So there still seems to be a sizable portion of the free and open source community that still doesn't know what "free software" or "open source software" actually mean. Neither term has anything to do with the cost of the software. In fact, price is not a factor at all!
Your support is very much appreciated. Thanks, guys!
so we need to clear up some confusion
here within the free and open source
software Community there are still way
too many people that think that free
software or open source software or as
the term I often use free and open-
Source software they think these terms
mean that the software is free of charge
that it's basically cheap software it's
no cost software is software that you
get for free for no charge you didn't
have to pay a price for it and and no
that is actually not what any of those
three terms actually mean free software
open- Source software free and open
source software they have absolutely
nothing to do with the cost of the
software when we talk about free
software we are talking about Freedom
the freedom of you being able to do what
you want to do with that software it has
absolutely nothing to do with price and
the reason I wanted to address this
today is because I put out a video the
other day where I took a quick look at
the recent release of zero Linux with
the gnome desktop environment and this
distribution is called zerog and the
creator of zero Linux is uh dark zero
Steve you guys know who Steve is he
often appears on my patrons podcast uh
you know that I do at the end of every
month and he charges for isos that he
builds of zero Linux and people in the
comments were saying oh that's crazy
he's actually charging for quote free
software that's wrong that's immoral he
shouldn't be doing that people were
trashing him people were trashing me
saying you know I shouldn't put it on
camera or you know in the video I said
hey I think it's great that Steve is
charging for his isos I think more
people that are putting out free and
open source software should charge for
their time and people are like no DT
you're wrong for saying something like
that that's a moral that's against the
ideals of free software and open source
software and free open source software
and no it it's absolutely not against
any of those things I we need to address
actually what is free software and open
source software let's actually read the
definition so let's start with the free
software definition because that's where
this whole thing began right that's
where free software began and later you
know open source free and open source
you know all of this really it was
Richard stallman in the 1970s 1980s
created the free software movement he
created thee fre software Foundation he
created the G new project and there is a
free software definition there are only
four lines to the free software
definition so the four essential
freedoms is what these are called and
nowhere in these Four Freedoms is cost
or Price ever mentioned free software is
nothing about price every time Richard
stalman speaks from the 1970s 1980s
until today any time he speaks and he
speaks often about free software he
makes it a point to tell people this is
about Freedom not about cost it's okay
to charge for your software if you go
watch any lengthy uh Speech or anything
that Richard stalman has ever given he
hammers this point home constantly free
software has nothing to do with price so
let's go over the Four Freedoms the
First Freedom is the freedom to run the
program as you wish for any purpose so
this means anybody can use the software
so regardless of nationality race gender
religion you know nobody is prohibited
from using this program and you can use
it for any purpose you deem fit nobody
can restrict you so that again it's
about Freedom the next one is freedom
one which is the freedom to study how
the program works so this is basically I
need access to the source code so any
program that I get if it's free software
there has to be source code available
for this that I can go and view the
source code has to be published it has
to be uh freely available it can't be
locked behind a pay wall or anything and
it can't be unnecessarily burdensome for
me to get that source code so typically
these days because of the internet it
has to be published somewhere on GitHub
get lab you know something like that the
next freedom freedom two is the freedom
to redistribute copies so you can help
others so basically I should have the
option to modify the code to my likings
so again you know because the source
code is out there I get to see the
source code but now I also get to modify
the source code and redistribute copies
I share it with my friends and family
should I choose and in fact it specifies
that in Freedom 3 the freedom to
distribute copies of your modified
versions to others and that is it that
is all free software is it's very simple
anybody can use the software for any
purpose and then they need access to the
source code and they're allowed to
modify it and redistribute it if they
want to so no mention of price you know
or cost and Richard stalman again he
hammers this home all the time it's not
about free of price in fact Richard
stalman charges for things and has for
decade you know back in the day I think
he was charging people for some of his
uh uh like distributions of emac where
he build emac and put it on disc and
drives or you know what whatever media
he was actually putting those things on
back in the 1980s or whatever
and you know he would charge people for
that obviously because it's costing him
something to make that and also he
probably wanted to charge a little bit
for his time and effort you know make a
few bucks on it but that didn't mean
that emac wasn't free software you
absolutely could go get the source code
for emac somewhere and you know you
could compile it yourself you could
build a binary of it yourself if you
knew how right but you know if you want
Richard stalman to do that for you and
put it on a disc and send it to you heck
of course he's going to charge for it I
know I would and this has been kind of a
standard thing that a lot of people do
with free software it's been around for
decades is you know I'm going to charge
you for you know building a package you
know myself you know if you want me to
actually build a binary or in Steve's
case with zero Linux building an ISO you
know what you're going to pay me a
little money for that but hey if you
want to build it yourself all the source
codes out there for you you can do it
there's nothing preventing you from
doing it but this is kind of a normal
thing really big programs that you know
often do this you guys probably know
ardor ardor is a digital audio a piece
of software free and open source
software right they have a version that
they actually charge money for because
they build the binary package and if you
want that pre-built binary package
you're going to pay ardor for that but
if you want to build it yourself the
