Winston Marshall: I Left Mumford & Sons and Found My Voice | Stories of Us | PragerU

PragerU
800 followers
1.7K Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
He had it all—fame and success—with Mumford & Sons, one of the world’s biggest bands. But a single tweet changed everything. After praising @AndyNgo 's book on Antifa, @winston_marshall faced intense backlash, forcing him to choose: stay silent to save his career or stand by his beliefs. He chose truth, even at great personal cost. Now, he shares his powerful story of conviction and courage—and why he wouldn’t change a thing.
📲 Watch our content ad-free on our app: https://prageru.onelink.me/3bas/vgyxvm79
Follow PragerU on social media!
Instagram ➡️ (https://www.instagram.com/prageru/)
X ➡️ (https://twitter.com/prageru)
Facebook ➡️ (https://www.facebook.com/prageru/)
I can either have a life where I have a
microphone but I'm not allowed to speak
into it or I don't have a microphone but
I can say what I think and I was like
well I'm going to say what I think cuz
it's no way to live with your mouth
shut my name is Winston Marshall and
this is my
story for 14 years I was in a band
called mid and S which I founded as a
teenager my relation ship with music
Started absolutely terribly I was so bad
at the piano when I started playing that
I quit pretty quickly and my parents was
like no you have to have some sort of
instrument so I picked up the trombone I
was so bad at the trombone that my
teacher asked me to quit and
eventually I found the guitar and I sort
of fell in love with it because of the
music I was listening to then I picked
up the banjo which had the great
advantage of no one else playing which
means they getting jobs is much much
easier
essentially fell in love with the banjo
probably because I also had a great love
for America there's a magic about the
music of
America so I start playing in these
different bands form this bluegrass band
Captain kick and the cowboy Ramblers
then we're starting playing with loads
of other bands around London in the pubs
around London it was it was a great
Lively time and innocent time the band M
and Sons came about because of the many
talents there one of of them was Marcus
mford who had a set of beautiful songs
he has this stunning voice we ended up
playing with Marcus and then that really
sort of whittled down to the four of us
it seemed to be the core elements was
banjo double Bas piano and guitar M and
Suns ended up doing very well we were
bound together by a love of not just the
music but touring and we started touring
very
quickly we first came to America in 2008
supporting
Johnny Flynn and Laura Marling for a 3
and 1 half week tour it seemed like to
be very gradual it was never a sudden
burst every time we came we played a
slightly bigger venue first it was clubs
and then it grew and grew and grew there
were a couple of moments that were
really big for us we played the Grammys
with Bob Dylan and the AA brothers
that's when things started getting very
surreal for us actually because Bob
Dylan was just a poster on my wall he
wasn't a real human being and now we're
actually in a room with him I haven't
worked out how to articulate those
moments cuz it was such a whirlwind I
remember it being emotional because it
felt like so we'd all sacrificed so much
and we'd all work so hard it was like
wow it was worth
it there's something about the kind of
um if you the really
[Music]
quick that that that Rhythm it's I
remember first hearing it and it's so
infectious I'm sure to a lot of people
maybe most that's the most irritating
sound in the world but to me that I
remember hearing that and it's like
a I just wanted to be able to do
that touring is pretty brutal for
relationships you're away for long
periods of time there's a lot of drug
people want to maintain the high that
they had on stage so they'll come off
stage and they'll carry on going I was a
very heavy drinker at the time after
doing this all for a long time and some
other things that were happening I
wanted to feel like I understood
everything that was going on around me
to make sure I remembered everything cuz
not everything was adding up so I
decided to stop drinking and all drugs
I'm now 6 years sober if you're going to
do the sobriety thing don't do it alone
I regret doing alone that I could have
gone very badly and I'm very grateful
that I managed to get through
that one of the immediate things that
happens when you do give up alcohol is
that you have a lot more
time so the last couple years of touring
every day I think I was reading a book a
day cuz you when you're on tour you're
waiting for the gig and that starts at
like 8:00 p.m. so you have all day
you're not hung over so you wake up
early like right what am I going to read
today and I I gave myself essentially an
education the book
reading actually was what would be my
undoing cuz I would I carried on and
then pandemic came along and then I was
like well I'm going to just share on my
social media what books I'm reading to
my not many followers I on Twitter I had
about 3,000 followers if that one of the
books was a book by Andy no a very brave
journalist documenting BLM and antifa
I tweeted about this book I said
congratulations Mr Andino you're a brave
man I I don't know how this thing's
happened but it ended up trending the
number one trending thing on
Twitter for like two days and not just
in my little old England but in this
country my instinct was just ignore it
it'll pass by the end of the weekend it
was a segment on both taka Carson and
the view and then you get phone calls
from friends and colleagues and how
upset they are so I issued an
apology the apology was because I was
seeing how upset everyone was my
bandmates were very upset and I wanted
to put out the fire and I didn't want to
lose everything that I had worked 14
years for so I wanted to protect that
another
aspect was that I thought well maybe I'm
wrong about this maybe I don't know
everything about BLM maybe I don't know
everything about Andy no I need to look
into this then in the coming months I
obviously dig deep into antifa BLM to
really understand this issue and the
more I did the more I came to closer to
the conclusion that I'd actually not
done anything wrong worse still that the
act that was wrong was the apology an
apology which was essentially what I
would eventually conclude was
participating in the LIE it was clear to
me that the only way forward was I could
stand by I believed but it meant it was
not tenable to work with the band I
wanted to protect them it wasn't fair on
them to suffer because of what I
believed so I published an explanation
and left the band the music industry is
unbelievably Progressive or at least the
progressives dominate the discourse
within it and yes musicians are afraid
to speak so many artists some of the
major artists they'll say privately I
totally agree but they can't say it
publicly it's it's such a shame what's
happening leaving the band was an
unbelievably difficult decision to make
because I knew you can kind of keep your
dream of touring but you're never going
to be able to speak your mind and the
other choice is well this might mean I
don't get to tour like I did and play to
tens of thousands of people every night
and basically living the the Rockstar
teenage dream that I I'd had and I don't
regret it as soon as I retracted the
apology for complimenting Andy no's book
a weight was off my shoulders and I got
my soul back it felt like getting my
soul back at the beginning of 2024 I
started an independent show and I can
interview whoever I want I can explore
any topics I want I can go for as long
as I want and it's it's so much fun it's
so rewarding I get the most lovely
messages as well I love my work now the
two choices I had I can either have a
life where I have a microphone but I'm
not allowed to speak into it or I don't
have a
microphone but I can say what I think
and I was like well I'm going to take
I'm going to say what I think cuz it's
no way to live with your mouth shut I
made the choice to just speak the truth
thank you for watching and if you want
to support prageru and their great
nonprofit work consider making a
donation I'm sure they'd appreciate it
very much
