Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle - The Book Club ft. Charles Kesler | The Book Club

PragerU
800 followers
@MichaelKnowles
Is the purpose of life happiness, and if so, how can we achieve it? Written nearly 2,500 years ago, Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics is as relevant today as it's ever been. Michael Knowles is joined by Professor Charles Kessler to discuss this seminal work exploring the age-old question of how to live a happy and meaningful life. As it turns out, Aristotle’s recipe for the good life has not grown stale.
SUBSCRIBE 👉 https://www.prageru.com/join
#books #aristotle #michaelknowles
[Music]
welcome back to the book club I'm
Michael nolles and today I am very very
happy I'm very happy to be discussing a
book the subject of which is happiness
and so much more that would be the nicam
mckian ethics by Good Old Uncle
Aristotle I am joined by my friend
Charles Kessler editor of the clemont
Review of Books professor at the
Claremont mcken college and Claremont
Graduate School and the author of many
many books in his own right Charles
thank you for being here thank you but
none of them nearly as important as the
Nick mckin ethics yet yeah yet we'll see
how they Faire over the next 2,300 years
this book was written a very very long
time ago by a very very smart man that
everybody's heard of though some people
might not know very much about so in
your very best 60 seconds summary
Charles what is the nican ethics what is
the purpose of
life in a word happiness to live a happy
life is the highest thing that human
being should uh aim at but what does
that mean I think a lot of people
consider happiness to be just a state of
being right but Aristotle says no it's
an activity a particular kind of
activity in accordance with a particular
kind of thing but it's an activity and
it's uh it's not simply pleasure or
experiencing pleasure uh although it may
be pleasant it may it has a connection
with pleasure but it's not uh defined by
Pleasure uh it has a closer connection
to
morality and so the in a way the very
reassuring answer that Aristotle gives
is that uh the best guarantee of
happiness that you can achieve in this
life is to try to be as moral as you can
be the moral person is in most cases the
happy person because happiness is a
state of character an activity of
character and it is as you said wisely
it's not exactly the same but its core
is morality it depends upon morality and
without being a moral person you can't
um consistently be a happy person but it
takes something more than that um the
you could say the formula is happiness
equals um character or morality plus
some uh external
support uh and whether that support is
money does you don't have to be rich to
be happy but you have to be um modestly
or moderately wealthy at least to be so
and it helps uh as well but also just in
General Good Fortune you know that you
have enough of the bodily Goods like
health and the external Goods like
friends and uh and money and other and
things some other things like that to
live a complete and uh and
self-sufficient as Aristotle would say
happy life right that sometimes people
say money can't buy happiness but it can
buy a jet ski and have you ever seen an
unhappy person on J which actually
probably many of us have so you need
some measure of material wealth just to
sustain yourself and you mentioned
friendship yes which I obviously agree
with but there are many people who are
Hardline
individualists self-reliant kind of
people who say I don't really need
friends why why what if if I'm virtuous
if I'm moral if I'm not dissolute and
I've got enough money to sustain myself
why does a happy man need friends
well because man is a social animal and
and a political animal as Aristotle says
famously and that means that uh to be
happy uh to be self-sufficient is not to
be isolated or to have just enough to
live on um by yourself it means to be
able to share your life with friends
with family with a city that has good
laws understands human nature and that
these things are not optional but that
they are constituents really of a life
that one would want to call happy which
would be an enviable life a life that
you would choose that is in some ways
blessed in other words you have to have
all of these ingredients in order to
enjoy Good Fortune as a human being as a
political animal and you need them also
in order to enjoy the greatest of Good
Fortune which is to live at happy life
okay then I we've got all the
ingredients here for the happy life so I
I want to go through them because
Aristotle tells me just be a moral
person and that that'll take you a long
way there okay well how am I a moral
person what do I have to do when we
think of morality we tend to think of
limits on action Thou shalt
not um you know Thou shalt not steal
Thou shalt not commit adultery and so
forth and Aristotle is aware of all that
but for him morality is uh and happiness
building on morality is a kind of
