Yet again, predictive computer models fail to predict. The coronavirus variance from region to region appears to contradict those models—and the quarantine and lockdown strategies recommended by experts do as well. What to make of it all? Dennis offers his thoughts.
0:00 Stuffed Version Of Your Dog? 1:06 What “The Economy” Actually Means 3:24 Experts Influencing Policy 5:37 Knowledge Vs. Wisdom 7:41 Good Intentions Without Wisdom 8:51 Lockdown Affecting The World 11:08 Are Fewer Deaths Due To Lockdown? 14:06 Otto Interruption 14:35 What About Florida? 16:25 Terrible Prices Being Paid 18:24 Why Do We Raise The Speed Limit? 19:08 Approach To Stimulus Checks 21:09 Debt Due To Government Help 23:50 Prayer: God Is Not Our Butler 26:23 Success And Character 27:50 Bigger Government, Smaller Citizen 30:17 Dog Chaos Builds, See You Next Week
Hi everybody, i'm dennis prager. This is the fireside chat the fireside the chat
The dog auto auto is excited tonight, and I don't know exactly why
um
No, I really don't know exactly why
You're really uh full of life today auto
That's the man
He's very popular auto for good reason. By the way, somebody sent me a
An ad some company put out where they will make a stuffed version of your dog
It was a debate between my wife and me as
As to whether or not
One would want that
She thought it was a lot of fun and cute and I thought
I don't know. It's sort of like demeans auto
I mean would I would I like
a stuffed example of me
Or one of my kids
But I don't want to anthropomorphize animals. So maybe it's fine. It was just an interesting thought
Anyway, great to be with you in this difficult time of the lockdown on much of the earth
It's uh, it's hurting some people horribly and that drives me crazy
Because i'm not sure that this was necessary
and
My column this week, which I really I don't normally make reference to but I hope you will read
It's titled
Is this?
Uh has the lockdown worked
Hmm, I guess yeah
I guess it could have been called as the lockdown necessary
But has the lockdown worked and uh, there's no there's no perfect way to know you'd have to ask some omniscient god
the omniscient god
Uh, you know has it worked?
We were told that millions would die just in the united states alone half a million in britain for example
And was on the basis of that
That the entire economy has been ruined
But and you know when you say the economy has been ruined
It sounds cold like oh economy versus lives. Hey, come on. Give me a break
But i'm not thinking economy. I'm thinking of the devastation in people's lives. My life is not being devastated
Economically, I i'm i'm losing money, but I but i'm in a wonderful position
And I don't mean losing money in stocks. I am not an investor
Just an income. I I speak a great deal around the world and it's a it's a
Factor in my life to be honest with you
But it's it's okay. I make a living
There are people who don't make a living
That's what economy means people who don't make a living
People stuck in homes with an abusive person in the in their midst
people who will commit suicide because of the
the economic devastation
We have food lines in america for the first time since the great depression in the 1920s
That's that's what i'm talking about here
That's what when you say the economy
We're not talking about how companies are doing and by the way companies matter because companies hire people
That's
The left has this bizarre notion. Oh company schmupany company who else hires people governments, I guess they would like that
but the
Where does the government get the money from it gets it from the income taxes that companies and individuals pay?
So, uh, I don't know if it if it's been necessary and I will read to you some data
In a moment, but that brings me to the the the opening before I take your questions
And it's about experts and I I had said I think on a previous one
Right. Was it on a fireside chat or my radio show that I had mentioned that?
