Professor Explains the Disagreement Over California’s Water Distribution | Thomas Holyoke

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
340 Video Views·Mar 6, 2025
The debate over California's delta smelt and water policies are heating up again
after the presidential executive order putting people over fish. In California, we have prioritized
endangered species like delta smelt over farmers and farmland when it comes to water.
As a result of it, thousands of acres of farmland has been fallowed. My guest today is Tom Holyoke,
who's a Fresno State University professor that specializes in water policy in the western region.
People of California really need to find a way to solve our political battles over water,
which are probably more intractable than any of our engineering or hydrological problems. The
single best thing that we can do is store more water when we have it. The best way to store
water is to store it underground. States' laws, interestingly enough, say you cannot
just take water and store it. Will California change its water policies? In today's episode,
we dive in deep to understand how the water is currently distributed out of the delta
and current proposals to potentially change this outside of the courtroom.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Tom, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Well, thank you. Glad to be here.
We want to talk to you about a controversial topic that has become very controversial in the state.
It's the delta smelt and how the state is getting its water to Southern California.
Can you explain to us how the water transportation system is set up in the delta?
Sure. It's a bit of a complicated topic, but California's water comes from the northern
part of the state, and there's two systems for bringing it south. One was built by the
federal government in the 1940s, the other built by the state of California in the late 1950s.
For the federal project, water is stored in Shasta Lake behind Shasta Dam on the Sacramento
River. It's allowed to flow south and control pulses, where it enters then the delta region
between Sacramento and San Francisco. The water goes through the delta and is pumped out with a
set of massive pumps and put into a large canal called the Delta-Mendota Canal. And from there,
it provides irrigation water for a good portion of the valley. The state system, the water is
collected from the Feather River behind Oroville Dam at Lake Oroville, and then also released in
controlled pulses into the delta, where another set of really large pumps pulls it out and puts
it into the California Aqueduct. The California Aqueduct then takes it down south over the Tehachapi
Mountains into Southern California. And why do these pumps exist? Is it because they have to
bring the water up? Yeah, so to get water into the Delta-Mendota Canal and into the California
Aqueduct, these giant pumps have to literally pull the water out of the delta and then deposit
the water into the canals. There's no other mechanism for getting the water out and putting
it into those canals. And we're talking about huge volumes of water as well. So these are really,
really big, powerful pumps. And how much do they have to elevate the water? Like, how much higher
does the water have to go? I mean, the water probably goes up 20-30 feet or so, I suppose.
I've never been able to get a close look at the pumps. They don't let people down there.
But yeah, it's just the sheer volume of water that we're pulling out that requires so much power.
There's an endangered species, Delta Smelt. And why has this become such a controversy?
Sure. Once, around the 1990s, a lot of concern was being expressed about environmental damage
being done in the Delta, including several fish species that seemed to be in rapid decline.
You know, salmon, Sacramento split tail, and the Delta Smelt. By the early 21st century,
it started to look like the Delta Smelt was in a lot of trouble and in danger of going extinct.
Now, there's a federal law called the Endangered Species Act. There's also a state Endangered
Species Act, which is essentially the same thing at the state level. These require the government
to do everything possible to stop that species from going extinct. Use whatever powers it has
to stop the species from going extinct. The question then became, what exactly was causing
the Delta Smelt to go into decline? And that's where the controversies began.
And what are the thoughts on that?
Yeah. So, a lot of work has been done by biologists, and it's still not exactly clear
what was hurting the Delta Smelt. In fact, chances are, a number of things were affecting
the Delta Smelt. Part of it was probably the intrusion of salty water. I mean, the Delta
opens up onto the ocean. If there's not enough fresh water, then salt water from the ocean
comes in, and that's bad for the Delta Smelt, which is a freshwater fish.
There's a variety of predators on the Delta Smelt. There could be some problems with
Sacramento's Municipal Utility District putting its wastewater into the Delta,
not too far from there. But the main blame has been put on the pumps for the Central Valley
Project and the State Water Project. And it is true that the pumps operate at such a strong
level that many Delta Smelt are sucked into the pumps and therefore killed.
And does the Delta Smelt exist now? Has it been observed?
This is a very good question, actually.
Once a year, I think it's once a year, biologists do a smelt count. And the last couple of years,
they have not been finding much at all. I think even one year, they didn't find any smelt. So,
there's some concern that it may already be too late for the smelt. Now, these population counts
are difficult to do and not very decisive. So, there could still be smelt there. But if there
is still a smelt population, it's probably very small. And in some people's minds, maybe it's too
late to save it from extinction. We don't know. And the idea is that the smelt is getting sucked
in by the pumps, and the pumps are destroying the smelt. Is this why people don't like these
pumps or they don't want us to pump more water out of them? Yeah, well, when the pumps were
identified as a cause, indeed, identified as the principal cause, many environmental
interests certainly wanted to have the pumps completely shut down. But even also the sports
fishing industry was supportive of shutting down the pumps because the Delta Smelt are eaten by
other kinds of fish that a lot of people like to come fish and support the sports fishing industry.
