I’m 21 and Being Pressured To Finance a Car 📈 Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a Free Personalized Plan. https://ter.li/5h1r0i
Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/kn49xr • 🏘️ Free Tools & Resources to Reach Your Home Goals - https://ter.li/jsnbsz • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
[Music]
brought to you by y refi refinance your
defaulted private student loans today at
y rei.com
Ramsey so I'm 21 years old uh I know
pretty much next to nothing about
finance and uh right now currently I'm
sharing a vehicle with my mother and uh
over the next couple years I'd like to
sck away some cash in buying my own car
and um the car I want to buy will be
worth a resale value of roughly 15,000
by the time I want to buy it um my
parents suggest that I take out a loan
on this car instead of paying upfront uh
with cash which um I mean I've been
listening to the show for a little bit
but it even just on my Basic Instinct
doesn't really seem totally right I mean
if I have the cash and if it doesn't
swap my net worth then um I don't see
why I shouldn't just pay Upfront for it
and their uh basically their argument to
why I should do this is they claim that
the interest that I'd be paying on the
car loan would be less than the interest
that I would gain through uh some sort
of stock market portfolio um with the
rest of the
cash got it so they're saying hey you
could leverage that money in the stock
market instead of sinking it into a
car yeah so I I'm wondering George is
the finance guy George George knows way
more about numbers and money than I do
my first response to that is
maybe right so maybe like just just
number for number so if you get a car at
7% maybe you can put it in the market
and get 8% so maybe but that evaluation
doesn't take into consideration that the
value of that car goes down every
day and so it doesn't Factor
depreciation so you're paying money back
on something that's worth less and less
every single
day do you get what I'm saying so you're
you're you're you're trading one thing
for another but if you don't factor in
the depreciation cost of that of that
used car then you're not taking in the
entire Financial
picture right and there are no
guarantees in the stock market and I
don't know what they're invested in and
what's going on in Canada but I'll tell
you here in the US we don't know what
the future holds and there's a
guaranteed return when you pay cash for
that car instead of going all right I
spent 15 grand and in the end I paid 20
with interest and now the car is only
worth 10 by the time I pay it off that's
the reality of of the math of how cars
work and therefore cars are one of the
dumbest things to go into debt for
because they're continually going down
in value while you pay interest on it
and your your the market return may be
lower like you're so I think a couple
years ago I'm I'm trying to remember off
the top of my head but I think my whole
thing went down 177% last year it was up
24% or something like that that's cool
if I'm looking at a
50-year play right or if I've got this
stuff in the market for 30 years if I'm
holding a four-year car note that's
horrifying because the one consistent
that that never changes is that car
payment is do every
month no matter what you get what I'm
saying so I it sounds to me tell me if
I'm wrong your parents just want to stop
sharing a car with
you um I mean it's kind of just the car
was actually my idea like to save for my
own car um it's just uh the car we're
sharing or at least the one I'm sharing
with my mother is uh quite old and um
you know by the time I'd be getting this
other car uh that car will probably be
about 20 or so years old so um why did
she pay off her car did they pay cash
for
theirs uh I I actually don't know um
might be something to ask them if it's
such a good idea why aren't they doing
it they should be taking out as many car
loans as they can get and putting it
into the stock market yeah beating the
market right I know that uh the car that
my father bought when I was very young I
know he took out a loan on that one but
the most recent one he bought he paid
fully cash for yeah what dumb idea that
was he could have been leveraging that
in the stock market Noah do you see
where I'm going with this it's okay to
be Miss line with your parents this is
why I'm confused yeah don't be confused
here's it is your mom and dad have
whatever algorithm they've worked out
they think it's the best and they're
probably trying to love you in the best
way they know how it's all good they're
not bad people they're not bad people
the reality is um the best thing I can
tell tell you is at my house in George
camel's house in Dave's house and our in
Jade's like we write a check for
cars almost always unless you're Dave
almost always uh used
cars and it gives you if it gives you
any Solace I still disagree with my
