Antiquities Circle Lecture - The Etruscans

Museum of European Antiquities
22 followers
My name is Brittany Bevel. I'm the education curator for the Tampa Museum of Art and it is
my pleasure to welcome you all for this virtual Antiquities Circle lecture on the Etruscans.
First and foremost, I would like to thank the Antiquities Circle members for their continued
support of the museum and of programs associated with our Classical Antiquities collection.
The Antiquities Circle is a membership add-on at the museum and if you're interested in joining
or learning more, I'll be sending links for more information about the program in the chat
function. You can also find more information by visiting tampamuseum.org. I am so excited
to introduce today's speaker. The Tampa Museum of Art has appointed Dr. Branko van Oppen as
Consulting Curator of Ancient Art. During the pandemic, Dr. van Oppen will join the museum
from the Netherlands where he currently resides. He is an ancient historian specializing in
queenship during the period from Alexander the Great to Cleopatra. He received his PhD from the
City University of New York and recently has worked at the Allard Pearson Museum which holds
the archaeological collection of the University of Amsterdam. With that, I'd like to invite
Branko to turn on his camera and begin the presentation for this afternoon. Thank you,
Brittany, for that introduction and hello to all and thank you for joining today's Antiquities
Circle lecture. In the webinar today, I would like to pitch a proposal for an exhibition. I have done
so in previous lectures and I would like to do that again today, this time about the Etruscans.
Using first the TMA collection as a starting point and additionally, I will present a concept
with selected objects from museums for a more prominent exhibition project. Before I start,
I would like to thank the TMA for all their support and assistance providing information
and images over the past weeks and months while I am working from home across the Atlantic,
six time zones away. As Brittany has already mentioned, feel free to leave comments, raise hands
to the chat or if you're on Facebook, leave a comment there. We are always very interested
to hear what you think and there is room for questions also after this chat.
So with that said, I would like us to begin. The Etruscans are a fascinating ancient people about
whom much remains a mystery. They inhabited an area of northern Italy, approximately
present-day Tuscany and beyond, immediately above Laetium of which Rome became the capital
in antiquity. It is only through their often violent contact with the Romans that we know
something about the Etruscan history. They have left no historical accounts of their own,
or if they, we know that they did, but they have not survived to our time.
Their written language can be deciphered and partially understood, but its linguistic origins
have yet to be ascertained and it is certainly that it is not an Indo-European language like
English or Latin or Greek. Etruscan culture was also influenced by different cultures that
surround the area. Central European and Celtic culture, for instance, Greek culture, particularly
Corinthian and Athenian, as well as the Punic and Phoenician cultures from Carthage and the Near
East. The Etruscan culture emerged from an Iron Age culture that is called Villanovan,
which reached its height from the 9th through the 7th centuries BCE. Etruscan civilization
on its own reached its height in the second quarter of the first millennium, that is to say
from the 7th through the 5th century, after which it was gradually subsumed by the Roman
sphere of influence, which was a long process of acculturation spanning from the 5th through the
1st centuries BCE. Gaining their wealth through copper and iron trade and joined into a federation
of city-states, the Etruscan culture is best known from tombs and temples. Much of the preserved
Etruscan material culture is therefore of a punerary or religious nature. Some salient insight
can be gleaned from archaeological remains, in combination with Greek and Latin historiography.
The Etruscan pantheon included gods of the sun and moon, land and sea, love and war,
birth and death. Apart from their indigenous deities, some of their gods and heroic figures
were adapted from Greek and Roman myth and religion. Other figures reveal influence from
Central European, Punic and even Egyptian religion. An important role was conferred on priests who,
through divinization such as inspecting animal entrails, interpreted the will of the gods.
