Top 20 Genius Scenes in Sherlock

Benedict Cumberbatch
4 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 12, 2025
Now, that's pretty impressive.
Welcome to WatchMojo UK and today we'll be counting down our picks for the Top 20
Genius Scenes in Sherlock.
For this list, we'll be looking at various scenes in which characters – usually Sherlock
– exhibit genius traits, astonishing intellect and or impeccable planning. Basically, anything
that made us respect the intelligence of the characters involved.
20. Sussing Out the Safe
A scandal in Belgravia. It's scenes like this that prove the brilliance of Sherlock
and Watson as an investigative team. When Sherlock originally meets Irene Adler, he
has extreme trouble reading into her, due to her utter lack of clothing. But then Watson
and Sherlock team up for a dazzling bit of deduction. Watson lights a magazine on fire
in order to trigger the smoke alarm, leading Irene to nervously glance at the secret location
of his safe. Sherlock notices her glance, but
which in turn leads him to the safe in question. It doesn't require Sherlock's otherworldly
intelligence, but it's nevertheless a very smart – and very funny – trick. It's
masterful in its simplicity.
19. The £9 Million Hairpin – The Blind Banker
At the end of The Blind Banker, Sherlock discovers that Van Coon and his secretary, Amanda, have
been in a secret relationship. And he makes this deduction through simple hand soap. Sherlock
finds an expensive brand of scented hand soap in Van Coon's apartment, which he figures
is for a lady friend. He also realises that it's the exact same brand of hand cream
that is used by Amanda. Put two and two together and you have a secret love affair. If that
wasn't all, he also discovers that the treasure the kidnappers were after is actually a £9
million hairpin that Van Coon had given to Amanda after his return from China. The exorbitant
treasure was in her hair all along.
18. Mystery of the Dead Hiker – A Scandal in Belgravia
Even under sedation, Sherlock Holmes is much smarter than the average person. Soon after
finding the hidden safe, Sherlock is drugged by Irene Adler, resulting in a fever dream
in which he solves the mystery of the dead hiker using Adler as his guide. As a nearby
car backfires, the hiker turned to investigate the sound, resulting in his boomerang slamming
into the back of his head and killing him instantly. There was no trace of the boomerang
as it had bounced into the nearby river and drifted downstream. It's very nice work
by dream Sherlock, and the entire sequence is aided by some hauntingly beautiful music
and lots of visual splendour.
17. Studying the Lady in Pink – A Study in Pink
This was one of the first glimpses we received into the unnaturally perceptive mind of Sherlock
Holmes, and what a tantalising glimpse it was. Sherlock is brought to the crime scene
of one Jennifer Wilson, who is lying dead with the word, RACHE, scratched into the floor
nearby. With the help of some visual clues, we follow along with Sherlock as he makes
his clever observations. When Lestrade asks if he's found anything,
and Sherlock gives his novel-sized explanation, we know exactly how he came to the answers.
It wonderfully establishes character and the show's unique visual style. It's a brilliant
bit of inference by Sherlock, and a brilliant piece of filmmaking by the filmmakers.
16. Airline Seats – A Scandal in Belgravia
We have to keep going back to A Scandal in Belgravia. It's just so darn good. In this
scene, Irene approaches Sherlock and asks for his help in deciphering a code from the
Ministry of Defence. This being from the Ministry of Defence, you'd think it'd be a tough
nut to crack. But not for our dear Sherlock Holmes. In the time it takes Irene to kiss
Sherlock and for Watson to place his mug on the table, Sherlock discovers that the code
is actually airline seat allocation numbers. Not only that, he figures out the exact flight,
time and its destination. All from, well, a lot of different things actually. It's
amazing to witness.