Now, what actually happened was that after a series of lawsuits, federal courts ordered a
partial shutting down of the pumps. When the Delta Smelt happened to be in that region of the Delta,
by federal court order, the pumps were to be shut down so as not to suck in the fish.
It's not a permanent shutdown, but it is a shutdown at a time when they really need to
be going, the pumps. And can you tell us the impact of these pumps not working? What's the
impact of it? This is a loss then of irrigation water to farmers in the San Joaquin Valley.
Farmers who are used to getting their irrigation water off the Delta-Mendota Canal.
I mean, theoretically, it should have been a loss of water to the State Water Project as well. But
since the State Water Project largely supports cities, the law of California says cities have
a priority over agriculture. So in practice, the cutbacks hit agriculture pretty hard.
So that, in other words, is frankly just less water for irrigation. And that has caused many
farmers in parts of the San Joaquin Valley to fallow lands. So that's less agricultural
production. And of course, that has adverse ripple effects in farming economies here in the valley.
Many of these smaller communities in the valley are largely composed of, made up of farm workers.
And when there are no crops to be harvested, there's no jobs for farm workers to have.
And so they are unemployed. And in some of these small towns, especially during the serious drought
years, remember 2014, 2015, but even still somewhat today, this would lead to unemployment
levels well in excess of 50 percent. Five zero, not 15, 15 percent. So, and these pumps right now,
are they working, they're not working at full capacity because of these lawsuits, right? Are
they, do you know at what capacity they're working? Well, I couldn't tell you exactly today
what they are doing, but the main problem is, is that they simply are not working at the points in
time when they need to be working the most. I mean, there are points in time when there's a lot
more fresh water coming into the Delta. It's not that fresh water is snow melt. So when the spring
hits and the snows melt in Northern California, that is when the most fresh water comes into the
Delta. And that's when the pumps are really needed. But it also happens to be the time when
the Delta smelt tend to be in that part of the Delta where the pumps are. So in other words,
when the pumps need to be active, they're not. And if that water is not
captured, it ultimately flows out into the Pacific Ocean.
We are honored to be sponsored by Shen Yun. Shen Yun Performing Arts is reviving 5,000 years of
lost Chinese traditional culture. It takes you back in time to the magical world of ancient
China with a unique blend of brilliant dancing, beautiful costumes, and legends coming to life.
The show choreography and production values are top-notch. However, it isn't just the technical
ability of the dancers. It's the inner beauty and the devotion of the artist that will stir your
soul to move you to tears. Make sure to go see it this year. Go to Shenyun.com and book your tickets
It was spectacular. So beautiful. I thought I was going to heaven. It was electric. I'm getting
chills talking about it. It gets a 10 from me, that's for sure. It was that good. Absolutely
marvelous. Hands down the best show I've ever seen. So it seems like the Delta smelt is prioritized.
First is the need for the cities, and then it's Delta smelt, and then it's the farmers, right?
Well, that's certainly the perception of it from here in the valley, which is why the farmers
complain a lot about the government putting fish over people. And the law does require that the
government do everything it can to save a species from going extinct, and that does not take into
consideration adverse impacts on human civilization. So there is some justification for farmers to feel
If this smelt wasn't part of this endangered species,
would these pumps be fully operating all the time? How would it look like? What would it look like?
Well, it's hard to tell. I mean, if the Endangered Species Act was, let's say,
repealed, Congress couldn't do that. And if other supporting environmental acts were repealed,
then theoretically, I can't imagine that there would be a legal barrier to having the pumps on.
There could potentially be other reasons, I don't know. But that would be one removal of one legal
barrier. And yeah, theoretically, the pumps would be more active if the Endangered Species Act was
not there. And is there enough water to support these pumps in fresh water coming in?
You know, that depends on the year. I mean, California's precipitation is all over the place.
In a wet year where we have a heavy snowfall, a heavy snowpack in the mountains,
yeah, there'd be plenty of water. Other years when there's not much of a snowpack,
no, there really isn't enough water to go around in the state. And the state needs to keep a
certain amount of fresh water in the Delta anyway to hold back the ocean. There's a lot of
agriculture that happens in the Delta region as well. It's not just the San Joaquin Valley. And if
there's salt water intrusion into Delta farmlands, that means salt water will destroy
their land. And so they're big proponents of also keeping the pumps not running all the time.
