Religion in 16th Century Mexico: Aztec & Catholic Beliefs and Practices

Explore History
10 followers
18 Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
Come explore the development of religion as transferred from Spain to what has become Mexico at a time when both were organized through devotion to family and community. Claassen will share how these two cultures melded from Zacatecas to Oaxaca.
Cheryl Claassen earned her Ph.D. at Harvard and is now a research professor of anthropology at Appalachian State University. She focuses on the symbolism of art and culture.
Comments are disabled for this video.
I never held a microphone while I spoke, so this could be a bit of a gymnastics thing here.
I'm going to talk today about the first 50 years of Catholicism in Mexico, and this is
known as the Primitive Church Era, from 1524 to 1574.
It's so named because it resembles the first two decades of Christianity in Europe.
Imagine a blank landscape, lots of opportunity to preach, nobody but disciples running around
the landscape.
As you know, the Aztecs are a series of lineages that all claim descent from a homeland called
Aztlan, and all of them left Aztlan and headed southward.
We don't know where Aztlan is.
Moved southward, and many of them dropped out along the way in the states of Zacatecas
and Hidalgo, and went on down to Tlaxcala and Puebla.
Those Aztec lineages you know as Chichimex, Tarascans over in Michoacan, the Otomi, Huichol,
and then down to the right of the Basin of Mexico in the south we have the Cholulans
and the Tlaxcaltecans and some others.
Some of the groups went on down into the Basin of Mexico such as the Xochimilco and the Mexica.
The most famous of these groups are the Mexica, and they're the ones who are generally referred
to as the Aztecs.
As the Aztecs migrated, as the Mexica migrated southward, they left Aztlan last, and as they
migrated southward they went through their, sorry, yes, I've got to learn to do all of
this.
They went through various kin groups and adopted from the Huastec, which are actually not Aztec,
an Aztec group, but adopted from the Huastec and then from the Otomis and the Chichimex
several ceremonies and cults that you may know them for.
For instance, the cult of the New Fire, the cult of all the Polque gods, the cult of the
Arrow Sacrifice, the cult of Quetzalcoatl, the cult of Zipitotec, and deities related
to cotton, as well as adopting the solar calendar and the double pyramid style.
When they got on down into the Basin of Mexico, the Mexica were influenced by other groups
that were there, including other kin-related Aztec groups, and there they adopted the
Tlaloc cult, agriculture, and cults of various corn deities.
By the mid-15th century, the Basin of Mexico was ruled by three city-states.
One of these was Tenochtitlan, the Mexica capital, and under the center of Mexico City
today.
The Mexica capital of Tenochtitlan was larger than any city in Europe at the time.
The Mexica had a full solar calendar, festival solar calendar, and a professional priesthood,
as well as written documents and social stratification exactly like that in Europe.
Elite lineages, elite communities.
In 1454, after three years of alternating drought and floods, the Mexica high priest
elevated the deity of Huitzilopochtli and its cult known for human sacrifices to be
the principal Mexica deity, and ordered a tripling of the human sacrifices in order
to bring the weather problems to an end.
Whereas Tlaloc and numerous other deities were the cults of the farmers, Huitzilopochtli
was the cult for the elite.
Within the 18 20-day festivals of the solar year, there were only three to Huitzilopochtli
in 1521, reflecting his newcomer status.
The 15th century for Spanish Catholics was even more eventful.
Now I'm talking about the centuries before the two groups meet.
The 15th century for Spanish Catholics was even more eventful than what I've just told
you for the Mexica.
Official doctrine expanded to include the adoption of the rosary, the adoption of purgatory,
of indulgences, of the immaculate conception of Mary inside her mother Anne, and saw an
explosion of popular cults of Mary, often in the form of apparitions, such as Our Lady
of Guadalupe, which reappeared in Spain in the 1300s.
In the late 1400s, many Spanish church leaders believed that Christ's return would occur
in the 16th century, and that a Spanish king would be the restorer of Jerusalem.
And that moved from Charles V to Philip II, and then they gave up on that idea.
And they also believed that the Pope would be the antichrist.
Columbus believed it was his mission to secure the wealth needed for the restoration of Jerusalem,
and to open up an avenue for all the unbaptized of the world to be baptized before the second
coming.
That brings us to 1517, and the start of a rebellion by German Catholics.
