Today, we look at former UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak's first major interview since he left office.
Nick Robinson joins Adam to unpack what Mr Sunak had to say, including why he regrets the ‘Stop the Boats’ slogan, how he felt about a podcast questioning his Englishness and what his political philosophy boils down to.
But first, Adam is joined by BBC Economics editor Faisal Islam to discuss the UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves looking at making spending cuts worth billions to the government’s welfare budget.
The Treasury will put the proposed cuts to the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) on Wednesday amid expectations the chancellor's financial headroom has disappeared. Adam and Faisal Islam unpack what we know about the proposed cuts, and the chancellor’s Spring Statement later this month.
We've picked up hints that the government is preparing to cut the welfare bill to deal with
the public finances and also Rishi Sunak, the former Prime Minister. Remember him? Well he's
back and he's given a really long interview to a BBC podcast. We'll discuss all of that
on the BBC's daily news podcast, Newscast. Hello, it's Adam in the Newscast studio and shortly we'll
cross over to Westminster to speak to Nick Robinson to hear about Rishi Sunak's return
to the political fray because he's done that two-hour long interview which is available to
listen to on Political Thinking, Nick's podcast on BBC Sounds. But first of all we're going to
talk about the current government and Rachel Reeves, we are told, is pouncing in some cuts
to the welfare budget, particularly sickness-related benefits, to deal with the fact that the government
is facing a grimmer economic picture than they were expecting when Rachel Reeves did her budget
in October last year. And the person who's been picking up all these hints and gleaning all there
is to be gleaned in Whitehall is the BBC's economics editor Faisal Islam, who is here,
hello Faisal. Hi, I want squatter's rights. Yeah exactly, please feel free to stay as long as you
like. Right okay, before we dive into the details of kind of what you've gleaned we probably have
to set out a bit of, I hate the word context, but just what's the kind of the process that we're in
ahead of the Chancellor's big statement on the 26th of March that means there is this news?
There's a sort of what they call a process, a tit-for-tat process, where the OBR comes up with
an assessment of the economy. The Office of Budget Responsibility. Yes of course, the
government's official broadcaster and it tries to mark, if you like, the Treasury's homework. So the
and the OBR comes in and does the maths to take away the temptation that you had under previous
sort of chancellors to sort of slightly put in optimistic assumptions to fudge tough decisions.
So that's the point of it. They go through that process, they have loads of inputs,
so what's going on in the world, what's going on in Europe, what's going on in global interest
markets, exchange rates, everything goes into a giant blender computer and out comes some
forecasts of the economy and whether or not the government is going to hit that target. Now at
budget, Rachel Reeves left herself a fairly slim room for manoeuvre of about just under £10 billion
in the single year at the end of the forecast, so sort of 2029-ish. And that's known as the
headroom isn't it? That is known as the fiscal headroom, right, and this has become a sort of
target whenever there's changes in economic circumstances that you don't want to miss. Now
our assumption, and I've had nothing to dissuade me from this generalised assumption,
is that all of that, almost all of that, has been used up. And so the challenge at the spring
statement... And used up as a combination of the economy being less good than people might hope
and the government probably spending a little bit more than they intended to. Well it's over five
years so it tends to be less about the news in the air, but that doesn't help, that's true.