Science has replaced religion as the religion and so experts are the clergy as it were
Whereas you had priests and ministers
uh in in religion, you now have the priests and ministers of
Science are the experts or scientists
Let me let me tell you I want to talk about experts just for a moment
Uh, this is this this this I've said this all of my life. This is this is completely not new
I've written it. I have said it. Uh
The notion that we look to experts for policy as opposed to for their expertise
If I want to know
Uh what my if I if I had
God forbid if if I or a loved one had cancer
Clearly, I would go to an oncologist
Because an oncologist a cancer doctor
knows
cancer
Clearly I want
uh their uh
Their knowledge, how could I combat cancer without an oncologist? I understand that
But how much money society should pay
uh for
Oncology research is not decided by oncologists
That is decided by society
The the notion that an expert
Has wisdom as opposed to knowledge
is silly
uh, the the best example one of the best examples is
Scientists made the atom bomb
Not not lay people scientists
You had to have a scientist have that the knowledge of how to split the atom and so on
and create, uh, what is it fusion, I believe
and
Clearly scientists made the the atom bomb
But it was not scientists who decided on whether it should be dropped on japan to end world war ii
That was decided by the president of the united states who had no science background
His background was in politics and before that
uh
Running a retail store in in missouri
because we understand that
Knowledge and wisdom are not necessarily related at all. I'll give you another example
And I know I know this is so long ago that I I know how long i've been saying this
I remember an ad in the new york times many years ago
Um something like I don't know 100 nobel prize winners
Come out against capital punishment for murder
And I remember saying on the radio and this is a long time ago
Why do I care?
What a nobel prize winner and let's say chemistry
Thinks about capital punishment
It's a non-sequitur. It's it's it's it's truly silly. You might as well have 100 football players
Come out for capital punishment
you would say
Well, that's ridiculous
What a football players have to do with capital punishment what a nobel prize winners have to do with capital punishment
The issue is a wisdom issue not not a an expertise issue
so
This this is a terrible problem in an age. It doesn't value wisdom
it only values knowledge and so
Wisdom is everything wisdom is everything
There are people who never went to high school let alone got a p never got a phd who have a lot of wisdom
My grandparents never went to high school
They had a lot of wisdom
They understood life that by the way is a direct result of the death of religion in the west
And in other parts of the world for that matter, but i'll speak about the west
because
religion gives wisdom
Not that every religious person is wise of course not they're a dumb foolish religious people
but but
overwhelmingly
We got our wisdom
from religion
Get our knowledge from secular sources
That's correct. That's why I don't look for scientific knowledge to the bible
That's not what it's there for it's there to give me wisdom
But wisdom is the key to a good world
Good intentions without wisdom lead to bad things lead to evil
That's why there there are so many fools at the universities in the western world
Because they have knowledge and no wisdom
So I am I am only impressed with experts expertise
But uh, so whether or not to bring it to the current moment
Whether or not to shut down society and put tens of millions
Just in america alone out of work
And a billion people in the world at least a billion
Having no income whatsoever
I remember reading an article early on in this lockdown of a poor guy in bangladesh who produces jeans
For american companies the man has no income. He he can't feed his family now
And bangladesh doesn't exactly have a lot of wealth so that they could give this guy three months income to sustain him
when you close down
America or england or france or germany you're closing down bangladesh and india and vietnam as well
It's a that's not a decision. I I want an epidemiologist to make
Or or or a or a biologist
Or a medical doctor that's that's not their province
That's why this this should not be made. But but uh, this whole decision should not be made by them
But politicians and the media they they worship
experts experts
So as soon as the imperial college london announced, oh 2.2 million deaths in america half a million in the united kingdom
Then immediately, uh, they went into lockdown
Uh boris johnson in in in the uk did not want to lock down, uh the uk
That report so scared him
Half a million brits is a lot of there's a lot of brits
That he uh, he closed down the society
and then they immediately changed, uh,
Like a week later or so they changed it to uh,
To a hundred thousand and then to twenty thousand and then they said oh it's because of the lockdown
How do you know it's because of the lockdown?
How do you know
So i'm gonna i'm gonna read you something
I normally don't read you anything because I just talk to you from my heart and my brain
But I I have to because I want to get it right. So this is from my column again. I really hope you read
Uh has the lockdown worked?