Many of the complaints raised by Martin Luther had been circulating among European Catholics
for decades and even centuries.
With the discovery of the New World, Spanish Catholics in particular settled on a new possibility
for getting it right, for creating a pure Catholicism free from all the complaints that
Martin Luther had raised and many of them shared.
Spain itself would not permit any other religion in its boundaries until the 20th century,
and Latin America would become the greatest Catholic success.
Cortes embarked over land in 1519 from the coast of Veracruz.
This is the first chapel that he built in La Antigua, Veracruz.
You can still see his home, a home, a temporary home, and this chapel if you go to La Antigua
in Veracruz.
Throughout the journey, the groups that Cortes met and then subdued saw him and the Spaniards
as liberators from the hated Mexica.
The attitude among Native Americans, whether they're in Mexico or North America or South
America, the attitude among Native American elites was that one should have as the principal
patron of the lineage the most powerful deity.
For many of these lineages, it was at the time of contact Mishkawai, the old fire god.
As the Spaniards subdued the Totonacs, then the Tlaxcaltecans, and then the mighty Mexica,
elites were eager to adopt the god of the Spaniards.
You see here, this Tlacopan was one of the Triple Alliance cities.
In the Basin of Mexico, and you see here this symbolism of the Tlacuani, the king of Tlacopan
embracing Christianity, wading out into the water and embracing Christianity.
The hole in the globe signifies the incomplete baptism of the world's peoples.
Go to the next one.
Here you see the Tlacuanis of the various different groups that you know of, like the
Totonacs and the Mexica and the Mixtecs and the Zapotecs and many other groups holding
the flags of their various diocese.
They reportedly were quite worried about getting the prayers and the ritual action correct.
Many anthropological interviews with native ritual specialists or their audiences say
that the understanding is not important, that the god expects, the deity expects to hear
a rhythm and sounds and smoke and things.
It doesn't matter that you understand what you're doing.
It doesn't matter that you understand what the new god, what you're saying, you need
to understand what the god wants.
These elite native peoples expressed a lot of concern to the Spanish missionaries.
Were they getting it right?
The Catholics are worried about getting it right and the native peoples are worried about
getting it right too.
The first step to baptism for Franciscans, Dominicans and Augustinians, starting in 1524,
and this is a period of course of adult baptism, was to get everybody legally married, church
married, not legally, but church married so that they could then be baptized.
They required then that in these polygynous elite families that the elite male choose
one woman to be his wife and send away all the others.
There are reports of many elites moving beyond the reach of the missionaries so that they
didn't have to do this.
Nevertheless, thousands of couples, sometimes whole lineages, were married then baptized
in a weekend in some missions.
The missionaries applied a centuries old Catholic expansion strategy of establishing the main
church in the largest native city and calling that a doctrina.
Then in secondary tribute cities to that larger city, they would establish visitas that had
to be visited at least once a month by the missionaries.
Or better yet, forcing the native communities to relocate to some place much more convenient
to the missionaries.
They would force them to move by burning down their villages.
Creating new communities that the native peoples built themselves, they built the towns and
they built the churches.
Creating these new communities was called reductions or congregation programs.
The last one of these ended in 1602.
Both Aztecs and Catholics experienced religion through cult membership.
This is a major aspect of the assimilation of Catholicism in Mexico and elsewhere in
the New World.
Franciscans had cults in the form of brotherhoods to different advocations of Mary, particularly
the Immaculate Conception, as well as San Miguel and San Francisco.
Dominicans favored Dominic and the Rosary.
Both Aztecs and Catholics had professional celibate priesthoods with required schooling
and with acolytes.
A religious festival calendar with participation required of the populace, a covenant with
a patron deity, shrines, processions, religious songs, dances, and music, secret religious
knowledge, and a remote religious language.
Both cultures awaited an imminent apocalyptic ending.
Both had the sacraments of baptism from the same idea of filth at birth, communion, and
confession.
For instance, confession.
Confession was practiced by many Native American groups throughout the Americas long before
the Spanish showed up.
Mexica held confessional events twice a year.
In front of Xochiquetzal's image, people pierced their tongues once for each of their regrets
or sadnesses, and the priests collected the thorns and then burned them.
The penitents then took a ritual bath and ate maize dough with honey, which represented
the body of the goddess of Xochiquetzal.
Next slide.