It tends to be more about longer run factors and in particular the assumptions about things
like interest rates. So the fact that government interest rates have gone up from what they
assumed in August is a big factor. But then anything that takes away from growth, remember
there's a government that argues that it's going to do a whole lot of things that add to growth,
well the OBR is a little bit sceptical about that these days. But just to go back to the process
then, that is the reason we're talking about this at all today. So what the latest version
of the government's future spending plans has gone to, is going to the OBR. Well no,
the Treasury have that and now they're going to respond, pretty much when people are listening to
this, they'll respond with their major measures. That's what it is, the official title, which is
if you like the course correction to get things back on track in terms of that headroom that we
talked about, the government's own homework meeting its rules. So that's what's going on
now. Now that's not the final stage, the things that they put on this letter email that's gone
to the OBR aren't cast in stone, they can evolve that. The process here is the OBR will say well
do you know what, we don't think it's going to raise as much money, actually it's going to raise
a lot more money than we think. That sort of thing is happening. And so I guess the takeaway here
is the government knows the size of its challenge and the government has, as we speak, put forward a
set of policies to change that. So we know that now about them and then we can see and we can
divine everything that they say in a different light, knowing that, as I understand, they have
a focusing, and you know we've known some of this already at this stage, on multi-billion cuts to
welfare bill and to government spending through efficiency and productivity. And there may be
other stuff too, but that's what I know. And have you managed to glean anything else about
what they think about the welfare bill or how they're going to tackle it? Or do we just know
that that's actually the area that they're kind of putting the magnifying glass over? Well it isn't
just the welfare bill, they're pretty focused on the health outcomes. We talked about it a lot on
newscasts for people at work. There's been a massive increase in that since the pandemic.
It's continued and now it's got even worse. So the question that arises is, are we sicker
as a nation? Do we define sickness in a way that's more expansive now?
That is very real for the people that are engaged in that. Is that sustainable? Is the generosity
of the welfare system too much for this level of sickness? All these questions come to mind.
Now the government is saying privately, this is not the reason why we're doing these sorts of
changes. We'd have done them anyway. We want to make welfare work. We've got to fix the welfare
bill. But the brutal reality is that at first pass that will mean either fewer people eligible
for some of these benefits and or, I think probably both, some of them become less generous
in order to get this money. We're going to have a speech from Ms. Kendall, I think next week,
not entirely sure. And that may well outline some of those decisions that are taken.
Then there's two other speeches, one from the health secretary of West Streeting
and from Pat McFadden, the cabinet office minister in general sort of power, about government
efficiency. Now, this is where I do some interpretation. I cannot imagine you can get
scorable benefits of many billions of pounds unless you do something very concrete like shrink
the number of civil servants. There may be some other stuff going on here. There may be some like
do better on contracts. A little twist here, and it's a problem I think for the government,
is that the OBR had started to say under pressure from Jeremy Hunt, it was not under pressure,
that certain policies would generate growth. And that helps everything. It helps the numbers.
It means that that hole in the public finances against your self-imposed targets shrinks. So
it's exactly what you want. You want to persuade the OBR, I'm going to generate growth. Jeremy Hunt
did that a little bit with some of his policies a year or so ago. This time they happen to have
got an independent report in from the Dutch version of the OBR who have said, do you know what,
if you just do that on the way up, you've got to do it on the way down. Otherwise it's biased.
So I think it has emboldened some scepticism on things like Labour's planning reform. So planning
reform should yield growth. Can the OBR believe that? And to the extent they don't believe that,
there's no benefit. Yeah, interesting. Because my mind is blown about the fact that we're now
getting advice from the Dutch version of the Office of Budget Responsibility. I wonder what
they're marking their homework, who are marking the Treasury's homework.
Yeah. Another way of looking at this is what's the alternative? And politicians are really,
really saying there's no alternative. This is why I'm pursuing this course of action.
But isn't the alternative here that actually Rachel Reeves changes her fiscal rules or
finds a way of being more generous to herself so she can borrow a bit more? And I'm just thinking
about, we keep hearing from Brussels that they're going to change the EU's version of the fiscal
rules to exclude defence spending so they can ramp up their defence spending without falling
foul of the fiscal rules that they have for themselves. I mean, those are alternatives.
They are. So the first thing to say is that this game about this year's
forecast is a bit silly, right? It's like, does it really make a difference? Has the world,
you know, we're gonna hear a lot actually from the Treasury about how the world has changed.
Is this how it's changed? Like a few billion here and there, 0.25% extra in the government
interest costs. This is not fundamental. The idea that you greatly change policy as a result of
this. And they're stressing, headroom or no headroom, this is not why we're making these
changes. We'd want to sort out welfare, we'd want to sort out deficiency of the civil service.
