Fireside Chat Ep. 161 — Lockdowns Hurt More Than They Help | Fireside Chat

PragerU
800 followers
25 Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
There is a cost of locking down the country, just as there is a cost of NOT locking it down. Every decision comes with a price, but in the case of coronavirus, too few are asking—or caring—what that is.
0:00 Otto’s Oblivious To The World
1:42 Be Mature & Ask: What Is The Price?
6:30 We Can’t Only Ask: Will People Die?
8:30 The US & Worldwide Lockdown Price
11:10 “Follow The Science” Is A Lie
13:33 Why Are Leaders So Pro-Lockdown?
17:26 Why Are Most Jews On The Left?
21:55 Small Businesses: Don’t Listen!
25:05 Socialism No Longer Has A Dirty Name
26:31 Who Is Teaching You Wisdom?
Subscribe so you never miss a new Fireside Chat! 👉 https://www.prageru.com/series/fireside-chats/
Hi everybody dennis prager in my home with my dog his name is otto otto
And many of you always include regards to otto and the thought that I should give him a rub good. You're a good man otto
otto
I have to say has not been affected by the tensions in america at this time
He's sort of oblivious. I have to admit and sometimes I envy him
But he has this what me worry attitude to life
And when he snores I get relaxed. I mean i'm pretty relaxed. Anyway, it's a it's my temperament. I am very lucky
Anyway, uh, hello from uh my home the fireside chat is every week I get
to think and express my thoughts to you without
uh any
Footnotes, no not footnotes, uh without any what do they call again when you read off the screen teleprompter no teleprompter. Yeah
So then I take your questions and
I do want to remind you by the way about fireside chat
If you are touched by these
Please know what are we up to about 150 something?
161 this is this is fireside chat 161
Any of them would be beneficial to you to uh to you, I believe
In other words if you find today's beneficial you will find number 103 and number 57
also beneficial
Because I I try to offer thoughts about life, even though it might be about a specific moment in time
So anyway, I want to talk to you about a number of aspects on the lockdown issue
Which I have opposed from the outset
I called the lockdowns the world's biggest mistake
And
uh, that was in march or april
And I was uh condemned and I was ridiculed and I was right
That's the eye me
I'm, not i'm not happy. I was right, but I was right
see
the
Perhaps the most mature question a person could ask
about any decision
And when you think about it, it really is just about any decision
Is what is the cost?
What is the price?
Now i've mentioned this but it's been a while
So if you buy something
The first thing you ask is how much does it cost? What's the price?
So you determine
Is it worth the price of x amount of money?
to get that item
You're you every time you buy something you are weighing the benefit of the item versus the cost of the money
So if the cost is too much
Whatever the benefits you won't buy it you right that that's the way
That's the way all of life works
Give you any number of examples
My favorite because they're so dramatic
Should I get married?
There's a cost to getting married. There's a price in marriage
But there's also a price in not marrying in staying single
Now if you don't know the costs of either
You cannot make a mature intelligent wise decision for yourself
This is these are the costs of marriage. I don't mean financial costs though. That might be
One of the costs and these are the costs of staying single if you don't think if you think getting married
Uh is has no price. You're you're being naive
And if you don't think that single has no price you're being naive
They both have prices. So you have to maturely decide which price do I want? So in getting married?
There is a compromise on your freedom
Obviously you you you can't do whatever you want anytime you want as if you're single
Now if that's the most important thing to you stay single
But if you stay single the price is you don't have a companion through life
Maybe you may say I don't kind of want a companion through life. Okay, so good, but at least know that
uh, there there are uh, there are overwhelming benefits in my opinion to having someone
That is
your friend
To live with your your friend
Usually of the opposite sex that that's a that's a terrific thing
now
I fully acknowledge and i've gone through it. I I as I always say there's nothing better than a good marriage
And there's nothing worse than a bad marriage
People are so afraid though of a bad marriage that they don't get married
But that's like saying i'm afraid of a car crash, so I won't drive
It doesn't make sense to me. You don't live life
Fearing what could happen bad?
Then it's no life
So same with children, what are the benefits of having children?
What are the benefits of not having children? What are the costs of having children?
What are the costs of not having children?
To me, I always opt for what will enrich my life
What will make my life fuller? I don't want to die having not experienced the fullness of life
I felt that when I was 15 and I feel that today
It was a great decision on my part
It entailed pain
There is usually pain
in
In marriage and children there is pain. I have been divorced. I know the pain of that
I wouldn't take anything back
and
uh, I am
Incredibly grateful to have led a full life
because of these decisions
So now we come to the lockdown
What's the cost of a lockdown? What's the cost of not locking down?