Professional priests and trainees confessed and did penance daily.
Once in a lifetime, one could confess before the goddess Tlazoltlaloc for drunkenness,
a capital crime, if committed a second time or not confessed.
The difference between the Native rite of confession and that introduced by the Catholics
was, of course, for the Catholics, there was a never-ending list of sins for which you
never got to stop confessing.
For both groups, confession preceded penance.
The Franciscans in New Spain introduced weekly confession for church-married natives in 1526,
two years after arriving.
Quizzing them on the Articles of Faith, the Ten Commandments, seven moral sins, the Pater
Noster, Ave Maria, the Creed, the Salve Regina, all, of course, in a foreign language.
Confessional manuals were quickly prepared in Native picture conventions and were often
created to probe the kinds of sinful activities the natives were continuing.
One confessional manual had 180 questions.
Another had 52.
Men and women were asked different questions.
Contrition was expected and was measured by tears.
Missionaries at the beginning of the 16th century considered the natives of the New
World to be the world's most pure people, the most godly people on earth, because of
their poverty and because of their lack of awareness of European sins or their lack of
inculcating European sins.
For this reason, missionaries sought to keep the sin-filled Spaniards away from the people.
All doctrinas in 1550 were declared Indian republics in which no Spaniard could stay
more than three nights.
Mission schools trained native scribes, clerks, lay workers, and spies.
Missionaries refused to teach natives Spanish.
Missionaries advocated for native rights, particularly against slavery and with the
encomenderos, and they conducted all religious teaching in native languages.
At first only spoken Nahuatl and picture books, but fairly quickly also Otomi, Mixtec, and
Zapotec.
Incredibly, the Franciscan friar Andres de Olmos produced the first Nahuatl grammar book
in 1547, the first Totonac grammar sometime before 1554, and the first Huastec grammar
sometime before 1571.
Several Nahuatl speakers had been taken to Spain in the 1520s, and they resided in the
monasteries so that the prospective missionaries could learn Nahuatl before they came.
By 1525, three years after Cortes has conquered the Aztecs, the Mexica, by 1525 the Spaniards
believed they had crushed the cult of Huitzilopochtli, ending its human sacrifice and priesthood,
and dismantling the pyramid shrines to Huitzilopochtli in the region's cities, such as the Templo
Mayor in Tenochtitlan.
The agricultural cults dedicated to Tlaloc, Chalchitlicu, and the Polpe gods were still
intact in 1600.
These were the deities and the cults of the agricultural peoples.
These agricultural communities were too widespread and the farmers too independent to do much
damage to these cults of the commoners.
The missionaries were constantly worrying that the natives were surreptitiously hiding
their old cultic practices among the new Catholic ones.
When they swept, when they wove, when they danced or sang or made offerings.
It didn't help that the native pyramids were torn down and the same rocks used to construct
a Catholic church upon the same foundations, whatever its orientation, thus incorporating
the native landscape alignments that invoked native deities and sacred calendrics.
This also violated the east-west alignment principle of Catholic churches.
Perforce, the native stone workers, native painters, and native musicians adorned the
new buildings and embellished the mass and funerals, all arenas for idolatry.
A quick examination of a couple of the other shared theological concepts will reveal the
slippery slope observed by the missionaries.
Afterlife.
For the Aztecs, death was the passage from this world to the disorderly underworld.
The geography of the afterlife for all Aztecs consisted of several destinations for the
soul.
The western sky for women who died in childbirth.
The eastern sky for warriors who died on the sacrificial stone or of a ripe old age.
Tlalocan for those dying a watery death, and that includes some diseases like emphysema
and pulmonary problems and drowning, and Mi'klan for everybody else.
The destiny was determined by the cause of death, not the way of life.
Reincarnation, primarily through name and physical likeness, was anticipated.
Those going to Mi'klan spent four years traversing the seven levels between earth and Mi'klan.
The living assisted them during that time with annual food offerings, but after the
four year transition, that relationship between the living and the dead ended.
For medieval Christians, the geography of the afterlife consisted of heaven, purgatory,
and hell.
Once destination was securely tied to the life lived on earth, Roman Catholics believed
that the masses died in a state of spiritual imperfection and had to go to purgatory first,
where sins were slowly cleansed, primarily through indulgences bought by the living.
