The Bermuda Triangle: Real Danger or Sea Legend?

Decoding Loch Ness
7 followers
Hello, everybody, welcome back to another episode of Decoding the Unknown.
As always, I'm your host, Simon.
Welcome, welcome.
Katie wrote today's episode.
It's the Bermuda Triangle.
Real danger or sea legends?
I'm pretty sure the Bermuda Triangle is just something that where,
at least statistically, it's not actually that much more dangerous.
And it's just kind of people.
Anytime a ship sinks there or a plane crashes there, people are, oh, my God,
Bermuda Triangle.
But the chances of it crashing anywhere else are just about the same.
But I'm not sure that's why there's a video all about it written by Katie.
Thank you, Katie.
I've never read this before.
It's all new to me.
And then afterwards, Jen, our wonderful video editor,
is going to add in some music and some memes and all that sort of goodness.
Thank you, everybody. Let's get into it.
For me, the Bermuda Triangle has always existed in my mind
as something that's really there, a certain patch of the globe
where ships, planes and people go missing in mysterious circumstances.
Growing up in Surrey, England,
I occasionally wore probably ill-advised Bermuda shorts as a preteen,
but never gave the area they were named after much thought.
Well, Bermuda is a Bermuda is a real place, right?
There is a place called Bermuda, and I think it's in the Caribbean.
It's a British overseas territory.
Well, what do you know?
Well, you don't even care.
It is a real place and it is.
Oh, it's I guess it's in the Caribbean.
I mean, sort of.
It's kind of quite far off.
No, it's too high.
It's it's way out in the Atlantic Ocean.
I'd say it's about a fifth of the way to Europe from America
off the coast of the Carolinas, roughly at that latitude.
Fascinating stuff.
It looks quite nice, to be honest.
I'd visit Bermuda.
This was the early 90s.
So think of something geometric and luminous like fresh Princewood
rock, and you'll get the general idea.
This was probably then teamed with a global hyper color T-shirt
that I thought was the epitome of cool before hitting puberty
when it was embarrassing that your armpits were a different color
to the rest of your shirts.
Oh, my God, really?
I've never heard of these.
But that was fashion in the 90s.
Apparently, everybody different colored armpits.
Anyway, getting back to the point, I definitely was aware of the Bermuda
Triangle growing up without the Internet being a thing yet.
There really wasn't much cause me to question it or really think about it too much.
The information I did subconsciously glean must have been taken
must have been references taken from films, TV shows and quite possibly the news.
All of which is to say that I never had any particular reason to doubt
that the mysterious area was real until now.
Yep. At the ripe old age of slightly older than your charming host.
That's right.
I find myself taking my first ever deep dive into the mystery
of the Bermuda Triangle, and here is what.
I found.
So just for me, like I'll also give my impression as Katie gave hers
in my mind.
Also, as a kid growing up in the 90s, no Internet.
Apparently slightly younger than Katie is.
The Bermuda Triangle was a literal triangle
somewhere in the South America or the Caribbean to me,
like between three points, obviously fairly big area.
And for some reason, in my mind, there was a giant squid creature
that would drag boats down to the bottom of the ocean
and also planes somehow down from the air.
Obviously, my child brain, because, you know, it's a plane.
A giant squid can't just reach up and get it.
But that's what was going on.
And then later in my life, I assumed the Bermuda Triangle
was just a particularly dangerous stormy area.
And then at some point, either I made a video about this
or I read about this and I kind of I found out that statistically
it doesn't actually exist.
At least that's what I remember.
That's my wonderful history with the Bermuda Triangle.
You're welcome, everybody.
The mystery of the Bermuda Triangle.
The Bermuda Triangle is an area of ocean
that has long been connected to mystery.
While it's not an official region with definitive boundaries,
it's largely agreed to be an area in the Atlantic
with three points of the triangle being roughly Miami, Bermuda
and Puerto Rico.
That means like it's a weird triangle.
It's kind of a long triangle.
I know, I guess it could be because
I sort of a weird it's a weird shaped triangle.
This means it's difficult to calculate how much of an area it covers,
but at least it's at least 500,000 square miles
or nearly 1.3 million square kilometers.
For reference, that's slightly larger than South Africa,
but smaller than Alaska.
Brilliant.
Even going as far back as Christopher Columbus,
weird things have been reported happening on board ships
that enter this particular area of the Atlantic.
These tales have culminated in legends of ships
being swallowed by the ocean, boats and planes
just vanishing out of existence
without even transmitting a distress call
and even extraterrestrial involvement
because, well, it wouldn't be an episode of Decade of the Unknown
if it wasn't like, could be aliens.
Could it?
Could be. And ghosts.
This has led to the Bermuda Triangle's other nickname,
the Devil's Triangle.
Oh, in reality, there are many documented instances
of weird stuff, crashes and mysterious disappearances
inside this fabled triangle.
So let's take a look at a few interesting examples.
