The government's unexpected important signal scares China's rich

China Lens
27 followers
Mar 4, 2025
In recent months, tax officials have asked wealthy individuals and companies to "self-check" their tax payments and make up any shortfalls.
The government's unexpected important signal scares China's rich Beijing is asking wealthy
individuals and companies to recheck their tax bills for any underpayments.
The Financial Times reported on Monday, November 4th, a move that could further undermine investor
confidence in the world's second largest economy and cause anxiety for businesses that are
struggling to survive in difficult times.
In recent months, tax officials have asked wealthy individuals and companies to self-check
their tax payments and make up any shortfalls, as local governments look for revenue to replenish
coffers depleted by the real estate slump.
The tax move comes as Beijing prepares to announce details of a massive fiscal stimulus
plan this week, which is expected to focus on restoring the finances of local governments,
many of which are struggling to pay suppliers and employees.
Economists are pinning their hopes on the stimulus package, the next phase of a plan
launched in September to help restore confidence among households and investors after two
years of deflationary pressure from the real estate crisis.
Beijing's move comes as China's third quarter economic growth fell short of its official
target of 5 percent this year.
A China-based tax partner said the tax requirements have sparked uneasiness and even fear among
wealthy Chinese in cities such as Beijing, Shanghai and Shenzhen.
When asked to conduct self-examinations, some of them simply didn't know what to declare.
Many also hadn't realized before that their overseas personal income would be taxed in
China, the partner said.
Companies that found no problems during self-examinations have been asked to submit certificates with
official seals and keep evidence for inspection, according to a notice from one city seen by
the Financial Times.
Authorities have also asked individuals to start paying back taxes, including from their
overseas investment earnings, in some cases invoking a rarely used 2019 legal provision,
people familiar with the matter said.
One lawyer said his wealthy Chinese clients were able to negotiate with tax officials,
suggesting they had some wiggle room on potential tax liabilities.
The central and local governments' revenue-raising measures, which also include a sharp increase
in fines and penalties for the private sector, come as China's property market has slowed
for three years.
The slowdown has hit local government finances and dented confidence among households and
investors.
Revenue from land sales, one of the government's main sources of revenue, fell nearly 25 percent
in the first nine months of this year compared to the same period last year.
National tax revenue fell 5.3 percent over the same period.
China's total fiscal revenue fell 2.2 percent year-on-year to about 16.3 trillion yuan,
2.3 trillion dollars in the January-September period, official data showed.
Local governments clearly don't have the money, said an executive at a mid-sized manufacturing
company in Suzhou, one of China's industrial hubs near Shanghai.
The executive added that local governments often impose heavy fines on companies in his
area.
China's fiscal deficit has reached a critical point, said Gary Yang, senior economist at
French bank Natixis.
There is more urgency to find other sources of revenue.
Taxing the rich and some companies has less direct economic impact on most residents.
Ker Sheng Li, co-head of Asia Pacific at the Alternative Investment Management Association,
a hedge fund industry group, said China's push for strict taxation was pragmatic and
On the other hand, if the crackdown is expanded, it could shake the confidence of companies
and investors, he added.
Chinese-listed companies have made a slew of announcements about their tax bills in
recent months.
In addition to requiring self-inspections, local governments are also imposing fines
on companies to make up for the decline in land transfer revenue, the Financial Times
said.
Last year, fines and confiscation revenues surged in seven of 16 provinces, with Chongqing
in the west and the capital Beijing increasing by 22.4% and 21.9% respectively, according
to Chinese media Yikai Global.
Many local governments have stopped publishing fine revenues due to the abnormal growth in
recent months, according to local media reports.
This kind of local government imposing additional fines and taxes on companies happens every
day, which hits the morale of companies, said an economics professor in Beijing who
asked not to be named.
Tax collection targeting the rich and private companies may not be enough, said Ng of Natixis,
adding that officials may ultimately consider real estate-related taxes and broaden the
tax base.
China's catering industry has collapsed on a large scale, and people are suffering.
This year has been the worst for the mainland catering industry.
The industry has now collapsed on a large scale, with small and medium-sized restaurants
especially affected.
The turnover of stores that are barely managing to stay open has also shrunk significantly.
Some in the catering industry have mocked their own situation online, saying,
I had more than 200,001 when I opened the store and I could get more than 400,001 when
I closed the store, but unfortunately I was in debt.
1.05 million catering companies closed down in the first half of the year.
According to data from the National Bureau of Statistics of the Communist Party of China,
the growth rate of national catering revenue from January to August was the lowest in 10 years.
In the first half of this year, 1.05 million catering companies closed down.
High-end catering brands in first-tier cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, and
Shenzhen were the first to bear the brunt.
These include Din Tai Fung, known for its Michelin-level dumplings, and Shanhei Wanduo,
a Michelin-starred restaurant with multiple awards.
Da Luo, a blogger who has operated catering stores in Chaozhou, Guangdong for many years,
recently said that this year's data on restaurant closures is the highest he has seen,
with closures continuing in waves.
He noted that despite this, there are still restaurants lining the streets.
The root cause, he said, is that too many people have no work, so they enter the low
threshold catering industry, leaving him, as a seasoned catering professional, bewildered.
Too many people are opening restaurants now.
After one closes, another wave of people comes in to try, perpetuating the vicious cycle.
Price wars are inevitable, and many people can't survive.
Small and medium-sized catering businesses are struggling.
The popular WeChat public account Mr. Z, known for financial analysis, economic trends,
and industry insights, stated in an article that, after examining financial reports from
various listed companies, very few have achieved year-on-year growth.