fulfillment so it's using all of your
faculties in a moral way and in a and in
a way that makes for a happy life so
it's being courageous it's being
moderate it's being generous it's being
just it's practicing all of the virtues
uh and that takes great effort The Twist
that he introduces is that moralt virtue
this whole new domain of Human
Excellence is essentially uh attainable
by habit you can habituate yourself or
you can be habituated since most of us
don't do it to ourselves it's our
parents it's the authorities in the
schools and in the city or whatever that
uh who help us uh along in this way um
but it but by going through the motions
committing just acts one becomes just um
and that means that it's really open to
a lot of
human types A lot of uh Strivers of one
kind or another who want to um uh lift
themselves up from unhappiness but also
from you might say the the most vulgar
kinds of pleasure and uh uh activity
right this would seem to be an inversion
of what a lot of people think about
being a good person they'll say look I
abuse all sorts of drugs I cheat on my
girlfriend all the time I'm a complete
degenerate but deep down I'm a really
good person you know you don't
understand all of the things that I do
might not be great but deep down I'm a
good person Aristotle says no the the
morality The Virtue is in the habit yes
and and that it's not merely enough to
do a good action the most striking part
going back through the nicoman ethics to
me in the year of Our Lord 2023 is the
four types of virtuous person I guess
you'd say that that he describes the
first is not virtuous at all the
self-indulgent person who does bad
things and he's totally unrepentant and
he gets a real kick out of it next up is
the incontinent person the person who
who knows that he should be doing good
things but he keeps doing bad things
right right then the continent person
who knows he should be doing good things
and basically avoids doing the bad
things but only through a real exercise
of Will and endurance yes and then I
think for most people that's where they
think it stops they don't realize that
there's this extra category frankly even
I in my wayward youth didn't realize
there was this category of person called
The Virtuous person who does good things
and enjoys doing the good things right I
I'm not sure I even thought that was
possible and that that's why uh pleasure
is attached to Virtue and to happiness
the test of of when you are genuinely
virtuous and not just going through the
motions because someone else is making
you or will punish you if you don't play
fair um is that you take pleasure in
playing fair you're not you're not
forced to do it it's not the pain
attending playing unfairly that you fear
it's that you wouldn't dream of playing
uh dishonestly because you
enjoy uh playing honestly you pride
yourself on playing honestly you hold
yourself to those high standards and you
have in a way taught yourself to enjoy
it even when you lose playing Fair
playing well uh bring pleasure to
and that's that's virtue this is a theme
that I notice throughout the whole book
which is that whenever Aristotle asks
okay well what's the what's the best way
to exercise this kind of virtue whatever
it is courage this or that what is
courage what is Justice what is it very
often tends to be not one extreme or
another but the mean right moral virtue
you can say there are three components
of it one is precisely um the mean which
will come to the other is habituation
which we were talking about and the
third is that it's
voluntary uh that is that you can choose
it uh you can choose to act
virtuously uh or viciously and that it
is it's possible it's attainable for
more or less ordinary uh people or at
least many Ordinary People if not if not
most um but the mean is a very useful
teaching device before you're
virtuous uh and and the philosophy of
the mean is simply that you know
Aristotle describes it for each of the
moral virtues that he talks about and
there are 10 10 to 12 of them depending
on how you count friendship um there's a
uh a golden mean in the middle which is
the virtue and then there's an excess
and a defect which are the vices so The
Virtue let's say is courage
too much of the spirited bravery that
would would be a virtue is the vice of
um rashness or audacity too little of it
is cowardice so in a way this is because
the virtue varies according to the
situation that you're in this is another
thing that people will find odd perhaps
about Aristotle's account of virtue
there aren't categorical imperatives
there aren't hard and fast rules there
are no formulas exactly The Virtuous
thing to do will depend on the
circumstances under a certain set of
circumstances uh let's say you're a
soldier on the battlefield um the
courageous thing to do is charge the
enemy and die bravely but under a
slightly different set of circumstances
the brave thing to do might be to
surrender if your unit is defending an