By the way, Simon, I'm pretty sure you've already given your spoiler alert.
Probably correct opinions about the Bermuda Triangle by this point.
Yes, he did.
Katie!
Oh, how did you tell?
Well, because I've just got such a vast big brain of knowledge
that I just can't help myself, can I?
Such a giant big brain.
So let's just keep it mysterious for now, shall we?
We'll get into all the theories later, I promise.
OK, fine.
Well, I like these because it's like, let's, you know, it's the ocean.
There's obviously been like mysterious disappearances and ****.
Let's read about them.
Going all the way back to 1492, when he was sailing the ocean blue
and, well, definitely not discovering America for the first time,
as we now know, Christopher Columbus wandered into Bermuda Triangle territory
while his original logs and diaries about this event have not survived.
Transcriptions of them and secondary source material
from people who sailed with Columbus absolutely have.
On the 15th of September, 1492, this is reported to have happened, quote,
And on this night, at the beginning of it,
they saw a marvelous branch of fire fall from the sky into the sea,
distant from them four or five leagues.
Was leagues a real measurement?
Because there's that book the Jules Verne, like 40,000 leagues under the sea
or something. Is it 40,000?
It's a lot of leagues.
And I always thought from that title that even though he said leagues,
it wasn't actually a definitive form of measurement.
Anyway, not important. Let's carry on.
A couple of weeks later,
they reported having seen a small and faint light,
like a small wax candle that rose and lifted up.
Also around this time, when they were in Bermuda Triangle territory,
the crew started having problems with their compasses.
They used the North Star to navigate.
And a note about Columbus's diary from the 17th of September, 1492 states
the pilots took the north, making it and found that the compasses northwest
at a full point and the sailors were fearful and depressed and did not say why.
The admiral was aware of this
and he ordered that the north again be marked when dawn came.
And they found that the compasses were correct.
The cause was that the North Star appears to move and not the compasses.
Stars moving around and strange lights in the sky.
This set the tone for the triangle's future reputation.
And yes, while we will, of course, go into some cool headed reasoning later on,
let's just carry on with the weird stuff first.
Yeah, I mean, one thing that the North Star doesn't do
and obviously it moves through the North Star,
that it moves through the sky, but like it doesn't move unpredictably
because the Earth moves real predictably.
Same for the North Star.
Is the North Star Alpha Centauri?
That doesn't move. It's a star.
I mean, of course it moves in like the grand scheme of the universe,
but not relative to our star.
Much, much like noticeably.
Here are a couple of more famous examples of creepy Bermuda Triangle goings on.
In 1890, in 1918, the USS Cyclops, along with 306 passengers and crew
and a cargo of manganese or disappeared forever
after sailing through the Bermuda Triangle.
The ship was an eight-year-old naval supply ship
and had been commissioned as a transport ship during the First World War.
In March 1918, the Cyclops left Brazil and headed back to Baltimore,
but was never seen again.
The last known communication from the ship was a radio message stating,
Whether fair or well.
But after that, nothing.
The ship basically vanished off the face of the Earth
and not a single trace of it has been found to this day.
The deaths of the 306 people on board the Cyclops represents
the US Navy's largest loss of life outside of a combat situation.
This is totally possible, though.
Look, it's 1918.
It's well over 100 years ago.
It was just not that good in the past.
Like even today.
What was that Malaysian Airlines flight like MH17 or whatever
that went missing like 10 years ago?
That is just I think they found like one little bit of it,
but they never found that plane.
And it's a giant plane disappearing in the 21st century.
Like a ship just disappearing and sinking back in the day is just like,
yeah, it sank, didn't it?
They didn't have time to send our message.
And then their lifeboats all got drowned in a storm.
It's just that happens.
One of the best known stories about the Bermuda Triangle
again involves the US military.
On the 5th of December, 1945, a group of torpedo bombers,
collectively known as Flight 19, took off from Florida.
Oh, I've heard of this one for a routine training mission.
I think flying over the Bermuda Triangle, the entire group,
which comprised four planes and five planes, sorry, and 14 airmen disappeared.
The last communication from the leader,
Lieutenant Charles Taylor, was radioed.
We are entering whitewater.
Nothing seems right.
We don't know where we are.
The water is green.
No, white.
No wreckage from these planes has ever been found.
And the official naval report gave its conclusion as cause unknown.
Yeah, the whitewater one.
This is definitely one I've heard of.
Even more eerily, once the original five bombers had been reported missing,
two search planes went out looking for them.
One of these planes, a Martin Mariner with 13 people on board, also disappeared.
On the 30th of January, 1948, a small passenger plane, the Star Tiger,
was heading in for a 5 a.m. landing in Bermuda.
It never made it.
It was heard from at 3.15 a.m.
when the plane checked in with a radio operator in Bermuda.
After that, nothing more was heard.
No distress call was ever sent.
The plane, again with 25 people on board, had seemingly just vanished.