But the more fundamental change that you allude to, which is, for example, a one percentage point
of GDP increase in defence spending, which is entirely plausible. That's where we get into land.
You know, how you deal with that, that does raise some really serious questions. And one chart the
OBR provided in a very obscure document two years ago, was to show that the health and welfare bill
as a percentage of our national economy went up significantly, but only as we enjoyed the peace
dividend, only when defence spending went down from 10% to like even below 2%. And now we're
talking about getting back up to 3%, 5%. Where does that come from? Does that come from shrinking
the state, the generosity that comes initially from shrinking the international aid budget?
That's not wholly out of the woods in terms of the Labour Party right now. Where else does it
come from? And you make the point about the fiscal rules. Now, at this very moment, practically to
the hour, it's not just the European Union. But as you know, the Germans who have not just a set of
fiscal rules, it's hardwired into their constitution, the debt break, exactly. And it's designed to sort of create
the utmost credibility. And it eventually led to the fall of the Olaf Scholz government in the election
that we've just seen. And they have changed it as a result of the fact that the circumstances have
changed palpably. So they're going to exempt defence spending above 1%. They're also on top of that
separately, because the German economy has been pretty moribund. They're going to inject 500
billion euros into infrastructure spending. So they have altered to reflect the current
circumstances. I think the government, Treasury, Rachel Reeves will argue, well, we have done
something similar on infrastructure, we've exempted capital spending. But if there is, if people do
argue, and it's a fairly common argument, you've heard it on Newscast, that we need to spend
tens of billions more on defence now. I think, you know, the argument will come about the
fiscal rules. They were, they were forged in a different time.
Well, yeah. And then the other, the other alternative is tax rises. But of course, Rachel
Reeves is hemmed in by two pledges, one from the election to not increase the main rates of income
tax, employee national insurance, or VAT. And then that sort of second pledge she made at the CBI a
few months ago, saying actually, she wouldn't do a repeat of the last budget and actually kind of like
the big tax rises for this parliament are already done. So she's kind of, that's why she can't do
tax rise.
And we don't think anything's going to change at the spring statement in three weeks time.
But like an obvious route, if you needed a tax raising weapon, and remember, taxes are still
a very high now as proportion and records have been pushed higher. But if you needed to raise
still further, it would be to continue the freeze in income tax thresholds that conservatives do.
Easy in a sense that the conservatives will find it very difficult to attack that having
done it repeatedly over more than a decade or so. But she sort of dismissed that as an idea
in the final flourish of her budget speech in autumn. So she's a little bit restricted on that
too. But that's an option maybe for the autumn.
I suppose that one of the things that makes it politically easier to do things with the
welfare budget is the opposition are probably going to support it. Because I was listening
to Nick Robinson's big log interview he's done with Rishi Sunak. So Rishi Sunak's come
back to the political stage is a two hour long multi episode series of political thinking,
Nick's podcast. And actually, Rishi Sunak is kind of on board with this stuff. He says,
what is his actual phrase like the spending on on welfare sickness related welfare benefits
is out of control and unsustainable. Actually, the opposition is probably going to go along
with anything.
They will go along with it. But the Labour backbenchers have been fairly mute on all
sorts of things, including the cut to the aid budget. But although they're not connected at
the moment, presentationally at the spring statement, we will also get this the world
has changed defence spending. I think the Chancellor will start allocating some of that
uplift in defence spending and mapping out this route to 3%. Now, at the same time,
announcing welfare cuts, well, that might crystallise some at least political thought
amongst the Labour backbenchers about, okay, you know, we understand that Europe has to
rearm, but do we want this to be paid for by international aid? Do we want this to be
paid for by a lower welfare bill? You know, and you start now to test the actual limits
of what price are the public willing to pay in terms of solidarity with Ukraine, maybe
quite a lot in terms of generalised rearmament, someone's got to pay the bill.
