What Are the Hindu Virtues? | Jessica Frazier

HINDUISM • Beliefs • Life
4 followers
66 Video Views·Mar 2, 2025
Are there common denominators between Indian and Western morality, and can Indian virtues even be compared with Western ones? Jessica Frazier, who works at the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies, talks about South Asia's multifaceted ideas on good and evil.
What is a virtue and what is a vice? What does it mean to be good?
These are questions we ask ourselves in relation to society, one's self and perhaps one's God.
Joining me to talk about this today is Jessica Frazier, who is a fellow at the Oxford Centre
for Hindu Studies and an expert in intellectual history. Now, you talk about how the South Asian
tradition, and there's a wonderful quote, you say, a culture that doesn't have an apodictic
morality deriving from a single covenant with a single God. How does that distinction play out
and how radical is that difference? Yeah, I think the Western world is so
deeply embedded in an idea that God tells you what is good and bad, God tells you what is right and
wrong. And there's a kind of a commandment structure to our idea of virtue and advice.
You know, we have a clear picture of what it is that's good and what we're supposed to do.
And in a way, I think that translates over into the secular picture. You know,
we all know what goodness is. I think you even get that in arguments that are made by Moore and
Jeremy Bentham and in the modern philosophical world, we know good, we know pleasure, we know
pain. These things are obvious. But if you look around the rest of the world, if you look at not
only at South Asia, but South East Asia, East Asia, the sense of what is good and what is right
is much more complex. The sense of good and evil is not there in quite as simple a way.
They acknowledge that human life involves situations where to do good is messy. You may
have to be tough or you may have to suffer or even cause suffering. To do bad is messy. You may
do bad for good reasons. So that I think when you come out of this kind of God-given virtue
model, you get into what we in philosophy might call kind of value pluralism, context ethics,
understanding according to circumstance, the many ways we can go forward towards different kinds of
good and bad. That can seem confusing to the West, that it's not simple, but it can also seem much
more adult, much more mature, much more complex, humane and humanistic in a way.
I think we understood as kind of very, you know, you're making this distinction. Are we looking at a
totally separate tradition? Are there consonances? Are there lines of influence? I mean, I'm sure
by now there are, but you know, historically have there been kind of connections between
Christian thinking and, as it were, Eastern thinking? Yeah, it's a good question. I mean,
on a purely historical mode, there isn't a clear sense of any actual historical influence between
the two until quite late, I think. Arguably, there's a kind of a Gnostic trend toward inner
reflection, meditation, self-control and calming of the passions that you see in yoga that's quite
similar to the sort of stuff you see in more Gnostic traditions in the West, not dissimilar
to Plato. So there may be a kind of a cultural shared pool of ideas, but historically there
aren't clear direct influences. But of course, the funny thing is, I think the more you look
across cultures, the same human concerns arise so that there's a very clear, very similar
movement in India to think about what good social behaviour is. And once you have to
think about good social behaviour as just a product of having a society, a community and a
governance structure, you get people in India thinking in very similar ways, actually,
about what it is to not prioritise your ego and desires over other people's wellbeing,
to consider what it is to create a generally good community and to start to develop things like
empathy, compassion and a certain amount of self-sacrifice for others. So those ideas
actually come up on both sides and in India that's associated with the notion of dharma
becomes a very important core theme for the Indian world.
Yes, can you talk a bit about what dharma as a concept means and how we would understand it?
Yeah, so insofar as India wants to think about social ethics, the concept of virtue we put
aside for a second, but social virtue, this arises fairly early on. India in its sort of
Sanskritic classical culture associated with the Brahmin caste, the priestly caste, and these
people are highly literate, they're already writing in India from 1000 BC and they develop
ideologies to do not only with ritual piety towards the gods, but also gradually with the
concept of natural order. Originally that's called rita, which means a kind of cosmic order,
but it starts to turn into a more broad natural order concept called dharma.