A huge search and rescue mission was launched following the Star Tiger's
failure to arrive, but no trace of the plane was ever found.
Yeah, because how big did we say it was?
Like a million square kilometers, like half a million square miles.
This alleged Bermuda Triangle, if we're taking those three points,
Puerto Rico, Bermuda and Miami.
I mean, it's a big area to search.
It's larger than South Africa.
And this is a small passenger plane.
It's no surprise that they couldn't find it.
And that's not like counting how deep the ocean is.
Isn't the Mariana Trench like around there?
It's deep. The ocean's real deep.
Deepwater is always something that I found really unsettling.
I remember being scared of it as a kid.
Like I wasn't scared of the water.
I'm a pretty good swimmer and I'd always be fine, like always fine.
Shallow water, no problem.
But like diving pools, you know, where it's really deep
or the deep end of the swimming pool.
I'd be genuinely scared of that as a kid.
And even as an adult, I find it like slightly unsettling or like
it's just like, oh, I don't like it being too deep.
It's like, I don't know why.
I know I'm not going to drown.
But the idea of swimming in the ocean above the Mariana Trench or whatever,
where it's just like miles down like that, that is, I don't know why it's scary
because there's all sorts of weird shit lurking down there.
I don't know.
Or even like being on a boat above the Mariana Trench.
I'm like, oh, I don't like that.
I don't like that because, you know, how far down it is weird.
And my parents are always like, why is just the same as being in shallow water?
Because you're swimming, you know, it doesn't matter how deep it is.
You're swimming on the surface.
And I'd be like, that doesn't make me feel any better.
I'd look down there in the diving pool and be like, it's really deep.
I don't like it.
And this this continued for me till I was a teenager, I remember,
because I'd go with swimming and we'd go swimming at school
and it was a diving pit and I'd never want to go.
And I always be like, I'd never been in the diving pit before
because I was afraid.
And I joined the swimming club and we'd all just go diving off the boards.
And because, you know, peer pressure or whatever, I must have been like 13
or 14 years old.
So I was like a little kid.
And I was like, yeah, no worries.
I'll just jump off the diving boards.
And then I just went in the deep water and I was totally fine
because I didn't want to appear to be a coward.
What a fascinatingly lengthy tangent, Simon.
Let's get back to the video, shall we?
The British Aviation Ministry carried out an investigation
but came to this puzzling conclusion, quote,
In closing this report, it may truly be said that no more baffling problem
has ever been presented for investigation.
In the complete absence of any reliable evidence as to either the nature
or the cause of the accident of the Star Tiger,
the court has not been able to do more than suggest possibilities,
none of which reaches the level even of probability.
What happened in this case will never be known.
And the fate of Star Tiger must remain an unsolved mystery.
Unsolved mystery.
How about it just had an engine failure and crashed into the ocean
and then disappeared into the crushing depths of the Mariana Trench or whatever?
That doesn't seem that that is not even a remote possibility.
Who is this? The aviation ministry?
It seems totally possible to me because you're looking for a small craft
in an area the size of South Africa.
What are you doing?
And how about the disappearance of the perhaps appropriately named Witchcraft?
On the 22nd of December, 1967, Daniel Burek and his friend,
Father Padraig Hogan, were in Burek's luxury cabin cruiser
checking out the Christmas lights of Miami from the water.
One of the men radioed in to the Coast Guard at 9 p.m.
to say that they had hit something and needed a tow.
But it wasn't an emergency situation.
At this point, the boat was less than a mile out.
The Coast Guard reached the Witchcraft's supposed location about 20 minutes later,
but couldn't find any sign of them.
Burek had said that he would let off a flare to show their location,
but no flare was seen and no further communications were received.
Burek was an experienced sailor with all the necessary safety equipment on board,
plus another safety measure of an added flotation device
that would mean at least part of the hull would always remain afloat,
even if it were ruptured or flooded.
After a six day search, the Coast Guard called it off with their official verdict
given as they are presumed missing, but not lost at sea.
Seems like they're lost at sea.
I mean, or maybe they're presumed.
No, no, no. OK, they just drowned, didn't they?
That's what happens.
This is one of those things, though.
This isn't a mystery in my mind.
Like, OK, we don't know if it's true, but it seems highly probable
that they simply underestimated the scale of the disaster.
Like they'd struck something.
They're like, oh, we're leaking a little bit.
And then they're like, oh, we're leaking a lot.
Oh, my God, we're leaking a lot.
And then the ship drowns.
Ship drowns. The ship sinks and they drown.
Doesn't seem like a big, big mystery to me.
There are plenty more cases I could mention,
a lot of which involve no distress calls and no wreckage or bodies found.
But you're probably getting the idea by now.
So let's move on and talk about what could possibly be going on
in the Bermuda Triangle.
I hope at least a giant squid's mentioned, because otherwise I have no idea
why I thought it was a giant squid for most of my childhood.
The more off the wall explanations.
As you might expect, a lot of weird theories have been given
as to what might be going on in the Bermuda Triangle.
