It’s hard to imagine how we could screw up higher education any more than we already have, but we’re about to—if we make sweeping student loan forgiveness a reality. How? To answer this question, we must start by asking another one: cui bono?
#studentloandebt #studentloans #debt
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
📲 Take PragerU videos with you everywhere you go. Download our free mobile app!
Download for Apple iOS ➡ https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prage...
Download for Android ➡ https://play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Script:
It’s hard to imagine how we could screw up higher education any more than we already have, but we’re about to—if we make student loan forgiveness a reality.
There’s a Latin phrase that helps explain why. The phrase is “cui bono”—who benefits.
In the case of student loan forgiveness, it’s first and foremost the colleges and universities who can charge outrageous tuition largely paid for by student loans; second, politicians who make cheap promises of debt forgiveness to win votes; and third, students from upper middle-class families who would get taxpayers to pay off their student debt.
Who doesn’t benefit? Everyone else. That includes those who didn’t go to college and a new class of “suckers”—people who went to college and paid off their student loans. Student loan forgiveness is a reverse Robin Hood—it takes from the poor and gives to the rich.
The most obvious argument against forgiving student debt is that no one forced anybody to borrow money for college. Why, then, should others be forced to pay it off? Before you think I’m going to go all tough love on you, let me say that I have a lot of sympathy for young people who have dug themselves into the student debt hole. I am one of them.
For decades, our society has made the claim that you need a college degree to get ahead in life, and that the smart bet was to take out any amount of loans to ensure a bright future.
And if you need help with the tuition? Uncle Sam—the US government—stands at the ready with his generous student loan programs. Fill out a few forms, and presto, there’s a check in your mailbox. You’re off to college.
But here’s the dirty secret: for every dollar of student loan money the government makes available, university tuition goes up by 60 cents!
Colleges and universities don’t see college loans as a problem; they see a gravy train.
Most college administrators may be cowards ready to cave before every politically correct fad, but they’re not dumb. If the government is going to loan you money to go to college, they can raise tuition virtually at will. You can afford it; just borrow more.
And what do the universities do with all that tuition money? Build more buildings. Hire more administrators. Hey, somebody has to pay for all those Diversity, Equity and Inclusion officers, right?
Cui Bono.
Meanwhile, you stagger out of college with a degree and a boat load of debt to pay off, to get the same job and salary that a decade ago didn’t require a bachelor’s. What great way to start your adult life!
If you fit that profile, you’re very likely to favor student loan forgiveness. Who can blame you? With a simple stroke of a pen, some or all your debt goes away like it was never there. And, the least you can do, in return, is vote for the politicians who made it possible. At least that’s how the politicians see it.
Cui Bono.
But who’s going to pay for your good fortune? The taxpayers, course.
The most modest debt relief proposal out there now—$10,000 per borrower—would cost $300 billion. To wipe it all out? $1.8 trillion.
And a lot of those taxpayers will be working class people who didn’t go to college—in many cases because they didn’t want to take on all the debt. That’s why despite easy student loan access from the government, people in the lower and middle classes make up a smaller percentage of college students than they did 50 years ago.
The reality is that loan forgiveness would overwhelmingly benefit the already well-off.
It’s projected that for every dollar of debt cancellation that would go to the lower middle class and impoverished student loan holders, seven times that would go to the top 20% of earners—the lawyers, accountants, and doctors who borrowed heavily for their degrees.
This group also includes the people who staff government bureaucracies, corporate HR departments, and school administrations—the people chiefly responsible for the woke mini-revolutions upending institution after institution. For this managerial class, student loan forgiveness would be great.
But is it fair?
Cui Bono.