Small and medium-sized catering businesses are suffering, with revenue generally falling
by 15% to 50% compared to the same period last year.
Mid-range and moderately-priced restaurants are facing the most challenges.
With reduced foot traffic and a drop in average customer spending, they are caught between
survival and bankruptcy.
Internet-famous restaurants that focus on trendy elements have been closing almost as
quickly as they rose.
Typically, holidays such as May Day, Winter and Summer Breaks, and major festivals like
Mid-Autumn Festival and Dragon Boat Festival, provide opportunities for businesses to recover.
However, this year's results have been disappointing.
Foot traffic was slightly higher than usual, but mostly consisted of customers who only
made minimal purchases before leaving.
Official social financing data showed that M2 money supply grew by 6.8% year-on-year
in September, above the market expectation of 6.4%, but M1 money supply fell by 7.4%
year-on-year.
And the gap between them continues to widen.
Mr. Z's article indicated that the M1 data reflects insufficient market vitality.
The reason is simple.
People's expectations for future income have diminished, making them hesitant to spend
freely.
Besides downgraded consumption and collapsing domestic demand, the biggest challenge facing
the catering industry is market oversaturation, with too many stores.
Even if businesses can barely stay afloat, they face fierce competition within the industry.
Everyone is in a struggle for survival, and making money is secondary.
To maintain customer flow, small and medium-sized catering businesses are also being forced
into promotional wars.
The problem is that this cutthroat strategy is beyond the financial reach of most ordinary
businesses.
All together, and the Shanghai Composite Index dropped below 3,300 points.
On October 9, the three major A-share indices opened low and continued to decline.
The major consumer and real estate sectors collectively adjusted.
The Shanghai Composite Index dropped by more than 6%, falling below the 3,300-point mark.
The Chinex Index, which had risen sharply earlier, also corrected significantly, falling
by more than 10%.
The semiconductor sector was active against the trend, with the Science and Technology
Innovation 50 Index rising by more than 5% in the afternoon, though it later fell again
during late trading.
The market saw a general decline, with more than 5,000 stocks in Shanghai, Shenzhen and
Beijing falling.
The turnover of the two markets was about 2.94 trillion yuan, significantly smaller
than the previous days.
Regarding Hong Kong stocks, the Hang Seng Index and Hang Seng Technology Index both
fluctuated during early trading.
In the afternoon, the Hang Seng Index rose by more than 2%, but then fell again.
Internet stocks adjusted, with Dongfang Selection and Alihealth declining.
Wang Yi, Director of Quantitative Investment at Southern East Asia, commented,
The market is struggling between expectations for more stimulus measures and economic reality.
Investors hope to see stimulus measures quickly translate into improved corporate profits
and better macroeconomic data, whether it's inflation, employment or local government
debt.
However, there is a time lag between such expectations and economic reality.
Bloomberg reported that consumption patterns during the National Day holiday showed that
Despite signs of stabilization after the government launched a series of stimulus measures in
recent weeks, Chinese consumer confidence remains sluggish.
Goldman Sachs economist Li Xinguang and colleagues reported that low per capita travel expenditure
and low service prices indicate that China's domestic demand remains weak, and consumption
continues to downgrade.
KeyXin.com reported on October 9th that the recent strong market rebound prompted some
Since September 23rd, a total of 272 listed companies have announced share reductions.
The Chinese and Hong Kong markets have been very volatile recently, as both domestic and
foreign investors are still rebalancing in response to stimulus measures and a surge
in liquidity, said Marvin Chen, a strategist at Bloomberg Intelligence.
Onshore and offshore markets are trying to converge after a long holiday.
There may be some profit-taking in the onshore market, while the Hong Kong market is rebounding
from yesterday's massive sell-off.
I don't know what the NDRC director is thinking, said Alicia Garcia-Herrero, chief economist
for Asia-Pacific at Natixis SA, hours after the NDRC press conference.
Frankly, the longer they wait for clarification, the worse it could get because people will
realize that this stimulus has no fiscal effect.
It's just monetary, boosting the stock market, and so on.
This is very dangerous.
The market's reaction shows a disconnect between stock investors and officials in Beijing,
despite Chinese officials stating on Tuesday that they are confident of achieving their
economic growth target of about 5% this year.
The question now is whether Beijing will stop at this goal or take further steps to pull
China out of a deflationary spiral that could bring greater economic pain in the coming
years.
Market rebound requires more stimulus.
Bloomberg reported that the performance of the Chinese market has signaled to Chinese
Communist Party leaders that more economic stimulus is needed to drive the market rebound.
Zheng Nanhai may introduce additional measures.
The Information Office of the State Council of the Communist Party of China issued a notice
on Wednesday, October 9, stating that Lan Fuan, the Minister of Finance, will host a
press conference at 10 a.m. on Saturday.
Although Saturday is a working day in mainland China, the market will be closed.
It is anticipated that the Chinese Communist Party may launch the kind of stimulus measures
the market expects.
Banks, including Morgan Stanley and HSBC Holdings, predict the introduction of 2 trillion RMB
in stimulus measures, while Citigroup expects 3 trillion RMB.
The Ministry of Finance of the Communist Party of China is typically responsible for issuing
bonds to finance stimulus measures and additional spending.
Policymakers may not yet feel much pressure to do more, said Christopher Beddor, deputy
director of China Research at Gavikal Dragonomics, referring to the market rebound since late
September.
But if the market starts to plunge without any news in the coming days, they will have
to take further action, Beddor added.