So I think this is about the time to talk about how and why
it's been given such a spooky reputation.
Well, as we just found out, strange things seem to have been afoot
since the 15th century.
The current hype all started back in 1964,
which isn't actually that long ago in the grand scheme of things.
That was the time the phrase Bermuda Triangle was first coined
when American author Vincent Gaddis used it for an article in Argosy magazine.
It should be noted that Argosy was what was known as a pulp or pulp fiction mag,
which meant that it was a cheaply produced publication
dealing chiefly in short stories and fictional content.
Yeah. Yeah.
So this is how often so often this is how these weird things start,
because it's like it's that weird blending of semi-fact and semi-fiction
that sends someone a few years later is like, wow, I read this.
It must be true.
And then it's like, yeah, but it wasn't.
It's sort of a semi-fictional story.
Yeah, I imagine like we'll see all these, you know, semi-fictional TV shows.
Like right now I'm watching this.
That's fairly average.
It's a show called Inventing Anna on Netflix about the the fake heiress in New York
who was like, I don't know, just, you know, defrauding money or whatever.
And just as people would watch this in 50 years, it'd be like, yeah, it's a documentary.
It's like, no, not quite.
While Argosy did change focus over the years to add in true crime columns
and later got a bit spicier in the 1960s,
it was primarily a publication for fiction, not investigative journalism.
It seems that Gaddis did like to write about paranormal things
and also like to expound on his left field theories
with no evidence or thought for more rational explanations.
Hey, he's kind of like the opposite of this show.
I mean, where would be the fun in that?
Hey, to quote from his Wikipedia page,
he was known for inventing mysteries where none existed,
which, spoiler alert, seems to sum up the Bermuda Triangle in a nutshell.
And also, I mean, this is just this sort of shit has found a new home on YouTube.
Like I, one of the reasons I wanted to do this channel
is because there is so much just of this,
like semi pulp, like or pulp fiction,
semi evidence, but not really elaborate.
No research nonsense.
And it does really well.
I should have probably just leaned into that if I had no moral compass.
He didn't come up with this piece totally on his own, though.
He seems to have gained inspiration from a 1952 article
in Fate magazine by George X. Sands.
This is titled Sea Mystery at Our Back Door
and goes on to tell the tale of several disappearances,
most of which end up in Gaddis' article 12 years later.
Sands doesn't really provide any theories as to what might have happened,
just presenting them as mysterious events.
He also comes agonizingly close to claiming the name of Bermuda Triangle himself,
but just veers off at the last seconds and calls it a watery triangle
bounded roughly by Floro de Bermuda and Puerto Rico.
So close, George!
You could have been the next douchiest spokesperson in the world.
Gaddis even lifted the title of this article for use in his own piece in The Argosy,
which contains the sentence,
During the past two decades alone,
this sea mystery at our back door has claimed almost a thousand lives.
Oh, sea mystery at our back door, I don't think is a unique thing to be like,
he stole it!
Anyway, Gaddis' take on said triangle was attention grabbing,
as he landed the front cover of Argosy with the title,
The Deadly Bermuda Triangle, Who Will Be Its Next Victim?
The cover image is a skull on a red triangle with a black background.
All the images I found had a sticker covering some of the subtitle,
but it goes on to say, UFO, Flying Saucer, Natural Phenomenon,
then maybe, Water Monster Claimed, The Subscorpion, 10 Ships, 12 Airplanes,
and then a number of people which I couldn't read, but it's probably thousands.
His article starts,
What is there about this particular slice of the world that has destroyed
hundreds of ships and planes without a trace?
and presented as fact.
This piece is not written as a story. It's written more as an editorial,
with lots of examples of incidents in his now-named Bermuda Triangle,
a couple of which we talked about earlier.
While steering clear of outright mentioning UFOs or other supernatural phenomena as causes,
Gaddis cloaked every incident in mystery,
and tries to hint at the unlikelihood of rational explanations.
He ends the article with,
The sea guards well her secrets.
I don't like people who...
What did Katie just write?
I don't like people who try to hint at the unlikeliness,
unlikelihood of rational explanations,
because we should always be looking for the rational explanation.
Looking for something irrational is insane.
It's entertaining, but if you're trying to do something factual, it's insane.
So Gaddis was taking the idea of unexplained happenings in the area,
giving it a good brand name, and sending this idea out into the world.
And the next person to grab onto the idea really took it to the next level.
Enter Charles Balitz.
If the surname sounds familiar, it doesn't.
Yes, he was a member of the Balitz family.
No idea who they are, who started the language centers.
What are those?
Am I missing something?
Is the Balitz Language Center super famous?
He was something of an enthusiast in the realms of the mysterious,
and was obsessed with the lost city of Atlantis,
ancient astronauts, and all that type of stuff.
Go on, Simon, have your say.
And then I'll just add that I personally think it's extremely fun
to dip into all kinds of stuff like that,
but it's probably not a great idea to make it your life's work.
