The collapse of 'tofu-dreg' buildings in mainland China: Why does it still happen today?

CN Under
3 followers
Mar 6, 2025
The collapse of 'tofu-dreg' buildings in mainland China: Why does it still happen today?
Please investigate the Tofu Dregs construction project,
said one netizen who identified herself
as the aunt of one of the victims.
When the entire roof of a middle school gym
collapsed in Chikihar in Heilongjiang province
in July this year, the tragedy killed 11 people,
including 10 members of the female volleyball team
and a coach.
Shoddy initial construction,
widely known as Tofu Dreg Buildings,
was blamed for the heavy loss of people's lives,
According to China Insights Channel,
the Tofu Dreg construction has lasted for several decades.
Although people have discussed
and condemned the tragic phenomenon,
the situation has not been controlled.
On the contrary, it happens more frequently
in different ways.
Let's take a look at some examples.
Collapsing building.
The collapse of a nine-story building in central China
that killed 54 people in Changsha in April 2022
was caused by shoddy, illegal construction
and local officials' failure to enforce standards.
News reports at the time said the building had six stories,
but were added up to a partial ninth level.
It noted that extra weight overwhelmed
the poorly built structure
of the original five-story building.
At least nine people, including the building owner,
were reportedly arrested
following the April 2022 disaster in Changsha,
which trapped survivors under rubble
for up to five days.
Shaking building.
A landmark Shenzhen skyscraper swayed on May 18, 2021,
causing thousands of pedestrians to flee.
After the investigation of the 350-meter, 150-feet
SIG Plaza in the Huakyang Bay Electronics District
of Shenzhen, experts said the perceived vibration
was caused by a combination of vortex-induced resonance
of the rooftop masts and changes
to the dynamic characteristics of the building.
A rectification plan was to remove the rooftop masts
and repair damaged areas.
After the removal of the masts,
the plaza is no longer among
the city's 10 tallest skyscrapers,
since its height was reduced to 292 meters.
However, residents tend to feel insecure.
An electronics wholesaler, surnamed Wu,
who moved out in late May, said,
I think no one can guarantee that it can be fixed 100%.
I just want to avoid disruption to my business again.
A Centaline property agent in Shenzhen
said she was not optimistic the SIG Plaza
could recover its losses.
She added,
A video shows a tofu-dreg road in Kaohsiung City,
Guangdong Province.
A man is riding a motorbike on the road.
Suddenly, the road cracks, leading him to fall in the hole.
The next accident took place in Qidong City,
Jiangsu Province.
This time it was a white car.
Jiangxi Province in June 2021
witnessed the same accident.
Tofu skin buildings.
Buildings in China seem to be afraid of rain and wind,
since if it rains heavily or has strong winds,
the nature of tofu-dreg projects is revealed clearly.
Especially their outer layers.
The video shows how easily the outer layers
of the building fall due to strong winds and heavy rains.
That's why these buildings are named tofu-skin projects.
However, the harmful effects of such construction
are manifested not only on the outside,
but also on the inside.
In July 2021, the government auditorium in Jiangsu
experienced serious leaking like a waterfall due to rain.
Building materials.
Many strange building materials
have been adopted in construction.
It is easy for the construction inside the accommodation
to fall out since it was built of paper.
Steel bars are also easy to break.
Liquor bottles are used instead of stones,
sand, and cement.
Bamboo sheets are used to replace steel bars
in constructing China's pavement.
Some homeowners try to test the quality
and they feel deeply disappointed
when sand and soil fall off right away
with just a knock or a scratch.
Many studies find out the reasons
for the tofu-dreg constructions in China.
Corruption of local officials is a typical cause.
Next are technical issues such as improper earthwork height,
the excavation of foundation pits
violating relevant regulations,
lack of supervision and management,
or the violation of safety measures.
Or instead of using cement,
contractors utilized other low-quality
alternative materials.
Despite these reasons, low-quality constructions
and buildings are still common in China,
causing significant damage to people's lives
and social stability.
