Ep. 365 — Who Suffers When Standards Drop? | Fireside Chat | PragerU

PragerU
799 followers
10 Video Views·Mar 10, 2025
The Law School Admission Test (LSAT) now allows extra time for test-takers with mental and psychological disabilities. Is this compassionate, or could lowering the bar in fields like medicine and law lead to the dumbing down of America’s doctors and lawyers? As well-intentioned but misguided affirmative action policies shift professional requirements, who ultimately suffers? Plus, Dennis answers your questions about risking grades to stand up for truth, Jesus, Halloween, and preferred pronouns.
many days there are in the year except
the leap year which is
366 but I just thought I'd note
it I have a really
interesting subject for my opening
comments then of course I go to your
questions and it is
completely uh a thank you to Julie
Hartman with whom I do the Dennis and
Julie podcast every week for uh the
Salem uh News Channel you you you would
enjoy there's no question it is a it's
amazing she she's
25 and we have such a rapport it's it's
it's worthy of its own
commentary what does age mean it's a
very interesting
question but I'm not going to get into
that now anyway she raised this topic
and we discussed it for over an hour but
I'll I'll I'll give about five to 10
minutes so I just learned I mean I had
vague
Notions of this but I just learned she
just took or she's preparing to take
lsats that's law school exams to get
into law school I guess you have to take
Elsa do you guys know this anything
about that is that right I like there
isn't there mcats for medical school
yeah
so the she's taking an
online tutoring
class uh Zoom class and the the zoom
facilitator said in passing that he
wanted them to know that if they have
any what is the word disabilities yeah
any any mental
psychological
disability they can have extra time on
the
exam this sounds to most Americans as
has entirely right because it's
compassionate and not only compassionate
it's only fair because it levels the
playing
field so that you who have
some mental I won't say defect it's too
strong a word
disability uh you you won't be penalized
you have extra time and you can get a
better grade as a result
and this is a really really good issue
to
show many things including how you
cannot govern by compassion you must
govern by
standards it is
100%
wrong to
allow anyone but someone who is
physically hand
handicapped in terms of they just can't
hold a pencil or they can't press a
computer
button to have extra time it's
completely unfair it sounds
compassionate and fair but it
isn't because what it does is it gives
you a fraudulent
number if I get I don't know how what
the grades are let's say I get a
600 and I have kept assiduously to the
top time Factor the time limit right you
get a 600 but you had 50% more time to
do it that
600 is is an unfair
representation especially
since you are not allowed to tell law
schools that your grade was
achieved through having extra
time that's just that's it's
it's not it's not right it's not fair
it's not
accurate
so most Americans will say what are you
talking about this just the to use the
the term always used it just levels the
playing
field well it it may level the playing
field but it's it's an it's an untrue
number the best analogy I can give is
sports
let us say you have a track competition
right it's Track and Field track so a
running
race and competitor
a starts at the starting line and
competitor b gets a 50 meter
Advantage because of a a an innate
inability to run
fast would you say that that's fair
that's leveling the playing
field but you would never do that as I
said on the Dennis and Julie
podcast there one of the reasons Sports
is so popular is that it is the only
area of life that actually tells you the
truth I if someone won a race you know
they ran it faster than anybody else
that's
it they by the way they they are
attempting uh to cheat that's the irony
the same people who I'm I'm I'm sure
agree with more time on an elsat for
those with mental
disabilities uh if you say you're a
woman hey then we're going to allow you
to race against
women I just read today the United
Nations which is all
protrans has come out with a report that
900 women in different competitions have
lost medals because men saying their
women compete against them
900 I'm surprised it's not
more if I get a 600 I'm I'm just
arbitrarily picking a number on an
exam and I had to finish the exam I
don't know again a a number within 3
hours you get five hours to do the exam
and you get a 600 that's not a fair
600 it it doesn't represent your ability
why is there any time limit the whole
point of a time limit is what can you
answer correctly within a given amount
of time but if that time limit doesn't
exist for some people then the number is
is is a false representation of what has
happened
not only that law schools are not told
who got extra
