China's economy is worse than expected! Big changes ahead: A CCP insider reveals

CN Under
3 followers
8 Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
China's economy is worse than expected! Big changes ahead: A CCP insider reveals
China's economy is worse than expected. Big changes ahead, a CCP insider reveals.
The Chinese government is heavily in debt.
Analysts Beijing has limited room for fiscal stimulus.
Nearly 40 major shareholders of A-share companies reduced their holdings in one day,
with some cashing out 150 million yuan. Wang Duruo of Apollo.com reports that the
Chinese stock market has stopped rising for several days, and selling pressure has emerged.
At the close on Wednesday, October 9th, the Chinex Index plummeted by 10.59%,
the Shanghai Composite Index dropped 6.62%, and the Shenzhen Component Index fell 8.15%,
dealing a severe blow to market confidence.
Does this mean that China's economic difficulties have reached an unexpectedly dire situation?
Regarding this, Lao Man, a well-known economic observer who once worked in China's land department
and has a large following, commented that the background of this rescue can be analyzed from
two perspectives. First, the central government's fiscal revenue, and second, consumption in major
cities. Fiscal revenue has decreased by 30% per month, and consumption in major cities has frozen.
Behind this is the sluggish real estate industry and the Chinese government's regulation
of specific industries. While investment institutions initially applauded these efforts,
experts familiar with China's problems, or those within China's industry and academia,
have been more cautious about this rescue package.
Looking at the top-priority housing market, Stephen Roach, former chief economist at Morgan
Stanley, and a longtime friend of the Chinese Communist Party once known as a
Wall Street China expert, said that China's latest financial stimulus measures are impressive.
However, the current fiscal plan still lacks clear details on how to effectively deal with
the further decline of the real estate market. Take Country Garden, a giant in China's real
estate industry, as an example. In 2023, it had around 36,000 houses that were completed but
unsold, approximately 350,000 houses that were under construction but unsold, and 730,000 houses
that were sold but not yet completed. This is the core of the problem and the most dangerous
battlefield for ensuring delivery of completed buildings. According to Liu Ting, the chief
economist for Nomura Securities in China, an estimated 3 trillion yuan, around 13.7 trillion
new Taiwan dollars, of fiscal injection will be needed to solve this crisis. On the 8th,
Ray Dalio, founder of Bridgewater Associates and another longtime friend of the CCP,
said at an international forum that investment in China must be extremely cautious at present,
as China seems to be fundamentally distancing itself from capitalism.
Big things are happening there, including a debt crisis. They also have a capitalist crisis.
The Chinese government is heavily in debt.
Analysts. Beijing has limited room for fiscal stimulus. The Information Office of the State
Council of the Communist Party of China announced that the Ministry of Finance will hold a press
conference this Saturday, October 12th, to provide information on increasing fiscal policy adjustments,
once again raising public expectations for fiscal stimulus measures. However, some analysts have
pointed out that due to the heavy government debt burden, the fiscal stimulus space is limited,
and expectations should not be too high. On Tuesday, October 8th, the National Development
and Reform Commission, NDRC, of the Communist Party of China did not introduce new fiscal
measures as the market had expected, leading to a significant cooling of the Chinese and Hong Kong
stock markets. On Wednesday, October 9th, the Communist Party of China officially announced
that the Information Office of the State Council would hold a press conference this Saturday
morning, where Finance Minister Lan Fuan would introduce plans to intensify the counter-cyclical
adjustment of fiscal policy. Whether Beijing will launch a new large-scale fiscal stimulus
package has become a key focus for public opinion both at home and abroad. Hong Kong's
English-language media, the South China Morning Post, reported on October 9th that officials from
the National Development and Reform Commission said on Tuesday that they would accelerate government
spending, increase investment, and continue issuing ultra-long-term government bonds to
support major projects. They also moved forward the 100 billion yuan strategic investment plan
originally scheduled for 2025 to this year. However, some analysts have pointed out that
the window to support China's economic recovery through fiscal expansion may be narrower than
previously thought, as the government is already heavily in debt, limiting the space for fiscal
stimulus. The report quoted Zhang Deli, chief macro researcher at Zhongtai Securities, as saying that
considering the sharp decline in land transfer revenue, the largest source of income for local
governments, local governments' actual income may decrease by 3.4 trillion yuan this year.