A good death might speed up the process, and a good death meant suffering or agonizing
sufficiently long in order to obtain some repentance and pardon of sins.
Catholics could expect to spend an eternity in this waiting place, and the living with
a never-ending obligation to the dead in the form of these indulgences.
In 16th century Mexico, the native infant who had gone to paradise was now perpetually
placed in limbo.
The earning or purchasing of indulgences, which were so important in the Catholic European
experience, were denied to natives in the New World.
Mi'klan was cast as hell, and Tlalocan was absorbed into Eden.
Communion.
Eating flesh by Aztecs.
When I say Aztecs, I mean all of these lineages, not just the Mexica.
Eating flesh by Aztecs is depicted in codices and was done in a highly charged religious
context during three religious feasts.
Priests were the consumers among the Tarascans, while Mexica priests, merchants, and warriors
consumed their own captives' flesh after ritual sacrifice.
Rarely did the populace at large eat human flesh.
Instead, they were given pieces of doughy images of the deities, Huixlapochtli and Xochiquetzal,
for instance, after consecrating with song and dances.
They believed that it was the body of the God that was passed out, and it was received
with great awe, fear, and weeping.
For the 15th and 16th century Catholics, the sacrament of communion was thought to strengthen
one's spiritual life and move one toward spiritual maturity.
It was administered usually at Easter and only after confession, and frequently only
the priest in Europe consumed wine.
In Mexico, the Tarascans were the first to be given communion.
These are the Puropetro Tarascans over in Michoacán.
The Augustinians were the most open to giving Indians communion and gave it much more readily
to Nahuatl than to Otomans, believing the Otomans to be of inferior intelligence.
Dominicans offered communion only to native members of the Rosary Brotherhoods, and only
at Easter or when bravely ill.
In general, Franciscans only admitted to communion a handful of Indians.
No one was given wine, and tortillas were the host.
The refusal to give communion to natives, which is considered the greatest gift, Catholic
or Christian gift, the refusal to give communion to natives was condemned by popes and archbishops
and theologians alike, although ignored.
From my perspective, the primitive church era in New Spain is largely one of a series
of aspirational failures in four important ways.
This one here, the failure to recruit Spanish monks.
Many men who volunteered for the New Spain mission in the first two decades of the mission
activity did it because they either wanted to further the goal of baptizing all the world's
peoples before the apocalypse, or because they wanted to die a martyr's death.
Missionaries in the New World in this first 50 years were gravely disappointed.
Many of these men had joined orders in Spain that valued contemplation, brotherhood, silence,
poverty, scholarship.
None of that was possible in the New World except for poverty.
Typically two men were placed in each doctrina and were left to school the elite boys, marry,
baptize, hold mass, see the funerals, and visit each visita, sometimes three a weekend.
This is all on foot, carrying whatever food they could manage to drum up from the native
population in their mission.
In the lowlands, missionaries were dying from diseases.
The army expanded the Catholic domain at a ceaseless pace, spreading the orders thinner
and thinner.
The Mexican head of the Franciscans sent a mandate and a quota to the monasteries in
Spain, send men to New Spain, but to no avail as the Protestant revolt and news of the mission
experience in New Spain deterred men, and the new Jesuit order founded in 1536 attracted
a lot of men who might have come to the Franciscan order instead.
Franciscans had 80 monasteries in Mexico in 1559 and only 30 friars.
The head of the Franciscans proclaimed in 1581 that all friars in New Spain needed to
recapture their commitment to recollection and withdrawal, so he ordered the building
of hermitages and removed the men from administrating sacraments, teaching, or visiting villages,
abandoning many native communities.
Neither the Dominicans nor the later Jesuits had the same focus on prayer and hermitic
lifestyle as did the Franciscans.
Next slide.
The failure of the orders to maintain control of the religious life of the natives.
The archbishops of Mexico.
Catholicism is divided into secular priests who answer to bishops and archbishops and
are funded by tithes, and the religious are those people who withdraw to cloistered or
something like cloistered life, and they don't answer to an archbishop, a bishop or an archbishop,
and they are funded by royal grants by kings and queens and some by businesses like beer
and wax candles and things like that.
The archbishops of Mexico, so representing the seculars, pressured the religious orders
to hand oversight of native Christian life to the secular priests.