time so in effect what we have done to
law school entrance exams lsats is
render them
useless a a a law school has no idea who
got a grade within a certain time and
who didn't because you're not you're not
allowed to tell
you can't govern by compassion you can
only govern by standards then you can
have
compassion in in your private life and
you should compassion is a beautiful
thing but so are
standards the it's it's permeating
America this notion that we change the
rules in in the United States of America
today if you took out a a large amount
of money in a loan to attend college you
don't have to pay it because you know
the government will ultimately want to
pay it for you but there are millions of
Americans who did pay it so you show
compassion to the people who uh are no
longer burdened with college
debt but you're showing contempt for the
people who paid it off off right isn't
that
obvious oh you're a
sucker you paid your college debt you
just had to wait till a certain party
was in office and then all the debts
would be rendered cancelled because the
government would pay it for you that's
not compassion that's that's
contempt the people who actually thought
I'm morally bound to pay my debt end up
looking like suckers
because that's that's the way that law
would treat
them there has to be a universality
about standards irrespective of your
ability to live by them or
not and this this would be an
instance you can't govern by
compassion that's why that's why social
justice is the opposite of
justice social justice is governing by
compassion Justice doesn't know
compassion Justice knows what is just
what is true that's it those are the
only questions in in in
Justice if a billionaire and a poor guy
are in a
lawsuit you can't favor the poor guy
over the billionaire by the way that's a
Biblical law in the book of Exodus you
cannot favor a poor man in judgment
because it's it it ends the concept of
justice social justice is as I said is
the opposite of
justice justice is blind it's why they
have a picture of the Statute of Liberty
wearing a
blindfold but social justice is the
opposite of
blind another example is
uh there are
trouts for people who want to play in
orchestras in the United States let's
say you
are a person who plays the trumpet
you're a musician plays the trumpet and
you want to join the Seattle Symphony
Orchestra well I can't pick the Seattle
Symphony Orchestra because I don't know
this exists the New York philarmonic
where I know it exists there is a
curtain so the people choosing the next
trumpet player for the or violinist or
any obviously any instrument for the New
York philarmonic Orchestra don't know at
all what the trumpeter looks like they
only know which is all that matters how
does this person play the
trumpet so there's a curtain we don't
know the color we don't know the sex we
don't know if they're handsome or pretty
or ugly it's heavy thin nothing
nothing only how does the trumpet sound
which is the way it should
be but uh obviously if you want to have
what's called affirmative action
compassion for minorities then you
wouldn't have a curtain you wouldn't
only choose the next Trumpeter for the
orchestra based on how well he or she
plays the
trumpet that's that's what we have done
all the rules are
changed because we think we're being
compassionate but it's not it's not in
the long run it's not compassionate and
in the long run it undermines the thing
it's supposed to protect music or law
school or whatever it might
be Okie
do time for questions take it away hi
Dennis my name is Lyla green I'm from
Tuscaloosa Alabama and I just recently
graduated from high school I'm taking
summer classes this year and I just got
my first woke assignment do I risk my
grade and speak truth or do I tell her
what she wants to hear by the way
looking forward to working with you one
day well I want say I would like
that okay one minute okay I did
it well let's see Lyla yes Lyla green
and Tuscaloosa I've been to
Tuscaloosa long time ago so first of all
I hope hope you do work with the prageru
one day that that would be
wonderful by the way when I I saw the
picture of Lyla and the dog I was hoping
the dog would ask the question just for
the
record so this is a very very very tough
question you might have thought I would
have a slam dunk on this one oh come on
you say what you believe and the ends
that ends the
issue first of all it gives you an idea
of how ubiquitous how
common
teachers favoring students who
are progressives like they
are no kid is afraid to write left-wing
ideas in in a paper in a book report I'm
shocked that they still have book
reports frankly
so this question
arose oh about five years
ago I I was at a a retreat as what they
call scholar and residence and so is Ben
Shapiro of the daily
wire and this question arose and Ben and
I had opposite reactions and we agree on
on almost
everything I said this was my my answer