That's the only question that is mature and responsible
So we are only told the price of no lockdown more people will die
The number of decisions we make in life for society where more people will die is very large
More people will die when we raise the speed limits, you know that
Thousands of people guaranteed
Guaranteed every year will die
If we raise the speed limit from in america 55 miles per hour to let's say 65 or 65 to 75
And so on
But we still do it. Now. Why is that?
Because saving a life while that's the greatest thing an individual might be able to do
That is not the greatest thing that a government should be able to do a government has much larger questions
Than will anybody die because of this policy?
People die when when a country goes to war
so, uh
You should take the pacifist notion. I'll never fight a war but there's a price to be paid if you don't fight a war
You get conquered
Now you you say so what?
Right, that's a possible option. So what?
Now that was basically gandhi's view
Gandhi was a pacifist told the jews not to fight the nazis
A lot of people don't know it, but you could look it up. It's really remarkable
You'll be a great model to the germans and to the world if you don't fight the nazis
Meanwhile, if they didn't fight the nazis, they got exterminated which is what happened
every, uh, every aspect of the of the lockdown
Revolves around those questions. So i'd like to tell you as I have and i've written some of the costs
The the tens of millions of people and this is just america. I I actually care about the whole world
The vast numbers of people who have lost all of their money
Who have no work?
Do you know what happens to to people when no one in the family can earn money?
Even if they do get money from the government or from some charity
You know why men jumped out of windows during the depression the suicide among men?
Because when you especially for a man
When you remove the ability to provide for a family to a man
You have in effect castrated him. I'm using a very severe
uh
Parable or
Analogy, but that that's really what what what it does
We get a much of our
meaning
from the ability to provide for
a family
That's maybe it's right. Maybe it's wrong
But that's that's a big part of our
self-image
And our identity and our sense of worth
People need a sense of worth
The deprivation of this i'm not talking about the people hundreds of millions in the world according to the un
Uh that are on the brink of starvation because of lockdowns
Remember if if there's no business here, then we're not buying goods from bangladesh
So the the guy or the woman making stuff in bangladesh is now is now impoverished
They they were making a living until the lockdowns in the west
Because the buyers in the west stopped buying what they were making in bangladesh
But the bangladeshi government doesn't have the money to support them. What do they do?
or india
and so many other places
talking about
Irrational lockdowns in africa where there are so few deaths
Unbelievably few they still lock down
And now and now people again are back to the brink of starvation in vast
in vast parts of africa
There was an article in the new york times about truckers in africa
Who who who have have no goods to bring and if they bring the goods?
They have to wait at the border till they get themselves checked for covid
But nobody's dying of covid in any large numbers in africa. It's useless
By the way, none of this is political you may think it's political but it isn't
Because right-wing regimes have also done done. This israel india
britain is conservative
No, the the in the united states. It's political republicans
Uh republican governors do not lock down their states nearly as as quickly
Or as often as as democratic governments
So in america, there is a political and by the way, the one country that didn't have a lockdown
Is not a not a conservative country by any means sweden
Sweden is the proof that lockdowns are are useless
Sweden did not lock down
Their 20th in the world 20th
in the world in per capita deaths
And if the number keeps getting lower, they'll probably be 25th
They never once not one day did they shut schools for kids under 16 years of age at the height of the pandemic in the spring
They were still going to school in sweden almost nobody wears masks in sweden
Why aren't they dying on the streets?
Probably because of herd immunity so many people got it in some way
That they are uh, they're probably now immune as if they got a vaccine
Sweden thank god for sweden. It it provided the world this test
People say well follow the science
No, they don't mean that that's that is a phony
Phrase
They mean follow the scientists we agree with
that's what that
The people who say follow the science are lying to you and to themselves. They don't follow the science
They follow the scientists they agree with
read the great barrington
declaration
Epidemiologists from oxford harvard and stanford universities
headed a group of
A I don't know a thousand. I don't know massive number of people in the sciences who are against lockdowns
It wasn't even reported in the mainstream news on television
Or in print it wasn't even reported
Because the left doesn't agree with the great barrington declaration. They want people to believe all science says
lockdown
You know supports lockdowns by and large people who have their jobs and incomes
For them a lockdown is a lot easier than for the poor guy who invested his whole life's
Savings in his little restaurant in chicago
That guy is it's all lost
I don't know how how he'll recover
Oh, no indoor dining
You can have indoor dining in an airplane. Why can't you have indoor dining in a restaurant?
Nobody's ever answered that one for me
I've been on airplanes quite a few times during this time
I took my mask off
And and dined you can't dine with a mask on
And they weren't eight feet away from me
They were a foot or five inches away from me
People not dying from airplane travel. Why not?
Indoor dining's fine on airplanes. You know, why?
Because the governments think that airlines must survive and they're right
I agree with that
Why doesn't the little guy who owns a restaurant have to survive because the little guy doesn't mean a damn to the left
That's the irony. They speak in their names, but they don't care about them. Anyway, the
The small business owner is probably not a democrat anyway
So what so if he goes out of business, so what there's always the big guys
Who are big contributors to the democratic party?