Yeah, exactly.
This is my whole point.
Like that ancient astronaut thing,
and there's like the crazy sculpture and stuff where the guy...
It looks like an astronaut.
For real, looks like a dude who would be walking on the moon.
Fun to dip into.
Fun to analyze.
And then move on from quickly when you realize it's nonsense,
rather than dedicating your life to this.
Because, I mean, look, it's all pointless.
Like, let's be realistic.
We all live.
We all die.
No matter what we do.
Ultimately, in the grand scheme of things,
even like Elon Musk with his electric cars,
saving the world, all of this.
Well, you know, he's like,
I'm going to get people living on Mars to save humanity.
I've got some news, Elon.
At some point, humanity is f***ed.
Like at some point, it's going to happen.
Either we evolve beyond humanity, best case scenario,
and then that future evolution of homo whatever
is also f***ed when the universe collapses in on itself at some point in the future.
It's all pointless.
Neolistic rant over.
Wow, how did we get there?
Oh, s***.
What are we doing?
In 1974, Berlitz published the best-selling and unoriginally titled book,
The Bermuda Triangle, an incredible saga of unexplained disappearances.
One of the things he managed to shoehorn into the book was his theory that, yes,
Atlantis was located somewhere on the seafloor inside the triangle,
and that it had, in fact, been a victim of paranormal forces that are prevalent in the area.
This idea was then elaborated by other alternative thinkers to suggest that the Atlanteans were,
in fact, the cause of the disappearances due to the crazy energy crystals they used.
Dude, I think I'm going to dig into crystal meth.
Ah, please.
Although I left over when Atlantis sank.
It's like, okay, okay.
Do you have any evidence to back that up whatsoever?
No?
Shocking.
These crystals would mess around with compasses and end up vaporizing boats and planes.
Except, no, they wouldn't.
What are we talking about?
I think these kinds of things are popular because they're entertaining,
and people are along for the ride and just ingesting the information presented to them
without much thought about it either way.
That's why the Decoding Unknown show.
That's for the discerning viewer or podcast listener.
And if you're a discerning podcast listener, I mean,
have you considered leaving me a review?
I love that.
I love those reviews.
I see them come in.
I like them.
When they're good.
When they're five stars.
That's the only type of review I should be leaving.
No, it's okay.
You can leave what you want.
It just hurts my feelings.
It was quite telling, though, that several reviews of the Berlitz book
mentioned how the readers love it when they were younger,
but now thinking about it, they realize that the whole idea had no corroborating
factual evidence and just seems, well, completely laughable.
So, yes, we've now got the name and a strong association with the paranormal
read by thousands and thousands of people.
In fact, I just looked it up and Berlitz's book sold almost 20 million copies worldwide.
Oh, my God, I'm wasting my life with a skeptic.
I should just be like Bermuda Triangle.
It's real.
Did you enjoy this video?
Buy my book on the Bermuda Triangle.
Sell 20 million copies.
And well, that's a lot of money, isn't it?
That's that's a lot of money.
This book was the seed that spawned the legend of the Bermuda Triangle,
as we now know it by inspiring movies, TV shows, and more books about the phenomenon.
While it might already be clear that we're leaning on the side of skepticism here,
what?
There are real instances of boats and planes going missing in the Bermuda Triangle,
so what might be causing these strange disappearances of aircraft, ships, and possibly
entire cities?
Entire cities have not gone missing in the Bermuda Triangle, I'm sorry to say.
Aliens
It's time to say hi to our extraterrestrial pals.
They haven't had much of a look in on the channel recently, but now is their time to shine.
Remember Columbus seeing the lights on the water?
Well, yes, there's a theory that the lights were from alien spacecraft.
This particular example isn't a great one, though.
While I gave actual examples of what someone had written about the lights, albeit not Columbus
Other sources have stated things like he saw lights shooting up into the sky or stars spinning
around.
This is not the case, as he used to be people taking the notes in his diary completely out
of context and interpreting them however they want.
These sensationalized and inaccurate examples then got picked up and reused in future pieces
about the Bermuda Triangle, so as we've seen many times before, these alternative
facts get attached and embedded into the narrative.
We know from as close to a primary source as we can find that Columbus did see some
lights, but it was nothing flying saucer-like at all.
The first instance of a marvelous branch of fire that fell from the sky was more than
likely a comet or an asteroid or something cool like that.
There was no indication given of the crew feeling scared or of further paranormal things
happening relating to this event, so I think it's safe to say it was a one-off.
It seems that our friends in flying saucers are always on the shortlist when it comes
to unexplained disappearances, but as usual, why they would choose to pick up ships and
aircraft from this particular piece of the planet is up for debate.
We don't seem to have pinned any other disappearances from anywhere else on the seas
to them, so why here?
Maybe they're using a tractor beam to try and raise Atlantis from the depths and these
ships and planes happen to get in the path at exactly the wrong time.