15. Cracking Jennifer's Phone – A Study in Pink
While studying Jennifer Wilson, a.k.a. The Lady in Pink, Sherlock discovers that she
was scratching Rachel into the floorboards, but died before completing the L. They reckon
that this is the name of her deceased daughter, but it's actually far more than that. Sherlock
finds an email address on the tag of Jennifer's luggage, and infers that she did business
on her smartphone rather than a laptop. He uses the email address as her website username,
and deduces that Rachel is actually her password. She had planted her phone on her killer in
the desperate hope that someone would find them using its GPS signal.
14. The Mayfly Man – The Sign of Three
The Sign of Three is an interesting episode, in that it uses John and Mary's wedding
as a catalyst to explore a variety of smaller cases. One concerns the so-called Mayfly Man,
a man who impersonated deceased males and occupied their recently vacated apartment
to have affairs with women. But the truth is actually far more complex. Sherlock discovers
that the Mayfly Man actually courted women who worked for Major James Sholto. He used
them to get info about Sholto's whereabouts, so he could murder him in retaliation for
his brother's death, who died under Sholto's command. He also manages to find the Mayfly
Man posing as the wedding photographer. Even while serving as best man at a wedding, Sherlock
is in tip-top form.
13. Moriarty Breaks Into The Crown Jewels – The Reichenbach Fall
Sherlock saw his greatest opponent in Moriarty, who opens the season two finale in spectacular
fashion. While posing as a tourist at the Tower of London, Moriarty uses nothing but
his cell phone to shut down the tower's security, open the bank of England's vaults
and unlock the cells at Pentonville Prison. Following that, he uses chewing gum, a diamond
and a fire extinguisher to shatter the glass surrounding the Crown Jewels. All that while
turning Sherlock into a social pariah and a wanted man. In the end, we learn that Moriarty
didn't actually utilise a fancy coat to do all that, he just bribed security. You
want to hate villains, but Moriarty is just way too smart – and way too much fun – to
hate.
12. The Guardsman – The Sign Of Three Another intriguing mystery found within The
Sign Of Three is that of the Queen's Guardsman, Bainbridge. Bainbridge had supposedly been
stabbed to death, but the lack of a weapon and escape route resulted in the case going
cold. By the end of the episode, the case interconnects with the Mayfly Man and Sholto
subplot that was previously discussed. Bainbridge had been stabbed with a stiletto blade, but
his tight military waist belt had prevented him from suffering the effects. It isn't
until his belt is loosened that the flesh part – and the body – reacts to the stabbing.
Sherlock also concludes that the Mayfly Man had stabbed Bainbridge to practise his killing
of Sholto. This type of dextrous storytelling is why we love Sherlock.
11. The Fake Vermeer – The Great Game While observing a supposed Johannes Vermeer
painting, Sherlock receives a call from a child hostage, telling him that he has ten
seconds to prove the painting is a forgery. What follows is perhaps the best ten seconds
of Sherlock history. He eventually finds that the painting depicts the so-called Van Buren
supernova, which was observed on Earth in 1858. Therefore, it couldn't have been possible
for Vermeer to paint the supernova in the 17th century. This is actually a case of artistic
licence, as there is no such supernova that was observed in 1858. Regardless, it's a
wonderful and exciting conclusion that caps a wickedly tense sequence.
10. Capturing Smith's Confession – The Lying Detective
Introduced in series four, Toby Jones' Culverton Smith cuts a shifty and suspicious kind of
character from the off, despite his philanthropic and entrepreneurial reputation. And it didn't
take Sherlock long to twig Smith's true villainy, capturing his confession with a
perfectly laid trap. Thanks to Watson's predictable nature, and a cleverly planted
recording device in his walking stick, Smith incriminates himself beyond dispute. Of course,
much hinges on John arriving to save Sherlock so that the confession can be released, but
that was never in doubt either.
First impressions are everything, and Sherlock knows that better than most. Here, he runs
into a supposed superfan, but he immediately works out the ruse. Kitty Riley's in fact
a journalist, looking for the latest scoop on one of the UK's most elusive characters.
Of course, Sherlock never takes too kindly to the press, and he promptly puts Riley in
her place, with some typically astute comments on her look and demeanour. The whole scene
each tries to outplay the other, but there's only one winner here.
