In a world without consequences, are humans naturally good or is there darkness within us all? Laruen Chen sits with Michael Knowles to discuss the classic novel Lord of the Flies about a group of British schoolboys who become stranded on a deserted island. Free to behave however they please, the boys reject societal norms and devolve into depravity. If the human impulse for power and groupthink overtake reason, is there any hope for Western civilization?
Today on the book club we will weep for the end of innocence, the darkness of man's heart,
and the fall through the air of the true wise friend called Piggy. But first, Dallas Baptist
University is a comprehensive, Christ-centered, nationally ranked university with a mission to
produce the next generation of servant leaders. DBU graduates are men and women of a deep faith
who strive to reflect the values of genuine patriotism. They can be found leading in
classrooms, in courtrooms, in boardrooms, and beyond all throughout our country and around
the world. To learn more about the value of a DBU education and how you or your student may
be eligible to receive a $1,000 scholarship, visit PragerU.com slash DBU. That way you or
your child can be educated and if they're ever marooned on a desert island will not descend
into anarchy and savagery and kill each other. Here to help me describe that particular phenomenon
is my friend Lauren Chen as we go through William Golding's Lord of the Flies. Lauren,
thank you for being here. Thank you for having me. I'm so excited to talk about this book.
I had not read this book since I was the age of the kids in this book. I was probably in seventh
grade the last time I read it and it's a very very good book. Can you in 60 seconds or so
just summarize what goes on? Sure, happy to. So Lord of the Flies tells the story of a group of
British school boys who in the midst of a nuclear war end up stranded on a deserted island and the
boys quickly elect this one character Ralph to be their leader and he's very much symbolic of
civilization rules and order. He wants to establish day-to-day goings-on on the island and make sure
that they can actually get rescued. Things quickly go south mainly due to the fact that this other boy
Jack would rather focus on the more primal elements of living on this island. So he's
leading a group of what he calls the hunters who are the other choir boys and quickly these two
different factions who kind of represent the civilized versus uncivilized versions of ourselves
they come to deadly blows and eventually after death, destruction, and almost burning down the
this group is only ended up they they're eventually rescued by the military who happens upon them.
Yes, so you mentioned in the beginning something that a lot of people forget about when they go
over this book which is the entire context for it. You've got the airplane flying in with these kids
something goes wrong in the airplane the plane crashes the kids end up on the island there's no
grown-ups and they say at the beginning if only there were grown-ups if only there were adults
then we could take care of ourselves but as you point out the only reason the kids were on the
airplane in the first place is there's a nuclear war going on the grown-ups blew themselves up too
I don't they probably wouldn't have done any better than the kids. Right and that's what really
interests me about this book because I remember when I was first reading it I was probably 12
or 13 or something it was very much painted as you know on a deserted island we are uncivilized
that's the primal nature of the man versus what we are in society but I think like you that Golding
actually had a very different interpretation and don't forget he is someone who served during World
War II and was also a teacher which I think exposed him to a lot of darkness of humanity
you know I've been around school kids we're just talking about that so not only does this whole
book only happen because of a nuclear war that was started like you said by adults but even
within the book we see that the characters who are meant to represent the best of humanity
civilization as well as intellectualism they ultimately in their own ways end up falling
just like people like Jack who are from the get-go more interested in abandoning
the more civilized aspects of themselves anybody who has ever been or met a 12 or 13 year old boy
in particular the boys the girls are a treat too especially these boys and it's all boys on the
island knows that they are the worst people on earth 12 and 13 year olds are the worst people
on earth they have lost their childhood innocence they have not yet been educated to maybe hopefully
try to deal with themselves responsibly they're mean they're petty they're vicious and according
to William Golding they're killers yes and I think it's really interesting that he comes from the
position of a teacher that is writing about this because I think him more than anybody would
understand that even though we might like to see the dividing line as being civilization versus
not being civilized I think you'll find that even within the realms of a society that has rules and
laws there still is the opportunity and in fact sometimes even the worst atrocities are only made
possible by the fact that we have almost built ourselves up nuclear war like one that started
off this novel is a great example of that well this is the key because at the very end when
we're skipping a little bit obviously we'll go back but at the very end this ship shows up
and they actually the boys do get saved and the the English captain of the ship says so what's
going on what have you boys been doing you've been just playing pretend and making war and
and the the boys say yes because we've literally been making war he says oh it's like the coral