I tell I tell the following
anecdote where a woman called in and she
said what do I tell my daughter does she
write what she believes or or and get a
lousy grade or does she you know write
nonsense that she doesn't believe in get
a good grade I told the story of this
woman calling me on my radio show and
this is what I said to her I told the
audience at this retreat I said I told
this
[Music]
woman if your if your
daughter compro something to the effect
if your daughter
compromises on the truth for a good
grade when will she not compromise on
the
truth this is just a
grade you got to start building your
courage muscles
early and your conviction muscles this
is what I believe and let the chips fall
where they may but Ben had a very good
argument in the opposite
direction
Ben got up and he said you know in
principle Dennis Dennis is right
but in
reality wouldn't it be better for our
cause he said for the values we believe
in
that we have more kids attend the
Harvard's and the colombias and the Y
and the Berkeley and the UCLA and you
name it isn't that better for our
cause if we if we all say what we
believe in high
school very few uh of those who share
our values will end up in Elite colleges
and we want them there it's good for the
cause and my senses were both
right but the reason I still think I am
a little more right
is
that when you start compromising for
benefits in this case getting into a
prestigious College when you start
compromising when do you stop that's was
my argument but I I mean it in a
different way as well you get into the
Habit because there will be no time in
your life when there you don't pay any
price for telling the truth you will
always pay a
price Elon Musk is the richest man in
the world he he is a truth teller and he
look at the amount of of hatred he
receives the day being courageous exacts
no price
will be living in a great
world but it's not
imminent
so maybe there's a way to figure out how
to tell the
truth without rubbing the professor's
nose in it I'm not
kidding to be able to say certain things
in ways that don't elicit
antagonism that might be a good way of
getting getting around it
so that's a really tough question thank
you so we have Prager United go to
prerun united.com that is how you
support
prageru and make everything that we do
continue to be allowed to be for free
not only that you get big benefits when
you join prer United one of them is the
first question after the video question
week Kelsey L Chicago Illinois pray your
United member
question hi Dennis I absolutely love
your Fireside Chats as they have
challenged and enhanced my critical
thinking good so thank you for that my
question is you have stated multiple
times that you are okay calling a
transgender person by their preferred
pronouns slash change name
I'm curious as to why you are okay with
this do you not feel that a transgender
person is insulting God by theoretically
saying he created me wrong so there are
a few items here first of all my
attitude on what on how to refer to a
person is very simple what do you look
like in in all of life do you ever
debate you're checking in your bags at
the airport do you debate whether it's a
man or a woman checking you if it looks
like a woman you you you you assume it's
a woman if it looks like a man you
assume it's a man on rare occasions I
will admit and it's happened to most
people you can't tell for some reason
right is that a man or a woman I have
said that to my wife on maybe two or
three occasions in 20
years and that may be more than most
people have it's exceedingly rare that
we don't have an immediate impression
this is a man this is a woman so if
you're a transgender woman you're a man
who thinks you're a woman you look like
a woman you talk like a woman you dress
like a woman you have a woman's name why
would I even think to ask gee are you
transgender what genitalia do you have
what what what right so I don't even
know why it comes up it shouldn't come
up you look like a woman I think I say
she you look like a man I say he but I
if you want to fake us all out and
trivialize the distinctions between men
and women in other words you have a
beard and you wear a skirt I'm not going
to say
she then I am playing along with your
charade that's a charade I have a beard
and I wear a skirt call me Barbara it
doesn't work work with me if they ask
you directly you would say no no okay so
if they if you ask me directly no so he
say uh hi I'm Barbara and you you know
the waiter the wait waiterwaitress I'll
say Barbara okay but uh uh if I would if
I referred to the person in the third
person talking to my wife I'm not going
to say
she now if the person were present what
would I say interesting question it's
never Arisen because how often do you
talk about someone in the third person
when they're around right it it doesn't
happen but my my solution is the common
sense solution what do you look like
