Should you lie to your kids about Santa? And why not just say Happy Holidays? Is the commercialization of Christmas really that bad? 🎄 Dennis Prager discusses this and more in this special Christmas episode of Fireside Chat! 😄 Enjoy.
0:00 Christmas Is An Important Holiday 1:12 PragerU Hit 3 Billion Views! 1:50 We Are Not On A Set 2:30 Should Parents Lie About Santa? 6:47 Santa Doesn’t Take Away From Christ 9:25 Why Is Christmas Not Inclusive? 10:57 Christmas Is A National Holiday 12:28 Stop Being A Narcissist 14:06 Fewer Decorations Is A Tragedy 14:54 Commercialization Of Christmas 16:59 What Is The Alternative To Gift Giving? 18:26 Dennis’s Favorite Christmas Call 19:59 Should Politics Take A Backseat? 20:45 Leave A Cigar And Scotch For Dennis? 21:48 “Baby, It’s Cold Outside” 23:22 Many Christmas Songs Written By Jews 25:10 Is It Okay To Regift? 46:44 Kwanzaa Isn’t An African Holiday 27:54 Favorite Christmas Movie 28:17 The Most Beautiful Time Of The Year
I think you would look cute with those antlers on.
I would?
She's flipped out.
She is truly flipped out.
You can take them off right away.
You can say, today I identify as a reindeer.
Okay, then I'm going to get the trans community upset.
Trans reindeer community.
Let's see.
Okay, and that goes on auto?
Yes.
Okay.
All right.
Ready?
Yep.
Ready.
Okay, everybody.
Welcome to the fireside chat.
Clearly, it is a holiday chat.
Is auto okay with it?
It already fell off.
They convinced me to do this, to show up with antlers.
And you know what?
I'm okay with it.
I'm going to talk to you about Christmas, by the way.
I have a lot of things to say about it.
And it added credibility because I'm Jewish and Hanukkah is my holiday.
But Christmas is a very important holiday, even if you're not Christian.
Which is what I want to talk to you about.
First news.
Da-da-da-da-da-da.
PragerU hit 3 billion views.
By the way, if they see this, it may end PragerU.
It may no longer be taken seriously since Prager himself is wearing reindeer antlers.
But I pretty much do what Megan asked me to do.
Are you the producer of the fireside chat?
You certainly are.
I have to say that.
Okay, so did you all see me?
Can I take it off?
Okay.
Anyway, the fireside chat, every week, it is I, Dennis Prager, at my home.
Do you know that people ask, is this a set?
How do I prove it's not a set?
Anyway, it's pretty elaborate for a set.
It's my home, I promise.
What would I do, bring my dog to the set?
Anyway, I guess people would.
No, no, this is really, this is where I do most of my work.
So anyway, from my home to yours, whatever you're celebrating,
Happy Hanukkah or Merry Christmas,
and anything else that you might be celebrating,
and certainly, everybody, Happy New Year.
But I really want to talk to you about this,
and there's an opening question, as we have every week.
So let's go to it.
Our opening question.
And you can all send them in,
and hopefully we'll choose yours.
Okay, here we go.
Hi, my name is Micah Hart.
I'm a Prager Force member.
I live in Rhode Island, but I attend school in Massachusetts
at White and Christian School.
I am 17 years old, and I'm a junior.
My question is, what do you think about parents lying
to their children about Santa Claus?
All right, that's a big one.
I have done shows about that, about that whole issue.
Let me get back to, here we go.
All right, so parents lying to their kids about Santa Claus.
The word lying is a loaded word here.
You're lying if a kid says to you,
your kid says to you, Mom or Dad,
is there really a Santa Claus?
And you say, yes, there really is a Santa Claus
who lives in the North Pole, et cetera, et cetera.
Okay, that is, in effect, telling your kid something
that isn't true.
By the time your kid is going to ask that question,
you can level with your kid.
But why would anybody feel odd about allowing their child
this fantasy world?
If you read your kid a book, a fairy tale, any fair,
Pinocchio, do you tell your kid first,
you know, there really wasn't a Pinocchio?
Right?
You let your child live the fairy tale.
It's a lovely, innocent part of childhood.
Why clobber their innocence when it's unnecessary?
That's the way I look at it.