The Etruscan aristocracy participated in an elite culture of exchange, revolving around
sophisticated wine consumption and gift-giving, reaching from Petruria to Magna Graecia in
southern Italy. Their wealth was flaunted in rich jewelry worn by Etruscan women and the
beautifully decorated mirrors with which they adjusted their appearance. Etruscan military
power is reflected in their warriors' impressive armor. Etruscan artwork consists of large and
small-scale bronze and terracotta statues, architecture and its decorative elements such as
antifixes, metalware such as what you see here, a drum-shaped cosmetic box or candle holders and
incense burners, and ceramic vessels, for instance, in the so-called Buccaro technique,
specifically Etruscan ware that imitates metal vessels. Aristocratic family tombs house
anthropomorphe sarcophagi, or cinerary urns, which often place emphasis on married couples,
such as this beautiful example from the Louvre that you see on this image.
Disparity may be understood in such a way that the position of noble women was more prominent
than that of their Greek or Roman counterparts. Rich grave goods attest once more to the wealth
of the Etruscan elite. The walls of the Etruscan tombs, particularly at Starquinia,
were embellished with colorful frescoes, paintings that depict scenes of mythology and funerary
banquets such as here in the background, as well as occasionally scenes of hunting,
athletics and everyday life. The importance of aristocratic funerary architecture and its
decoration indicates that the Etruscan elites placed great emphasis on commemorating their dead,
and it also illustrates their belief in the afterlife. Now before I move on at this point,
are there perhaps questions that I could address? If not, then so far. Excellent, then let's move on
the proposal of an exhibition based on the TMA Etruscan collection.
Because the Antiquities Collection of the Tampa Museum of Arts contains a respectable assortment
of about 55 Etruscan objects, covering a period of about 500 years, from 750 to about 250 BCE.
Now notably, 18 items derive from the Richard and Mary Perry bequest. Six are part of the acquisition
of the Joseph Beach Noble Collection, another six were given by Mr. and Mrs. Moody, and six more are
the bequest of Charlotte Dunwoody. So some of the very prominent friends of the museum in the past
have donated or have bequested their objects to this collection. These objects include about 15
bronze figurines, a dozen items of jewelry and a mirror, a cinerary urn, and additionally various
types of vessels. You see a collection of Etruscan pottery over here. Together, these objects
illustrate aspects of four main themes. There's myth and religion, jewelry, pottery,
everyday human animal life, as well as death that makes four. Accompanied by colorful and
illustrative images, these 55 objects would suffice for a focused display on the TMA's
Etruscan collection in one of the museum's galleries. Now what I would like to do is give you a quick
illustration of some of the examples of the objects in the collection and what kinds of themes
the museum could illustrate with these artifacts in the Etruscan collection. What you see here,
for instance, are some figures representing deities and mythological beings from Etruscan
religion. From left to right, at the top, you see Turan, Amins, Tuns, and Aplu, who you might
compare to the Greek Aphrodite, Eros, Hermes, and Apollo, or the Roman Venus, Amor, and Mercury.
Now Apollo is a Greek deity who did not have an originally Roman or Etruscan equivalent.
Both the Romans and the Etruscans adopted Apollo wholesale. The Etruscan goddess of love,
Turan, is here shown holding a dove in one hand and a pomegranate in the other, and these are
attributes that are not immediately associated with either Aphrodite or with Venus. At the bottom row,
you see a scarab, that is an object from Egyptian religion, and a few other objects
with aspects of Etruscan religion. This slide shows some of the two dozen objects that illustrate
aspects of human and animal life as well as death. The two women with the entwined arms originally
served as a handle for a bronze cosmetic box. The wine jug in the bottom row is decorated with
dancing women, panthers, and sirens. The plates with the wave-shaped patterns are a produce of
chyra, that is present-day cerveterie, that were very popular for everyday use. Many museums in
the world have an example. If they have an ancient collection, it is very, very common.
Next, a lovely sculptural fragment of a young woman that originally graced an architectural
structure, quite likely a temple. While the terracotta statuette was made in Etruria,
it is inspired by a Greek marble structural type that is called kore, that is a Greek word that
means girl or maiden, an unmarried young woman. Terracotta figurines such as this of young women
were a feature of a façade of a temple at Kairi that was predominantly decorated with warriors
and amazons and a row of kneeling maidens. You see in the background a little line drawing of
that temple façade. On the top, the horsemen are the amazons and the horsemen warriors, and then
on the horizontal row, you see the kneeling maidens, and it is assumed that this example belongs to
that very same group. What exactly the kneeling girls are supposed to signify is unclear. Perhaps
they were good charm figures that ward off evil, that means that they have an apotropaic
function. It has also been speculated that they might represent winds or something else that is
unfortunately not very well understood. But I'd like to emphasize that this lovely
statuette is part of the Peri Bequest to the TMA. This next object is probably my personal favorite,
of course that's also why it was the poster image for this lecture. It belongs to the Moody Bequest.