that's how I refer to you so as a part
do I not feel that a transgender person
is insulting God by theoretically saying
he created me wrong that's a separate
question
so I don't think that that's uh a a
foolproof
argument this notion this is how God
created
me is one I'm very very hesitant to
use people use it all the time they if
your child is born deaf people will say
that well God created my child
deaf so what does that mean you won't go
for a co- clear uh uh implant later
what what if there is a surgery that
enables a person to hear you won't give
that child are you insulting the way God
made the
child I I think Many Many religious
people and they are my allies in in in
virtually every
Arena use God a little too
freely I I I don't know how God op
searates uh I know what God
wants cuz he told me in Micah oh man God
has told you all he wants to pursue
Justice love goodness and be and walk
humbly with your God I know what God
wants but I don't know what God
does it's not knowable to us
Mortals so I mean what once you say that
by the way you fall into into a trap
because gay people say God Made Me
gay do you believe that God made them
gay well if you believe that God Made
You male and God Made You female then
then did God make you now I believe God
made the human being male and female
that's what it says in Genesis I believe
that I don't believe I don't believe you
can become the other sex and I don't
believe you could be neither sex it's
not language I use it's
like uh you know people said when there
was an assassination attempt against
Donald Trump and and it missed his his
his brain by a fraction of an inch God
saved him how do you know how how does
one know I don't know that for a fact I
I thank God that he was saved but but I
I have no idea I thank God in the
vernacular I do I know whether God
specifically intervened there was a
firefighter who was killed who was at
that rally so God saved Trump but not
the
firefighter how does the wife of the
firefighter when the whole country is
going oh God saved X but not my
husband so we we don't know the
answer it's very tempting to want to
think that God did X or Y but that's why
I call my Bible commentary the rational
Bible I I can't I can't abandon
reason so we just don't
know okay Jacob 26
Leroy
Iowa hey Dennis do you have any fun
childhood memories of Halloween you
could share any particular costumes you
remember dressing up
as yeah oh I I dressed up as a talk show
host very early age I just knew that's
what I should dress up as I I don't no I
um most of my Halloweens as a kid were
spent giving out treats rather than
trick-or-treating and I will tell you
this I was always overweight including
as a kid I went to the Husky section I
was born overweight and I went to the
Husky section for clothing with my
mother and I tell you this because I
went crazy for Halloween it was the one
day of the year my mother out candy into
the
house so I was probably the cheapest
treat Giver in the entire
neighborhood where kids would go
trick-or-treating in in fact I would
give so little that we got Tricks played
on us we got the trick that's what
trick- or treat
means the trick is rare it's rare we
were we got Tricks because I didn't give
much treats I was in charge and I'm
thinking hey wait a minute this is the
only candy I will see this year why
should I give it all away
now I know this is not a noble story to
relate to you but what am I going to do
I'm going to do penitence for what I did
it when I was
10 as I got older I gave more candy out
I will admit but then I tell Mom we
don't you didn't buy
enough God I remember Tootsie Rolls
Tootsie Roll pops and and there are
there are candies from my childhood do
they still does Baby Ruth still exist it
does okay M&M's of course do there was
another what else did we have that I I
don't know I don't oh I don't remember
oh Clark Bar you ever hear of that you
heard of a Clark Bar where did you grow
up North Carolina North Carolina oh
Delaware H please what the Delaware
doesn't have clock bars my grandpa it's
well known your grandpa what my grandpa
talked about him he talked he talked
about Clark bars but you never
encountered one I don't know if they
still exist anyway that's my memory and
I thought I thought you'd get a kick out
of it all right Patricia 40 new M
Minnesota as a religious Christian
although I enjoy movies for the most
part I find myself conflicted about the
horror
genre I of course understand there is
something Primal within us that makes us
enjoy to a certain extent the feeling of
being scared or on edge but on the other
hand a part of me believes that
Hollywood uses horror movies to inject
awful images and scenarios into our
psyches am I overthinking it what are
your thoughts on horror movies do you
enjoy them thanks for all you
do so the this is great example of
interacting with the public on an
intellectual level you learn so much I