So listen to this there was an article in the los angeles times just this past week
This was the title of the article
california's
Coronavirus death toll is way below new york's
Here's why
Okay
Well, that's interesting. Why is california's is way below and california's the most populous state
Plus california got an immense number more
Many more people from china where the virus started than new york did so you would think california
with gigantic cities like new york, I
la
Obviously the most obvious san diego san francisco
It should have been a lot of a lot of coronavirus deaths in california, but very few
So they say here's why that's the article
So they they uh report a man named nicholas jewell
identified as a university of california berkeley
Biostatistician
Explained why california had so many fewer deaths than new york quote
Just putting those control in controls in place
a single day earlier
Makes a huge huge difference in the growth rates
jewel said referring to california governor gavin newsom's
Lockdown order of of march 19th
Okay
Whereas the governor of new york andrew cuomo?
Waited three more days
So according to this biostatistician at the university of california berkeley those three days made all the difference in the world
That's why there are so many more deaths in new york
Than there are in california
So I thought look
Am I a biostatistician? No
so
You would think most readers including the people who wrote the article go. Oh, gee that makes sense
But now listen to this
So then they go on to write
The article added a line that undermined the whole thesis of the article quote
florida governor ron desantis
Didn't impose a stay-at-home order until april 1st
Apparently it never occurred to the los angeles times authors
to even look up florida's death rates
The non-conservative media have been largely worthless during this crisis
Intellectually vapid. This is what i'm writing
And along with experts the primary stokers of panic. What's the matter? Mr. Otto?
You know what? Sometimes he's troubled by talk of the coronavirus. I keep telling him he's not a candidate
Megan are you going to try to put it back in his bed? Okay. He's a bulldog
If he goes back to his bed, I will be a very impressed guy
He did well done i'm shocked
All's good. Otto all's all's well that ends. Well, okay
So listen to this. This is really important
If a few days later for california saved all these lives compared a few days later, excuse me
In new york the lockdown a few days later
Is why so many more new yorkers have died than californians
then
What about days later in florida florida should have even more deaths than new york, correct?
If a few days delay in ordering the lockdown of a state makes a quote huge huge difference unquote in death rates
Florida should have had a worse death rate than new york
Let alone california
Yet florida's death rate is among the lowest in the united states
Despite the fact that it has the largest
Percentage of elderly people
As in any state except for maine
so isn't that a fairly a powerful argument that
Maybe the lockdown isn't the reason that
The deaths aren't reaching so high and are in fact going down
Maybe it's not the lockdown
So on the basis of modeling that was the whole basis computer models
Lives have been destroyed
Millions have been if not destroyed horribly hurt
On the basis of these models, maybe they're right, but the evidence doesn't prove it
That's what I mean by
panic
And why I felt from the beginning that we we had more hysteria than anything else and I would like to remind you all
as I do constantly
The regular flu kills between 30 and 70 000 a year
As of this moment in the united states, it's 20 000 from the coronavirus
Even if it were 50 000
If it were 80 000 100 000
I mean, obviously there's a certain point where you have to say look the the death rate is so the death numbers are so high
We have no choice
But those are not the numbers
So then you get people writing this this
Almost heartless stuff. Oh, so what are you saying?
That it's uh stocks are more important than lives. It has nothing to do with stocks nothing
It has to do with people's jobs livelihood being stuck in a home with an abusive person
I'll bet you the divorce rate goes up as a result of this just among other things
There are terrible prices being paid
God, I think because I I I always eat out. I just love to
Not at fancy places. I just like eating out. I did a lot of the writing of all my books and restaurants
and and I you know, I think of
The number of people employed by restaurants in the united states and all over the west
the guys in the kitchen or the the women and the guys at the tables the
The person who checks you in the person who does the tables? I mean, it's just
The dishwashers
They're not employed now
What are they doing?
so the the the issue isn't you don't care about the debt if if
I mean theoretically then we should why don't we shut down the country every year for the for the flu?
