,000.
And I'm not, again, this is not a statement
about for or against private equity.
The question is, is that a good thing?
Is a public market transparency good?
Is having market-to-market capital good?
And why do people leave?
And if you analyze why people left,
it was litigation, regulation, the compensation schemes,
boards have to cross Ts and dot Is.
It's the SEC, it's frivolous shareholder meetings,
it's, you know, NGOs trying to get your company
to do all these various things.
People leave, I would leave the public markets if I could.
But is that what you want?
I think it's a bad idea for America.
And so I think people should answer those questions
before they say, I'm just gonna impose more things on them.
Because remember, these public markets are very transparent
and we have the best financial system in the world,
including private credit and private equity.
But I would go back to the thing,
if you're gonna regulate certain things,
regulate the product the same.
I would be more in that mode.
You know, and including inside insurance companies.
So you don't, so you have the market competing,
but it's not arbitrage.
It's a great question you raise around the size
of private equity and private debt
and sort of that grows in that industry
and a good question to come back to.
I before, I wanna turn to another set of regulations
about consumer protection.
We had Rohit Chopra here last week.
He's former head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
I guess it's fair to say you aren't exactly buddies.
But can you talk a little bit about, you know,
do we need a regulator who's watching out for, you know,
those consumers who are less financially sophisticated
to prevent, you know, charging excessive or hidden fees
to consumers and so forth?
Yeah, of course.
Of course you need proper consumer protection.
And again, it goes back to how you design it.
So, and then someone made a statement recently,
they said, well, if they don't have it there,
the banks would have,
we have consumer protection in the OCC,
we have consumer protection in the Fed.
When they did the CFPB,
it was supposed to go to one place, it stayed in all three.
We also get it effectively from the SEC,
we get it from a whole bunch of other people,
sometimes from the DOJ.
Of course you want proper consumer protection.
And I have no problem with Rohit.
I think he's very smart, I think he's arrogant.
I think that he's one of those guys, I told him,
that was a major intellectual flaw
is when you use your brain to justify what you already think
and that's what he does.
He came with a mission,
and some of the stuff he knew wasn't exactly right,
but it was kind of like, that'll show them, you know,
when he didn't mind about,
it's like some of the people didn't mind being sued,
and none of what he did was bad.
I'm not against it, you know,
but there's been very thoughtful stuff
about what is he trying to accomplish again?
And so some of his stuff was misguided,
but I actually respected him for his intellect.
If you liked the video,
do like, comment, share, and subscribe.