And by the power of podcasting, we're now joined by Nick Robinson, who's in Westminster.
Hello, Nick.
Hello, Adam.
Hello. We were just talking, I mean, Faisal, about your epic interview with Rishi Sunak.
Well, the question is whether you mean epic in quality or in length. It's certainly very
long, isn't it? Which is a new thing for me. And I think it's a new thing for the BBC to
do what some American podcasts do routinely, which is to talk to someone for a couple of
hours. And I have to say, I was a bit of a sceptic before doing it. The former prime
minister was determined to do a conversation, not an interrogation, a podcast rather than a
conventional news programme. I needed some persuading. But I have to say, I think, I hope
people find if they listen to it, there's quite a lot that comes out of it that wouldn't have
done from a conventional interview.
Oh, I totally agree. And I listened to it over my breakfast this morning. And we'll come on
to kind of the philosophy behind it in a second. But just that point that me and Faisal were
talking about there about Rishi Sunak saying, yeah, we need to tackle the sickness-related
bit of the welfare bill. He talks about actually, you need to quite radically rethink what the
state does, doesn't he?
Exactly that. And you can see in him the frustrated former chancellor. This is a guy,
I remember, spent a fortune, and we really do mean a fortune, on tackling the Covid pandemic.
400 billion quid. Now, what does that mean? Because it's a vast sum, which frankly, I don't
really understand, but I got someone to do the numbers for me. It means the whole of
the budget for the NHS, the whole of the defence budget, the whole of the education budget,
the whole of the policing budget, all add together, you still haven't got as much as
that. It is a vast sum of money. But his view was always, that was a one-off to stop us
going through a kind of 1930s-style recession, in other words, mass unemployment in the face
of the Covid pandemic, but it would have to be paid back. Now, in addition, he thinks
that we, as many people say, we've got to increase defence spending. Where are you
going to get that money from? Not only have you not got the room to borrow more and more,
you can borrow some, the Germans are doing it after all, but there's a limit to that,
it also costs a lot more to borrow now than it did when Rishi Sunak was chancellor and Boris
Johnson was prime minister. So he's saying, therefore, you have to take big choices,
make big decisions, and his big criticism about politics, politicians, but the likes of you and me,
Faisal as well, the media, in other words, and people listening is, we're not willing
enough to discuss trade-offs, that if you want something, you can't have something else,
and he thinks, if you want defence, you're going to have to lose something, and in his case,
that means billions of pounds of welfare, which means people who've currently got benefits
will have to lose them, in his view. Faisal, have you started listening to this? I haven't
got through the whole thing, but I'm totally fascinated by it, and I thought, I think he's
quite a fascinating character, and I always detected, and some of it came out in the bit
that I heard, a bit of reluctance to assume the position that he did. I wondered if he would have
preferred staying Chancellor for a bit longer, rather than take on being Prime Minister in the
circumstances that he had to, but I also recall, while he was Chancellor, in the middle of this
Covid epic, he was, and he reflects on this, that his approval rating went through the roof.
He was hugely popular. It was Dishi Rishi, remember? I wondered whether, as perhaps Boris Johnson,
and he talked about falling out with Boris Johnson earlier than we imagined in Nick's podcast,
I do wonder whether he may have noticed that the British public had changed a little bit
as a result of some of those interventions. Faisal, I'm going to let you go, because I know
you've got lots of news to do, and Bob, me and Nick have a chat, so I'll see you later on. Thanks for
coming in. No worries. Nick, just that point that Faisal was making about, would Rishi Sunak
have liked to stay Chancellor for longer? You actually addressed that with him, and he's quite
candid about, yeah, just the level of disagreement between him and Boris Johnson, and how long they
were disagreeing on economic policy for. That's right. They used to have regular dinners on a
Sunday night in Downing Street, because one living above number 11, one living above number 10, and
of course in Covid you were limited to your ability to get out and about and see anybody else,
and it became clear in our conversation that they had steadily started to fall out about
economics, because Sunak having on the one hand given all this money, then as I was saying a
moment ago, thought we're going to start paying it back, whereas Boris Johnson was saying let's
find some new things to spend on. So an example of that is social care. Now lots of people think
the system of social care in this country is extremely unfair, that you can lose the price
of your house if you're unlucky enough to have dementia yourself, or your loved one has dementia,
and that there should be a system of, you know, limiting the ability, limiting the risk, I'm
sorry, of losing your house. Sunak's view was very clear to Johnson, and it's very clear now.
