Americans fought a long and bloody war to get rid of one tyrant, the English King, George III. They didn’t want to install a new one of their own making. So how did the Framers ensure that the President would have enough power to be an effective chief executive, without making him a dictator? John Yoo, Professor of Law at the University of California, Berkeley, has the answer.
#prageru #president #constitution #history #americanhistory
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
Script:
How much power should we give to the President? This was one of the most vexing (and critical) questions facing the Framers of the United States Constitution in the summer of 1787.
To be effective, the President had to be perceived—both in times of war and peace—as the leader of the nation. For this to happen, he would have to be given significant authority. Americans learned this lesson in the years following the Revolutionary War when the nation floundered under the Articles of Confederation which had no provision for a chief executive.
But this chief executive couldn’t be made so strong that he could become a tyrant. Americans fought a long and bloody war to get rid of one tyrant, the English King, George III. Nobody wanted to install a new one in his place.
The Framers answer is found in Article II.
The opening sentence reads as follows: “[t]he executive power shall be vested in a President of the United States.” This might sound straightforward, but it was anything but.
Here’s why.
“The vesting clause” of Article II, as it’s known, differs significantly from the vesting clause of Article I, which concerns the powers of Congress—the House of Representatives and the Senate. Article I’s vesting clause states: “all legislative powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States…” It then goes on to list those limited powers. That’s it. Congress can’t do anything else.
There are no such limitations specified in Article II. The difference is subtle, but important.
Whereas Congress is given specific responsibilities, the President is given broad responsibilities and wide discretion as to how he fulfills them. This is part of his executive authority.
And just what is that executive authority?
This is spelled out in Sections 2 and 3.
The President is the commander in chief of the armed services. He sets military policy.
He makes treaties with foreign countries. He sets foreign policy.
He appoints his own advisors—what became known as his cabinet. He sets domestic policy.
He appoints judges to the Supreme Court. That obviously gives him a big say in judicial policy.
And finally, “he shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed.”
This list is at once brief and vast because there’s so much involved in all these duties. Indeed, the President stands at the head of the entire administrative apparatus of the Federal government with all the rights and responsibilities that entails. For example, if the President can appoint federal officials, it stands to reason that he must be able to fire them, too.
When you realize that enforcing the law involves layers and layers of people from department heads to federal law enforcement to government lawyers, all of whom are accountable to the President, you start to grasp how much power the chief executive has.
So, how did the Framers keep the President in check?
First and foremost, they gave Congress “the power of the purse,” the power to fund the operations of the federal government. Congress can restrain the President by withholding funding.
The President literally can’t buy a light bulb for a lamp in the Oval Office without a Congressional appropriation. If the President proposes to add a new federal agency or to launch a war, Congress can bring his plans to a halt simply by refusing to fund them.
The Constitution strikes a similar balance in foreign affairs. The President, as Commander-in-Chief, controls the strategy, tactics, and deployments of the U.S. Armed Forces, and also dictates U.S. foreign policy. Only Congress, however, has the power to declare war, and the Senate, by a two-thirds majority, must consent to any treaty negotiated by the President.
Congress also has the power to impeach the President in cases of serious misconduct—treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. But the bar for impeachment is set very high to protect the President’s independence from Congress.
For the full script, visit: https://www.prageru.com/video/the-constitution-presidential-powers
how much power should we give to the
president
this is one of the most vexing and
critical questions facing the framers of
the United States Constitution in the
summer of 1787.
to be effective the president had to be
perceived both in times of War and Peace
as the leader of the nation for this to
happen he would have to be given
significant Authority Americans learned
this lesson in the Years following the
Revolutionary War when the nation
floundered under the Articles of
Confederation which had no provision for
a chief executive
but this chief executive couldn't be
made so strong that he could become a
tyrant Americans fought a long and
bloody war to get rid of one Tyrant the
English King George III nobody wanted to
install a new one in his place
the framer's answer is found in article
2.
the opening sentence reads as follows
the executive power shall be vested and
a president of the United States
this might sound straightforward but it
was anything but
here's why
the vesting Clause of Article 2 as it's
known differs significantly from the
vesting Clause of Article 1 which
concerns the powers of congress the
House of Representatives and the Senate
article 1's vesting Clause States all
legislative powers here in granted shall
be vested in a Congress of the United
States it then goes on to list those
limited powers that's it Congress can't
do anything else
there are no such limitations specified
in Article 2 the difference is subtle
but important whereas Congress has given
specific responsibilities the president
is given broad responsibilities and wide
discretion as to how he fulfills them
this is part of his executive Authority
and just what is that executive
Authority this is spelled out in
sections two and three
the president is the commander-in-chief
of the armed services he sets military
policy he makes treaties with foreign
countries he sets foreign policy he
appoints his own advisors what became
known as his cabinet he sets domestic
policy
he appoints judges to the Supreme Court
that obviously gives him a big say in
judicial policy and finally he shall
take care that the laws be Faithfully
executed
this list is of once brief and vast
because there's so much involved in all
these duties indeed the president stands
at the head of the entire administrative
apparatus of the federal government with
all the rights and responsibilities that
entails for example if the president can
appoint federal officials it stands to
reason that he must be able to fire them
too
when you realize that enforcing the law
involves layers and layers of people
from department heads to federal law
enforcement to government lawyers all of
whom are accountable to the president
you start to grasp how much power the
chief executive has
so how did the framers keep the
president in check
first and foremost they gave congress
the power of the purse the power to fund
the operations of the federal government
Congress can restrain the president by
withholding funding
the president literally can't buy a
light bulb for a lamp in the Oval Office
without a congressional appropriation
if the president proposes to add a new
federal agency or to launch a war
Congress can bring his plans to a halt
simply by refusing to fund them
the Constitution strikes a similar
balance in foreign affairs the president
as commander-in-chief controls the
strategy tactics and deployments of the
U.S armed forces and also dictates U.S
foreign policy
only Congress however has the power to
declare war and the Senate by a
two-thirds majority must consent to any
treaty negotiated by the president
Congress also has the power to impeach
the president in cases of serious
misconduct treason bribery or other high
crimes and misdemeanors but the bar for
impeachment is set very high to protect
the president's independence from
Congress
finally the framers made the president
accountable to the people
if the people are dissatisfied with this
performance the people can vote him out
and they don't have to wait long they
get a chance every four years
before the U.S Constitution no country
had ever had a leader whose fate was so
dependent on the will of the people
at the same time the founders had no
patience for Pure democracy which they
considered no different than mob rule
this is why presidential elections are
not determined by popular vote but by
the Electoral College as outlined in
Article 2 Section 1 yet another guard
against tyranny this time the tyranny of
the majority
it's often said that the president is
the most powerful man in the world
this is undoubtedly true but he's not
more powerful than the Constitution
Article 2 made sure of that I'm John you
professor of law at the University of
California Berkeley for Prager
University
thank you for watching this video to
keep prageru videos free please consider
making a tax deductible donation