And I always asked another question
If if the only criterion is how many lives will be uh taken
We should never raise the speed limit every time we raise the speed limit
We know that thousands more people will die
Yet we are willing to raise the speed limit because we don't ask will more people die
We ask what is better for society. Of course, there are prices paid
If we wanted to abolish all all deaths on the highway, we would abolish the automobile
But a lot of terrible things would happen if we abolish the automobile
Okay, I hope that that makes some of that more clear
time for your questions
Okay, here we go
Hey dennis. I'm hip from the netherlands. I'm a member of the prego force team
And I would like to know that
Uh, how do you think the stimulus packages in europe compared to the us like here in the netherlands people?
stimulus packages
Are 90 of the wages
Uh and in denmark people are getting paid 75 of the wages
How do you think that compares to the us where people are only getting a singular?
stimulus package of
1200 and um that may
Take some time till they get that. Do you do you think tron's approach is uh, the correct one or do you think the europe?
European approach is better
Well, thank you dunk you as you would say in uh in the netherlands
That was uh, that was a good one
Great to hear from you
Actually, uh a few answers to that
I actually do prefer the european approach, but it wasn't trump's approach
It was congress trump. It's not a matter of trump's desire in these matters. It's it's congress in the united states that
Passes these budgetary matters. I think it was a haphazard thing that was made up
Uh in sort of haste not sort of in haste
Uh, I prefer the idea. I wish I wish this in in general. I wish employers were given the following
Here is the here is the wages or or a percentage of the wages that you would pay
You do not have to pay
Uh your mortgage or or your rent
for your business
The landlord does not have to pay the mortgage to the bank. It's as if these two months never existed
So you won't have those expenses and we will cover the expenses to your employees
I think that would have been ultimately a better thing. However, I want to say something that is true for europe and the united states
Your generation which and this i've said well before this your generation is being given such a massive debt
No generation in history has been given the national debts
That your generation is being given
Uh by uh, the my generation
Uh, at least by the the liberals and progressives and leftists of my generation
Who have believed that the government should take over more and more of life?
Pay more and more money out to more and more people
And where are they going to get the money if there isn't uh, if there if the taxes don't bring that money in
Where is the money going to come in?
Where is it going to come from?
This notion that the government should take care of people
Sounds beautiful
Until you ask the question margaret thatcher the great british leader asks
Who is going to pay for it?
socialism works
Till you run out of people paying for it
Socialism takes other people's money to pay for its programs
Socialism has never raised a nickel. That's american terms for five cents has never raised a pound a peso
A euro whatever currency you might use
Governments don't make money
individuals and and individual companies make money then they give to the government of
What they have made and that's how the government has the money to do what it needs to do
We're going to run out of money. So, you know what the united states is doing. It's printing money
It's printed just printed another I guess two trillion dollars to pay for this
And they're going to do another trillion probably
printing money
That means money becomes worthless
You might as well use a monopoly money. We'll just declare monopoly money is now real money
Somebody's going to pay it down the road or there's going to be terrible social chaos
So, oh, let's let's have everything free college free health care free
Give people a basic wage. Where does that money come from?
You either print it or you take it from people who are making money. There's no third possibility
That's called a responsible question
And responsible questions need responsible answers not irresponsible answers
So I ask again who's going to pay all this
all this debt
Okie doke next question
Benjamin 20 years old gainesville, florida. Greetings. Mr. Prager
What are your thoughts on prayer? Do you think god answers prayers regardless of whether or not he does?
Do you think it is worth praying to god?
So to answer the last part, yes, I do think it's it's very good to pray
Of course it is
it it it
It puts you in communion with with the ultimate reality of the universe or if you will our father in heaven
Which I do believe I think it's a great thing
But I uh, but I about god answering prayers
If answering prayers mean does god do what I would like god to do?
uh, the answer is
Not not usually
Uh, I must admit in my whole life I have asked god for something twice
uh, it was a very very, um, once I was a kid
And I I prayed to god that my mother wouldn't yell at me for breaking the expensive vase in the living room
I was about 10 11 years old
Amazingly, she didn't yell at me and I I don't know why I didn't conclude. Hey prayer works
But I didn't make that conclusion
But I did I was I'll never forget. I was so scared of getting really yelled. That was a very expensive vase. I remembered well
It's from italy
Uh, and I I did then prayed one more time about uh, 50 years later
And that also was answered as it happens
But I still don't I I don't ask god other than those. I never ask god for anything except for others
And uh, that's not my question
My question is not what what do I want from god? I I am consumed with what does god want from me?