We can't afford it. You know, we cannot have another scheme for the state subsidising people.
Forget it. We're not going to do it, because if we did we'd have to put your taxes up. He's very
clear about net zero. They fell out again and again. Remember Boris Johnson, like Theresa May
before him, was rather passionate about the idea of tackling climate change and that target of
reaching net zero by 2050. Richie Sunak stayed as Prime Minister, signed up to the idea,
but briefly said, or towards the end of his premiership, said let's do it a bit slower,
let's loosen some of these targets. Now he says he'd get rid of the legal targets altogether.
He's not a climate change sceptic, but he is, in the words of Kemi Badenot, the new Tory leader,
he's a net zero sceptic. He's doubtful that the price that people have to pay is wise,
and these arguments are one of the reasons he quit Boris Johnson's cabinet. Party 8 was another,
and of course his critics would say Ambition was a third that he wanted to get rid of Johnson.
And just in terms of other bits of news that emerged from the interview, as opposed to kind
he's very down on his old own slogan of stop the boats.
He certainly is. It's extraordinary to think, isn't it? Because if you and I had sat here and
said what's one phrase, what's a slogan, what's a promise you associate with Richie Sunak? I think
we'd instantly both have said stop the boats. Not only did he say it again and again, he was always
in front of that lectern, wasn't he? In front of him, stop the boats. And I remember the day I saw
it thinking that's a mad promise because you won't do it. I mean, I don't mean you shouldn't
want to do it. That's a matter of political debate, whether it's a good or a bad idea.
Many people would want to stop the boats, but to say that you will stop the boats,
and compare it with Donald Trump, for example, who, whether you love or loathe him, is a great
political communicator. In his first term in office, he didn't say stop illegal migration
over the border from Mexico. He said build the wall. In other words, in his three-word slogan,
he said something he'd do in order to deal with the problem. And I think Sunak clearly realises
that being tested against a slogan you could never, ever, ever possibly deliver, no border
in the world is completely sealed, was a daft piece of political communication and he regrets it.
Although he did that classic politician thing, which is to say, oh, it was a problem of
communication and the slogan was the problem, as opposed to his competency at handling the issue
itself. He sort of didn't go the whole way. No, and that means that some people on the Tory right
have said the problem wasn't communication, it was that you didn't deliver and you didn't deliver
because you weren't tough enough, would say some critics on the right. They, even members of his
own cabinet, even allies, like a guy who was Immigration Minister, Robert Jenrick now,
the Shadow Justice Secretary, old mate, and I do mean old, he's no longer, I think, a mate of Rishi
Sunak, fell out with him because he said, look, we tried everything, you've got to get out of the
European Convention on Human Rights, which stops us doing the sorts of tough things, intervening
with the boats at sea, packing people off to Rwanda the second they land. We've got to do those things
and we can only do it by getting out of that European call. Sunak now says, in my interview
with him, that he would be prepared to do that if the court doesn't change, but his critics on the
right are frustrated he didn't come up with that when he was Prime Minister. And what are we
learning about what he wants to do with the rest of his life? Because, I mean, you talk about this
with him quite a few times, that for an ex-Prime Minister, he's very young, still in his early 40s.
I mean, it's crazy, isn't it? 44. I mean, he was in the cabinet. It's a great age, Nick.
Yes, and you've got so much ahead of you, both of you, but we can do something together. But no, it's an
amazing thing, isn't it? To be an ex-Prime Minister, and he joked in the House of Commons the other day
in a speech, was 44 too young to be an elder statesman. I get the sense he hasn't yet fully
worked that out. Stage one was to stay an MP. Now, he was surrounded by social media posts.