It's called a cinerarium, that means an urn or an ash box in which the cremated remains of a
deceased person were kept in the family tomb. On the lid you see lying a woman in a heavy pleated
dress, a costume that is quite common in the ancient world, in Greece, in Rome, and among
the Etrurians. She's lying on a cushion of a couch. At the top frame of the box,
not very easily to see, but her name is written from right to left in painted letters of the
Etruscan alphabets. If you look closely you might see some red paint and that is her name,
and that spells in Etruscan Larthi Kallunai Faisasa. In other words she is called Larthi,
she is of the family called Kallun and she was the wife of Faisa. All of these names,
Larthi or the male equivalent Larth, Kallun and Faisa, are well attested in other Etruscan
documents. The mold made relief on the front of this terracotta box curiously depicts a battle
scene of five fighting warriors. And I say curious because it is not immediately apparent why a
woman's ashes would be kept in a box decorated with such a masculine theme. Now if you look
closely at this photo from the Cortona Museum in Arezzo in Tuscany, you will perhaps notice that
the top row of cinerary urns all have very similar scenes, yet the reclining figures on the lid are
men and women, boys and girls indiscriminately. These photos, by the way, also give you a good
impression of the mass production of these ceramic boxes. One more slide will have to
suffice today to show you a selection of cups and vases, the image of course I showed before.
The TMA's Etruscan collection includes about two dozen vessels, including two amphoras,
that means storage vessels, four ornocoe, wine jugs, and two ariballoi, usually round
oil containers, and a handful of cups, including three cantharoi, as well as three urns.
They are examples of local ware as well as international manufacture.
The two round dishes with satyrs in the central tondo are examples of Feliscan ware, and Feliscan
is a language and a peoples that live in the region between Lazio and Eritrea,
but the dishes themselves are indistinguishable from Attic red figure ceramics.
So this may be an appropriate time to pause for some questions. If there are, I think there is a
Q&A. Yes, Dr. Pages would like to know, are there any theories about why we don't have better
historical records about the Etruscans? That they were lost is the best answer,
which means that there were records in the past, and during the acculturation process
some of it may have already gotten lost. We do know that Emperor Claudius, before he became
emperor, was actually an expert in Etruscan history, which means that in the first century
of the Common Era there was still a good library of historical documents about the Etruscans,
but sometime in later antiquity, certainly in the Middle Ages, interest in the Etruscans
waned. Probably no one could read the Etruscan language anymore, and if you remember that
documents have to be hand copied in order to survive and be transmitted, you can imagine that
not everything can be kept. Sometimes it might be burned accidentally, but often documents will
deteriorate over time and will have to be copied by hand in order to preserve them. So that's the
best what we can do in terms of explaining why so little is known about the Etruscans, but I might
also add that actually, apart from the Greeks and the Romans, there is so much we do not know
of ancient peoples. Brittany, did another question come up? It did. The head of the lady on the TMA
piece looks to be a different style, is it? Can we scroll back? The piece being the Cinerarium?
Marion, you didn't specify, but if you, yes, she says yes. It's very likely that these boxes were
made of molds, and if you examine them, you will find that, for instance, the fighting warriors
reappear on other boxes, and it's the exact same identical scene, meaning that they used the same
mold for that. But the background, the friezes, the column, and the little patterns around it
might be different, meaning that the artisans in workshops had different molds available
with which they could create variations. There's a sort of basic shape, but then you can change the
decoration, you can change the scenery, and the same with the lid, that you have a basic body,
and you have a mold for that, and you might have a few molds for the head, but you can also sort of
add details while the clay is still wet, and that might be why the head is a little sharper,
either the mold for the head was fresher than that of the body, or that the artist
added some detail with a sharp stylus or other sharp object.