never would have thought about this
question so first of all uh let me see
what did you say here yes there is
something Primal within us that makes us
enjoy to a certain extent the feeling of
being scared I don't have that there is
no part of me that enjoy is being scared
I have to admit it I never got the
appeal of horror
movies what am I gonna say uh and I by
the way I think I know why at least
partially
why I don't have any joy in getting
scared is that I know how scary reality
is so I don't need movies to engender it
and I think that a lot of especially
young people are oblivious at least in
America and in Western Society generally
to how much evil there is in the world
so they like watching it but I knew from
an early age how much evil there is
because I know you know the real stuff I
I could never I mean so the guy you know
hor he go the guy with the you know the
slasher blades right a guy slashing
people I I there was no part of of me
that enjoyed getting being
scared uh what I did do interestingly I
told my older brother when I was about
10 or 11 that I couldn't watch horror
movies it was on TV they'd be on TV uh
because they really made me scared so my
brother said just keep watching them and
then eventually you'll start laughing
when you see these monsters or these
sword wheelers it'll it it the more you
watch it the the less it will impact you
and he was right so that then none of
the movies made me
scared I'll tell you the scariest movies
are based on
truth you know Nazi movies communist
movies uh you know slav ship movies the
the real the real deal that that's
scary so that's what affected me as as
regards implanting image is in your
psyche I I I I don't know if I relate to
that
I think it it's a woman right who wrote
this yeah I think women remember things
more than men do I think if if you
ask the average woman say a husband and
wife go to a movie ask her what happened
a week later in the movie and ask him he
most men will say what movie is that
fair to
say is that fair to say you remember
movie seriously if you do okay well he
has a feminine side it's
beautiful anyone whose grandfather had
Clark bars as a feminine side by the way
they're still around they are still
around you looked it up years yeah yeah
I I I I love that I love the Clark bars
I don't know how many I gave out very
few so uh anyway
uh look so I'll just speak for me I
don't I don't remember most movies do
you know what I you know what movie I
remember this is Eerie that this should
come up because I just mentioned it
today Castaway yeah I can't forget that
that movie I believe at least five times
every single year something about that
movie enters my brain I don't know
why maybe every time I see a volleyball
any anyway so the implanting of images
is not is not a thing there's one thing
that does still continue to scare me in
in horror movies only
one kids who are
scary I find scary children much scarier
than scary
adults right uh you you have that too I
think a lot of people feel that because
they they're off been used as as
frightening uh as frightening
figures but anyway uh I you know you you
I you might be overthinking it I I love
your sensitivity but some things are not
are not big are not big issues what's
our story good so uh we're good that's
such an adorable way of putting it we're
done yes we're
done it's
I have a Bittersweet feeling whenever
it's over I I enjoy it how shall I put
it I enjoy it as much as you do does
that sound arrogant because I'm assuming
you do but you wouldn't be watching if
you didn't enjoy you're not you're not a
masochist so I want you to know I enjoy
it as much as you enjoy it just for the
record so before I say goodbye I just
want to to note this is the first time
I'm I'm noting this but it's very
important to me and to all of us if
you're watching on YouTube is for you to
leave
comments I'll tell you this I always
read comments on on YouTube on articles
that I read on the internet I'm
fascinated by how people react not just
to what I write or what I do just in
general I I have done whole radio hours
on New York Times readers comments on an
article in the New York Times because
it's so
revealing about the the people who read
the New York Times I'm not saying bad or
good it's just revealing so please do so
and on occasion I will actually be
reacting as if you would sent me a
question I can't do it all obviously
because hopefully there'll be many many
many many comments so here is an example
okay I don't agree with everything
Dennis says but he is awesome and funny
people like him are our limited chances
to Save Our Youth and country well how
am I going to react to that no I'm not
awesome and
funny I'm just awesome or I'm just funny
so here's a good question what would I
rather be if I could only be one of
them what would you choose
funny awesome is a diamond dozen but
funny that's
rare okay just having a good time next