If this situation continues,
the people's agonizing calls,
especially from the aunt above,
will also be in vain since it will become a thing
of the past that no authorities really care about.
I thought there was an earthquake.
The ceiling collapse incident at Gulo Hospital in Nanjing
occurred on the afternoon of November 6, 2023.
On that day, a video circulated online
showing the sudden collapse of the ceiling
on the fourth floor of the hospital's outpatient building,
creating a shocking scene.
In the video, hospital staff can be seen shouting
and inquiring if anyone is trapped under the fallen ceiling
while urging patients and their families
to leave the danger zone.
Numerous onlookers also appear in the video.
According to publicly available information,
Gulo Hospital in Nanjing,
also known as the affiliated Drum Tower Hospital
of Nanjing Medical University,
is one of China's earliest Western hospitals
and is a Grade A tertiary hospital.
The hospital has been repeatedly commended
by the Central Civilization Commission, Jiangsu Province,
and Nanjing City as an advanced collective
in the national creation of a civilized industry
and a civilized unit,
receiving various honorary titles
from the National Health Commission.
The ceiling collapse incident occurred on the fourth floor
of the hospital's outpatient building,
which houses the obstetrics and gynecology department
and the gastrointestinal endoscopy department.
Currently, it is unclear whether departments
such as obstetrics and gynecology
are able to operate normally,
but according to hospital staff,
the network is in a paralyzed state.
The ceiling collapse incident exposes vulnerabilities
in the hospital's safety management system,
raising questions about the safety of hospital facilities.
Many are concerned about the possibility
of similar accidents recurring,
prompting a focus on the safety of public buildings.
It also prompts people to consider
how to enhance the safety of public building structures,
strengthen daily maintenance and supervision,
and ensure the safety of lives and property.
Woman breaks stone guardrail or shoddy construction again.
On October 29, in Jiayang, Guangdong,
a middle-aged woman was injured
when a stone guardrail she was stretching by the river
suddenly broke into several pieces.
Officials' response to this incident stated,
the guardrail's breakage is not due
to engineering quality issues,
but rather an accident caused
by the excessive force used by the resident.
The netizen who posted the video claimed
that the woman suffered two broken bones.
The video of the woman breaking
the stone guardrail barehanded sparked attention
and netizens discussed whether it was due
to the woman's excessive strength
or the poor quality of the guardrail.
Some said, is the woman naturally super strong
or is it a substandard project?
Others questioned, is it shoddy construction
or superhuman strength?
This is not the fault of the elderly woman,
but rather due to the poor quality of public facilities,
it suggested that it's a substandard construction.
A person could easily break it.
This is obviously a case of cutting corners
and just sticking stones together
and they'll weather and fall off in a few years.
Then they'll have to be redone to make money.
On November 12, near Zhongshan Elementary School
in Qiarutu Town, Yangjia County, Wenzhou City,
Zhejiang Province, a four-story residential building
undergoing renovation suddenly collapsed,
burying four construction workers.
It was known that all four individuals
tragically lost their lives.
Residents near the incident site revealed
that the collapsed building was undergoing renovation
at the time with several construction workers inside.
Unfortunately, they were unable to escape in time
and many were trapped inside the building.
The official announcement from Yangjia County
stated that a residential building
in the process of renovation collapsed in Yantu Lane,
Qiarutu Town, Yangjia County.
Four individuals were trapped and by 2 a.m. on the 12th,
three of the trapped individuals were found,
all of whom had unfortunately passed away.
Xinhua News and Kaixin reported
that as of 7 a.m. on the 12th,
all four trapped individuals had shown no signs of life,
confirming that they had all perished.
On a fateful day, November 6th,
in the heart of Hulanan County,
within Jiamusi City of Heilongjiang Province,
a chilling catastrophe struck
as the roof of a sports arena came crashing down,
claiming the lives of three individuals
and leaving two others in agony.
This duty officer mentioned that they weren't authorized
to disclose information regarding the incident
and suggested the reporter get in touch
with the county's propaganda department.