And is there a big, besides being an endangered species, the Delta smelt, is there any big
environmental impact of this fish for that region? Because there's been some arguments that
this is part of the food chain of other species and it will have a really big impact if this,
if it goes away. Sure. Of course. I mean, yeah, the Delta smelt would certainly be part of the
food chain in the Delta. It's part of the ecological web of the Delta. You remove any
piece of that and species higher up the food chain are going to suffer. Again, this is why
the sports fishing industry is supportive of the environmentalists in these kinds of lawsuits,
because larger fish like striped mouth bass comes to mind, they eat Delta smelt. No Delta smelt,
that's going to harm the bass population. That'll harm the sports fishing industry. But it's also,
it was, you know, waterfowl that eat smelt and it just, you remove one species and it could have
potentially catastrophic effects along the entire Delta ecosystem.
Would that impact us in a way, if that happens? I mean, the loss of the sports fishing industry,
it's an employer and a revenue generator in California, that would have a financial impact
to the state. To some extent, ecological damage in the Delta might also hurt the commercial
fishing industry and that would be a big blow to the state. As for increased pumping, would that
be a counter benefit for the state? It's hard to tell. Agriculture for all that it provides,
I think only provides about, you know, two to 3% of all of the revenue generated in California.
It's a huge employer, certainly, but it's not California's economic driver. It's probably
is the tech industry, which is also, I would point out, a big water consumer. As I understand,
I've heard it said that computer chips require, like, to be washed six times in really clean,
fresh water. They want to have tunnels in the Delta. Can you tell us about those projects?
Well, we're down to one tunnel now. Governor Brown had proposed two tunnels and really what this is,
viewers might remember late 1970s, early 1980s, the peripheral canal proposal, which was to ship
Sacramento River water in a new canal around the Delta and deposit it by the pumps.
Voters then defeated that in a referendum. Governor Brown's tunnel proposal is the same
thing, except that instead of moving fresh water around the Delta, would move it under the Delta.
Governor Newsom has scaled it back to one tunnel. But the idea is that if we can take,
if we can intercept fresh Sacramento River water further north and then deposit it right at the
pumps, that means the pumps would have to work less hard to be able to pump up fresh water for
the canals. And if the pumps are working with less power, there'd be less suction and it's
less likely to suck in the Delta smelt or whatever fish in and destroy them. So theoretically,
the tunnel proposal should be able to help the Delta smelt and San Joaquin Valley farmers,
theoretically. And when do you think is the timeline for that?
That's anyone's guess, isn't it? I'm sure Governor Brown thought this would be done on his watch. It
isn't going to be done on Governor Newsom's watch. They haven't actually started moving
dirt yet. Now, from what I understand, there was a lot of environmental lawsuits trying to
stop the tunnel project. I believe a lot of that has now been cleared away by the courts,
perhaps all of it. I think the project is slowly moving towards a start date.
But how long is it going to take? I don't know. Maybe we'll see high-speed rail done first.
So Tom, the environmentalists, you're mentioning they were suing this
tunnel, but this tunnel, isn't it supposed to help the smelt?
Yeah, so this is a strange situation. The original peripheral canal was, I believe,
originally endorsed by several environmental groups, like the Sierra Club, as a way to help
the smelt. And I think they even had expressed some support for the initial tunnel proposal.
As time went on, they turned against the proposal. And I think they would still admit
that it might provide some help for the Delta smelt in the Southern Delta. Now they're expressing
concern about what this might do to, what kind of environmental damage it might have on the
Northern end of the Delta, where the Sacramento River would naturally spill its fresh water into
the Delta, but the tunnel would instead take that water away. So environmentalists now seem to be
concerned about ecological impacts on the North end of the Delta, and consequently have decided
they just hate the whole tunnel idea. But there has been a decided shift in their policy goals
and priorities. So is there multiple different interests that are battling each other in the
middle of these water projects? Yeah, well, it would be wrong to say that all the environmental
groups are on the same page, or that they all act as a monolith. They most certainly do not.
And I think there probably are environmental groups who are more supportive of the tunnel
project. Please don't ask me to name a particular one. I can't seem to think of one off the top of
my head. But my understanding is that there are some environmental groups that still see
benefits of the tunnel. Now, in terms of transporting the water, do we lose water?
