Something is deeply amiss in contemporary American culture. Young people have lost touch with reality and have become trapped by moral relativism. Is post-modern education to blame? Education expert Max Eden joins Michael Knowles for an eye-opening discussion of Allan Bloom’s unexpected bestseller The Closing of the American Mind.
Welcome back to the book club. I'm Michael Knowles. This month we are going to be talking about
how we all got so dumb. But first, but first, Dallas Baptist University is a comprehensive
Christ-centered, nationally ranked university with a mission to produce the next generation
of servant leaders. DBU graduates are men and women of a deep faith who strive to reflect the
values of genuine patriotism. They can be found leading the classrooms, courtrooms, boardrooms,
and beyond all throughout our country and around the world. To learn more about the value of a DBU
education and how you or your student may be eligible to receive a $1,000 scholarship,
visit PragerU.com slash DBU. Very important to get a good education. Very difficult to get
a good education these days. As Alan Bloom wrote, what, 30 years ago now? 35 years ago now? In the
closing of the American mind, how higher education has failed democracy and impoverished the souls
of today's students. I'm very pleased to be joined by an education expert, a scholar at the American
Enterprise Institute, the author of the best-selling book, Why Netto Died, and most important of all,
my true friend of many years, Max Eden. Max, thank you for coming on. So good to be with you,
my true friend. So, you know, I'm using that word or that phrase rather carefully. Yes, as we should.
As we should because this is...I was gonna say this is at the heart of the closing of the American
mind, and it is, but the book is about so much. The book...if I had one takeaway from the closing
of the American mind, it would be perhaps the nature of friendship, perhaps the nature of
liberal education, perhaps the nature of the good in our...the main takeaway I have is,
man, I don't know anything. And that should be the takeaway of this book, right? Like,
if you read this book and you don't feel like an idiot, then you are an idiot. That's a good point.
But it's not in this book, but it raises a good question of what is an idiot, right? And part of
what this book does, it just, you know, sparks insights and insights based on where do ideas
really come from? What do they really mean? Right now, we think that an idiot is a dumb person.
Actually, the archaic notion of an idiot is somebody who cannot speak to public matters.
It's not somebody who's dumb. It's somebody who doesn't have anything to say
about political affairs, about soul matters. So there can be smart people who are political
idiots. And if you read this book and you don't feel stupid, then you might have a problem with
your soul, ultimately. So I think I've summed up, and you've summed up well, what the book
does to the reader. And that's why it's so important to read. But I'm going to give it to
you to explain what is this book about? Just one minute. What's the summary? Well, maybe I'll go
Socratic and ask you a question. Do you think it's a good idea to judge this book by its cover?
I was raised, but I don't know, we're in a bad education system. I was raised to believe
that you should never judge a book by its cover. Well, Michael, you are profoundly miseducated.
I already knew that. How could you not judge a book by its cover? What is a cover?
A cover is an author and a publisher partnering to try to telegraph what the book is for your
judgment, right? It's begging you to judge it. And all you need to do is to think for 30 seconds
about what is a book cover. And you realize that what you're told is the opposite of what is
obviously true. This seems to be revealing a truth about our education system. Many such cases.
So it might be useful to go through this cover to explain. First question, author, Alan Bloom.
Who is Alan Bloom? Alan Bloom has written the greatest English-language translation
of the greatest ancient book about education, Plato's Republic. The greatest English-language
translation about the greatest modern book about education, Rousseau's Emil. And he has authored
the greatest book about postmodern education, The Closing of the American Mind. How higher
education has failed democracy and impoverished the souls of today's students. Now, what's
interesting about the title is Bloom didn't want that title. That was the publisher's idea.
I think I do vaguely remember this. But so what was the title that Bloom wanted?
Bloom wanted Souls Without Longing.
Not the sexiest title. That doesn't fly off the shelves.
No. Why would you want to buy a book about how empty your soul is? Why not blame somebody else?
Good point. Wouldn't that sell more? Wouldn't that sell nearly a million copies in print?