For the full script, visit: https://www.prageru.com/video/the-student-loan-forgiveness-scam
it's hard to imagine how we could screw
up higher education any more than we
already have but we're about to if we
make student loan forgiveness a reality
there's a latin phrase that helps
explain why
the phrase is qui bono who benefits in
the case of student loan forgiveness
it's first and foremost the colleges and
universities who can charge outrageous
tuition largely paid for by student
loans
second politicians who make cheap
promises of debt forgiveness to win
votes
and third students from upper middle
class families who would get taxpayers
to pay off their student debt who
doesn't benefit
everyone else
that includes those who didn't go to
college and a new class of suckers
people who went to college and paid off
their student loans
student loan forgiveness is a reverse
robin hood it takes from the poor and
gives to the rich
the most obvious argument against
forgiving student debt is that no one
forced anybody to borrow money for
college why then should others be forced
to pay it off
before you think i'm gonna go all tough
love on you let me say i have a lot of
sympathy for young people who have dug
themselves into the student debt hole
i'm one of them
for decades our society has made the
claim that you need a college degree to
get ahead in life and the smart bet was
to take out any amount of loans to
ensure a bright future
and if you need help with the tuition
uncle sam the us government stands at
the ready with his generous student loan
programs
just fill out a few forms and presto
there's a check in your mailbox you're
off to college
but here's the dirty secret
for every dollar of student loan money
the government makes available
university tuition goes up by 60 cents
colleges and universities don't see
college loans as a problem they see a
gravy train
most college administrators may be
cowards ready to cave before every
politically correct fad but they're not
dumb
if the government is going to loan you
money to go to college they can raise
tuition virtually it will
you can afford it just borrow more
and what do the universities do with all
that tuition money
build more buildings hire more
administrators hey somebody has to pay
for all those diversity equity and
inclusion officers right qui bono
meanwhile you stagger out of college
with a degree and a boatload of debt to
pay off to get the same job and salary
that a decade ago didn't require a
bachelor's what a great way to start off
your adult life
if you fit that profile you're very
likely to favor student loan forgiveness
and who can blame you
with a simple stroke of a pen some or
all of your debt goes away like it was
never there
and the least you can do in return is
vote for the politicians who made it
possible at least that's how the
politicians see it
qui bono
but who's going to pay for your good
fortune
the taxpayers of course the most modest
debt relief proposal out there right now
10 000 per borrower would cost 300
billion to wipe it all out 1.8 trillion
and a lot of those taxpayers will be
working class people who didn't go to
college in many cases because they
didn't want to take on all the debt
that's why despite easy student loan
access from the government people in the
lower and middle classes make up a
smaller percentage of college students
than they did 50 years ago
the reality is that loan forgiveness
would overwhelmingly benefit the already
well-off
it's projected that for every dollar of
debt cancellation that would go to the
lower middle class and impoverish
student loan holders seven times that
would go to the top 20 percent of
earners the lawyers accountants and
doctors who borrowed heavily for their
degrees
this group also includes the people who
staff government bureaucracies corporate
hr departments and school
administrations the people chiefly
responsible for the woke many
revolutions upending institution after
institution
for this managerial class student loan
forgiveness would be great
but is it fair
cui bono
student debt is a real problem and it
requires some real solutions
but blanket loan forgiveness makes
everything worse and rewards exactly
those actors who have had such a large
hand in creating the crisis
especially the opportunistic
universities and politicians
instead we should focus on three common
sense reforms
one
reduce college tuition and availability
of student loan funds going forward we
have to break the vicious cycle of ever
increasing tuition and ever increasing
government loans to pay for it
two
we should target limited relief to lower
and middle class americans who have been
sold a bill of goods about the value of
an expensive university degree
not the lawyers accountants and
bureaucrats who have already benefited
from the system
three
relief should come from rich
universities not middle class taxpayers
yale for example has a 42 billion dollar
endowment
universities have taken advantage of the
problem and it's time for them to
contribute to the solution
cui bono
i mean stetman senior policy analyst at
independent women's forum for prager
university
thank you for watching this video to
keep prageru videos free please consider
making a tax deductible donation
you