Empty buildings: Beijing and Shanghai are becoming ghost towns of the economy

China Lens
27 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 10, 2025
The three-year zero-out policy, along with the economic recession, has dealt a heavy blow to China's economy. Today, even major cities like Beijing and Shanghai are experiencing a severe recession, with few people in shopping malls and deserted streets.
The three-year zero-out policy, along with the economic recession,
has dealt a heavy blow to China's economy.
Today, even major cities like Beijing and Shanghai are experiencing a severe recession.
With few people in shopping malls and deserted streets,
the state of China's economy is clear at a glance.
Beijing resident Wang Li.
The overall economy is not doing well.
You don't have a job, you don't make money,
and people like us basically avoid spending money if we can?
We are all being frugal.
It's no longer the case that people spend money on festivals like they used to.
The Mid-Autumn Festival and National Day holiday are approaching,
but the market in Beijing remains very deserted.
An anonymous Beijing resident said,
no one understands the state of China's economy better than the Chinese people living in it.
Beijing resident Wang Li.
Everything has gone up in price.
For example, a bottle of vinegar.
It used to cost 9 yuan, but recently it has gone up to 14 yuan.
Jobs are being lost on a large scale,
prices are rising sharply,
wages are shrinking,
and the decline in consumer purchasing power has made life more difficult for businesses.
Beijing's Zhongguankun, once one of the city's most prosperous areas,
now has deserted streets, sparsely populated malls,
and only a few businesses and retail investors remaining in the science and trade mall.
Lihua.
Take Bukasong, which is near West Chang'an Avenue
and the organization department of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China.
Every time I return, since July of this year,
I find the number of stores there has sharply declined.
There are streets where, in just 10 days,
7 adjacent stores closed down Lihua,
who frequently travels between Beijing, Hebei, and other places,
has noticed that foreign-funded supermarkets in Beijing have mostly closed.
Lihua.
They've basically all closed down.
Carrefour's last store in Beijing was acquired.
Without Carrefour, Walmart is barely holding on in Beijing.
However, this phenomenon is not unique to Beijing.
Shanghai, China's economic center, is facing the same challenges.
Video shooter.
There are a lot of empty shops everywhere.
And this location is pretty good, right next to Yu Garden, but now it's like this.
Shanghai resident.
Shanghai used to be very lively at night, especially with shops along the street.
Some for eating, some for drinking, some for shopping.
Now, often after 8.30pm,
malls are already closing and it has become very quiet.
Due to the weak economy and slowing business activity,
many companies and workers have begun to move out of Shanghai and even out of China.
Shanghai resident.
I know the boss well, so I chatted with him.
He told me that many people who left Shanghai have never returned.
This was rare over the past 10 years.
Not only are a large number of shops closing,
but office buildings where white-collar workers used to gather are also becoming empty.
According to data from international real estate service provider Savills,
in the second quarter of this year,
the office building vacancy rate in Beijing was as high as 18.3%, a 13-year record.
According to data from CBRE, in the second quarter of this year,
the office building vacancy rate in Shanghai reached 18.7%,
Shenzhen 20.3% and Guangzhou 17.5%.
Commercial activity in China's four first-tier cities has shrunk almost simultaneously.
While some may avoid criticizing the Chinese economy openly,
it is in fact, the economy is in serious decline.
Difficult to find a job.
Young people in Beijing's labor market are scrambling for temporary work.
After college graduates face unemployment and encounter setbacks in their job search,
some rely on their parents' support and lie flat completely.
However, young people who cannot depend on their elders are forced into the daily wage industry.
To make a living, they gather in labor markets before dawn,
competing for temporary jobs that pay daily wages.
An investigative report published by Korean media outlet Chosun Ilbo on September 4
revealed the current situation at the Majuqiao labor market on the outskirts of Beijing.
Majuqiao is the largest labor market in North China,
where thousands of people eager to find job opportunities gather daily.
Due to the difficulty of finding stable employment,
more and more young people with higher education have recently flocked here,
competing with other migrant workers for jobs such as kitchen assistants,
cleaners, security guards, and other temporary positions that offer daily wages.
On September 3, the investigative reporter observed that by 4 a.m.
at the Majuqiao labor market in Beijing, many young people had already arrived.