island I looked up I had never heard of the coral island I had never read the coral island so I
looked it up the coral island is this book by R.M. Ballantyne and it's a book that was regularly
assigned in British elementary schools and in American high schools shows you the comparative
value of the yes and the the coral island was a book about these three English boys western
Christian boys who go to a Polynesian island and the island is full of these uncivilized savage
tribes that kill each other and eat each other and do all sorts of uncivilized terrible things
and then the boys bring civilization to them and the tribes are civilized and this is a happy ending
and this book that Golding wrote is in a way the inverse of that book the the first book the coral
island was written in the 19th century we're talking about the height of the British empire
the Victorian age you've got a western civilization that's really proud of itself very confident
in what it believes this book the lord of the flies was written just after the second world
war in fact a review of it in the guardian when it came out said the book could not have been written
before the horrors of Nazi Europe the horrors of the second world war that well the the coral
island shows evil is something that is external to us that we have to deal with what what Golding
says in lord of the flies is that no no the evil lies within yeah and I think it's interesting
because comparing those two types of works these are still this is still a discussion that people
are struggling with is man inherently good or is man inherently bad and I think you know people
have criticized Golding for being too pessimistic and I've even heard people try to assert that he's
racist and trying to portray the the descendant of savagery through the use of things like
face painting and hunting and spears almost trying to draw a parallel to see these cultures that
still do that they're worse than us but it's like no no he's saying any negatives that are
associated with that that's just inherent to who we are as people and I'm you know I enjoy Hobbes
I'm a Calvinist personally I am very much in agreement with Golding and even if we look at
what we've just been through the past two years uh you know this we haven't really seen a descent
into anarchy or a lack of rule of law but I still think the inherent I guess desire to abandon
civility because of our fear that is still very much with us and I think we just saw that play
out with COVID sure well you and and you did see a lot of lawlessness over the last two years
you see it at the beginning of the book you've got the leader Ralph who you mentioned and he's got
this sort of friend it's a kid that he's the kid's fat and he's got asthma and he can't see without
his glasses and his name is Piggy and he says please Ralph whatever you do don't tell the other
kids what they used to call they use it's right on the back of the book they say they used to call
me Piggy and what does Ralph do mean little 12 year old punk he he tells all the rest of the kids
that he was called Piggy and they all make fun of Piggy but Piggy is really smart Piggy says
this is a scientific world don't believe in ghosts don't believe in monsters believe in reason believe
in the rule of law he finds a conch shell you know that you blow through on the beach he says
this will be the symbol of leadership Ralph you will be the leader and for a while not for very
long but for a little while the kids are behaving and they're building huts and they're exploring
and they're they're building the most important thing to them which is the fire the smoke signal
so that they can be discovered by a passing ship but very quickly everything breaks down and they
let the fire go out right and I think it's important to know that the reason why the fire
goes out it's not just because they forgot or they were lazy it's because they were actively pursuing
I think it's hunting right that other more primal instinct which I mean obviously if you want to
survive you need to eat but in this book it's very much an allegory for that darker aspect
of ourselves because of the way the boys engage in it it's very it's it's violent and you can
see that there are several times throughout the book where they almost act out these pig hunts as
as you know murders of other people which they do end up doing to this one boy Simon ironically
while he's trying to reason with them that there's no monster on the island they in their
blood lust end up killing someone who is trying to present them with reason and logic you bring
up Simon I think he's my favorite character in the whole book so we've already got for those
who are tracking the characters we've got Ralph he's the leader he's elected chief then you've got
Jack he's the hunter who makes himself the rival chief you've got poor little piggy who's just
trying to be protected and call people back to reason and you've got Simon who's in a way
the prophet or the priest of the island after the hunters go and they kill this hog they're they're
so afraid of the ghosts the the beast the evil that lurks they believe outside of themselves
on the island whenever the darkness comes that they leave a sacrifice literally an animal sacrifice
which is the head of the pig right the lord of the flies and the lord of the because all the flies
come to the head of the pig on the on the spike and so Simon this strange kid kind of the prophet
or the priest of the island he goes up and he has a conversation with this pig sacrifice idol and the
pig sacrifice idol says the evil it's it's in you all you can't run away from me the darkness of
man's heart is just where it is it's just in man's heart and you mentioned that the hunters and the
all of the kids eventually would not merely go on the hunt but they would act out the hunt they