That seems to be it for the moment. All right, excellent, so then let's move on to a more
ambitious idea of an exhibition in collaboration with some other museums, because if you want to
give a more comprehensive overview of Etruscan culture,
the TMA collection would not be sufficient for that.
You would need a few other museum collections to do such a thing. Such a presentation would allow
for a touring exhibition to a few other partner institutions, and what I will do here in a few
minutes is suggest exactly that, but if you stay within the same geographic, chronological,
and cultural scope, such an arrangement would also substantially broaden the thematic scope
of the exhibition, increase the artistic quality of the selected objects on display,
and I would say raise the level of interest for the museum visitors both at Tampa and elsewhere.
This arrangement allows for a much broader presentation of Etruscan pottery, both of
local manufacture and of imported produce, a wider range of metalware, a parade of military
artifacts, and a wealth of jewelry, a fuller scope of religious themes, including mythological
creatures, divinities, and ritual scenes, more human and animal figures, including an array of
human heads, as well as a more in-depth display of sepulchral and funerary aspects.
The objects illustrated in this proposal, selected from a choice of collections, show in what
artistic delights the museum visitor would be able to revel at the Tampa Museum and the other
possible venues. The region of Etruria, present-day Tuscany, was rich in metal resources, especially
copper, iron, lead, and silver. Their cast bronze sculptures are particularly famous and were highly
desired in antiquity. It is indeed remarkable how much has survived, because bronze and other metals
are easily reusable by simply melting down objects. Here you see a selection of Etruscan
artifacts from various museum collections, including mirrors, vessels, incense burners,
and candle holders. These are some of the more typical Etruscan metalware objects that survived.
Brittany, tell me, is that a question for me that I can answer in between?
Yes, Bill Zawadzki asked, aren't there some attic vases from the noble collection that were found
in Etruscan tombs? Yes, exactly. So this is why, if you want to show Etruscan pottery, you also have
to show that some, in fact many, attic vases are found in Italy, in southern Italy, but also in
Etruria. So certainly this is why I mentioned that Etruscan pottery includes local manufacture,
as well as imported produce. So this slide is for the boys out there, some military artifacts such
as helmets, shields, breastplates, greaves, and spear points. Also some bronze and terracotta
figurines showing how Etruscan warriors would have looked. Like any other ancient civilization,
the army was an important feature of Etruscan society. Campaigns into neighboring regions
offered the possibility of additional territory, plunder, and war captives for ransom and for
slavery. Military victories were a source of prestige as well as wealth, and most of these
military artifacts have been preserved in Etruscan tombs. In my opinion, these human figures are a lot
more delightful. They illustrate aspects such as dress, beauty ideals, male nudity,
as well as funerary sculpture. They also demonstrate far-reaching influences from
elsewhere, not only in Italy and Greece, but even Egypt and Assyria. Also note all the way in the
bottom right the anatomical figure with exposed internal organs, which may perhaps have been
a votive for stomach ailments. This slide here shows a selection of heads of men and women,
as well as mythic creatures such as the gorgon and satyrs. It is difficult to see here, but the
bust of a woman on the center left is a stone sculpture with original paint remaining,
including red, yellow, faded black, and bluish-purple on the tunic. The terracotta head
in the upper left also preserves ample original paint with white for the skin, red for the hair,
and gilding on the crown. Vessels were created in shapes of heads too, as you can see here,
just as they were in ancient Greece. Some of these vases portray black Africans,
and they raise the question if they reflect ethnic uttering. Are they made with genuine
respect, or are they examples of stereotypical prejudices based on racism?
From human heads, it is perhaps a logical step to jewelry. This selection amply demonstrates
the precious jewelry with which the Etruscan elite flaunted their wealth. I imagine the slide
speaks for itself, but I would like to draw particular attention to the signet ring in the
lower left. The bezel is incised with a winged sphinx in the middle, wearing a cap associated
with Etruscan and Roman priests. Above and below are stylized bird-like figures with open wings,
and the hull is contained within a rope-like border that resembles a cartouche,
that is, the device in which the throne names of Egyptian pharaohs were written.