Who did it ever hurt to have a belief that Santa Claus,
anyway, it's got a moral message, right?
He knows if you've been good, right?
Isn't that the way the song goes?
He knows if you've been bad or good.
That's right.
Which song is that?
Yes, Be Good for Goodness' Sake.
And it's really, to me, a sort of a sign of the time
in which we live that people don't want their child
to believe at five years of age that there's
a Santa Claus, but they do want their child to believe
that they have no future because they will be drowning
in hot seas because of global warming.
That they really want their child at five to believe,
but not that there's a Santa Claus.
It's sick.
We live in an upside-down world.
We don't protect children anymore.
It's like parents' job is no longer to protect children.
It's to ruin their innocence.
It's a beautiful tradition.
What is the big deal?
Well, I obviously have passion on the subject.
And ironically, in my home, there wasn't a Santa Claus.
I grew up in a very religious Jewish home,
which didn't have any feature of Christmas in it
except the music.
Everybody loved the music.
I still love the music.
It's my favorite time of year, actually.
And I'll come to that momentarily.
But for those who have Santa Claus in their home,
what's wrong with it?
I'm curious.
Some parents have, what is it, the tooth fairy?
The kid loses a tooth, and they put a dollar under the pillow.
When I was a kid, it was a quarter.
Inflation.
And, you know, oh, there really is no tooth fairy.
Well, how did I get into the world?
Well, of course, when sperm meets egg,
through the act of intercourse,
do you tell your six-year-old that,
your five-year-old that?
Or do you just say things that are not exactly accurate?
Isn't protecting a child's innocence a good thing,
and to let them enjoy this?
By the way, the objections come from all over,
because I've done this on my radio show so often,
and I've heard from people who have objections.
It not only comes from people who are hyper-enlightened,
it comes from a number of religious people.
There are Christians who call my show,
say, you know, Christmas is supposed to be only about Christ.
Why?
For a Christian, of course, it's about Christ,
but why only about Christ?
Why does Santa take away?
By the way, here's a little secret for all of you
who want to raise religious kids, as I have wanted,
and hopefully did.
The more enjoyable you can make the religion,
along with all the seriousness,
the better chance you have that the child will keep it alive.
There's an emotional aspect to religion,
not just an intellectual or theological one.
So it's a very healthy thing to have your child love Christmas,
if you're a Christian,
and love Christmas even if you're not a Christian,
which I will get to.
So obviously, it is a non-issue to me.
I don't want you to lie to your child
if your child's asking a black-and-white question.
But by the time they ask that question,
anyway, even parents have told me,
they said to their kids,
well, there is a Santa in the way of we believe
that it is a beautiful thing to be generous on Christmas
and to bring people gifts.
They've answered it that way.
You can answer it in any number of ways.
But I will admit, it's a strange family
where somebody at 30 years of age will say,
you know, I've never been able to recover.
My parents faking me about Santa Claus.
If you think that way, I don't know how to put this,
but you should seek counseling.
I want to put it as gently as I can.
If that's the biggest trauma in your life,
that your parents told you there was a Santa,
you've got a great life, let me tell you.
All right, does that answer our Rhode Island
in Massachusetts Christian young man?
Okie dokie, good.
Enjoy life, folks, and enjoy religion.
Santa helps it.
All right, now let me tell you a couple of words
about Christmas, and I've written this.
You can look it up on the Internet,
anywhere you are in the world.
Dennis Prager, Christmas.
You'll see a lot of articles that I've written on this.
And the tragedy of dropping Christmas.
No longer Merry Christmas, but Happy Holiday.
No longer do schools have Christmas vacations.
They have winter vacations.
No longer do companies have Christmas parties.
They have holiday parties.
I will never forget.
Or no Christmas tree at a school, for example,
because I love this one.
It's not inclusive.
I'm not Christian, but why is it not inclusive?
Why is saying to me Merry Christmas
in any possible way, shape, or form
uninclusive or, God forbid, even worse, insulting?
It's beautiful.
In fact, I'm the guy, I go around,
and I tell everybody Merry Christmas.
They're all saying Happy Holiday
because they're afraid that they'll be just attacked.
The flight attendant or the captain of the airplane,
Happy Holidays.
But as I go, I wish people Merry Christmas.
And then they look around and they go, Merry Christmas.