It's a very sad situation
So we're told don't get together for the holidays I will
Having the same number of people for thanksgiving
As I did last year
And i'll be one of the older ones at the at the gathering
I am more at risk than the younger ones. My daughter-in-law just got covid just yesterday
Spoke to her today on the phone. How are you? I got a sniffle
That's her covid experience
The vast majority of people under 70 that's their covid experience a sniffle
Of course, there are people who die from it under 60
There are people dying car crashes. Nobody's advocating not driving
It's been an immoral thing all over the world. I'll end with one thing
I've been really racking my brain to figure out why our leaders
Right and left. Why are they so pro lockdown?
This is what I think I may be wrong. This is my theory
these people
are are
Are frightened beyond words of going down in history
as under their watch
the following number of their countrymen died
That's what I think it's about
The governor of new york state when he locked down new york state, which was completely immoral
Why was syracuse and buffalo and little towns upstate new york, why were they locked down when all the deaths were in new york city?
It's incredibly immoral thing to do
Anyway, he said at the time
If everything I do saves one life, I will be happy
governor of new york governor cuomo
Really?
If all the people you put out of work
Just saves one life. You'll be happy
These are people who never ask
What is the price?
Okie doke
Question video question. Take it away
Hi there, mr. Prager. My name is verena yusef and i'm a 20 year old egyptian australian currently residing in melbourne, victoria
You recently mentioned that a lot of young jews are leaning towards the left and that's primarily due to the fact that they conflate
Conservatism with nazism
So could you please expand on that and also outline other factors that have contributed to this political conversion? Thank you and god bless
Now is she special or is she special?
An egyptian australian asking me why jews
Conflate conservatism and nazism. I love it. I do love it. You are very impressive. I hope we meet one day
alf shukran
Means a thousand thanks in arabic
But megan knew it. Why am I explaining it to megan? I can't believe it
Megan's married to a filipino. So obviously she would know arabic
of course
Exactly. Oh, by the way, uh in tagalog. It's salamat. Correct. Thank you. Huh? Salamat. Yeah
Uh, okay
Good manner husband
But you have never seen his arm
All right
It's not just young jews reyna. It's uh jews in general
Uh who identify not conservatism as much as just right wing the word right wing
for most jews
Immediately conjures up a swastika in their mind. That's the that's a big part of the issue
hitler was called right wing
The jews believe he is right wing i'm not saying they're wrong i'm not saying they're right i'm just telling you what it is
Hitler was not right wing and hitler was not left wing
Remember nazism stands for national socialism
Most 99 of humanity doesn't know that but that's what nazism means national
socialism
So I just it's just worth noting hitler was uh, hitler was race-based
Race-based is not left-wing or right-wing
It's just sick
and
Uh, anyway, whatever the the issue is the left hated him. So therefore he's called right
All right, so jews bought this
Which is understandable
Not correct, but understandable
And it's not a debate I ever get into was hitler right or left. Okay. Hitler was sui generis
in other words his own unique thing, but
Again, that's beside the point jews identify right wing
with
Antisemitism, it's instinctive this reaction. It is not thought through
and uh
I'll give you my great analogy
imagine your grandfather
Was killed by a hit and run driver
Coming from the right
Right you cross the street coming from the right
a hit and hit and run driver
killed your grandfather
so
Would you when you cross the street only look at the right when you cross the street?
for hit and run drivers
That's what jews have done
They got hit from the right. They only look to the right like they can't get hit from the left
But the the place of most antisemitism today in america and the west is the left
Jeremy corbyn in britain head of the labor party was an antisemite
And the number of antisemites on on the left in the u.s
Dwarfs the number of antisemites on the right the right of the jews best friends right now in almost every country
but
What are you going to do? Most people do not think in life. Most people react. They don't think things through
It doesn't shock me. I never had a high view of humanity. I have a high view of humans
There are wonderful spectacular humans in this world
Humanity is unimpressive
And that's the way it is. It's completely unthought through
But that's the reason
All right
Let's go to more of your questions
How are we doing on time?
Great sam 12 years old stillwater minnesota. Hi dennis. Hi sam
I was wondering if the left will shut down the country again and make the small businesses fail
And what we should do to stop it
P.s. I saw you at the minnesota state fair as a baby
And got a picture. It was great
Is that awesome?
So sam is 12 now. So this was you know, like 11 years ago
That's great
We should get another picture, but I am not returning to the minnesota state fair. I am minnesota state fared out
That is about as hot
An environment as you can enter
Without being hospitalized the minnesota state fair in august
Anyway, uh, I I love visiting minnesota probably been there two dozen times
But uh, that is adorable that there's a picture of you and me
in
When you were a baby
That's sweet
So the question is what could we do about it?