So the whole signet, in fact, displays an Egyptian influence.
We could go on, of course, but one more slide will have to suffice for today. In the left column,
top to bottom, you can see a satyr, a centaur, and two conjoined winged sphinxes. These are
mythic creatures known particularly from Greek religion, although the sphinx also derives from
Egypt. These are figures that the Etruscans knew, but what we do not know is what they were called
in Etruscan. The ringed figures in the upper center are the sun god Ussil and a divine attendant
called Lhasa. Below them, in the middle, are the supreme gods Tin and Merva, that is, the Etruscan
version of Minerva. And bottom are perhaps Meampe, a goddess of fertility and victory,
a bit like Nike or Victoria, but also a goddess of fertility, hence the little children around her.
And next to her is Hercule, the Etruscan version of Hercules.
Then in the column on the right is a youth carrying a sacrificial pig,
a young priest pouring a libation offer, and a sacrificial scene. I see that this is a good
time to ask questions, both on Zoom or perhaps on Facebook, that I can answer.
On Zoom, we did have a comment from Michelle Kidwell Gilbert.
I believe the Met's great Euphronius crater was also found in an Etruscan tomb, albeit in many
places. Yeah, correct. So thanks for that. But it is precisely because these Etruscan tombs were so
well preserved that from the 18th, 19th century, when these tombs were reopened, all these artifacts
came back that have not survived or have not survived as well in the Greek world.
And there are demonstrations of the very intense trade networks and gift exchange networks between
at least southern Italy and northern Italy, but probably even directly to the Greek world.
Anything else? Not so far.
All right. The main purpose of the first option that I present today is a proposal
focused on the Etruscan objects of the TMA's Antiquities Collection in its entirety,
in a single gallery, without further recontextualization beyond, of course,
up-to-date labels and accompanying texts. Another Q&A popped up?
It did. Suzanne Williamson asked, would TMA be able to do any research with this
exhibit that could add to knowledge of our objects and the Etruscans?
You're jumping ahead. I will get back to that in a couple of minutes. Thanks, Suzanne.
If you do this single comprised gallery, there might not be much reason to do renewed research.
But when you do the second, more comprehensive option,
proposing a partnership with some national or North American institutions, then yes, I think
doing some research, inviting specialists would be a great idea.
It would also allow the museum visitors to better place the objects of the TMA's
collection within their cultural context. The TMA collection is certainly respectable,
but of course it cannot be comprehensive. The idea would not only be to pair the TMA's
Etruscan objects with collections from other museums, but also to send off that
exhibition to selected other venues. The chief aim of this second option is to
gather some of the most attractive Etruscan objects from national or North American collections.
The exhibition may further occasion questions about the significance of cultural exchange for
ancient aristocratic communities, the diversity of interactions between Etruscans and other italic
and Greek communities, the trade connections with Central Europe, Carthage and Egypt,
the martial nature of Etruscan society and the position of women, as well as reflections about
the physical manifestation of sepulchral and funerary art and their importance for beliefs
in the afterlife. Despite the saying that a picture is worth a thousand words, objects cannot
really express complexities such as ethnicity and cultural identity. Yet in the case of the
Etruscans, the origins, language, culture and ethnicity remain fascinating enigmas for which
even seasoned specialists have no convincing answers. Exactly because of these mysteries,
the proposed exhibition will allow the TMA to engage the visitors in a dialogue and reconsider
some of these issues which in fact also continue to reverberate to the present day.
Brittany, what's the question? Oh, it's the same one from before, I just hadn't dismissed it yet.
All right, very good. So the first focused option to display the entire Etruscan collection of the
TMA in one museum gallery has many benefits and I think that it hardly requires much explanation.