indefensible position and that which has
no strategic significance and the enemy
is mild enough to perhaps treat you well
and so forth it would be vicious of you
to waste the lives of yourself and your
men it would be courageous to risk the
uh you know the disapprobation of people
back home uh by surrendering but it
might be the moral thing to do under the
circumstances similarly what is it to be
generous or liberal it depends on the
circumstance I mean it's possible to to
give wrongly y to the wrong person for
the wrong reason in the wrong way
generous acts may seem very ungenerous
depending on the circumstances so what
do you need to know you need to have
experience this is Aristotle's way to
explain it you need to have experience
with doing generous or courageous acts
many times in many different sets of
circumstances and in that way you learn
learn to think morally um that is to to
think
prudently because it takes a while but
in book six one of the ethics one
discovers that you C you need a little
bit of intellectual virtue to be morally
virtuous you don't need theoretical
wisdom you don't need philosophy as such
but you need Prudence you need practical
wisdom which comes
from experience itself it it is shaped
by having to choose many times in
different moral um circumstances well I
love this keeps recurring in the book
where he says it would be ridiculous to
try to U arrive at a principle with a
degree of precision that is not
appropriate to it that's right so you
have you have a certain degree of
precision expected and the one of the
examples he uses is the way that a a
geometer looks at a right angle and the
way that a carpenter looks at a right
angle they're they're both looking at
the same thing but for different
purposes and so you might have extreme
Precision for the geometer right the
carpenter doesn't need that it wouldn't
be appropriate for the carpenter to
waste his labor on it on that kind of
degree of precision so too in the moral
life and so too in politics yes um this
is what Leo Strauss called the wise
inexactness of
Aristotle life is full of inexact um
choices to be made uh you can't reason
mathematically or scientifically or
deductively in all circumstances and
certainly not in moral circumstances and
so you have to be uh you have to acquire
experience at looking at the finding the
mean in many different situations and
figuring out in this situation it's
courageous to fight to the end but in
another situation it may be courageous
to surrender rather than waste the lives
of your men probably the most important
part well vir which is pretty important
but at least one of the two most
important parts of this book for for a
modern day reader and most shocking I
think is on friendship because you see
everywhere throughout all of social
science which I generally doubt but I'll
cite it when it serves my purposes uh we
see this collapse in Friendship we see
people are lonely they're alienated
collapse in marriage for that matter but
especially in Friendship especially
among men a lot of people say I don't
have any friends and Aristotle reminds
us many people today don't even know
what a friend is right and he identifies
three kinds of
friends frankly only two of which most
people seem to be aware of right so he
talks about friendship based on
utility uh a friend who's useful to you
like and this can be like a business
associate uh or it could be uh you know
um someone who's cooking you enjoy um
also friendship based upon a virtue
which is sort of the highest um category
and and friendship based on Pleasure and
for him the the the steadiest the most
constant and satisfying form of
friendship is among good men and women
good human beings with one another and
that's a friendship based upon virtue
and in which your friend is really
another self to you I mean uh it's uh uh
it's a it's more important really than
Justice he says because people who have
friendship don't need Justice uh and so
in in a in a political and this will
also strike modern Americans perhaps as
as uh hopeless or uh or too hopeful and
that is um you know a city strives for
civic friendship ought to strive for
civic friendship even more than for
justice because you want you want
citizens to love one another in some
sense and not simply to respect one
another's rights or your obligations to
them you want to befriend them you want
to enjoy them uh and and they you and
and that I think as I say may strike
people as too hopeful uh in divided
times but it it isn't really because I
think the disappointment that Americans
feel at the divisions in our own Society
um reflected difference in opinion about
what Justice is but more than that it
just reflects a kind of um alienation
from each other and impatience and
otherness in one another which we
experience as very unpleasant and very
um difficult to to handle and and that's
I think because we we are meant to be
more than simply just to one another in
a in a Civic sense and especially within