Well, there's probably always some water loss, partially because when the water goes into these
canals, it's exposed to the sun. And especially when we get to July, August, September, there's
going to be a certain degree of water loss due to sheer evaporation. Which, interestingly enough,
has prodded us to start really thinking about covering some of our canals. In fact, in kind
of an interesting two-for-one on the Friant-Kern Canal, which is a big canal on the east side of
the San Joaquin Valley, not only are we covering it to reduce evaporation, but we're recovering it
with solar panels. So we can put the sun to some practical use and generate electricity.
There's President Trump, and he wants to do something about this. And the federal
government, I don't know what their policy could be to help out the farmers, or would it get
stopped by the courts? So President Trump, in his first term in office, promised to help the farmers
by getting them more water through the Central Valley Project. By and large, he was not really
able to deliver on that. Things he tried got tied up in the courts. Second administration now,
he still wants to fulfill those promises. And he's given orders to the Department of the
Interior and the Department of Commerce, they're the two departments that have some jurisdiction
over this, to find ways to move more water to the farmers. But that is not going to be easy to do.
The operations of the federal government in the Delta are through an agency called the Bureau
of Reclamation, part of the Interior Department. The law actually says that the Bureau of Reclamation
is subject to the laws of California. It's a quirk that we don't see in most federal programs.
But Bureau of Reclamation is subject to the laws of California. And that means California has a lot
of management responsibility. It really has primary management responsibility of the Delta.
So in other words, it's kind of California's choice about how long the pumps are run. And on
top of that, we have federal court orders that still require the pumps to be stopped at certain
times in order to try to save the smelt and some other endangered species. So within those
constraints, which are pretty formidable, I'm not entirely sure exactly what the Trump
administration is going to be able to do. Maybe they'll come up with something novel. I don't know.
And who is in charge of these pumps to make sure how much they're going to pump out? Is it the
state leaders? Well, the decisions are usually made by a few coordinating agencies, I guess
we'll say, government agencies that are responsible for the Delta. And they generally set
terms for how much water can be pumped out. I mean, the actual control of the Central Valley
Project pumps is still under the control of the Bureau of Reclamation. I mean, they literally
would throw the switches or do whatever you do to turn the pumps on or off, but they just simply
can't do it when they feel like it. They're subject to the dictates of these coordinating
agencies. It's a whole bureaucracy that manages the Delta. And does the courts oversee them too
because of these lawsuit settlements? Or do they have to factor in the court's lawsuit settlements
into their decision? It's more the latter, as I understand it. It's a complex web, but it's more
of the latter, that these coordinating agencies are operating with partially under court orders,
but with certainly a healthy respect for the court orders. Tom, you've been studying the water
policies of the state, right, for over the last two decades. Is there a solution for us? Because
we've heard from some experts that we have enough water, we just don't store it. We have heard from
some other experts that we don't have enough water. There's no easy solution, let's put it that way.
However, probably the single best thing that we can do is store more water when we have it.
I mean, some years we have enough water. Many years we don't have enough water. And so the
challenge is to take those few years when we do have excess water and find ways to store it.
And it's becoming a little more accepted that the best way to store water is to store it underground,
to turn it into groundwater. That way it cannot evaporate. You put water in a huge
surface reservoir and you lose up to 40% of it to the sun. So storing it underground.
But storing it underground, there's physical challenges. You have to find the right kind of
soil that can accommodate water. And there's also the challenges of getting it into the ground.
You have to get the water, use fancy injection wells to do that. But there's also legal barriers.
And that's probably the bigger problem right now, is that you just can't take excess water in a
river and put it underground for storage. The state's laws, interestingly enough, say you
cannot just take water and store it. You have to take water, you have to use it for something.
We call that beneficial use. And frankly, the state really needs to make some changes in its
water rights laws to make it easier from a legal point of view for us to store our water
underground. That would be a huge, huge help. So is it illegal to store water on the ground
if you are a farmer and you put the water in, or if you're trying to store the water underground?
This is confusing because these are the questions that are now being asked and there's,
it seems to me there's not a lot of legal clarity to it.
But a couple of years ago when we had a really huge snowpack and a lot of excess water in the
state, there was a lot of concern that it was illegal to take those excess waters and put it
underground. The governor actually had to issue a special proclamation waiving these legal
restrictions, which you could only do on a temporary basis. But basically what he was
waiving is the legal requirement that if you take water, you have to do something with the water,
use it beneficially, which means you can't store the water because under the old law,
that's considered water hoarding. The governor was able to temporarily suspend that so water
could be stored, but a temporary measure is not what we need. We need the legislature to actually
change the law to make it clearly legal for farmers to store that water.
And do you think this storing water underground needs to be done by farmers, or do you think
there needs to be other projects that actually make these in a larger scale for the state?