These objects have not been presented as an ensemble together. They include big quests of
some of the most important past and even a few present supporters of the museum. The presentation
will require only a minimum of cost, research, planning and effort, and yet it will allow the
museum visitor to appreciate the charm of Etruscan art and culture as distinct from, yet evidently
related to, Greek and Roman antiquity. I feel that demonstrating that the museum has an Etruscan
collection, that it is not an extension of the Greek and Roman collection but a separate entity
in that collection, would be very beneficial. The show could easily be slotted into planning
after the upcoming renovation projects have finished. But should the preference be felt for
the second option, should that become realistic, the first option may not have to be discounted.
If the touring exhibition were to be scheduled, the TMA's Etruscan objects would be off-site for
maybe a year or two. The first option might thus be a nice goodbye presentation.
While the second could be considered a kind of welcome back occasion for the more
comprehensive exhibition. In other words, one need not have to choose, both options could be planned
to take place. The more comprehensive approach naturally has many more attractive features that
the first option does not have, and the strengths of this option would seem self-evident from what
I have just mentioned before. But there are also some weaknesses and pitfalls to consider.
There are certainly two collections from which loans will not pose any difficulties. I'm thinking
here about the Hearst Museum in Berkeley and the Filth Museum in Chicago. But some of the
important items that are necessary for supplementing the exhibition will have to be requested from
prominent institutions that may not be so willing to see their objects leave for two years
and travel to other venues. It is suggested therefore to choose as collaborating partners two
outstanding institutions willing to participate in terms of research, as well as both lender
and venue. For this I have in mind the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston and either the Johns Hopkins
Archaeological Museum or the Walters Museum in Baltimore. This partnership will then offer the
opportunity to present the exhibition to two more venues with a small or with no Etruscan collection
at all, such as the Toledo Museum of Art or the Vincent Price Museum in Santa Monica.
Let me stress that the TMA or I personally have not been in touch with any of the museums that I
have just mentioned. Another major weakness in the present proposal is the absence of objects
from Italian collections, such as most obviously the Vatican Museums or the Villa Giulia in Rome.
And treating Italian collections would involve a significant investment of both logistical
and diplomatic resources and will further increase the expenses. The proposal that I
am presenting here is based on the assumption that North American collections will suffice
for the purpose of the present project. According to Florida demographic
statistics, about five to six percent of the population of the larger Tampa Bay area is of
Italian or partially Italian descent. The exhibition then would provide a perfect opportunity
for the TMA to strengthen its ties with the local Italian community to demonstrate continued
interest in ancient Italian and pre-Roman art and culture for scheduling Tuscany-inspired
events at Gasparilla Plaza. The museum could consider collaborations with the Italian Club
for instance, or even Little Italy in St. Pete, among others. Indeed, this exhibition is a seamless
fit for encouraging tourism to Tuscany, to its archaeological sites, its capital Florence,
as well as Pisa and Siena, not to mention the Tuscan vineyards that produce Chianti
and Montepulciani wines, among others. Finally, it has to be acknowledged that the current proposal
does not aim to present Etruscan art and culture in an innovative design. That is not to say that
multimedia applications cannot be developed or that dialogues about issues relevant for
contemporary society are to be shown. What I mean to say is that the proposal is in essence a
traditional archaeological and art historical project, intending to contextualize the Etruscans
in their broader historical and cultural horizon, according to the most recent scholarship.
And unless I am mistaken, there has not been an exhibition of this nature about the Etruscans
in the entire North America since 2012. And again, to the best of my knowledge, there are about
eight museums with relevant Etruscan collections in North America. Of these, the Field Museum in
Chicago would be the most obvious institution for supplementing the exhibition with loans,
not only because the museum has a relatively substantial collection of nearly 500 highly
interesting objects, but also because none are on display. Moreover, the field objects derive
either from archaeological excavations or were acquired early in the 20th century,
and therefore that avoids issues of provenance.
It would have two or three partners, exporters and vendors, for the exhibition, not only for
sharing the financial burden with other organizations and institutions, but also to
ensure the development of an equitable exhibition partnership. The museum in Philadelphia has a
collection of 2,000 Etruscan objects, but naturally their most important pieces are on display in the
permanent presentation. The same reasoning will apply to the Etruscan collections at other
prominent museums, such as the Getty Villa in Malibu or the New York Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Some of these organizations and institutions may eventually become recurrent or long-term partners
in a more or less formal consortium for future projects.