You can't be surrounded by a post, you know what I mean? There were a lot of them
claiming that the reason he called an early election was they had a secret plan to head
off to California, where he still had a house. He used to live there when he was a city trader,
or for a period at least, and as a student. And he didn't. And he stayed in Richmond. He stayed the
MP for Richmond. That is where his home is. That's where his family are, as well as living, obviously,
sometime in London, because he's a Member of Parliament. And I think he wants to say to people,
look, I'm committed to this, which is one reason the charitable foundation he's set up
is called the Richmond Project, the one that deals with his particular passion, which is education,
and his particular passion within that, which is trying to get the spread of numeracy. In other
words, making sure that everybody has the basics of adding up, because he and his wife at Charter,
he runs this project with, believe that that inability to do the very basic sums that you need
to do everyday tasks in life, whether it's shopping or checking your bills add up,
making sure you're not ripped off by people you deal with, that if you haven't got those skills,
it really holds you back. So at the moment, I think we're at that level of using that charitable
foundation to take some initiatives. He did something on cancer the other day, prostate
cancer, he became a spokesman for that charity as well. I can't help thinking, though, that as the
next election approaches, he'll have to think, do I want to do another five years? Shall I pack it
in? And then what would that job be? I'm just wondering how different he seems now from the
last time you had a big high profile conversation with him, which was during the general election,
when you were doing all the interviews with the individual leaders. Does he seem different?
Massively more relaxed. I mean, the curious thing, and it was just by chance, is we used the same
little studio in Broadcasting House to do the interview, the Panorama election interview,
as we did for this podcast. We did the same, what we call the green room, and otherwise the place
you have a cappuccino biscuit beforehand and afterwards. So I really did think as I was
chatting to him in the green room, and as I was talking to him in the studio, I did keep remembering
back and the tension there was at the beginning of that election campaign. He'd had that dreadful
start with announcing it in the pouring rain, then with the row about leaving the D-Day
commemorations early. I remember him saying something to me about the difficulty of
getting a hearing, and I came up with the not entirely original parallel, but I said, look,
the electorate are a bit like an angry teenager who've stormed upstairs, slammed the bedroom door
and put the music on full volume. They're not hearing anything you're saying. And one of the
main reasons he had an early election was to try and kind of force people to, you've got to listen,
because you've got a big choice. Now, reality, either they didn't listen or they didn't,
they didn't like what they heard. This time round, relaxed, comfortable with himself,
ready to be pretty open, I think, for a guy. You're not naturally someone who talks about
themselves, and a bit wistful, Adam. I thought the most striking thing was him talking about it being
a lonely job. Lots of people have said that about being Prime Minister. I asked him whether he'd
enjoyed it, and he really struggled to think of a moment he'd enjoyed. He thought it was important,
worthwhile, and he kept coming back to this Hindu concept, and faith is clearly important to him as
Britain's first Asian Prime Minister. Hindu concept on Dharma, which doesn't, I'm told,
strictly translate as duty. The other way of putting it is not duty so much as public service,
but the concept, crucially, is this, that you do what you have to do and should do,
but without an eye on getting a reward from it, without believing, because I've done this,
I get something back. It enriches a reputation, and there's similar concepts in all big,
major religions, aren't there? But clearly, the way he got through being Prime Minister
was that sense he'd had since he was a little boy of, this is my duty. Get up, do it. Don't worry
about what the consequence of doing it is, and that gave him, his word, detachment. Now, I think
detachment's a problem as well as a strength. Well, I was going to say, I'm glad you mentioned
the concept of Dharma, because I think that's such a key thing to understand how he approaches
the world, and it recalls that criticism that people had of him, that just getting up very
early and working very hard and be able to make your own spreadsheets about the public finances
rather than relying on the public servants isn't the same as either delivering in politics or
winning in politics. Yeah, or leading, really, isn't it? Yeah, there's no prize for turning up.