Hey, it ties together nicely for me, and also ridiculously.
You might recall that Columbus's voyage did also have issues with navigating as well
as seeing those lights.
We'll talk more about the compass bearings later, so for now, let's knock this alien
theory on the head.
Yeah, Columbus wasn't the best at navigation, I guess, because didn't he think for like
a long-ass time he was like, I have reached India, and he's just hanging out on an island
in the Caribbean?
Other kinds of science fiction stuff.
True story.
I mentioned to my friend that I was writing a piece in the Bermuda Triangle, and their
response was, oh, wasn't there that one ship that went missing?
Isn't there a hole or something?
I replied, a hole?
Them.
Oh, in the sea.
In the air.
Like a black hole.
No.
Me.
No.
Them.
What was that?
Wasn't there that female pilot that went missing?
Me.
Do you mean Amelia Earhart?
No.
This is an insane conversation.
Katie did read it.
One of Katie's friends was like, yeah, I know what caused the Bermuda Triangle, it's a black
hole.
Mate.
If there was a black hole in the sky above Bermuda, do you have any idea how f***ed we
would be as a planet?
It would all be over.
It would all be over for our solar system.
It would all be over for our, like, galactic neighborhood, having like a black hole just
consume all of our s***.
I was going to direct them to the Amelia Earhart episode of this show, but I'd kind of lost
the live to will by then.
Anyway, the wormhole slash time portal slash interdimensional black hole theory is of course
on the list.
Do these craft enter some sort of rip in space and then pop out somewhere else?
Due to the fact that they've never reappeared in the past or future that we know of so far,
we can only conclude that no, this is not what is happening.
Of course, if the witchcraft or the Cyclops suddenly rematerialize, I'd be happy to react
and retract this entire section, but I think we're in safe territory here.
Boy, it would be awkward if between now and the time this video goes out, one of these
ships that disappeared in the past appears now in the future with everyone having not
aged at all and them saying that it was like, yeah, it was an interdimensional black hole
and aliens.
I mean, I guess I'll have to eat my hat.
And if that happens, I will literally eat an entire hat.
I will.
It's not going to happen, though.
So don't worry.
I'm not worried.
Of course I'm worried.
And you should be too.
There are scenes from the movie, close encounters of the third kind, where all sorts of things
previously abducted by aliens do make a reappearance, but, well, that's a movie.
It's not real life.
There has never been any sort of rift or opening detected in that area of the Atlantic.
Or in fact, anywhere.
Or of course, there's always the possibility of a huge government cover-up about the existence
of such a portal, but then they'd probably have manufactured reasons not to travel through
that area and there are currently no restrictions, so yes, again, I'm going to say that this
is not a viable theory.
It's not in any way whatsoever.
It's insane.
And you maybe, I mean, I don't know if you should show this video to your friends, Casey,
because that's kind of like, really believes this.
Sea monsters.
Oh, yeah, we're keeping with the weird stuff.
There have been legends about Kraken's giant sea Kraken's Kraken's.
I always get that one wrong and I try to remember the correct pronunciation, then I'm never
sure if I get it right and I'm not professional or caring enough to look it up every time.
Giant sea snakes, huge tentacled things, and other monsters of the deep since humans first
started sailing the oceans.
So this is the one from my mind as a kid.
That giant sea monster that reaches up and snatches planes out of the sky, which is absurd.
Could something be lurking way down in the depths of the Atlantic that occasionally pops
up and grabs a tasty boat snack with a side of human?
While we know very little about what goes on in the depths of the sea, it's not that
likely that a huge sea creature is the cause of these disappearances.
Yes, enormous squid do exist.
A 30 foot or 9 meter one was found off the coast of Japan in 2005, and the largest one
recorded to date was nearly 43 feet or 13 meters long.
It's f***ing massive.
I guess it's not impossible for an animal of any description to maybe take out a very
small boat, but for the Cyclops, this was a very large coal ship.
The biggest squid in the world would have no chance, and none of the examples we have
given ever gave any sort of distress call.
There would be time to mention that a sea monster was attacking before the whole ship
went down, surely.
And don't forget that some of the most well-known disappearances are aircraft.
Unless they were skimming the waves, which they were not, I think they should have been
high enough to be safe from a monster attack.
Unless they were in Mega Shark vs. Giant Octopus, where yes, a Mega Shark does indeed jump out
of the water and take out a plane.
Don't tell me that's real.
There's a movie called Mega Shark vs. Giant Octopus.
As if we don't have enough to worry about when flying thousands of feet over the planet,
in a metal tube they go and add shark attacks in.
Oh my.
You may have guessed from the tone of this section that sea monsters are not high on
my personal list of explanations, but hey, it's a free country unless you're watching
this from somewhere it isn't, so you probably can't get YouTube then, can you?
Unless you're watching it through your VPN.
Again, it'd be great if this episode was sponsored by one of our VPN sponsors.