Mr. Zheng, a 29-year-old interviewed at the scene,
said he has recently noticed many people younger than himself here.
Most of these young people are new, and when they first come, they are glued to their smartphones.
After failing a few times in this first-come, first-served environment,
they eventually lower their phones.
Mr. Zheng, who is from Baoding, Hebei province,
worked at a semiconductor equipment factory in Beijing two years ago,
earning a monthly salary of 6,500 yuan.
After losing his job, he now lives in a dormitory costing 20 yuan per day
and rushes to the labor market each morning to look for job opportunities.
Reports describe elderly vendors near the Majuqiao labor market selling thread gloves
for 2 yuan a pair and work shoes for 10 yuan a pair.
The main buyers are new young workers.
Every morning from 4 to 6 a.m., vans and buses pick up construction workers,
kitchen assistants, logistics center sorters, cleaners, and security guards.
The daily wages for these part-time workers generally range from 160 yuan,
with more physically demanding jobs like express delivery loaders paying over 200 yuan.
The report also revealed that, starting from the second half of this year,
wages for daily jobs in the Majuqiao labor market have mostly fallen to below 200 yuan.
However, the cost of accommodation in four-person rooms in the nearby
daily rental village has risen to about 20 yuan per day.
Near the labor market,
some people can be seen sleeping on the streets to save on accommodation costs.
The report noted that statistics released by the Chinese job search website Jiaopin
in November last year showed that 50% of temporary workers in China are under 25 years old.
Given the dramatic increase in the number of graduate students unable to find jobs,
the actual youth unemployment situation in China
is likely much more severe than official statistics indicate.
In 1990, China joined the WTO on the recommendation of the United States
with the promise of the world's most populous nation's potential.
After enduring a harrowing year of deep economic and political crises,
the nation had just experienced the tragic Tiananmen Square Massacre.
China needed a powerful impetus to transform its economy,
to ease the social tensions that had been brewing and were on the verge of exploding.
After 30 years of reform and opening up,
30 golden years with massive investment pouring into China's economy from around the world,
the country had changed.
It had altered its methods of production, changed its culture, and reshaped its national image.
Mega-cities and global landmarks sprouted across China.
Yet, the economy was still just the economy.
Fundamental and core issues in society remained unchanged.
As long as the system did not alter the backbone rules,
negative aspects within the society would persist and could become intensely severe.
The wealth gap, social divisions, were becoming increasingly pronounced.
From there, a new culture emerged, a culture of the era.
It was a culture that combined the living conditions and the dominant ideological system.
That culture was the party culture.
In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic officially brought an end to China's 30 years of economic growth.
Prior to this, the economic warfare between China and the U.S.
had caused many aspects of China's economy to decline,
but the COVID pandemic, coupled with the government's COVID policies,
marked the end of the Chinese dream.
The middle class had to tighten their spending and give up their extravagant lifestyles,
while those with lower incomes faced a real catastrophe.
The unemployment rate in China's urban areas increased by 6.2% in February,
a record high in recent decades.
However, it is believed that this figure does not fully reflect reality.
In March, the rate decreased slightly as businesses were allowed to reopen
as the pandemic was gradually brought under control.
Yet, the worst is yet to come.
People in major cities are struggling to maintain their daily lives,
while the poor are barely surviving, with some not even having the opportunity to try.
Data from China's Ministry of Commerce shows that foreign direct investment
FDI into China in September 2023 was recorded at 72.8 billion Chinese yuan
10 billion U.S. dollars, a 34% decrease compared to the same period the previous year.
This is the largest decrease since monthly figures began to be published in 2014.
China's balance of payments data also paints a bleak picture for foreign investment.
Financial inflows from foreign direct investment, FDI, a measure of foreign capital flowing into
China, reached 6.7 billion U.S. dollars in the second quarter of 2023.
This is the lowest level since 2000 and a drop from 21 billion U.S. dollars in the first quarter
of 2023. This recent decline contradicts the foreign investment boom that China had achieved
during the pandemic.
Brad Setzer, a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, noted,
the data suggests that foreign firms are no longer reinvesting in China.
Instead, they are moving profits out of China as quickly as they can.