Yes, yeah. But, and everybody who says there's a new diary out from the former Chief Whip, the guy
who was in charge of discipline for the Conservative Parliamentary Party, which is quite a lively job
to have at that time, as we said, he says that he'd never seen anybody more dedicated, that he would
see Rishi Suna hour after hour, day after day, night after night, toiling on his own in an office,
through papers, through decisions. But, as you say, that isn't the same as trying to lead or
inspire a party, which I think people who run businesses often forget is basically a group
of volunteers. Nobody has to do what a leader tells them, let alone leading a country where
people have to cut some slack to a leader and say, well, times are a bit tough, but you know what,
at least this guy's telling us where we're going, and I think he suffered terribly from
that sense that while he was trying to crunch through problems, get inflation down, that's the
thing he's proudest of, reverse long NHS waiting list where he didn't manage to do it, stopping the
boats, well clearly as we've just discussed, he didn't manage to do that, that in a sense he wanted
credit for trying and the progress he'd made, what he didn't do until the very end when he started
throwing out much bigger ideas, banning smoking and scrapping HS2 and reversing some of the net
zero targets, he didn't really set up any sort of picture of where he was going. And the picture he
presented kind of changed on a sort of quarterly basis. I just thought also there was two bits
where he just clearly doesn't necessarily want to do the things that people want him to do.
Exhibit A, when you ask him about the election defeat and his instinct is to talk about phoning
his colleagues who lost their jobs, rather than sort of addressing the Conservatives records for
the 14 years that they were in office, and maybe acknowledging why people might be angry with them
and wanted them out of government. And secondly, when you talk about that meeting he had with Boris
Johnson in Boris Johnson's office, just at the start or the end of the second Tory leadership
contest when Boris Johnson was thinking about joining the fray again, and you put to him,
it's like, didn't you think you should say to Boris Johnson, hang on, what makes you think
you've even got the right to think about becoming Prime Minister again, when your record is so kind
of checkered? And he just says, oh, that wasn't, no, of course I didn't have to say that in the
conversation to him. Nope. Yeah, he's not someone who I sense relishes personal confrontation
at all. So his whole instinct on coming to power was not to say, well, thank God they've gone, Liz
Truss has just crashed the economy and Boris Johnson just tore up the idea of standards in
public office by breaking rules that he himself had set. Now, when I put to him that he could have
done those things, that he could have behaved a bit like Donald Trump had done and said, right, now I'm
in, here I am with my sharpie pen, I've got, you know, a whole series of things I want to do
straight away, I'm going to get my Elon Musk figure in to cut public spending. He said, again, slightly
wistfully, I thought, he said, look, I thought stability was what mattered, that meant bringing
people together. And then he pauses and says, well, I could have done that. I suppose some people would
think I should have done that, but it would have been very high risk, which, of course, it would
have been. It could have been that the whole thing imploded, given the state of the Tory party.
But it really did mean that he had to spend most of his premiership looking over his shoulder and
wondering what this or that faction, or indeed cabinet minister, for goodness sake, people like
who he brought into the cabinet against everybody's advice, well, not everybody, but a lot of people's advice,
meant that that, again, struggled to give a clear sense of direction.
I also wonder, like talking about what his role is going to be in our national life for the next
few decades, if maybe he will get drawn into something that he's not keen to do, which is
identity politics, because actually, the bit that comes closest to being emotional in an interview
is when you say about those podcasters that questions whether he was really English or not.
Yeah. And there's a big pause as he sort of grapples with it, because, well, obviously,
it's a big subject, but also it's something he doesn't really want to get involved in. That's
not his area. I mean, of course I'm English. I was born here, brought up here. Yeah, I mean,
of course I'm English. Actually, funnily enough, I think when we were doing that first one of these
some time back, you asked about the Tebbit test, and I think you did.