Regrettably, repeated attempts to reach
the Hulanan County Propaganda Department went unanswered.
Notably, the Yuecheng Sports Club
is an integral part of the Yuecheng Plaza,
a flagship investment project of the county government.
The collapsed gymnasium was part of the first phase
of the Yuecheng Plaza Urban Complex Project.
The Yuecheng Plaza Project covers a total area
of 35,163 square meters
and started construction in July 2017,
boasting an investment exceeding 400 million yuan
with multifaceted features encompassing shopping centers,
recreational amenities, and residential quarters.
Xinyuan News Agency reported that Building 7
within the complex housing the Yuecheng Sports Club
spanned an impressive 3,208.96 square meters
with a towering height of 9.5 meters.
This structure successfully passed construction
acceptance in July 2020.
The eastern section comprised a two-story construction
featuring a robust concrete roof.
In contrast, the western section,
which tragically crumbled,
covering an area of 675 square meters,
featured an H-shaped cross-section steel beam roof structure
since December 2022.
The management of this sports center fell
under the purview of Xinyangguang Fitness Club
in Hulanan County,
primarily dedicated to hosting basketball,
table tennis, and badminton activities.
This tragic event sent shockwaves through the region
reminiscent of a similar calamity just three months earlier.
In July, the northeastern province of Heilongjiang
witnessed the horrifying collapse
of a school gymnasium in Kikihar,
where a coach and 10 female volleyball players
met their untimely demise.
In the case of the Kikihar Gymnasium,
it was attributed to the ill-advised storage
of perlite on the roof,
which soaked up rainwater,
ultimately causing the structure to buckle under the weight.
Some may philosophize that every snowflake
bears guilt in this tragedy,
implying that even nature played a role.
However, astute observers point to grave concerns
about the overall quality of construction
in China's booming industry.
If the authorities fail to take swift and decisive action
to rectify these quality issues,
it is feared that more innocent lives may be tragically lost.
I don't want to talk about anything right now.
I'm just looking at the final results
of the paper investigation,
said the family members of the victims
of the collapsed roof accident at Yueqing Sports Club
in Huainan County, Jiamusi City, Heilongjiang Province,
to Jiamian News on November 10, 2023.
Currently, the families of the three deceased
high school students are still gathering
at the funeral home to visit their children.
After the accident, the developer of the building,
Heilongjiang Yuxing Real Estate Development Limited Company,
immediately came to the forefront.
The Tianyancha app shows that the legal representative
of the company is Wu Likian.
The lay number of employees
in Wu Likian's real estate development company
was not large, all family members.
The company did not have the corresponding qualification
for construction engineering construction.
The usual practice was to be affiliated
with another qualified company.
According to a 2019 judgment
from the People's Court website,
the Yueqing Shengxi Community was developed
and constructed by Yang Jinli in 2012
through a company named Xinlong Real Estate.
Yang Jinli did not have the corresponding qualification
for construction engineering construction.
The development of the Yueqing Plaza project
allowed Wu Likian to make a lot of money on his books.
The Tianyancha app shows that in 2018,
Yueqing Real Estate's revenue was zero yuan.
By 2019, the revenue of this company with only 15 people
reached 141.7 million yuan.
In the same year, the relevant part
of the Yueqing Plaza complex was completed.
By 2020, Yueqing Real Estate's revenue,
although significantly reduced,
was still 69.25 million yuan.
And in 2021, it dropped to 12 million yuan.
Calculated this way,
Yueqing Real Estate's total revenue for three years
reached 222.72 million yuan.
However, strangely, Yueqing Real Estate
was officially deregistered on May 11, 2022.
For unknown reasons,
the burning question on everyone's mind remains,
are these roof collapses the result of shoddy,
subpar construction practices,
infamously known as tofu-dreg projects,
or is Mother Nature solely to blame,
unleashing her fury in the form of heavy snowfall?
It's important to note that sports facilities like these
are held to stringent safety standards,
far beyond those of regular civilian structures.
In times of crisis,
the public instinctively seeks refuge in these buildings.