families of course as you mentioned and
and you see the same kind
of collapse within the family and the
same kind of creeping legalism and U
dryness I suppose right U so part of
that is because people view friendship
as just you and your college buddies
going out and getting hammered at the
bar you pleasure or of utility well so
and so is he's going to get me a really
nice business deal he's my friend is
but for that third one the true
friendship which is only possible
between good men it's not bad men cannot
have a a good friendship Is it is it
possible that that has also collapsed
because people now doubt the the very
existence of the
good um that may be a component of it I
suspect that there are other more
mundane ones though for example for
Aristotle really good friends have to
spend time together you you have to know
each other in order to trust each other
uh and in order to as you come to know
each other you sort of discover deeper
similarities and deeper
affinities um uh modern people Americans
in particular are so busy and they move
around so much that many of our
friendships are electronically
maintained now over Zoom or the phone or
something uh but but that is from point
of view very thin um grul you know for
friendship it's not enough really to
sustain friendship there's something
about us that is naturally face Toof
face and involves living with the other
person you know seeing them more often
than once a year or you know once a even
once a month probably uh so we've um
become so mobile and so commercial in
many ways that uh we don't invest in
friends and our life is not built to
make friendship easier it's it it really
makes friendship harder uh and that's um
terrible thing to overcome I think
there's one more word that I have it's
not a chapter it's not a book there's
one word I have to ask you about it's
this word that crops up
udonia which is the word for happiness
which is what the whole book is about
right I don't have ancient Greek I but
is does that refer to a
demon yes it it literally means good
Demon um I've never met one of those in
my life but it's What happiness is so
it's it emphasizes the Blessed component
that is that you need a certain Good
Fortune um Divine favor if you want to
call it that that makes you healthy that
you know that gives you these bodily and
uh external Goods in addition to Goods
of the Soul
um which are important for happiness
stoics and all sorts of later
philosophers would maintain that
happiness is entirely a state of mind
and so famous stoic Paradox you know the
philosopher who is under uh torture and
in and body is racked with pain
nevertheless is entirely and happy
through this experience and Aristotle
would say that's crazy uh no because
happiness is your state of mind and
character but it's also the state of
your body and the real Goods of uh like
health and freedom from Pain and and uh
and friends and other things uh which uh
go into happiness and you can't you
can't neglect that exterior component of
it which centers in basically a kind of
uh you know thank God I'm healthy thank
god um uh you know I have these great
friends and this is what I love so much
about Aristotle maybe more than any
other philosopher is he doesn't allow
his ideas to run away with him and take
him away from reality so you know he
won't say you don't need any money you
just need to contemp he'll say well
little little money's good you know
little money's you don't need to worry
about your body just have your head in
the sky and fall into a ditch somewhere
now say no you've got to eat no no
that's right and he even I mean on the
question of money so he has he divides
generosity into two virtues one is
ordinary generosity you know liberality
but there's also what he calls
magnificence and this is a virtue that
requires bucks big I mean a big gift not
podcast money we're talking real money
to to be capable of that this is very
anti-christian of course for I mean from
the Christian point of view the Widow's
might is more valuable than the millions
given by
uh the you know the rich guy but uh from
aros's point of view very practical and
as you say Common Sense point of view if
you can give you know um a building or a
college or something if you have the
resources to do that that's a a special
subdivision of um uh generosity which is
meant to be impressive it's it's meant
you know in a social animal to impress
other social animals uh and but also to
do good right it's not it's not
just to to be a peacock or something
like that it's it it might have that
effect but it it is appropriate to the
public and so when you pick up the tab
right that's generous that's liberal
when you donate the new library that's
that's magnificent and does improve our
good or or is conducive to our good
because we're the political animal
that's right that's right it's a
hopeful note to end on that uh one could
have this Clash of things and not have
the society completely fall apart little
tough looking around our society right