About the small businesses failing what should we do to stop it?
Don't listen to the governors. They have no right to tell you you can't make an income none
They are tyrants. I don't but you see we accept the tyranny because it's not in the name of health
Every nation has accepted
Tyranny every nation that has had tyrants has accepted tyranny in the name of something terrific
Or something they believed in the current god is health
So in the for the god of health we can ruin tens of millions of lives
We could have more people go on drugs more people become alcoholic more
Addicts who were recovering regress and go back to drinking or go back to drugs or go back to gambling
Or go back to whatever their addiction was that's okay
Because it's all done in the name of health
Safety as if it's called
So don't listen
This is to disturb me greatly about the american people
I had a I I had not only an affection for
But a belief that they this was a people that really loved liberty
And I turned out to be wrong the left has done its damage
Americans loved liberty until the last two generations
In the 1968 69 there was a huge
epidemic the hong kong flu
Took the equivalent of 165 000 american lives
Nothing closed down nothing
Not one store not one business not one restaurant not one school
It's a different america today because the left has been able to raise two more generations
Through the media and through academia
Stan 28 cherry hill new jersey been to cherry hill a number of times right outside of philadelphia
Do you think the people supporting socialism marks and realize there is no way back to freedom once they vote for socialism
They don't think they're voting for socialism and many well, I take that back
Socialism does not have a dirty name now
Because people don't know the people don't know history. You know, you're not taught history at high school or college
I've always said I would just I would like to do
Give a test
to
harvard
students
I don't even seniors
Identify the gulag archipelago
If you don't know what the gulag archipelago is
That's a very bad sign
I wonder how many know who stalin was i'll bet you almost none know who paul putt was
The communist leader in cambodia who killed a third of his people
or the great leap forward
in china
Which ultimately, uh caused about 60 million 40 to 70 million chinese to starve to death
Deliberately mao sent the food to russia the soviet union to get arms because he wanted to have a great
military power
Yep
David 20 slovenia. I was in slovenia. I had a great time. Hi dennis. This is a short one
How does one acquire wisdom? That is awesome
By the way, the short ones are the toughest
In episode 158 you talk about courage you said something
To the effect to be courageous. You have to want to be courageous. That's exactly what I said
Is it similar with wisdom?
Where to start thank you and can you give a rub to the producer megan otto already gets enough?
That is a very good point. Are you feeling neglected megan?
not really
Not really good, okay, but it was a very thoughtful thing that was very sweet
okay
so
That that's right. Is it dissimilar with wisdom? Yes
The first the first step to becoming wise is wanting to be wise
But if I gave a list of things to high school students, how old are you?
Let's see 20 and 20 year olds if I in 20 year olds in slovenia or or in in new jersey
If I gave a a list, what do you most want to be?
And wise was one of them
I have a feeling famous would beat it out smart would beat it out
Successful would beat it out happy would beat it out
uh
Rich would beat it out
Good looking would beat it out
Wise nobody thinks about it
I thought about it because a I admit I have an innate i've always had an innate desire to get wisdom
But the other is I studied in a religious school. That's the beauty of religious schools
That you they teach you wisdom
There's no wisdom taught in schools today
That that's the whole point. That's the difference between secular education and religious education
You may get a better education in trigonometry in a secular school, but you'll get more wisdom in a religious school
In a good religious school, obviously, there are probably lousy religious schools
But that's what I got
and
The fact that you want to be wise
That's it. That's beautiful. That really is half the issue
Then you then you search for meaning and for wisdom
And one way of getting wisdom is to always ask the question what is the price paid for x
Big government is another perfect example of what I was talking about at the outset
The advantages of big government takes care of more people
The disadvantage of big government takes care of more people
the advantage the price
And the advantage are the identical thing
Like the problem there's a big problem when the government takes care of more people. You don't
If the government takes care of me my family in my community, then I don't take care of me my my
Family in my community, correct
That's why americans give more charity than europeans
Because americans have been raised to we take care of each other europeans have been raised the government takes care of us
That's why american conservatives give more charity than liberals
Because they and devote more time to volunteering
Because they're not going to wait for the government to do it
The more people get used to the government taking care of others. They stop taking care of others
See my speech on on the internet at the university of wyoming
How socialism makes you selfish?
Good luck there
David in slovenia. What's our timing?
On the nose
I have more great questions, but I don't have more great time
Anyway, my thought is it is better to leave you wanting more
Than not or as i've always as I always say at speeches
From the beginning of my speaking career. I believed it is better for the speaker to leave before the audience does
That's with that
Not terribly profound thought
Thank you for being with me
I'm, dennis prager. This is the fireside chat and I will see you next week
Thank you for watching this video to help keep prager you videos free
Please consider making a tax-deductible donation