In a book, I'll just wrap up, it's framed as social science, which is a category that
Bloom would have utterly rejected. But there is one interesting thing from the back cover that I
I'll just read the first sentence of the bullet back blurb. In 1987, eminent political philosopher
Alan Bloom published The Closing of the American Mind, an appraisal of contemporary America that
hits with the approximate force and effect of electroshock therapy, according to the New York
Times. I've always thought this is a conservative book. Well, so that's what's interesting, right?
Bloom himself, I strongly believe on a very good basis, would have rejected that notion. He would
have rejected political appellations of modern America. He understood himself to be a disinterested
philosopher. He did not have a partisan stake in the direction of America. He was just fascinated
by how our society is crumbling and was so fascinated that he was moved to study and
write about it. Now, such an accusation, also, frankly, at this point, just the reading of old
books might peg you as a conservative these days. But the fact that the New York Times,
when this book came out, said it hits with the approximate force of electroshock therapy,
shows that our 2022 liberal-conservative dichotomy isn't really an eternal divide.
It's much more of a contingent thing. And this book, one of the many things it will do,
it can do if you read it in full, is explain, well, how did we get to a point where somebody
who reads old books is pegged as a conservative? Well, this is what I want, because I think you're
evading the question. You've told me a lot of interesting facts about Bloom, and the cover,
and the title. So, but here's what I want to know. Yes. How did, I'll use both titles,
how did the American mind get closed, and how did we end up with souls without longing?
Yes. So, one quick way to put it, one sentence or less, it's all the Enlightenment's fault.
Okay, good. All right. The Enlightenment was, as one can read between the lines of Bloom,
the Enlightenment was going to be an inherently failed project if you actually understand
what it was and where it was going. If you understand its telos, its nature, its direction.
The motto of the Enlightenment was, dare to know, right? Dare to know, sapere ade.
On the assumption that what you receive, traditionally from Revelation, isn't
true, you must doubt it, and doubting is the first step to greater knowledge. Now, this makes sense
up to a point, but it also has no limiting principle. You try to eliminate prejudice
as you doubt, as you try to learn, and isn't prejudice a bad thing? Shouldn't we eliminate
prejudice, Michael? As I've always been told, prejudice is the worst, just about the worst
thing in the world. Well, you're, I'm sorry, very dumb. I'm miseducated. Very, very miseducated.
Prejudices, strong prejudices, are visions about the way that things are. They are divinations of
the order of the whole things, and hence, the road to knowledge of that whole by way of erroneous
opinions about it. Error, indeed, is our enemy, but it alone points to truth and therefore deserves
our respectful treatment. The mind that has no prejudices at the outset is empty. So our minds
were closed because we were all told as an axiomatic truth that we should not be prejudiced,
we must be open-minded. So you're telling me, as Bloom tells me, but you're summing it up very
well, that the American mind got closed because the American mind was so open that you might say
the brain fell out. Yes, we were so open that the brain fell out. I think that's the pithiest way to
put it, right? You and I, longtime friends from college, we were educated and or miseducated
together. We read this book together over a decade ago, and I remember when I read it,
it really struck me as true. It was one of the first books to make me realize how little I knew
and what had gone wrong with the American education system. When we had traditional
philosophical education, philosophical education was about what is true, what is good, how should
I live my life? But as Professor Bloom notes, now philosophical education isn't about,
is that thing that Socrates said true? Philosophical education is, what did the
Greeks think about morality? And he adds to that, who cares what the Greeks thought about morale?
I don't care. I want to know what's good. I want to know what's true. And we're not getting that
on campus. No, we're not. I want to read a couple quotes to that effect and kind of stack
them in a fun way. So what is a liberal education? I mean, this is the question of the book. This
should be the question of anybody under the age of 80, frankly. We should all be striving
for a liberal education. Should we be? Why? Well, as Bloom says, and this is not the only opinion,
there are stronger opinions, there are weaker opinions, but this is a good opinion. A liberal
education means precisely helping students to pose this question to themselves, the question of
what is math, which is the question of what is highest for a man, what is best for a man,
and to become aware that the answer is neither obvious nor simply unavailable,
and that there is no serious life in which this question is not a continuous concern.