source code is all available for you you
can go build that particular version of
Ard door yourself if you know how to and
you want to take the time but if you
want to save a little time and just get
their pre-built version of it their
binary of it pay them a few bucks you'll
get the binary that's perfectly okay
there is nothing against that there's
nothing immoral about that that is
perfectly in line with the four
essential freedoms regarding free
software so hopefully now that we've
taken a look at the free software
definition you know that free software
has absolutely nothing to do with free
of cost that is not what we mean by free
software when we talk about free
software we're really talking about
Freedom software is really what we're
talking about matter of fact it should
have been called Freedom software
because that would clear up a lot of the
confusion but again that's the free
software definition let's go look at the
open source definition so let's go to
the open source initiative website and
there is an open- source definition
that's very similar to the free software
definition except it's a little bit more
wordy they have 10 criteria but it's
just a longer version of the Four
Freedoms is a central all it is if we
take a look at what open- source
software is you can see free
redistribution so you know I can modify
it and then redistribute it so that was
one of the freedoms with free software
same thing here with open source
software source code source code has to
be freely available I should be able to
find the source code of this program and
then modify it and then you know
redistribute it derived works you I can
make a derivative of it you can see
number five here no discrimination
against persons or groups so anybody can
use the software for any reason no
discrimination against fields of
endeavor again that's kind of you know
the same thing but is a little bit more
wordy right it's the only difference
between the free software definition and
the open- source definition but very
similar is that there is no real mention
of cost or price in the open source
definition except in one place source
code the source code must be available
preferably on the internet without
charge right you can't hide the source
code because that's part of Open Source
software was also part of free software
is whether you charge me for a pre-built
binary or a pre-built ISO the source
code has to be out there somewhere for
me to go and actually view it uh get it
myself modify it redistribute it yada
yada yada so you can't hide the source
code that's the main thing you can't
charge people for source code if you
start doing that then you are violating
free software and open source software
then that program would no longer
qualify as either free software or open
source softare Ware so now we've cleared
up those two terms free software open
source software but I know some of you
are going to be like hey the but you
always use the term free and open source
software and I know that people
sometimes interpret that to mean free as
in charge plus op- Source software well
that's not actually what most people
associate free and open source software
with if you actually just do a simple
Google search I know it's it's a lot to
ask you know people you know it's I had
to type like seven words in Google what
is free and open source software and
then their little AI overview you know
Google's little AI Gemini you know free
an open source software or Foss right is
what we often call it is software that
is available for anyone to use modify
redistribute with its source code
publicly accessible allowing users to
expect change improve the software
without restrictions y y y but here and
it essentially means the software is
free to use in terms of Freedom not
necessarily price straight from Google
right if you're if you were confused
about this and there were a lot of
people in the comment section of this
video confused because they were saying
yeah you can't charge for free software
you can't charge for open source
software and people were like hey you're
wrong there were a lot of you guys that
rightly knew what free software and open
source software was and you're like hey
you're wrong free software it can be
paid software right and people like no
no it's like just do a Google search if
you would have spent 10 seconds rather
than arguing in the comment section of
my video if you had done a simple Google
search what is free software what is
open source software Google's AI spits
out the answer and immediately talks
about it has nothing to do with price it
would have told you but you didn't ask
but you know it doesn't really make me
angry the laziness of people what makes
me angry about some of the people that
are all up in arms about uh people
charging for free and open source
software is that these people not only
are misguided but the real reason
they're upset is because they feel like
they are owed free as in cost software
they feel entitled right they refuse to
pay for software and that is really what
has been holding us back as far as the
free and open source software Community
that's what's been holding us back for
decades is that so many people within
our community think it should be free of
cost software they they know that's not
actually what those terms mean but
that's what they want it to mean they
really don't care about the freedom
aspect they would rather it all be about
the dollar amount aspect and no that's
not why we're here that if you want free
as in charge there's actually a term for
software that is free of cost we call it
freeware you've probably heard that term
before freeware that is a term that's
commonly used to refer to software that
is free of charge now most of that is
also going to be proprietary software
that's freee of charge but you know you
could also refer to open source software
that's free of charge as freeware but
typically we're not going to use the
term freeware when we're talking about
open source software usually freeware
it's kind of implied that it's
proprietary software it's just free of
cost proprietary software yeah but
getting back to some of the entitled
people on the internet that are all
upset that they have to pay for software
get over it you don't have to use it and
a matter of fact there were people in
the comments section I'm not paying for
this Linux distribution okay nobody
cares then that's like me going to the
store and I'm shopping and you know
99.99% of the things inside the store
I'm not there to buy I don't go around
and telling people hey I'm not buying
that I'm not buying this I'm not nobody
cares what you're not buying like we all
make decisions every single day about
what we purchase and what we're not
interested in purchasing and nobody
really cares the fact that you feel like
you need to yell it on the internet like
you're so important right like you know
people really want to know what I'm not
buying today um
man you
guys I just need to turn off the
camera peace guys