I don't know if it will be, but also, I mean, you're still not in a free country, are you?
That's kind of a bummer.
VPN doesn't buy you rights, it just gets you access to watch YouTube in a country which
has rights.
But that's close enough.
A VPN that starts offering that would be really good.
That'd be a unique selling point, VPN companies.
Let's move on to some more likely theories, or at least some theories that are based in
the real world.
Magnetic anomalies.
Is there some sort of electromagnetic thing that is happening in the Bermuda Triangle
that makes compasses and navigational equipment go haywire?
Columbus's men had trouble lining up with the North Star, and the pilots of the ill-fated
Flight 19 also apparently couldn't work out where they were.
I've seen a couple of explanations here.
One is that sometimes magnetic north and true magnetic north line up in what's called an
agonic line.
Columbus could have passed through an area like this in the Bermuda Triangle, and this
would have changed the readings for magnetic north related to the North Star, I think.
To be honest, I got a bit confused here, and it seems to turn out that there shouldn't
really be any issues with compasses in this area more than anywhere else.
Even if the compass is pointing to true north for a time, as well as magnetic north, it's
also pointing to magnetic north, so navigating shouldn't be an issue.
Columbus also may have been in some rough weather, which caused his rudimentary compass
to just spin around a little bit.
There aren't any known magnetic disturbances or anomalies in the Bermuda Triangle, so I'm
thinking this can probably be put down to later writers exaggerating things that weren't
a big deal to begin with.
Natural Weather Occurrences
Weather can do weird stuff sometimes.
There are things like katabatic winds and ball lightning which have been given as possible
and plausible reasons for the events of the Dyatlov Pass, another great Decoding the Unknown
episode by the way.
Definitely check it out.
In the ocean, there are sea quakes and waterspouts which, while I'm plugging past episodes,
may have had a hand in the mysterious circumstances surrounding the Mary Celeste.
Basically, strange things can happen at any given moment, and we're all just hanging
on here by the skin of our teeth and the grace of our alien overlords.
Yes, it's possible that rogue waves can capsize a boat or a ship that could be taken
down by a sudden eruption from the seafloor, or a plane could run into some sort of atmospheric
megastorm, but how often is that likely to happen?
I've been reining it in this whole time, but now I've come to the rather disappointing
conclusion about the Bermuda Triangle mystery, and that is that there is no mystery.
Ah, boo hoo, hiss hiss.
We want mystery, you say.
We want aliens.
We want black holes opening up and swallowing planes whole, only for them to appear at some
magical future time.
Well, sorry, but you're not going to get any of that stuff off the coast of Puerto
Rico.
What we've been skirting around this entire time is that while there have been incidents
in the so-called Bermuda Triangle, there have been no more than any other routinely traversed
area of ocean anywhere else.
There are no definitive numbers, and I've found a huge disparity, but it's estimated
for certain that at least 50 ships and 20 planes have disappeared in the area, which
is nowhere near the hundreds of ships and planes as reported by Vincent Gaddis.
Yes, we should all be ignoring Gaddis, because he's a fiction writer.
In fact, in 2013, the World Wildlife Fund didn't even place the Bermuda Triangle area
in the top 10 most dangerous bodies of water for shipping.
Yes, there have been disappearances, but there have been disappearances all over the world
with nothing paranormal attached.
It was just assumed that the ship sank or the plane crashed, and that's it.
And that's what happened to the Bermuda Triangle cases, too.
Let's go back and look at the ones we talked about at the beginning in slightly greater
detail.
We've covered Columbus already, and I'll just add that they were voyaging into the
unknown in a faraway light going up and down.
It could have been anything.
A light in another boat, light from a settlement on land.
They had no idea that they were close to, etc, etc.
It's literally anything else that is reasonable.
Let's revisit the USS Cyclops now, with the 306 people on board.
That was the Navy's biggest disaster that wasn't in wartime, right?
This massive ship just disappeared, but there are the deepest trenches in the Atlantic in
the area.
Okay, I thought so.
I'm not sure if it's the Mariana Trench, but it's deep there.
The Atlantic Ocean is mega deep.
No trace would have been found from a sea search, obviously, because it's really deep.
There are lots of other factors that could point to it sinking rather than, for example,
being abducted by aliens.
It was potentially overloaded with manganese ore, which when wet could turn it into a shifting
load that could help unbalance the ship.
Add in that one engine was reported as not working, a heavy storm that was documented,
and revelations in the years after that those classes of ships had structural issues, and
you got the perfect situation for a big old ship to go down.
Moving on to Flight 19, or the five planes that went missing.
The flight leader was Charles Taylor, and he was the only really experienced pilot among
the 14 airmen.
He also had a history of getting lost, having ditched into the sea to be rescued at least
twice during the war.
While the weather started off fine, Taylor managed to get the group lost, and as time
went on the weather got worse and they ran out of fuel.
An article I saw on theconversation.com stated that this type of plane could sink in under
45 seconds once it hit the water.