okay so here this is a comment on
something I said and this is from I
don't know if it's a man or a woman uh
you pay a terrible price so somebody had
written in question Dennis I think I
remember it oddly
enough you say you ask atheists always
opening question do you hope you're
right or wrong which is true I do I
always ask atheists you hope you're
right or wrong because if they say they
hope they're right they're not
intellectually honest why would you hope
there's no God if there's no God there's
no meaning to life there's no good and
evil there's no ultimate Justice there
there's no afterlife there's nothing
it's nothing the whole thing's a joke so
so and by the way most atheists I asked
do say they hope they're wrong they just
don't believe in God which is fine so
the question was posed what about you
and Christianity do you hope you're not
a Christian dentist and do you do you
hope I'm I'm a I'm a religious Jew just
for the record do do you hope you're
right or wrong well do you hope you're
wrong about Jesus being the Messiah yes
yes right or the Savior yes about Jesus
being the Savior
so I think I
said
um it's the it's the wrong question from
your
perspective because it it sort of would
make my point
if the if the atheist is right he pays a
terrible price there's nothing after
death life has no meaning there's no
ultimate
Justice
okay but and if he's wrong then that's
terrific there there is a God there is
Ultimate Justice he'll be reunited with
his children or or his friends or his
spouse or his dog whatever
but it's it's it's the opposite in this
case with the Christianity case if I'm
wrong or let's so I guess if I'm right
if I'm
right and I don't accept Jesus my Savior
and my Messiah if if I'm
right then I don't pay any
price it's the opposite of the atheist
if he's right he pays a big price but if
I'm right there's still God there's
still ultimate Justice there's still
meaning there's still the Bible there's
still
everything I I just it's just that
specifically Jesus of Nazareth is not
the
Messiah or the Son of
God so it it doesn't hold I'm not saying
I'm right I'm just saying if I am right
I don't pay a price but what about if
you're wrong okay so let's say I'm
wrong now so if I am wrong and he ah
okay that's that's a good one right so
if I'm wrong and he is the
Messiah then okay
then I certainly hope I'm right that's
what that's the whole point I'm asking
the atheist do you hope you're right or
wrong you're asking me as a as a
non-Christian do I hope I'm right or
wrong if I'm wrong I pay a price but if
I'm right I don't pay a price The
Atheist pays a price if he's right so so
it's not analogous is that clear okay so
there's another one on
that that
um so here's another one that came
through on on on a Jesus question that's
the point then it's none of us can be
perfect through works that's why we need
a savior
Jesus atheists should not hope they are
wrong because they are facing an
eternity of punishment whereas they
believe they will just die and that's it
okay I won't I did The Atheist part I
just want to say on this about none of
us can be perfect through
Works Jews never believed that anyone
could be perfect through
works it it it's it's a completely unje
and irrational belief no human can be
perfect only god is perfect but God
doesn't ask us to be perfect there is no
place in the whole Old Testament where
God asks us or in the Torah with 613
laws Thou shalt be perfect it doesn't
it's not even
hinted so I just look I want to make it
as clear as possible though it's clear
to most of
you
Christianity is uh is responsible for
bringing my beloved Torah to the world
we
Jews brought the Torah into the world
but it is Christians who spread the
Torah to the world the only reason that
people all over the world know about
Adam and Eve or the Ten Commandments is
overwhelmingly because of
Christians I think this a partnership
we're each doing God's
work so I I I'm a major defender of of
Christianity and Christians and I've
been all of my
life uh so I just want to I just want to
make that clear but I this argument that
we none of us can be perfect is a non
Secor of of course none of us can be
perfect it to me it's like saying nobody
could drive
perfectly
so why do we need all the traffic laws
for well we need laws the reason for the
Torah laws is not to make us perfect
it's to make us
better like all laws no laws are there
to make us perfect because it doesn't
that it's not a
possibility anyway I uh I about twice a
year I have a a great evening with some
major
christian uh Theologian or
pastor called ask a Jew ask a gentile or
ask a Jew ask a Christian some of them
are on on the internet you might might
find that
interesting so uh do please write
comments on YouTube if you're watching
watching the fireside chat on YouTube
thanks the fireside chat is made
possible solely thanks to Prager United
members please consider joining Prager