now which seems to have forgotten a lot
of these lessons but perhaps then it's a
a reason for people to pick up the book
because as you say he keeps coming back
to look this is natural this is the way
man is this is even even in the examples
where he says this is the nature of
courage or this is the nature of that or
this is why such and such virtue is
better than another one
he says you might disagree with me here
but you know come on you know it's true
and he mixes what I guess we would call
theoretical knowledge book learning with
common sense yes to all throughout the
book it's a great compendium of Common
Sense and Uncommon Sense uh so it's uh
it is a very humanizing book and and a
wonderful book to read at any age I
think now before I let you go I've got
to ask you one last question question
that he kind of tacks on there and the
whole the whole book He's zigging and
then I get a little zag at the end which
is the book seems so practical it seems
so political it seems so active and then
right by the end he says but the best
life is the contemplative life yes
where' that come from when you as
Aristotle does in basically invent the
category of of practice and practical
life and practical virtue morality and
moral virtue all of that fits together
you you allow moral virtue to be more
moral and you allow intellectual virtue
to become more intellectual than Plato
allows them because he tries to make
them one thing virtue equals knowledge
for him but the downside of virtue
equals knowledge is that it destroys
indignation yeah um and the advantage of
Aristotle is that it allows you to
preserve indignation by saying there are
things he should have known uh um that
he is responsible for not knowing and
they're not necessarily philosophical
things at all it's uh many common sense
things about the um equality and the
character of other human beings Visa
yourself and what Justice is and what
moderation is needless to say um and
these things uh have a kind of Integrity
that Aristotle is trying to establish
and preserve um but the same time
intellectual activity has a kind of
Integrity uh which applies to questions
that are not subject to human variation
and human change so astronomy cosmology
physics these are these are Realms of
theoretical wisdom about subjects that
are not changeable like happiness and
morality and action of human beings
and so partly as a result of this when
you say some of those are changeable and
some are not meaning my moral State my
whether I'm virtuous or whether I'm
happy that could change day by day the
stars are are fixed in the way that they
move yes and so you uh morality is a a
practical science because it aims at
action things that you will choose to do
or not choose to do but the the Stars
the the laws of physics one might say
these things are not changeable by our
choice we have to understand them um and
understanding them means in effect
contemplating them and that's
contemplative virtue which in its own
sphere is uh Sovereign but it uh Human
Action morality the happy life these are
things that are within our power to
affect by our choices that makes makes
sense and speaking of the heavens you
even think of the vision that we have of
God which I think
Aristotle UND saw glimpses of even
though he lived long time ago in a very
Greek Pagan culture but but God you know
doesn't go and mow the lawn God God no
right you know contemplates and so if if
we were to suggest that the more more
and mere human Endeavors Were Somehow
greater than that we would be making
ourselves higher than God yes that's his
View at least um God is not um uh
conscious of
particulars uh he's concerned with
things that that are always and and uh
everywhere the same uh human beings are
by virtue of Being Human Beings we live
in a world of particulars as well as a
world of unchanging scientific Truth uh
and so we have to uh be concerned with
um particulars of action and character
and so forth the Christian God is being
a an otherworldly God
who condescends to enter this world
begotten consubstantial with God the
father and fully human as well yes well
I I suppose we might have to have you
back on to to go over that book you know
that that's that's a much bigger book
that's a much bigger book than this
there's a lot of good stuff in here you
know what has been conducive to my
happiness Charles this very conversation
thank you for coming on the show thank
you it's it's good to have you as a
friend it is truly a good and truly
virtuous aspect of my life is your
friendship and your viewership thank you
so much for watching the show I'm
Michael nolles this is the book club
we'll see you next
time thank you so much for watching this
episode of the book club on Prager U
prageru is a 501c3 nonprofit
organization so we rely on donations
from viewers like you to keep this
content on the air please consider
making a tax deductible contribution
today to help keep this content coming
thank you very
much