Right? So there are stronger claims to liberal education you might be inclined to make. I feel
like I've heard you make that we can know the truth, the good, and the beautiful. We know we
can basically know what it is. We just need to be free to find what is good and do it.
And to cultivate our higher will and to make sense of our freedom.
Yeah, that's a stronger version of this case, but that's on the same spectrum. Now,
what's on a totally different spectrum whatsoever is the modern American university
and the modern American students, at least until a few years ago,
when the nature changed and we can cite other sources for the origin of them.
So we've got this soul, we've got certain natural longings, we've got certain desires.
The traditional view of liberal education is to perfect those desires, to raise them up,
to bring your base appetites into line with the rational will. You can be a free man,
you can be a free citizen, you can have a good country. Now we do the opposite. We deny the soul,
we replace the soul. We've got, as Bloom says, students with flat souls. And so you've got a
deformed individual, you've got a deformed society, you've got a whole sort of deformed
country. No one makes any sense of their freedom. That's too bad.
It's too bad, but that claim also isn't entirely true and Bloom wouldn't approve of it. Bloom
would certainly approve of it up to the point wherein he would say, yeah, we no longer look
to books for this. We no longer find old books sexy, we no longer look to the wisdom of the ages,
we don't look to the Bible, to Aristotle, to any authority, any printed authority, which is
thousands of years of human experience had us doing that. But we can't not do that.
How can you not be part of being human? It's impossible.
So what used to be liberal education has been replaced then, and this is probably the most
controversial chapter in the book. It's been replaced by music.
And so this is the one that really got him in trouble. Because Bloom writes this,
you know, as anyone can tell, very erudite, very dense book, this intellectual history,
this history of the university, it's part personal memoir, and then he goes after rock and roll.
Rock and roll.
He says rock, and this is the most controversial chapter of the book.
Its defenders say it's the most important chapter.
And it is. And before I read, I think, the most fun paragraph in the entire book,
in my opinion, we should justify why we say it's important. Or we should at least
cite an authority at the very least. And that authority is Plato. In Plato's Republic,
when they talk about education, music, rhythm, is, in Plato's view, basically the central component
of education. Now, why? Right? That sounds strange. We don't think of music as being
educative. Well, Plato would argue that melody and rhythm work together on the soul in a way
that can be either literally barbarous or uplifting. Now, barbarous in contradistinction
to purely animalistic, right? A tendency of man towards the animal, but retaining what is man,
right? Man is neither God nor animal, and we can be more civilized or barbarous as we come to each.
So his claim is that rock and roll is inherently barbarizing in a very crude and ugly way.
Maybe the most fun paragraph, picture a 13-year-old boy sitting in the living room of his
family home doing his math assignments while wearing his Walkman headphones or watching MTV.
He enjoys the liberties hard won over centuries by the alliance of philosophic genius and political
heroism, consecrated by the blood of martyrs. He is provided with comfort and leisure by the
most productive economy ever known to mankind. Science has penetrated the secrets of nature
in order to provide him with the marvelous, lifelike, electronic sound and image reproduction
he is enjoying. And in what does this progress culminate? A pubescent child whose body throbs
with orgasmic rhythms, whose feelings are made articulate in hymns to the joys of onanism,
or the killing of parents, whose ambition is to win fame and wealth and imitating the drag queen
who makes music. In short, life is made into a non-stop, commercially pre-packaged fantasy.
Now, you know, I have to tell you, it's harsh, but I think it's fair.
Well, but to one open question, is it still fair or is it actually far too charitable?
It didn't get a lot worse since 1987.
I mean, I don't like, I think if Bloom were around today and he listened to Ducardi B's
music, if you watch TikTok, right, you can see on TikTok people doing catchy little dances to
really the most obscenely abhorrent and evil things in the world.
