The Supreme Court seems to have the final say over every controversial issue from abortion to gun control to same-sex marriage. But is that what the Framers of the Constitution intended? Sherif Girgis, Associate Professor of Law at the University of Notre Dame, has the answer.
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
#constitution #supremecourt #prageru
Script:
Of the three branches of government—the legislative (the House of Representatives and the Senate), the Executive (the President), and the Judicial (the Supreme Court and the lower federal courts)—which is the most powerful?
Today, most people would probably say… the Judicial. It’s the Supreme Court that has the final say over every controversial issue. Prayer in school? Abortion? Same-sex marriage? “Let the Court decide” is the modern refrain.
But that’s a long way from how the Framers saw the role of the courts.
Let’s take a look at what the Constitution says.
Article III, Section 1 vests the nation’s “judicial power” in a Supreme Court and any lower courts that Congress may establish.
“The judges, both of the supreme and inferior courts, shall hold their offices during good behaviour, and shall… receive for their services, a compensation, which shall not be diminished[...].”
By “good behaviour” the Framers meant lifetime tenure. As long as federal judges didn’t do anything worthy of impeachment, they had the job for life or until they chose to give it up.
The purpose of lifetime tenure and salary was to place federal judges above politics, to make them independent of the legislative and executive branches. In this way, they would act as another check on the power of those two branches.
Yet for all that, Alexander Hamilton thought the judiciary was “beyond comparison the weakest of the three” branches.
Boy, was he wrong—but not in his assessment of the judicial branch as spelled out in the Constitution.
As Hamilton explained, the Executive bears the sword, or the power to coerce. Congress sets the rules and controls the purse—the federal budget. But what “weapon” did the judiciary have? Hamilton couldn’t see any.
He couldn’t see any because he and the other Framers never imagined that the Court would be the ultimate arbiter of what was “Constitutional” and what wasn’t. They saw the court as having a much more limited function—as we shall see.
The Constitution doesn’t even state how many justices there should be. That was set by the first Congress of 1789. They set the number of Justices at six which, to our modern sensibility, is bizarre. What would happen in the case of a tie vote?
Again, this points to the Framers’ modest conception of the Court.
As spelled out in Section 2 of Article III, federal courts have just one job: to settle disputes about the rights of the parties before them—not to use cases as platforms to resolve policy debates. For the Framers, setting policy was the job of the peoples’ elected representatives.
What about the ability to declare laws unconstitutional: didn’t that belong to the courts? Yes, but that didn’t make courts the only authority on the Constitution.
As understood by the framers, the legislative and executive branches have their own duty—and power—to interpret the Constitution when doing their jobs. For example, presidents have vetoed bills they considered unconstitutional. That’s what Andrew Jackson did when he refused to recharter the national bank in 1832. He didn’t think the Constitution gave Congress the authority to establish such an institution.
True, the President and Congress have usually followed the Court’s readings of the Constitution as a way of avoiding unnecessary conflict. But, there have been exceptions.
For the full script, visit: https://www.prageru.com/video/the-constitution-the-supreme-court
of the three branches of government the
legislative the House of Representatives
and the Senate the executive the
president and the judicial the Supreme
Court and the lower federal courts which
is the most powerful
today most people would probably say the
judicial it's the Supreme Court that has
the final say over every controversial
issue prayer in school abortion same-sex
marriage let the Court decide is the
modern refrain
but that's a long way from how the
framers saw the role of the Courts
let's look at what the Constitution says
article 3 section 1 vests the nation's
judicial power in a supreme court and
any lower courts that Congress May
establish the judges both of the Supreme
and inferior courts shall hold their
offices during good behavior and shall
receive for their services a
compensation which shall not be
diminished by good behavior the framers
meant lifetime tenure as long as federal
judges didn't do anything worthy of
impeachment they had the job for life or
until they chose to give it up
the purpose of Lifetime tenure and
salary was to place federal judges above
politics to make them independent of the
legislative and executive branches in
this way they would act as another check
on the power of those two branches
yet for all that Alexander Hamilton
thought the Judiciary was beyond
comparison the weakest of the three
branches
boy was he wrong but not in his
assessment of the judicial branch as
spelled out in the Constitution
as Hamilton explained the executive
Bears the sword for the power to coerce
Congress sets the rules and controls the
purse the federal budget
but what weapon did the Judiciary have
Hamilton couldn't see any
he couldn't see any because he and the
other framers never imagined that the
court would be the ultimate Arbiter of
what was constitutional and what wasn't
they saw the court as having a much more
limited function as we shall see
the Constitution doesn't even State how
many justices there should be that was
set by the first Congress of 1789. they
set the number of justices at six which
to our modern sensibility is bizarre
what would happen in the case of a Thai
vote
again this points to the framer's modest
conception of the Court
as spelled out in section 2 of article 3
federal courts have just one job to
settle disputes about the rights of the
parties before them not to use cases as
platforms to resolve policy debates
for the framers setting policy was the
job of the people's elected
representatives
what about the ability to declare laws
unconstitutional didn't that belong to
the courts
yes but that didn't make the courts the
only Authority on the Constitution
as understood by the framers the
legislative and executive branches have
their own Duty and power to interpret
the Constitution when doing their jobs
for example presidents have vetoed bills
they considered unconstitutional
that's what Andrew Jackson did when he
refused to recharter the National Bank
in 1832. he didn't think the
Constitution gave congress the authority
to establish such an institution true
the president and Congress have usually
followed the Court's readings of the
Constitution as a way of avoiding
unnecessary conflict but there have been
exceptions most famously Abraham Lincoln
rejected the Supreme Court's holding in
Dread Scott V Sanford that the
Constitution made African descendants of
slaves ineligible for U.S citizenship as
President Lincoln respected the Court's
decision about what should happen to
Scott a party to the case but otherwise
in running the executive branch Lincoln
followed his own view that persons of
African descent could be citizens under
the Constitution for example he gave
them U.S passports
today by contrast many think the
Judiciary is exclusive and Superior in
its power to interpret the Constitution
no wonder it seems like the most
powerful branch
the framers who had so carefully
constrained the power of the courts in
article 3 would have been surprised and
dismayed I'm Sharif gergis associate
professor of law at the University of
Notre Dame for Prager University
thank you for watching this video to
keep prageru videos free please consider
making a tax deductible donation