SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
If the government gave people enough money to take care of their basic needs, could we eliminate poverty? Proponents of Universal Basic Income think so. Are they right? Would it really be that simple? Aldo Buttazzoni lays out the pros and cons of UBI.
#ubi #basicincome #prageru
@aldobuttazzoni
Script:
How does this sound?
$1,000 a month. No questions asked. You don’t even have to buy a lottery ticket.
All you have to do… is breathe.
Too good to be true?
Well, that depends on your view of UBI or Universal Basic Income.
UBI is an idea that has been kicking around for a while.
The concept goes like this: give people enough money to take care of their basic needs and we can eliminate poverty. In other words, we establish a floor below which no one will fall. Every citizen is provided for.
Appealing, no? After all, we live in the wealthiest country on earth and yet we have people living in the street. It’s a moral travesty. UBI solves it.
Of course, there’s the small question of who is going to pay for it.
Giving $1,000 a month to every American citizen (that’s the Universal part of UBI) would cost something like three trillion dollars a year.
That would make it by far the most expensive item in the federal budget. Of course, everybody’s taxes would have to go up to pay for this gigantic new expense.
How much?
David Henderson, an economist at the Hoover Institution calculates that to pay for UBI “the federal government would have to increase taxes by 74 percent.”
Venture investor and former Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang, a vocal proponent of UBI, says we can fund UBI with a 10% value-added tax, which means that everything you buy will have a 10% surcharge built in. Would Americans agree to such a big tax on top of all the taxes they already pay? Seems unlikely.
The chances, then, that we could raise the money in taxes—by any method—to pay for the program are almost zero. That means the government would have to make up the difference; that is, go deeper into debt, which is just another way of saying “print more money.” The inflation this would almost certainly cause would raise prices and make the dollars people were getting from UBI worth steadily less, therefore defeating the purpose of the entire enterprise.
Of course, some proponents say that UBI would make many existing government assistance programs—like food stamps and Medicaid—unnecessary, and that would save a lot of money. Okay, but as generous as a $1,000 monthly giveaway might seem, do you really think it would cover food, healthcare, and other living expenses? Let alone your iPhone?
For the sake of argument, let’s say money or inflation were not big obstacles. Would it be a good idea then?
View the full script: https://l.prageru.com/45MqI4A
how does this sound it's a thousand
dollars a month no questions asked you
don't even have to buy a lottery ticket
all you have to do is breathe
too good to be true well that depends on
your view of Ubi or Universal basic
income
Ubi is an idea that has been kicking
around for a while the concept goes like
this
give people enough money to take care of
their basic needs and we can eliminate
poverty in other words we establish a
floor below which no one will fall every
citizen is provided for
appealing no after all we live in the
wealthiest country on Earth and yet we
have people living in the street
it's a moral travesty Ubi solves it
of course there's a small question of
who is going to pay for it giving a
thousand dollars a month to every
American citizen that's the universal
part of Ubi would cost something like
three trillion dollars a year
that would make it by far the most
expensive item in the federal budget
of course everyone's taxes would have to
go up to pay for this gigantic new
expense
how much
David Henderson an economist at the
Hoover institution calculates that to
pay for Ubi the federal government would
have to increase taxes by 74 percent
Venture investor and former Democratic
presidential candidate Andrew Yang a
vocal proponent of Ubi says we can fund
Ubi with a 10 value-added tax which
means that everything you buy will have
a 10 surcharge built in
would Americans agree to such a big tax
on top of all the taxes they already pay
seems unlikely
the chances then that we could raise the
money in taxes by any method to pay for
the program are almost zero that means
the government would have to make up the
difference that is Go deeper into debt
which is just another way of saying
print more money
the inflation this would almost
certainly cause would raise prices and
make the dollars people were getting
from Ubi worth steadily less therefore
defeating the purpose of the entire
Enterprise
of course some proponents say that Ubi
would make many existing government
assistance programs like food stamps and
Medicaid unnecessary and that would save
a lot of money
okay but as generous as a thousand
dollar monthly giveaway might seem do
you really think it would cover food
health care and other living expenses
let alone your iPhone
for the sake of argument let's say money
or inflation were not big obstacles
would it be a good idea then
Ubi supporters would of course say yes
when people are free from survival
concerns they contend they are free to
pursue their true interests instead of
merely making money they would have time
for creative writing or taking long
walks or whatever interests them and
here's another plus people would only
have to take a job that they find
fulfilling because they wouldn't have to
worry about the basics
but given what we know of human nature
another scenario seems much more likely
people would spend a lot more time on
the couch playing video games or swiping
their way through tick tock
and then there's the dignity that comes
from work
from making your own way in the world
developing habits of personal
responsibility
do we care about that or is that just a
remnant of an outdated way of looking at
life
and what if Ubi flat out just doesn't
work does anyone really think a thousand
dollars a month is what separates a
homeless drug addict from a productive
life is a thousand dollar handout going
to give someone purpose or meaning
furthermore wouldn't Ubi Stoke
resentment
nobody likes to toil so that their
neighbor can play that's hardly a recipe
for social cohesion
there's something else to consider when
discussing the downside of Ubi once you
give people things for free it's very
hard to take free away from them that's
pretty much a universal law
it's also a universal law that
government programs expand taking on a
life of Their Own
maybe a thousand dollars a month will be
good enough to start but how long before
it's not enough
do we have examples where UBI has been
tried the answer is yes not in it's a
thousand dollar a month form but in more
limited ways
Finland tried a Ubi program from January
2017 until December 2018 and then gave
up
two thousand unemployed fins got a
monthly payment of 640 dollars there are
no employment gains above the expected
rate but many participants said they
felt happier and less stressed
duh free money tends to have that effect
a few American cities have also tried
limited forms of Ubi
some of these programs are ongoing
Stockton California gave a few hundred
people five hundred dollars a month
the city government reported the
participants really liked it
and why wouldn't they what did anyone
think they'd say no stop giving me money
I don't want it anymore
Ubi might sound compassionate but it's
really not
because it doesn't Free People it
enslaves them to the government
for Prager University
thank you for watching this video to
keep prageru videos free please consider
making a tax deductible donation