Mick Jagger is Beethoven compared to Cardi B or some of these modern performers.
And rock and roll is Bach compared to TikTok, which is, you know, any soul with political
intelligence of even an animal recognizes TikTok is owned by an avowed enemy of the American people
and is used to barbarize our souls to find evil things catchy and fun and thereby
transmit vice into virtue. So I think it is the most important chapter of the book.
But again, we've barely done this book justice.
I mean, this is something that I have struggled with from the time we were in school and I first
read this book and now rereading this book is, you'll especially hear this in political dialogue.
People will just say things. They'll recite slogans and talking points. They will have no
idea what those things mean, if those slogans mean anything at all. And they certainly will
have no idea where those slogans come from. The intellectual history, which carries all
these premises, all of these ideas that then people will be mouthpieces for often unwittingly.
But I don't want to let go of the values just yet because we are so used to using that language. So
if values are BS, what's the alternative? The alternative is principles, right? Principles
are things you value something, right? The value starts within you. I choose to value this. You
choose to value that. There is no arbiter of our values. You have your values. I have my values.
Who's to say? Precisely. But what if we were to instead debate our principles, right? Our
principles suggest that there is some unity between you and me, which at the very least there
is. We both have heads and eyes and noses and mouths. We're humans. There's some unity.
Principles suggest that there's something above that unity. That because we share a certain
unity, therefore we also share something above that unity. And this is why we get notions of
first principles, right? And you could have a philosophical notion of first principles,
1 Thessalonians, or you could have a divine notion of first principles, God. And if you do that,
then you have an idea of virtue, of telos, of the end of your soul, the proper end of your soul,
what your soul should be longing for. Your soul should be longing for the highest that it can be.
And the reference point for the highest that your soul can be cannot be found within your uneducated
or possibly totally idiotic, therefore, soul. It has to be from outside of you. Principles.
It's a very scary book, but I suppose scary in an edifying way. That's why I'm so glad,
well, one, that you encouraged me to read it more than a decade ago. And now that we're reading it
again together, it's a book to come back and back to. And one hopes that the more you revisit it,
the better the situation has gotten, the more that we can attain that liberal education,
that increasingly we're denied. Alan Bloom says here, this is not just the rantings of an angry
old man yelling at the wind. He's seen this. His students in decades prior did know more stuff.
They actually were better educated. This is a social, political problem. It's not just some
subjective perception of a guy who's saying, ah, the kids these days, they don't know what we used
to know. This is a real problem. And if we're being failed by our universities, if we're being
failed by our high schools and our middle schools and our elementary schools and our broader
polity, we're going to have to do some of these things ourselves. Not necessarily as individuals,
maybe with true friends who are together seeking the truth with the help of our now dead friend
who can guide us in the right direction, Alan Bloom, to perhaps open our minds up again in the
right way. In the right way. Our dead but of blessed memory. Yes. A blessed soul. And again,
just to go back to where we started, a man who translated the greatest book on education written
by an ancient, Plato's Republic, the greatest book written about education by a modern, Rousseau's
Emil, and wrote the greatest book about postmodern education, The Closing of the American Mind.
A book that you should read if you have not read it already, The Closing of the American Mind.
Max, thank you very much for being here. Where can people find you?
They can find me on the AEI website, AEI.org slash Max Hypen Eden, Twitter at Max Eden 99,
or hopefully on future shows with you, Michael. Don't fall for those 98 other Max Edens. Don't
do it. Read Max's book, Why Meadow Died, and do that just right after you finish The Closing of
the American Mind. I'm Michael Knowles. We'll see you on the next episode of The Book Club.
Happy reading. Thank you so much for watching this episode of The Book Club on PragerU. PragerU
is a 501c3 nonprofit organization, so we rely on donations from viewers like you to keep this
content on the air. Please consider making a tax-deductible contribution today to help keep
this content coming. Thank you very much.