would perform a ritual it seems a lot like a religious ritual to to pretend one kid is a pig
and one kid is 100 it seems like any kind of savage tribal dance and as poor little Simon
is wandering out of the woods they treat him as the sacrificial victim they all pounce and kill him
and I think what's so frustrating about that scene is that not only is Simon almost kind of just
minding his own business but the reason why he is descending from I think the area that he was in
where he had seen this pig head as well is that during one of the nights there is a paratrooper
someone who a soldier that ends up parachuting down to the island who dies some of the children
who are on the island see that and they interpret that from afar to be the beast and this sort of
yeah it just it spurs on all the irrational fears that they're having Simon gets a closer look and
he sees it for what it really is oh this isn't a monster that's going to get us uh it is a dead
body which is horrifying enough as it is but no reason for us to be uh whipping ourselves into
this frenzy as he is trying to go and present this message of rationality and calmness that is when
ultimately he is attacked by his peers and it's not just the hunters like Jack but it's also people
like Ralph and Piggy who end up taking part in this murder even though after the fact they will
try to rationalize it and distance themselves from it that was such a moving scene because
I think it really spoke to the fact that even the most civilized of us the most rational of us
like Piggy likes uh like Ralph ultimately we can still fall prey to these same primal urges
we inevitably do it reminded me of the scapegoat you know the idea of the scapegoat goes back it's
in the bible it's in other ancient myths this idea that well I guess it was explained recently
relatively recently by a sociologist named Rene Girard and he had this idea of mimetic desire
and it's a very fancy term but basically it means that we our desires are formed through imitation
that man is primarily an imitative being and a ritualistic being and so the reason that I want
this coffee is not because of the coffee it's because you want the coffee and I see you want
the coffee and now I say that coffee's worth something I want that coffee it really plays
out speaking of young boys it really plays out when two guys are fighting over a girl
right maybe at a certain point neither of the guys even really cared about the girl but they see the
other guy wants the girl and so now I want her all the more and now you want her all the more and now
our rivalry has become so intense that you gotta punch that other guy in the face and so Girard's
idea of mimetic rivalry is that this is intrinsic to human societies we inevitably it leads to a war
of all against all and the only way to let it out is with a sacrificial victim the only way to let
it out the ancient israelites what would they do they would sacrifice one kid goat not a kid like
the lord of the flies but a goat they would sacrifice one and then they would cast all of
their sins onto the other one and send the goat out into the wilderness you need that sacrificial
victim and Girard sees this play out most fully in christ who is the sacrificial lamb he's the
embodiment of that but that all culture has this need and that's what they do to poor little simon
they have to cast their their mimetic rivalry onto this poor kid even as he's trying to give them
important information it doesn't matter and it and it's not even just the bad kids it's the good
kids too it's ralph it's even little piggy right and i think something that's really interesting
is that at the end of all of this uh you know these boys have gone through so much at the
beginning of this video you've mentioned the loss of innocence when they finally are rescued what do
they do they ultimately fall to their knees and they start crying every single one of them um and
i think it does go to show that even though at the time like this is what they felt that they must do
uh ultimately trying to satisfy those primal urges uh the the war of all against all it was
not enough to actually um you know i guess help them cope with the things that they have
had seen the things that they had done and that was only really possible when they were being
removed from the situation and i think that's also a commentary by golding is that even though
that may be part of us that inner desire for darkness for conflict and savagery it does not
lead us to a good place well and you know we've talked about this poor kid simon getting killed
we haven't talked about the most famous death in the book which is poor piggy they go because they
need piggy because piggy's glasses are the way that they start the fire the sunlight goes through the
lens and it's the only way that they can start fire and they're always picking on piggy and
finally they go and throw a rock and kill piggy poor piggy there's another kid who dies early
on in the book he's a kid with a mark on his face and he just dies he just they didn't take care of
him and he just died so you've got three kids have died how do they get discovered in the end
it's because they light the whole damn island on fire right because jack and the hunters in that
tribe they're hunting down the new scapegoat this new one guy ralph they're chasing him down the
whole place has been lit ablaze finally a ship finds them one of my favorite passages in the book
is one that's not actually usually mentioned and it's when uh ralph is talking to piggy
and they're asking about the fear of the dark the fear of the ghosts the fear of the beast
and ralph says the trouble is are there ghosts piggy or beasts piggy says of course there are
why not because things wouldn't make sense houses and streets and tv they wouldn't work