After a break-in at a bank where all the assailants did was leave graffiti on a painting, Sherlock's
asked to investigate, and the trail soon leads him to break into Edward Van Coon's
flat, where he finds Van Coon dead. Watson and the rest of the police rule suicide, until
Sherlock deduces otherwise. The super sleuth explains how Van Coon's apparent obvious
left-handedness makes it very unlikely that he shot himself, rattling through a list of
simple but brilliant observations to back up his theory. And there's some trademark
sarcasm just for good measure.
Sherlock's got one hell of a memory, on top of everything else, which he uses to solve
this case in the show's first ever episode. Chasing a taxi through the streets of London,
with Watson just about keeping up, he employs a photographic knowledge of the city, including
the latest roadworks and diversions, to eventually catch his target.
The scene does leave one question unanswered, though. Why does Holmes use cabs as frequently
as he does, if he can travel just as quickly on foot? Seems like a waste of fare money.
We're picking apart passwords next, as Sherlock's faced with the four-digit code
to Irene Adler's infamous phone. And with apparently endless combinations in front of
him, we spend the entire episode trying to figure out what it is. As usual, the actual
solution is so painfully simple that we're kicking ourselves for not realising it sooner,
as Sherlock's thrown into an unexpectedly emotional exchange. The I Am Sherlock line
quickly became a mantra for the show, and understandably so.
Sherlock's no stranger to injury, but he usually escapes fairly unscathed. Until Mary
shows up, that is. Just as we find out Mary isn't all she claims to be, she goes and
shoots our gifted detective. But things are never simple in this show. Not even point-blank
bullet wounds. Time seems to stop, and Sherlock has seconds to determine how to fall to reduce
the damage done. An ultra-intense moment, with viewers begging him to think fast, Holmes'
ability to make the right call was never really in doubt, was it?
Seeming like an ultra-logic superpower, Holmes'
Mind Palace stores all of his memories and every piece of seemingly pointless information
he's ever encountered. Quite unbelievably, it's actually a legitimate memory technique,
although Sherlock's is much bigger, more effective and more extravagant than anyone
else's could ever be, naturally. Tapping the palace for this scene, it takes him mere
seconds to solve a huge piece of the Hounds of Baskerville mystery, shining light on significant
details his brilliant brain has always had access to. He just needs to cut through the
chaos.
A huge moment at the start of the series, this scene establishes the Holmes-Watson friendship.
Serving as our introduction to both characters too, it's where we learn John's backstory
and it's when we get our first look at just how brilliant Sherlock really is. Watson arrives,
and Sherlock instantly deduces that he's an army man with family issues. Later, John's
amusement turns to amazement when Sherlock explains exactly how he came to those near-perfect
conclusions. We can't forgive him for that brother-sister slip-up. He's still human
after all.
For one of the biggest surprises in the entire show, Sherlock jumps to his death at the end
of Series 2. Or he seems to, at least. We soon learn that the sleuth is still alive,
but how did he do it? Fans had to wait two theory-filled years to find out, with the
first episode of Season 3 proposing multiple possibilities, including a plan involving
a Sherlock mask, Darren Brown and a bungee cord, and another hinging on a giant crash
mat. It's all about ambiguity here, though, with some fans still unconvinced by Sherlock's
version of events. What do you think?
It's not often that Sherlock shows his emotions, but here his straight-faced facade slips just
for a second, so he starts to question his most valuable asset – his mind. But just
because he's scared doesn't mean he's not still brilliant, and he proves this by
deconstructing a random couple nearby. Revealing everything from their familial relationship
to the breed of the lady's pet dog, he's very clearly still in control, turning simple
observations into spectacular details.
In case we didn't know it by now, nothing fazes this guy. Not even a supposedly supernatural
killer hound. The solution is always within his grasp.
Do you agree with our picks? Check out this other recent clip from WatchMojo UK and be
sure to subscribe and ring the bell to be notified about our latest videos.