That's what I think a
Truly religious person should ask. What does god want from me?
Not what do I want from god? I don't like religious people for whom god is a celestial butler
our butler in heaven
Please deliver the following
But but I I still I do think people should pray
And and if something terrible exists and your child has cancer
I think it's perfectly appropriate to say god
If it's possible and it's it you
If you could bring some miracle here, I don't you know, you're you're opening your heart to god. That's fine
Okay
17 year old georgia. I don't have the name. So is it georgia us or is it georgia a person?
No
Georgia us 17 year old. Can you please do a fireside chat?
Um, the ridiculous idea society is pushing that success and performance is the most important thing in life
When in fact it should be character and doing what is right what god wants from you how ironic it's what I just said
Also god bless you and pray to you for all you have done
You're doing an amazing job teaching people the truth about politics and so many other issues. Thank you
Thank you very much. That's what we're trying to do
uh
I have done
On fireside chats. I have done this
And and i've written a column on this or at least one column
I i'm the one that came up with this idea
I'm sure i'm not the only one but I you know, if if an adult asks your kid
Hey, so, what do you want to be when you grow up? You should teach your kid to say a good person
not an astronaut
Not a lawyer. Not a doctor. Not an engineer
A good person see how they react to that
That's I told my kids. I didn't care what they did for a living. I didn't even care if they went to college
I only cared that they were good people
That that's what I told them
I since I have two boys good men
Okay, eric 15 budapest hungary. Good day. Mr. Prager
Eric, I showed one of your fireside chats to one of my teachers in which you stated quote
The bigger the government the less free you are
He then stated that he thinks that you think
that therefore quote cooperation
Allows people to be free
He would like to ask if you believe that cooperation would provide people with freedom. Thank you
Can you give auto a rub for me? I rub him plenty and I will
so
Uh, I don't quite get your teacher's response. Yes, the bigger the government the less free you are
This is a perfect example. The government is controlling people in the state of michigan right now
You if if you have a second home
Uh, even you know a little place by a lake
Uh, you you can't drive there because the governor of michigan
Is so controlling over people's behavior at this time. You can't even get in your car
Drive somewhere
Otto is now shaking
the uh the light fixture
This is what happens. Uh when uh, when auto is not asleep
This is rare though. This is really rare. Yeah. I don't know. What's what's agitating him
Then he's he's looking around he maybe he wants to read a book
You know so many books in the room and you never know what it does for him, but I don't understand your your um
teacher's reaction
That he thinks that I think that cooperation allows people to be free
cooperation
It is not a freedom issue
Uh big government is a freedom issue. People should cooperate, but I don't know where that comes into the issue of freedom
But the bigger the government I have a motto the bigger the government the smaller the citizen
That is correct
The american dream and I think it's good for every country
Was to have small government
And have people take care of themselves take care of their families take care of their communities
The bigger the government the smaller the citizen and the less the freedom. That's exactly right
We are losing that ideal in america because so many young people are taught by people who believe in big government
what's our story on the uh
We pretty much hit the at the time too bad. Got a lot of great questions
Look, these are very important issues who should make decisions for our society this whole issue of experts
Have we done the right thing with the virus?
These are very big deals
Anyway, by the way a reminder I I did uh for prager u I I conducted a passover
seder
and um
Whoa, boy, i'll tell you this is a lot of this
Listen, i'm amazed. This is actually functioning without everything falling
uh
You might enjoy it. Even if you're not a jew you will I think uh, you will find it just a fascinating glimpse into
This famous ritual on passover of the seder
And now snoopy is showing up in otto's bed. This is a live wire evening. I gotta tell you. I feel like a traffic cop
Anyway, it's great to be with you. Take care of yourselves. I'll see you next week
dennis prager on behalf of
otto and snoopy
Bye. Bye
Thank you for watching. If you'd like to keep these fireside chats free, please do by donating to prager you