British museums grapple with returning prized, looted artefacts to countries they came from

Museum of European Antiquities
22 followers
Indian officials have denied reports that Udeli is planning to actively seek the restitution of
artifacts taken by the United Kingdom during the colonial era. Despite legal impediments and
political sensitivity, some objects in British museums are gradually marking and making their
way back to the countries where they originated. Julia Chapman reports from Glasgow.
Britain's museums are full of treasures. Many were gifted to the institutions,
but others were taken by force. The Scottish city of Glasgow has started a process of returning
some of its objects. The Kelvin Grove Museum is the first in the country to repatriate
looted items to India, a former British colony. There is certainly a feeling that there's a moral
obligation to return these objects where the circumstances were really being forcibly removed.
But I think beyond that, it's part of establishing a relationship of equals
internationally and allowing Glasgow to move forward in a modern 21st century relationship.
And to do that, we have to start by addressing historic wrongs. It's a long and painstaking
process. Researchers closely examine an object's origins and determine who the rightful modern
owners are. History museums, by their very nature, contain objects that reflect the past,
including the worst atrocities and thefts of empires. But while Glasgow's collections are
owned by the city and the city controls their fate, not all British museums have that power.
The country's biggest cultural institutions are restricted by law. It prevents them from
disposing of any item of cultural value. The government says it has no plans to change that.
That stands in contrast to the approach of France. In 2017, President Emmanuel Macron
triggered a process of returning objects to former French colonies.
He called African heritage the prisoner of European museums.
Well, the amount of stuff which is actually genuinely plundered and looted by the museum
is really tiny. I think people get carried away with the perceived scale of objects which have
been plundered. Actually, it probably represents only 1% of the holdings. I mean, remember,
there are 9 million objects in that museum. And the trouble is, that 1%, some of that 1%
are extremely important objects. Those objects draw thousands of tourists every year.
Critics of repatriation argue these items should have a wide audience. They say without so-called
encyclopedic museums, visitors would be left with only their own narrow history.
Glasgow's Kelvingrove Museum says the floodgates haven't opened. Only a handful of items are
currently under review. But the conversation continues about who has the right to display
fragments of the past. Julia Chapman, CNA, Glasgow.