father to this day anytime we talk about
money so this is just a thing of life
you're going to have to get used to me
and my father do not talk about money
anymore we just laugh it off and go
thanks Dad I'm good I'm good yeah but
the the truth is Noah you're you can do
this on your own and you're a grown man
who probably will soon move out and have
his own life
right of course and they don't pay your
bills and so they're not going to get a
vote in your financial choices and so
you got to do what is in your gut is the
best thing for your financial future and
you know too much to go into debt at
this point and so the next goal is how
do I save up really quickly to get a car
I can afford in cash how long will that
take okay it take you it's G to take you
about two years you said oh you were
actually asking oh um yeah it's it'll
take about uh about two years yeah you
living at home if I yeah I am what do
you make a year I could
say uh per year I'm not totally sure I
mean I'm about to be uh hired for a
landscaping company that pays about 22
per hour which is
roughly uh I guess 5200 per month before
taxes and pension deductions and all
that so you could have a car in five
months looking at like this 2-year plan
where you're saving up you know 5 600
bucks a month you should be able to save
up you know a grand a month and knock
this thing out within a
year no absolutely I guess um I mean
yeah you're absolutely right I guess I'm
just not uh too much in a rush to to get
a whole separate uh vehicle you know
what I mean I guess
uh well the longer you're Tethered to
Mom's vehicle the longer this is going
to get played out where you're just
intertwined with family finances I'd
love to see out on your own and that's
going to give you a sense of
Independence maturity and I've just seen
it too often where growth is stunted
when you stay at home for too long when
you don't need
to you're right yeah so even if you get
three roommates you grow up fast when
you're living with three dudes all right
you start to learn some things and It
prepares you for marriage and it boosts
your immune system too because a house
full of guys is
disgusting absolutely just kind of as a
general I'll tell you my my mom was just
in town Noah I revert to a child right
she's like no I'll get the dishes I'll
fold the laundry there's just a piece of
you that turns into a child when Mommy
and Daddy are there and so I think it's
going to really help you financially
spiritually emotionally mentally to move
on and Do Your Own Thing sooner rather
than
later I agree but good gut instincts
brother you're on your way man it's
awesome that's big so John this comes up
a lot there's a rub between there's a
thing this other person believes and
they're projecting it onto me and I love
this person I respect this person and
it's easy to say well just have a
boundaries conversation and tell him to
kick CRS and pound sand but the reality
is these are your parents these are your
loved ones right can I tell you what I
think so what's happening our culture
has told us if you have a a disagreement
with someone you have to hate them if if
somebody believes strongly about debt
and they and you believe strongly about
borrowing money then inherently we have
to hate each other if you vote
differently if you want to go to this
church and I want to go to this church
we have to hate each other and it's so
nonsense the whole I know he's from
Toronto the whole American Exchange the
whole idea of the United States is you
believe this and I believe this and
we're going to fure out figure out a way
that we can both live together move
forward so man people like your parents
most of the time there are evil actors
out there and there's morons out there
most of the time a mom and or dad sits
down and welled gives their kid what
they think is the next best right step
for them period so you don't have to
hate them and you don't have to do
everything that they say all the time
especially when you're a grown up now if
you're 22 and you still live in Mommy's
house and you're borrowing Mommy's car
then you're going to do what Mommy says
and if mommy says be home at at 10:30 at
night because I'm uncomfortable with
those what's going on out out on these
streets because I watch tons of news
then you have a choice be home at 10:30
or move out right but that's the world
we're in so golly dude if you can make
peace with people who just have
different thoughts than you and then go
do what's the next right move especially
I love what he said my guts are telling
me this is the wrong thing follow your
guts man just it's just the wrong move
apparently multiple this is plural guts
yeah I thought you had one but I love
that John has multiple that's the kind
of man he is yeah and and hash biology
and science # microbiome we'll look into
that later why refi refinances
delinquent private student loans for
struggling borrowers learn more at
yy.com Ramsey