Many analysts believe that given Beijing's concerns over local government debt,
there is limited room for official fiscal stimulus. Zhu Qiubing, chief macroanalyst at Bank of China
International Securities, bluntly stated that local government debt risks will limit fiscal
expansion to some extent. The key for this year's fiscal policy is to relax fiscal constraints
rather than increase stimulus. We should not have too high expectations for subsequent fiscal
policies this year, he said. Ding Shuang, chief economist for Greater China at Standard Chartered
Bank, also pointed out that by the end of 2023, central and local government debt would account
for 56% of GDP, gross domestic product. If local government's hidden debt is included, the figure
could rise to 100%. It is unrealistic to expect the government to expand fiscal spending when
local government tax revenue is shrinking. On September 10th, at the 11th meeting of the
Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, Minister of Finance Lan Fuan read
out the Report on the Management of Government Debt in 2023 on behalf of the State Council.
According to the report, as of the end of 2023, the statutory debt balance of governments at all
levels across the country reached 70.77 trillion yuan. Among this, the national debt balance is
30.03 trillion yuan, and the local government statutory debt balance is 40.74 trillion yuan.
Of the 11.14 trillion yuan in national debt issued in 2023, 4.16 trillion yuan was used to
5.22 trillion yuan to repay the principal of national debt issued in previous years
that matured in 2023, and 1.76 trillion yuan to cover short-term national debt issued and maturing
within the same year. It is worth noting that the above report from the Ministry of Finance
only covers the scale and use of the so-called legal debt on the government's books, and does
not mention the even larger hidden debts of governments at all levels. Previously, the Wall
Street Journal reported in July this year that many Chinese cities have accumulated between
U.S. $7 trillion, about RMB 50 trillion, and U.S. $11 trillion, about RMB 78 trillion, in hidden
debt for economic development over the years. Due to the opaque financing methods, the actual
total debt of local governments in China is unknown. Even the central government is unclear,
with estimates suggesting that up to 800 billion U.S. dollars of this debt is at high risk of
default. A report by the research institution Rhodium Group pointed out that, among the nearly
2,900 local government financing platforms evaluated by the institution in 2023,
only one-fifth had sufficient cash to cover short-term debts and interest. Under the pressure
of financial deterioration and debt, many local officials began looking for unconventional sources
of income, even resorting to extreme measures such as exploitation and intimidation of private
enterprises. Nearly 40 major shareholders of A-share companies reduced their holdings in one day,
with some cashing out 150 million yuan. After a significant surge over several days,
the Chinese stock market suddenly plunged on Wednesday, October 9th, with the three major
stock indexes falling sharply. According to statistics, major shareholders of nearly 40
listed companies reduced their holdings on that day, and some companies saw shareholders liquidate
their shares. Other major shareholders planned to reduce their holdings and cash out 150 million
yuan. Since the start of the current round of A-share surges, at least 250 companies have
issued announcements of reductions. Stimulated by a series of policies from the Beijing authorities,
A-shares had risen steadily since September 24th, peaking on September 30th. However,
they began to turn downward after the National Day Golden Week. On Tuesday, October 8th,
A-shares exhibited a rollercoaster performance, fluctuating throughout the day. Although gains
were halved, the market still closed on an upward trend. However, on Wednesday, the market experienced
a large-scale cutting-leaks trend, with the three major A-share indexes plunging sharply.
As of the close on October 9th, the Shanghai Composite Index fell 6.62%
to 3,258.86 points. The CSI 300 Index dropped 7.05% to 3,955.98 points.
And the Shenzhen Component Index declined 8.15% to 10,557.81 points.
The plunge was driven by a large number of major shareholders reducing their holdings to cash out.
According to statistics from the Huawei Research Institute, after the A-share markets rise at the
end of September, around 10 listed companies per day saw their major shareholders reduce holdings.
On October 9th, at least 38 major shareholders of listed companies announced reductions,
5 more than on the previous trading day, October 8th. This indicates that, following the National
Day holiday, the pace of holdings reductions by major shareholders has accelerated significantly,
with the intensity of reductions also increasing. According to Nanduan Finance,
since the A-share market rebounded on September 24th, as of October 8th, at least 256 listed
companies have issued announcements of share reductions, with 136 companies disclosing plans
to reduce their holdings. Around the National Day holiday, the number of companies announcing
share reductions increased significantly, with 28 and 52 companies disclosing plans on September 30th
and October 8th, respectively. Whether this wave of major shareholders' share reductions
is a temporary phenomenon of the technical correction in the Chinese stock market,
or a sign of a flash in the pan for the overall A-share market rebound, remains to be seen.