Local governments, burdened by the real estate crisis and the cost of zero COVID policies,
are trying to attract foreign businesses to reinvest.
However, these efforts have stalled in the face of deteriorating diplomatic relations
with the U.S. and Western calls to minimize risk in the supply chain.
Regions in China that previously benefited from foreign investment are now seeking
alternative sources of financing. Companies are relying on government funding to replace
foreign investors. Corruption has become the specialty, and the essence, of modern China.
Capital inflows from foreign sources flow into the government system and then to the labor force
is only a small percentage before being laundered out of China.
One of the main aspects of the issue lies in the policy regarding different social classes.
When policies are based on the principles of the Communist Party,
the consequences can be anticipated.
After social classes have formed, the government provides a different policy system for different
classes. As a result, the poor, those with low incomes, and those in special circumstances
become more miserable. In 2022, the Communist Party of China emphasized that China has achieved
comprehensive victory in the battle against poverty. However, some scholars have revealed
that as many as 940 million people in China earn less than 2,000 Chinese Yuan per month,
over 800 million people are in debt, and more than 200 million people are unemployed.
Elderly farmers in rural China are receiving meager pensions,
which have become an increasingly serious economic and social issue in the context of
rapid urbanization and aging demographics in the world's most populous country.
According to the South China Morning Post, SCMP Chen Yunfeng, the head of Yansang Village in
Hainan Province, expressed disappointment at the hardships faced by elderly farmers in Chinese
society. He said, we grow grains, but the grains are very cheap, and we are getting older, but the
welfare is too little. A retired farmer in the village receives a monthly pension of about 112
Chinese Yuan, 16 US dollars, at the age of 60. This amount is very low, much less than the average
daily wage in Chinese cities, and far from sufficient to cover even a modest rural lifestyle.
It is also significantly lower than the national average monthly pension of 2,000 Chinese Yuan,
290 US dollars, paid to urban workers in retirement.
The issue of insufficient pension for rural residents in China is not new. A pension
system was guaranteed exclusively for urban residents across the country until 2009.
After that, President Hu Jintao and Premier Wen Jiabao began to establish a national pension
system for rural people. This pension varies depending on the region, but in general,
rural residents receive much less than urban residents in pensions.
For example, in Chinchou City in Hainan Province, the average pension under this program was only
243 Chinese Yuan per month in 2019, less than one-tenth of the average pension of 2,928 Chinese
Yuan under the program for urban company employees. In most rural areas of China,
elderly people have to continue to rely on their own labor, their children, or savings
in their later years. The lack of financial support and other assistance for elderly farmers
has become an increasingly serious economic and social issue in the context of rapid urbanization
and aging population. A horrifying incident in May highlighted the severity of this issue when
a man in Hunan Province attempted to bury his bedridden mother alive because she could not
care for herself and had become a burden. The 79-year-old woman was eventually rescued,
and the man was arrested. The case sparked a nationwide debate on who will care for the
growing number of elderly people in rural China. SCMP noted that young people from rural villages
are migrating to cities in large numbers in search of better job opportunities,
which means that they cannot be present to take care of their elderly relatives.
Harsh family planning policies over many decades have exacerbated this problem.
Currently, in rural areas, there are more elderly people than young people.
This trend is likely to continue as the government continues to promote urbanization.
Many elderly people, due to illness and not wanting to burden their children,
choose to end their lives quietly in an old house or in the wilderness, a forest, or by a river.
The locals are all too familiar with this situation.
Some people say that if they are over 70 years old, unable to care for themselves,
face economic difficulties, and their children are also struggling,
then the act of elderly people taking their own lives is considered a wise choice.
Elderly people committing suicide due to economic hardship may be because they have no money,
no pension, or only receive very meager pensions that are insufficient to support themselves.
They live very hard and tiring lives.
Li Qixiang said in a press conference after the conclusion of the National People's Congress,
the annual average disposable income per capita in China is 30,000 renminbi,
but there are 600 million people with low incomes and below average.
Their average monthly income is only about 1,000 renminbi.
Tragedy will continue to follow tragedy, and the poor exist in all societies, but in China,
the poor have nothing left to lose, only the basic characteristics of survival.