Yes, totally.
This shit can happen really.
It was like my example with a boat off Florida or wherever, where it's like, we've had a
minor problem.
And then it very quickly is like, oh shit, this is bigger than we thought.
And then your boat is in the Mariana Trench in like 45 seconds, and you're drowning.
Brilliant.
What is even more sad is that radio communications confirmed that at least one trainee knew which
direction they should be flying in, but everyone bowed to Taylor's leadership.
Don't point that gun at him, he's an unpaid intern.
Yes.
The planes have never been found, as again, bad weather and a lack of knowledge as to
where they actually were hampered any search.
You've got the Gulf Stream passing through the area, so debris and wreckage could be
carried far away by the time a search party started looking.
The planes are somewhere on the bottom of the sea, waiting to be found.
This is the, uh, the, the, the crew bowing down to the captain.
It was like some, there's a great book called Black Box Thinking, I might have even mentioned
it before on this show actually, where this guy looks at this whole situation and how
many plane accidents have been caused because the captain thinks he knows what's up, and
was flying another ship, the SS Gaines Mills, observed an explosion which coincided with
the position of the Martin Mariner at the time, so it blew up.
Apparently, these planes had a history of gas leaking from their tanks, and this could
have been ignited in a variety of ways to cause this plane to explode.
This is actually the most mysterious of all the Bermuda Triangle examples, as what caused
the explosion is not known for certain.
It's been theorized that the phenomenon of San Dalmo's fire might have created the
spark, but no official cause has been given.
The Star Tiger passenger plane also has a plausible reason for vanishing.
The theory goes that the plane had been flying abnormally low, around 2,000 feet, due to
bad headwinds at their normal flying height of around 20,000 feet.
The pilots retired and had, at least on one previous radio call, said that they were 25,000
feet when they meant 2,000.
incorrectly.
For example, it was dark, and they were at the end of a long flight and did not realize
or remember their height.
On approach to Bermuda, they began their descent from what they thought was 20,000 feet and
basically just flew straight into the ocean.
No wreckage was found, as it was a small plane and could have easily been carried away in
rough seas by the time the search started, which wasn't for several hours after the
last known communication.
Yeah, this is entirely possible.
Just a pilot error.
Huge problem.
Octopus.
Squid.
Octopus.
Squid.
As with all these cases, we can't definitively say for sure what happened as no wreckage
has turned up, but this is one sad but plausible explanation.
Yes, just so much more likely than any of the crazy stuff, guys.
And how about Daniel Burek, Father Padraig Horgan, and the missing witchcraft?
Oh my god, this was back right- this is a long episode, I feel like this was a long
time ago.
There are multiple theories here, too, including that the boat wasn't where they originally
thought and a sudden storm then carried them even further out from the search area.
There's also the suggestion, though, that the whole radio call was faked so Burek and
Horgan could secretly sail off into the holiday sunset together.
Maybe the Coast Guard even suspected that this had happened, as their verdict of they
are presumed missing but not lost at sea seems to hint that they thought the boat hadn't
sunk.
That's entirely possible.
When you really start drilling down, there's no mystery around the Bermuda Triangle at
all.
In fact, articles like the one by Gaddis in Argosy add in cases that happened outside
of the theoretical triangle, which inflates the figures and don't even entertain alternative
possibilities.
The subscorpion that's name-checked on the cover of the Argosy didn't even sink anywhere
near the Bermuda Triangle.
It was found a few hundred miles southwest of the Azores, which is over 2,000 miles.
As you can see from the way I originally presented the stories, many pertinent bits of information
are intentionally left out to preserve the air of mystery when most things come down
to just human error or bad luck for many decades, and statistical irrelevance.
For many decades, there have been ships and aircrafts travelling through the area on a
daily basis, and apart from a few accidents we've mentioned, nothing untoward ever happens.
And going back to the article I found on theconversation.com, which was in answer to a question asked by
a child, I found this quote that also underlines why there is no real mystery.
In fact, from the mid-1940s to the mid-1980s, more small planes have crashed over the US
mainland than in the Bermuda Triangle, but because they crashed on land where the wreckage
was found, they were not considered mysterious.
Exactly.
Beautiful.
Succinct.
That's the reason.
It's no mystery, I'm so sorry.
See, you ruined it.
In 1975, writer Larry Cush published a book called The Bermuda Triangle Mystery, solved
after much research an actual gathering of, well, facts.
He concluded that previous writers had exaggerated, misinterpreted, and sometimes just made up
information in relation to events happening in the Bermuda Triangle area.
Larry, you sound like a legend.
So there you are.
After knowing very little about it, I feel that this may be the first time I can say
that the unknown has been decoded.
For me, at least.
I'm sure most of you reached this conclusion a very long time ago.
Maybe for me.
It was even before this episode started.
So happy travels and don't worry about accidentally entering a different dimension
if you're headed to Bermuda.
the Bermuda Triangle.