I did. Yeah. And it struck me, actually,
funnily enough, that this debate, it moves well beyond that, because it's not enough just to
support England at cricket. It turns out it may not be enough to even play for England in cricket
or football. You still can't be English. You look at the composition of our England cricket team,
England football team, on this definition, you can't be English even playing for England,
let alone supporting them. So I think the whole, yeah, I found the whole thing slightly ridiculous.
Yeah, he said that the most remarkable thing about being the first British Asian prime minister
was how unremarkable it had been. And he clearly loved that. He was simultaneously the proud
grandson of a poor Indian immigrant who'd made it, but at the same time thought it was brilliant
that he was not endlessly referred to by his race, ethnic background, religion, just as the
prime minister gets on with his job. That's what he thought Britishness is really about. You don't
have to make a big fuss about it, but he could light Diwali candles in the windows of Downing
Street with his daughters without anybody making a big fuss, but it being a very important moment
for British Hindus, seeing that that happened at the very highest level in British public life.
But he can't avoid it now. I have to say, when I first heard that there was a podcaster who'd said,
and it was pretty stark what he said, can you be brown and Hindu and English? And he suggested you
couldn't. I thought, you know what, I don't even want to have that conversation, thank you very much.
We decided on the Today podcast that we would eventually. It means quite a lot to my fellow
podcaster Amol Rajan for other obvious reasons, but we did as well because other people started
to pick it up, including Suella Braverman, who then wrote a piece in the Telegraph saying that she,
as a second generation immigrant born in Britain, did not think she could be English,
could be British, but not English, because she suggested it was an ethnicity, it was a cultural
issue. Suna just wanted to knock that on the head. I mean, he wasn't rude about her, but he was pretty
dismissive of the idea. He said, look, born here, bred here, schooled here, spent my life here and serving.
And he said, this is a concept that would mean large parts of the English cricket and English
football teams, English teams, could not refer to themselves as English. How daft, my word not his,
how daft is that, was clearly what he thinks. Yeah, I just wonder if he'll be drawn into that
conversation more and more than he might like in the next few years. I don't suppose you're
watching Prime Minister's Questions today, were you? I heard clips, I didn't watch it live. Well,
so I just wanted, there was a fascinating bit at the very start where Keir Starmer did a thing
that basically David Cameron and Gordon Brown used to do a lot, which was to pay tribute to
soldiers who'd lost their lives in Afghanistan, right? And I thought it was absolutely fascinating
because that is the diplomatic but also deniable smackdown to JD Vance and his comments yesterday
about European countries that hadn't fought wars for 30 years. How very interesting, yes. And it's
evidence, isn't it, of the care Starmer is taking walking this tightrope. Do not directly confront
JD Vance or Donald Trump, but do send signals to people who loathe what they're saying,
whether about that sneering comment from JD Vance about, you know, kind of some countries who've
never fought a war for 30, 40 years, offering up 20,000 troops, or Trump's behaviour towards
Zelensky, sending signals. You don't have to say Donald Trump behaved appallingly, you just hug
Vladimir Zelensky outside the black door of number 10. That does all you need to do,
you don't need to do more than that. Nobody can quote it and shove it in front of the president
and say, have you seen what he said? And I have to say, I think so far it's a pretty impressive
walking of the tightrope. There's a much bigger question, which is, will it lead to anything?
Will it actually change anything? Or is it just maintaining a kind of civility in the relationship
across the Atlantic? Nick, thank you very much. Do you want to do the plug for Political Thinking?
Oh, I'd love to. Thank you. If you want to listen to Rishi Sunak, not in one hour, but in two,
it is on Political Thinking on BBC Sounds. And if you want to watch it with magic moving pictures,
you can do it on BBC Two at seven o'clock. And indeed, if you don't catch any of that,
there's a one hour special on Radio 4 tomorrow night at eight o'clock.
Multi-multimedia. Nick, thank you very much. Thanks.
And you can go and listen to Nick's podcast now, because it's the end of this episode
of this podcast, but we'll be back with another newscast very soon. Bye-bye.