the dancing chanting boys had worked themselves away till their sound was nothing
but a wordless rhythm and then ralph asks the pressing question but suppose they don't make
sense not here on this island supposing things are watching us and waiting all this liberal
modernity that we're living in where we've got we've got five fancy coffee machines within a
we've got nice cars and heating food is everywhere and everyone's really polite
suppose that's fragile suppose that's not just permanent suppose there's something really dark
crouching within each of us and the moment you take just a little bit of that veneer
of civilization away things can get really dark i mean i personally think that you've just
described reality and i know that there are people who will push back those who believe
that no no man is inherently good and you know being in the civilization even if we are perhaps
more prone to rougher aspects when we are alone just being accountable to each other that will
make us good i still disagree with that but you you mentioned piggy's glasses and those are
interesting i think because not only uh i guess do they represent a way for a conflict to arise
within the book but i think they also represent um man's conflict with nature itself so we have
man's conflict with man and our our inner demons but also with nature itself uh being almost in
some ways fighting against our urge to civilize you mentioned the fire it's only through destroying
nature that they are eventually saved and it's the same thing with piggy as a whole in addition
to his glasses he is someone who represents man's rationality he is overweight he has asthma he is
incapable pretty much of seeing without these glasses and these glasses are the only things
that are really enabling these boys to survive long term and to continue to live on so i'm not
saying that golden was perhaps anti-environmentalist but i do think it's interesting that uh that
tension that friction is also there and and i am not a calvinist so i i maybe don't have quite as
dark of you human nature as you do but you know certainly one could not read this book or look
around reality and say man is at all times just a jolly happy wonderfully beneficent soul that
perhaps man is not entirely and completely depraved but man is made in the this would be my
take at least man is made in the image of god we have some good desires but we're so fallen you
know we kicked out of the garden of eden there's original sin the the imagination of man's heart is
that our our good desires can go really really wrong and you still see the way that they know
how they're supposed to behave is within them even these little boys on the island they know
they're supposed to be good but they just don't do it even the best ones among them right do not do
it and that's what's kind of the most interesting part for me of the the book as you're starting to
read it is that you can see slowly the boys start to realize that okay we know right from wrong and
we're supposed to do but who's still here to keep us accountable there's this one character i believe
his name is roger who's almost the sociopath right the one who's a total killer total killer and uh
you know it kind of starts off this one scene where he's i think throwing rocks at this other
kid and you know he's not he's not murdering or really hurting him seriously but you can tell
that urge is there and even just reading that passage ultimately you know that all right we
know what he wants to do he's not doing it but he's not doing it not because of any inherent
good in him but because he knows there are consequences but those consequences no longer apply
to this situation and that's kind of a a terrifying realization that i think if if this were to happen
in real life would ultimately unfold and we see that in emergency situations it's not really
rioting looting necessarily happening uh you know one second after the flood there there's that
security that people feel and it things take a while to gradually break down we've seen it you
mentioned the last two years with coveted but right we've seen it in the last two years with
the blm riots yes the summer of love it was really a summer of hate that the moment that you spread
the idea that this the system of justice isn't really going to work if you commit crimes you're
not really going to be held to account the minute the grown-ups leave in our allegedly
civilized society you get looting and rioting and burning and murder coast to coast as we film this
right now we are living through one of the greatest crime waves crime surges in recent history because
of that precise problem right and i think it's true it's it might seem like um esoteric fiction
to imagine us in a situation where we are on the stranded island it's a lot easier and more
topical to imagine perhaps system where police simply don't show up if they're called uh where
you know perhaps you just aren't charged for crimes and so we're already like you mentioned
seeing the results of that on a lesser scale but i think going back to the idea that this is still a
topical conversation there are still people out there who would deny man's nature to indulge in
those darker behaviors if he knows that there are no consequences and and even the different
different uses you can have for the same things you know that the most important character in
the entire book as far as i'm concerned is the fire the fire is what they're always talking
about the fire is at the heart of the conflict the fire is at the heart of their salvation
and ralph and piggy want to use the fire they're obsessed you the fire is forget about hunting
even forget about lots of the other things you want to do keep the fire going fire is the the