It's like there's doing, people curse more easily
than they say Merry Christmas in big cities.
I'm not talking about rural Mississippi.
I'm talking about in big cities,
people are afraid almost to say Merry Christmas.
It's really sad.
It's just sad.
It's just another way of getting rid of something joyful.
And by the way, I want to remind Americans,
and I know people watching all over the world,
but I want to remind Americans,
it's a national holiday in the United States,
like July 4th or Veterans Day.
It's a national holiday.
I am an American.
I am a member of the American nation.
So it is therefore my holiday too.
It's not my religious holiday,
but it's my American holiday.
90% of my fellow Americans are celebrating it.
Why would I want to deprive them in my narcissism?
It is narcissistic to be offended
by the words Merry Christmas.
There's something wrong with you.
I mean it.
Here, I'm a Jew, right?
So in Israel, people will say,
on the Jewish New Year Rosh Hashanah,
they will say to everybody in Israel,
remember, a fifth of Israel is not Jewish, it's Muslim,
the Arab population of Israel.
But people say to everybody, Shana Tovah,
Happy New Year.
But what if it's not your New Year?
Is that offensive?
Should they stop saying that?
Right?
Why is that different?
Or Shabbat Shalom, or Happy Sabbath,
Sabbath peace.
It's said on the radio as the Sabbath enters in Israel.
Should they stop that?
Because not everybody listening is Jewish?
But countries have to stop having their national holidays
because some people in the country may not observe that day?
That's incredible.
So there was a law school in Indiana
that decided to get rid of their Christmas tree
in their main building.
And I just thought it was awful.
Their argument was it's not inclusive.
So I had a law professor on, the one who made the argument,
oh, it's not inclusive, we can't have the Christmas tree.
So I had her on, and I said, I don't understand,
why is it not inclusive?
And she said, well, we have Jews at our university and others.
And to her shock, I said, well, I'm a Jew,
and I think you should have a Christmas tree.
I love having Christmas trees in my society.
It's a good thing.
It's a happier place Christmas time,
thanks to Christmas tree and decorations
and Santa clauses and Christmas music.
It's all great.
And this inclusive, this totalitarian inclusiveness,
there's something wrong with you, not society,
if you object to Merry Christmas or a Christmas tree.
You're the problem, not America.
You are a narcissist.
Everything must revolve around you.
It has nothing to do with inclusivity.
It has to do with your hypersensitivity and immaturity.
Am I strong enough on this?
Really, it ticks me off.
My God.
OK, it's a great time of year, and I want to keep it.
The country will be infinitely poorer.
And by the way, it's already poorer.
There's so many fewer homes with decorations
than when I was a kid.
It's really, you almost have to look for them in big cities.
I know there are parts of America where there are still many,
but in urban America, which is a secular America,
as compared to a more rural America, it's a tragedy.
It's such a beautiful thing to see these decorations once a year.
It enhances the life of the society.
OK, take your questions.
They're all about Christmas.
Chosen by Megan,
the very tough producer.
OK, all right, let's see.
Here we go.
Emily 18.
Hi, Emily 18, Avon Park, Florida.
What is my opinion, that's me, on the commercialization
of Christian holidays such as Christmas and Easter?
That's another loaded word, commercialization.
It's like the lying word.
People have understandably adopted the critics' terminology.
How about, not commercialization, how about generosity?
That's the word I would use.
People are buying things for other people for Christmas?
Oh my God, what a terrible thing.
I can't think of anything worse.
People are spending their money to make others happy.
That is really loathsome.
We have to put a stop to that.
What could possibly be wrong?
Can people spend too much?
Everything could be too much.
You could eat too much healthy food.
You could eat too much broccoli.
This doesn't mean anything.
Of course anything could be in excess.
I am with families on Christmas, Christian families,
and I watch them unwrap the gifts.
And it is so beautiful.
It's the beautiful tradition.
That once a year people are thinking,
gee, what could I get my husband or my wife or my parents
or my in-laws or my cousin or my uncle or my aunt or my friend?
What could possibly be wrong with that?
That's commercialization?
Why is that commercialization?
And if it is, what's wrong with that?
Always think whenever, and I'm not directing this to Avon.
Is that her name?
Emily, I'm sorry, Avon Park.