Well, it's not just farmers. Farmers certainly, but it also needs to be done a lot by
cities that can do it, really need to be doing it. And the state is also full of these
little government agencies that we call irrigation districts and water districts,
which traditionally they exist to build irrigation infrastructure to help deliver
water to farmers. And we have hundreds of them in the state. They should all be clearly empowered
to be able to grab excess water, including flood water, and store it underground. That's
we really need the legislature to do. Are there any other ideas to help with this situation?
Water recycling is something the state needs to give a larger priority to. We are getting better
at it, but we could learn a lot from a city like Las Vegas. I've heard it said that Las Vegas
recycles up to 90% of the water that the city uses. And Las Vegas is a city that is less rainfall
than any other city in the United States. And yet it has to support this vast hotel infrastructure
with tons of water requirements. They are good at water recycling. We could learn something from
them. And there's also desalination. There's a lot of water there in the ocean. There's
certain problems with that. Building a water desalination plant is a big, expensive capital
project. But more importantly, it takes quite a bit of energy to run a desalination plant.
And then you also have the problem of when you take ocean water and desalinate it, you get
fresh water, but then you also get a really, really highly salty brine water. What do we do with it?
You know, initially the idea is to throw it back in the ocean. Well, the environmental laws
probably won't allow that because it could be damaging, actually, to the ocean. So we need to
do something with the brine water. So these kinds of problems need to be solved before we can
really expand in desalination. But a combination of all these things, more water storage, better
water recycling, finding ways to do desalination, these are probably the things that are going to
make California more water resilient. And just on top of that, probably some smarter uses of water
by people. Because most water wasted in the state is usually wasted in the home. Running
sprinklers when perhaps we shouldn't, drippy faucets, bad toilet flappers, huge amounts of
water are lost from those things. Tom, what about solving this issue in the Delta? Is it possible
to get all these stakeholders in a room and have a discussion? And has this been done before?
Oh, it's been done several times with mixed results, I think it's fair to say. In the 1990s,
there was a piece of legislation passed. It's called the Central Valley Project Improvement Act,
which mandated that state government, federal government, you know, their relative agencies,
and then stakeholder groups, environmentalists, cities, farmers, they all kind of needed to work
holistically to solve problems. A big effort was made, and after about 10 years, that kind of
collapsed and led to a huge number of lawsuits, waves and waves of lawsuits. A lot of people seem
to be starting to exhaust themselves in the lawsuits, and now there's more interest, it seems
to me, on cooperation again. And there's been some surprisingly good efforts at cooperation
here in the San Joaquin Valley. Farmers and environmentalists actually finding ways to sit
down and talk to each other and even start working out some potential solutions. I mean, it's,
they suspect they've got a ways to go, but you know, they've got to make a start, and I think
we have made a start. So are these coalitions happening? Are people meeting up and they're
discussing these issues? They are. We have one here in the Valley, it's called Water Blueprint,
and it's one that's, in my mind, seems to have gotten the most attention, trying to develop
between environmentalists and farmers and other stakeholders, you know, kind of unified proposals
that they can give to the governor and the legislature to enhance water reliability for
farmers, and at the same time, you know, try to do something for the environment. Now for us in
California, our water mainly comes from the Delta. Is that true? A lot of Southern California's water
does come from the Delta. There's some local rivers as well. The big exception, though,
is Los Angeles itself. Los Angeles gets its water from three sources. The Los Angeles River,
but it also gets a large amount of its water from Eastern California, a place called the Owens
Valley. It's a long story, but over a century ago, L.A.'s leaders at the time, including a man
named William Mulholland, basically acquired the water rights to the Owens River in Eastern
California, which means they legally gained control of that water, then built a giant canal
called the Los Angeles Aqueduct that ships all that water to Los Angeles, huge amounts of water.
And then about a decade later, Los Angeles and the Imperial Valley, down at the California-Mexican
border, became big players in negotiating compromises on the Colorado River. The Colorado
River, of course, forms part of the border between California and Arizona, and California got a huge
cut of the Colorado River, splitting that water between the Imperial Valley and Los Angeles. So,
Los Angeles primarily gets its water from the Colorado River, the Owens Valley, and the L.A.
River, not so much the Delta. People of California really need to find a way to solve
our political battles over water, which are probably more intractable than any of our
engineering or hydrological problems with water. I mean, we have laws that have kind of been on
the books since the 19th century that we have not seriously revisited, that really need to be
changed to match, you know, the current reality of water. And, you know, we really need the state
legislature to step up and seriously look at overhauling our water laws. I think that would
help us immensely. Tom Holyoak, professor of political science at California State University
in Fresno. It was great to have you on Californian Center. Great, thank you, thank you.