gift from prometheus to man fire is one of the things that distinguishes man from from all of
the other beasts we can make fire we can control fire and the the bad boys want that want the fire
too but they just want to have the fire to go char their pork and be able to go and to eventually
destroy and eventually destroy the entire island the fire for ralph and for piggy represents hope
the only hope they've got that they can get off of this island and the really bad boys they've lost
their hope they don't have any hope they are not trying to get off the island they they are living
as less than human they're living as animals grunting and hunting and killing each other like
they would any other wild animal and i think that that still summarizes a great duality of man right
now you have those who politically philosophically within their personal lives are wanting to
preserve the fire and hold out for that salvation or that hope and you have other people who simply
do not care who would rather wallow in their current situation and that conflict is as real
today as it is on on that island thankfully at least where we are right now it's not bursting
into flames or among us but i think um we have yet to in the 70 years that this book was written
find a way to solve that in a way the the book though it's chock full of wisdom but it's also
it's just here are problems yes and not necessarily solutions but there's no certainly no no solutions
in it but but though the book is very full of wisdom it's also clearly a product of its time
and i guess here this book as the answer to the coral island is is important for us to think about
this is a book of a man who has given up hope for civilization i don't want to speak for the
nobel prize winning uh william golding but this is a man who looked at the coral island and he said
that's not how things really are this idea that we in the west can go around and civilize the
world and have a hope for a better future that's not what i saw with the atom bomb that's not what
i saw with the nazis that's not what i saw with the communists in the second world war this is a
really cynical pessimistic take and i'm not sure it's the correct one it's as we've been describing
it's it is one side of the story and there is there is deep wisdom in that side of the story
we will kill piggy leave us alone on an island we are going to kill poor little piggy
is there a way for western civilization to get our mojo back though is there a way for us to
to be confident in our beliefs have confident hope for the future can we wait for that ship
to show up on the coastline once they see the smoke that we've burned our whole civilization
down well i mean it's it's funny because i'm someone who like you mentioned i'm more inclined
to to agree with golding and i think when we look at the state of our our civilization or
individual countries right now it is i don't want to say it's it's proof that he was right in the
fact that we do have rising crime we're dealing with this huge situation right now in eastern
europe as well that's uh you know this is conventional warfare we're talking about way
more major war in europe and since world war ii exactly way more similar to as something that
golding himself had experienced than previous conflicts which you could have just chalked up to
you know individual radical ideas though this is like nature of man coming out and so you know i
think it would obviously be an oversimplification to say all men bad all the time but i think the
point that golding is trying to make is that we cannot civilize ourselves out of our inherent
nature and i so i don't think it's necessarily a question of just throwing the baby out with
the bath water oh we're always going to be a little bit bad anyway so just anarchy now party
party but it's just the the idea that we are above any of this savagery i think that is a mistake and
i think that's something that we do need to be reminded of because if you look at i mean not to
call out the people in like california too much i think there are people who are in charge and
who are making policies right now who would think that there are these dark urges or dark desires
that would never manifest themselves in our society and they are proven wrong all the time
right the idea you know if you just give the criminals a few more hugs than exactly right
well i suppose if there's any hope to be had it is this this might be golding's insight on hope too
it's going to get a lot lot worse and then when the smoke coming from the cinders of our entire
culture finally explodes into the air maybe a ship passing by maybe then able to save us it
reminds me of the distinction between a conservative optimist and a conservative pessimist
selena priest friend of mine told me the conservative pessimist says things cannot get
any worse and the conservative optimist says oh yes they can that's that's that's the hope that
we have to look out for here lauren thank you so much for being here where can people find you
so you can find me on almost every social media platform at at the lauren chen and you can also
find me on youtube odyssey rumble just by searching lauren chen hopefully if the algorithm
gods are looking down upon me favorably you will find me that's wonderful not just a lauren chen
you go to at the one and only lauren chen and this one and only book lord of the flies by william
golding if you haven't read it yet read it now so that you do not kill piggy i'm michael knowles
this is the book club we'll see you next month thank you so much for watching this episode of
the book club on prager you prager you is a 501c3 non-profit organization so we rely on donations
from viewers like you to keep this content on the air please consider making a tax deductible
contribution today to help keep this content coming thank you very much