I'm not directing this to you, Emily.
I'm not saying you're saying this.
But anybody who objects to A must always ask,
what's the alternative, and do you like it?
So what is the alternative to people
getting gifts for others on Christmas?
The alternative is people not getting gifts.
Would society be better if nobody
bought anybody a gift on Christmas?
Theoretically, if it's commercialization,
that would be better.
Why is that better?
It drives me crazy.
And by the way, you might as well say
the same thing of Hanukkah.
When I was a kid, my parents got me Hanukkah.
Hanukkah was the best gift of the year.
It was a better gift than on my birthday.
It's when I got my electric train set.
Nobody gets electric train sets now.
Why not?
Isn't that an interesting question?
Why would it?
Here's a better question.
I don't know the answer.
Would a 10-year-old boy, maybe girl,
but I think more boys would like it.
Would a 10-year-old boy like a train set?
I don't know the answer.
But it would be interesting,
what happened to trains?
It's not like people rode trains more then,
but I don't know what happened.
Anyway, I remember that in particular,
that my parents got me this train set.
So, getting gifts, oh, I'll never forget,
this was my, oh God, this was one of my
favorite calls in 37 years of radio.
A woman called me up.
She said, I'm a grandmother,
and Dennis, I don't get my grandchildren gifts.
What I do is, I write a poem for them.
And with great love and gentility,
I said, whatever her name was,
let's call her Ann.
That's a good grandmother name, right?
Ann, let me say this on behalf
of your grandchildren.
They rather get a gift than read your poem.
It was very tough for me to say.
But it's as true as two and two is four.
Personally, I would rather get a gift.
I'd rather get a cigar than a poem.
That may lower me in your view.
I understand that.
You might think, oh, Dennis Prager,
he would much rather get a poem.
No, I'd rather get a cigar.
I admit it, can't smoke a poem.
I mean, let's be honest.
All right, that was a little cute, okay.
It's very sweet if you write
your grandchild a poem,
but not in lieu of a gift.
All right, all right, thank you.
So get gifts, it's very nice.
Reagan 15 in Bristow, Virginia.
Should politics take a backseat
for the holidays, or should it
always be a priority?
Definitely a backseat, absolutely.
Get together for the holidays
and enjoy each other.
You can yell at each other about
politics the rest of the year,
but for the holiday, please,
just have peace in the house.
Don't talk politics if you're
going to just yell at each other.
I'm serious.
I have very strong views on
these matters, but I have relatives
who don't agree with me at all.
But when I get together with them,
we don't argue politics.
What's the point?
Family is family, and friends
are friends, and you just enjoy
each other. So the holidays
should take priority.
Robert, 20 years old, San Antonio,
Texas. Kids leave milk and
cookies for Santa.
Should people leave a cigar and scotch
for Dennis Prager? Definitely.
Although I don't drink. By the way,
I don't drink not out of principle.
I just get a headache from alcohol,
which is funny because I smoke
the strongest cigars made,
and I feel great.
So it's just the way you're made.
But I never dealt well with alcohol.
So you would leave me
a cigar
and
sparkling water.
I know.
I'm not the most exciting
party-goer.
Dennis, what drink will you have?
Seltzer.
It's not impressive.
Scotch on the rock
sounds better.
The irony is, my dad
loved scotch.
One of my sons loves scotch.
I'm sort of like the teetotaler
in the middle.
That was a fun question.
Cole,
17, Florence,
Kentucky. What's your opinion
on radio stations blocking the broadcasting
of Baby, It's Cold Outside
and other traditional Christmas songs
because they don't align
with leftist ideals?
interesting thing here
is, first of all,
I don't know what other Christmas songs
are ever blocked.
I don't think that
I don't know of any other Christmas song that is.
Baby, It's Cold Outside
I know he's trying to
for those of you who don't know,
I think it's a totally innocent,
adorable song.
I know you can read into it,
oh my God, he's going to give her stuff
to get her tipsy so she'll stay the night.
He's trying to convince her to stay the night.
What'll my mother say?
I mean, give me a break.
What'll my mother say?
It's pretty dated.
We've lost the ability to enjoy life
without any of these hypersensitivities.
This is not a
date rape song.
God, it's so sad.
They're killjoys on the left.
They're just killjoys.