In my opinion, again, the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston would be an ideal partner, not only
because of the exceptional quality of their Etruscan collection, but also only just about a
dozen objects are on permanent display, leaving over 500 items available for the exhibition,
Should the Boston MFA show interest in the proposed exhibition, it would also offer me
the exceptional opportunity to work again with the museum's curator, Laure Marrest. The Boston MFA
and the TMA could jointly edit an accompanying catalog consisting of invited contributions,
for instance by some of these experts mentioned in this list. In addition to a brief catalog
of entries for the traveling objects in the exhibition.
So before I wrap up my talk, perhaps there are questions that I can address.
Is there anything on Facebook? We just had a couple pop up in Zoom.
So do you know if there are any teachings about Etruscan history in high school? What questions
do you think these objects might present to our young people? What elements and characteristics
of the objects would appeal to them? Well, this is interesting. I think that the Etruscans are
often neglected in high school. And so if you have a presentation such as this, it would be wise to
create a kind of brochure for high school visitors, whether they come with their teacher or
in another context. But objects will be interesting. I think the human figures, I think the
gods. I made a joke, of course, about the military artifacts, that's typical for boys.
I don't mean to be prejudiced, of course, it was meant as a joke, but I'm sure that for many
young boys, these military objects are very fascinating. The jewelry is tremendous. But
I think a lot of it speaks to people because it's very immediate, recognizable to some extent.
Yeah, they have. So another question from Penny Liu, and I apologize, I am probably going to not
pronounce these names correctly, but you showed briefly the painting by Henri La Brouste of
Etruscan tombs. I was delighted to discover Alma Tatum's video showing the Parthenon Priest of
Friends. Has there ever been an exhibit of 18th, 19th century historical paintings dealing with
Greek, Roman, Etruscan themes? I'm sure there has been, certainly in terms of more specific,
rather than antiquity in general. But it is an absolutely lovely topic, of course,
in the 19th century, particularly people like Tadema had almost an obsession with antiquity,
not just Greek and Rome, but Egyptian, Etruscan, part of the grand tour for budding artists to
visit these sites and be inspired. These are certainly lovely occasions to think of,
but I'm not familiar with any recent exhibitions in North America.
And then one last question from the chat, from Barbara Stubbs. We learn about the Etruscan
culture from what remains of temples and tombs. What do you think would remain from our current
culture for future generations to study? Yeah, that's a question that archaeologists have,
because a lot of what we do now is so, yeah, it's digital, so that gets lost. Once technology
changes, a lot of our material, like our writing material is perishable. Back in antiquity,
things were written in stone. Now that's permeable, that survives. So
unfortunately, probably plastic will survive. Many of the things that we cherish now,
we do not save beyond our life. And so probably less will survive, the buildings, or at least
parts of buildings will survive. But a lot of it will get lost. But in antiquity too, of course,
more has been lost than has survived. And then just one last comment. So far on Facebook,
we've had a couple of comments, and they both would like to thank you for your presentation.
Well, my pleasure. I would like to wrap it up, and then we can address any further questions that
might come up. In my talk, I have pitched an exhibition proposal. Like I said, I've done so
in previous Antiquities Circle lectures. And this one actually consists of two concepts,
one of a focused presentation of the entire Etruscan collection of the TMA, and the other,
a touring exhibition project in partnership with several North American museums. The Etruscans
remain fascinating because of their beautiful works of art and their mysterious origins,
but they also continue to be relevant for contemporary society as an example of an
ancient people deeply influenced by other cultures with whom they were interconnected
through various networks. I would like to close by reiterating what I have said in previous lectures,
which is that the ancient world in general continues to inspire and educate us about art
and religion, cultural exchange, and ethnic diversity, and many other subjects. The beautiful
artifacts on display in the Tampa Museum of Art can thus teach us lessons that remain profoundly
relevant today. So please continue to patronage the TMA, to wander around the museum, and to
wonder about the ancient, modern, and contemporary art on display. Feel free to connect in your own
personal way with the objects, either in the introductory gallery of the TMA's permanent
collection of antiquities, or the ongoing Her Story exhibition that focuses on ancient heroines
and everyday women. I thank you for your attention. It has been a great pleasure again to propose
this exhibition concept, and I hope that one day we may soon meet each other in person.