Isabella and Ferdinand had given the religious life, control of religious life in New Spain
to the orders, not to the seculars, with a promise that at some point down the line the
seculars would replace the religious orders in daily spiritual life.
So the archbishops of Mexico, several of them in succession, pressured the religious to
hand oversight of native Christian life to the secular priests.
These men of the orders had long claimed that the secular priests who in New Spain served
the Spaniards, worked with civil authorities and ran businesses, that the secular priests
knew no native languages, had no interest in village life, had no interest in natives,
and it would greatly harm the native population to relinquish their missions and their missionary
activities to the seculars.
Since the seculars collected tithes for living expenses and at funerals, baptisms, and weddings,
tithing would further impoverish the Indians.
An order in 1574 finally elevated the seculars over the orders and guaranteed the seculars
a salary, but many Franciscans managed to drag out the transition for another 65 years.
The failure to incorporate native peoples into the religion, I'll go to the next slide.
The Franciscans opened a school to train native men in 1533, Tlatelolco, and that's the church
that you see overlooking the Aztec ruins of Tlatelolco.
They gave up in 1574.
Next slide.
The Protestant revolt was met by the church with the Council of Trent, which lasted from
1545 to 1563.
The Council of Trent considered all the complaints that the German Catholics had raised and rejected
all of them, reified the cult of the saints, reified marriage as a sacrament, even though
it's not in the Bible, and came down hard on controls for keeping paganism out of Catholic
practices.
The impact of the Trent meetings in Mexico on missionaries and natives was profound.
In order to stamp out the influence of native beliefs and practices on Catholicism in Mexico,
Rome ordered a stop to all textual production in native languages, prohibited the handling
of Catholic texts by natives, forbid all native dances, songs, and music and festivals on
church property or in doctrinas, ordered all artworks, carvings, murals produced by natives
in the churches destroyed, and mandated only Latin mass and Latin song lyrics.
So the natives are cut out of understanding anything that's going on.
And let's go to the next one then, the failure to convert.
None other than Bernardino Sahagun, who oversaw the creation of the Florentine Codex, penned
in a lament in the 1570s, it seems to me the Catholic faith can endure little time in these
parts. Of those who come to confess, very few respond properly prior to the confession.
Thus we can be certain that though preached to more than 50 years, if they were now left
alone in less than 50 years, there would be no trace of the preachings which have been
done for them. And Rome seemed to recognize the same thing. The inquisition established
in Europe to judge Catholic clergy, and then later any Catholic, was forbidden to try Native
Americans after 1571 because they did not know enough to be held accountable.
There are several reasons for the failure to convert. The huge language barrier, the
inability of too few priests to cover so vast a terrain, the complicated concepts, the dramatic
exclusions created by the Council of Trent, the refusal of most religious to give communion
to natives, nor would they give last rites because they felt the homes were too filthy.
Another significant impediment to conversion was the change in 1583 from the Julian calendar
to the Gregorian calendar. The Gregorian calendar was all about bringing the calendar back into
alignment with solstices and equinoxes, the very points of the sacred solar calendar that
the Aztecs and other Native Americans were relying on. So now they're putting, for instance,
John the Baptist smack dab on summer solstice. To all of these hurdles, we must factor in
the huge population decline among the natives. At least 13 epidemics hit Mexico from 1521
to 1599, reducing 22 million people to 1.9 million people. This, in fact, caused what
many scholars are now calling the beginning of race thinking, theorizing the failures
of the brown body and why they succumb so significantly to these diseases. Many of the
churches built between 1530 and 1570 were abandoned by 1590, lacking any significant
Native population to preach to or to tend to the church buildings through the brotherhoods.
The growing population of Spaniards and blacks in the large cities of New Spain themselves
needed missionizing. The people of each new mission, whether it be Germany, Scotland,
Mexico, or the Philippines, found ways to ignore or combine or mask their prior beliefs,
giving each religion a distinctive Catholic, each region a distinctive Catholic flair.
Catholic policies in New Spain of accommodation, protection, and ultimately abandonment ensured
that new brands of Catholicism would develop among elite natives, farmers, and transplanted
Spaniards. Not the Christian utopia, nor pure Catholicism that had been envisioned by the
Spanish orders for the new world. And you do the last step.
I didn't realize you were finished. That was absolutely fascinating. A very enlightening
talk, and thank you so much. I don't have a gavel, but this meeting is adjourned.