Can't enjoy Thanksgiving anymore.
It's now Native American
Genocide Day.
Christmas is,
you know, it's not,
I don't know, it's become nothing
for many people.
The music, I mean, this song,
there's nothing wrong with this song.
God.
All right, let's see.
Sammy 16, Layton, Utah.
What's your favorite Christmas song?
I love them all. I love so many of them.
I am
crazy about the season.
I'm crazy about it.
I happen to love, I gotta
admit, I have
a Holly Jolly Christmas.
It is so unsophisticated
musically and words.
But I don't know.
I just hear it
and it gets me in the mood.
But, you know,
there are so many, obviously, the
great religious songs.
Noel and Silent
Night. I mean, there are
just so many.
By the way, here's a
great example. How many, I bet
most of you don't know this.
American Christmas songs, which are
a phenomenal genre
of songs.
Phenomenal.
The biggest hits,
at least half of the
biggest, most popular Christmas
songs were written by Jews.
New York Times article a number
of years ago.
Not many people know that.
Did they feel
excluded, these Jewish writers?
I guess not.
It was a healthier time.
When it said,
Make America Great Again, there were great things
about America that have been lost.
That's an example.
Now, all of a sudden, tell me,
what is a better America, where everybody
says it's a beautiful season?
Or people say, oh no, you're excluding
people. Who's excluded?
Okay.
Let's see.
What's our time,
by the way?
All right.
Benjamin 19, Washington, D.C.
By the way, do people know that
if they're over 20, they're allowed to send in questions?
They think it's like a cut-off
point if you're 20 years old.
Benjamin 19, is it okay
for people to re-gift something
that they previously
received as a gift but didn't like?
Yeah, why isn't it okay?
Listen, if somebody
gave you a box of
cigars,
and you don't smoke cigars, and you
re-gift it to me,
I'm fine with it.
So, just, I want to put that thought
in your mind.
What's wrong with it?
People don't think rationally on
subjects. What is wrong?
I get a beautiful gift.
Now, if it's a cheesy junk gift,
but a cheesy junk gift is not good,
gift it, let alone re-gift it.
It doesn't matter if it's re-gifted.
If the nature of the gift
is worthy of the recipient,
who cares if it's re-gifted
or not?
What is better, to do nothing
in my house, or to give
somebody pleasure?
So, I want to repeat, if you
get a box of cigars and don't smoke,
I will be honored
to be the recipient
of your re-gift.
Even if it's the seventh re-gift,
if it went through
seven recipients,
none of whom smoke cigars,
I will be happy to receive it.
Okay, Christian23,
oh, there we go, it's an old guy.
23, Gainesville, Florida.
What is Kwanzaa, and why isn't it real?
Kwanzaa was developed
by a black professor
at Cal State
Long Beach, if I'm not mistaken,
in, I don't know, the 1970s,
I think it was, or 1980s.
It is not an African holiday.
He invented it.
Which, by the way,
does not dismiss it.
It's fine with me if a holiday
is invented. I don't have anything
against Kwanzaa. I just don't want
people to think that it's something it isn't.
It's not an African holiday.
Africans, if you
asked any African immigrant,
do you celebrate Kwanzaa,
he would say, I'm sorry, what?
But if there are
black Americans
who celebrate it, God bless them,
enjoy your Kwanzaa. But it's not widely
celebrated.
I don't know,
why would a black American
be less likely to celebrate Christmas
than anybody else?
Alrighty,
everybody. Okay,
finally, Reese, 16 years old,
Douglasville, Georgia. Favorite
Christmas movie?
So, It's a Wonderful Life.
That's my favorite.
It's very touching.
There are a lot of great Christmas
movies, just like there are a lot of great Christmas
music.
So,
why should we
in any way
want to diminish such a joyful
part of the year
in America
and presumably other countries?
Well, I can only speak
about America in this regard.
It's a beautiful time
of the year.
It's what one of the songs says, it's the most
beautiful time of the year.
I think it is.
And the question is,
why wouldn't
everybody think that?
So,
if you're celebrating it, Merry
Christmas. If you're celebrating Hanukkah,
Happy Hanukkah.
To all of you,
from all of us,
Otto,
my wonderful staff,
my family,
and
I'll see you next week.
Thanks.