If you have questions, I think there's about 10 minutes left for that. I would personally be very
interested in your thoughts, if you believe this exhibition proposal is feasible, if you would be
interested in visiting such an exhibition, and if you have any suggestions for improvements.
Bronco, perhaps while people are typing, one question I had for you. I know in the past
you and Joanna have talked about collectors from the collection in the museum, and I'm curious,
you mentioned four prominent collectors for this particular exhibition, and I know there are others
within the larger classical antiquity collection. So what does it mean for the museum to have so
many passionate collectors of classical antiquity in the area? It means that it is essential to
maintain as a museum a relationship with these people who are passionate, who collect for their
own personal motives, and to show them that we as a museum are interested in the same subjects.
I'm not sure if that fully addresses the issue or answers your question, but
it's certainly something that I think a concept like this would help. Same with, for instance,
the idea that I gave to have an exhibition about Knossos, to illustrate that the museum is
interested in many other aspects of antiquity, and it does not even need to be Mediterranean
antiquity. That happens to be what I'm specialized in, but certainly the Etruscans or the Egyptians
are very fascinating, and the museum would be very interested in enlarging its collection,
and it is through the passion and the support in many different ways from the friends of the museum,
collectors in the area, that the museum is able to enlarge that collection.
And Bill Zawadzki adds to that, that the museum's Magna Graecia show demonstrates
that significant loans, primarily from Italy, are possible if a significant budget is available.
Exactly. Money is, of course, always an issue, even for the Getty or for the Metropolitan Museum,
even for the big guys, money is always an issue. But that doesn't mean that
there is not a lot that a smaller museum or a medium-sized museum can do, and this is why
people like Bill Zawadzki and previous sponsors of the museum are so important.
There were one or two objects from Bill Zawadzki in the presentation today.
Following up on the question that Barbara Stubbs posed, we had a comment from Facebook that
Quartz is now collecting our memories, latest in memory chips, so perhaps there's some extension
of what will be left behind through new media. There are, yeah, exactly, there are attempts to
save our memory for the future, because if we don't do it now it won't happen by itself.
And then my last question, just in case, give people another moment to type if that's what
they're doing. In this presentation you presented a display of all of the Etruscan works together.
I'm curious if in your research into the objects at TMA, if you've gotten an idea of how the
Etruscan objects have been displayed in the past. No, at the museum I imagine that that is
the question. So no, I imagine that they have mostly been shown as an extension of Greek and
Roman culture, and so if you want to show a statue of Venus or Aphrodite, then you put Turan right
next to it, implying that they are identical or at least very similar.
And an exhibition focused on the Etruscans can emphasize these interconnections certainly,
but can also draw out the differences. Thank you. The one last comment it looks like we have is
thank you from Brad Arthur, thank you very much for an excellent presentation.
Well, it's my pleasure. I see a lot of chat and Q&A pass by, but it's impossible
to read everything, sorry folks. But are there two more questions left, Brittany?
No, more thank you comments.
All right, terrific. Well, thank you all for attending and for your input.
It's really a great pleasure to see so many people interested.
And to follow up on your request for feedback on the feasibility of this exhibition,
all of you who attended today's presentation will receive a link to a survey,
and we would greatly appreciate if you could fill that out and give us some more input.
Absolutely.
With that, thank you so much everybody for attending this afternoon's Antiquity Circle
Lecture on the Etruscans. If you want to review any of the material, we did broadcast live on
Facebook. So if you visit the museum's Facebook page, you can watch a recording of the lecture.
With that, I hope everybody has a wonderful rest of your weekend and a good week ahead.
Thank you all again.
Thank you, Bronco.
My pleasure.