Dhri can be many different things, it can be kind of to hold up. Dharma becomes really important,
particularly in the centuries leading up to nought, so kind of the early classical period,
and we get the dharma of your role in society. Are you a priest? Your role is to preserve
knowledge and to cultivate ritual. Are you a merchant? Your role is to acquire goods,
to generate capital. Are you a king? Your role is to understand what it is to
set aside your personal concerns for the good of the community. So we've got a kind of a functional
social ideal there. That sort of seems to be consonant with Aquinas' idea about, you know,
the rational order of the universe being an expression of God or indeed the medieval great
chain of being. Yeah, absolutely, absolutely, and it fits into that kind of notion, I think,
that there's a, you know, the divine right of kings in a way is backed up by a notion of natural law,
that there are certain structures that people should uphold, and, you know, almost as in
Aristotle, the natural world shows us as the seasons come again and again, and that makes the
agricultural world fruitful, and it just seems to know how to do this. We need to find within
ourselves a sense of the dharma of ourselves, of our community, and of nature. All of these go
together to fulfill that order, and there's a trust there in nature. If you can find that natural
pattern of things, and give into it, and help to cultivate it, participate in it, everything will
work out. You don't need to struggle against the world. The world has a kind of a smooth groove
into which you have to lean. So it's in some ways a very positive model, although, of course,
politics can come in, and the Brahmins can start to use this to advance their own well-being. So
it becomes also a way in which social injustice can enter. Of course. I mean, we'll return to
that maybe, but I'd like to get a sense, you know, it's a natural thing, it's, you know,
as it were, you don't need too many prohibitions, and how much, I mean, we're accustomed to thinking
of, particularly through Abrahamic religions, that the holy books are quite concerned with
this is what you should do, this is what you shouldn't do, you know, we have commandments.
Are the Vedas and the other sacred books of Hinduism concerned with or interested in,
you know, instructions for how to live, or are they doing something different?
Yeah, it's a good question. So you get, in this kind of super-fertile classical period between,
say, 300 BC and CE, right, those 600, maybe even 1000 years, everything becomes incredibly
fertile textually. And the Brahmin establishment, together with the kings who were supporting them
financially and ideologically, start to put out a lot of material about the importance of Dharma.
And it kind of hits on two levels. On one level, you get texts like what's in the West is called
the Laws of Manu, the Dharma Shastras, manuals of good behaviour. And they give details for every
part of life, for kings, for merchants, for good Brahmins, for fathers of families, for mothers of
families, for genders, for ascetics and yogis who are outsiders. Everything you do has strictures
attached to it. And some of them are quite extraordinary, you know, the details of how
you should wash, of what you should eat, of who you should marry, of how you should propagate,
of how women should behave, of… They're really detailed, aren't they?
They're super detailed. There's a wonderful one. But what's interesting is you think about how that
detail works and whether people really followed these rules. One of the most interesting ones is,
I think, if a student who's gone to live with his older teacher, and the teacher may have a
younger wife, if the student falls in love with the wife, and God forbid, gets involved carnally
with the wife, one of the punishments is for that, yeah, one of the punishments is for that student
he has to cut off his sexual member, hold it cupped in his hands as he walks toward the setting
sun until he dies. And that's his own self-imposed punishment, right? No one's going to force that on
him. I was going to say, that would put you right off. Yeah, put you off, exactly, exactly. But then
you think about this and you wonder how many students did that? I suspect relatively few,
right? But the Brahmins put forward this extreme kind of deterrent idea as almost a propaganda
strategy for persuading people it's a bad idea. People didn't necessarily do these things.
And I think reflecting that idea that strictures don't automatically work, you then get texts like
the Bhagavad Gita, this very famous text, which talks about what's the psychology you need. It
has to be internalized. So it talks at length about loka samgraha, which means holding the
world together. And that starts to open ethics up and virtue up to a more spiritual way of
thinking about things. You have to have the knowledge to understand what's needed for
yourself and your community. And you have to have the yogic self-control and restraint and
strength of character to engage that, to do that well. And if you do all of this, the world,
the cosmos itself will be held together, partly by you. Yeah, you do your bit. Yeah, you do your
bit. And that becomes your virtue. It's wisdom. It's a kind of philosopher king idea of the
intelligent person who sees what's needed and does it. Well, this is something that you mentioned,
you know, psychology. And I'm just trying to get a sense from you of how, in polytheism,
I mean, in monotheism, we tend to think, you know, the single God is identified with
particular kind of moral positions. But obviously, when you don't have a single God,
you can't quite have that. How do we think about how, you know, Rama and Sita and Sita and Kali,
what do they represent? Do they represent, as it were, kind of psychological or behavioural
archetypes? Or do they represent different versions of the good? How did, how are they
understood in Indian culture? Yeah, it's a great question. And I think that's exactly right, that
once India understands that dharma is useful, but that doesn't tell us what is the good to become
as a person, what is your ideal to move forwards? They get to say, well, there isn't one.
There are many ideals, there are different goods for humankind. And I think that the gods,
as they develop throughout the early medieval period in a series of texts called the Puranas,
kind of mythic texts that unpack the stories of each deity, they get to unpack different virtues.
So that, for instance, Shiva is kind of the ascetic God, he's the yogi, he sits
in meditative position in the Himalayas, dressed in animal skins, living an austere life.
He represents yogic virtues of spiritual self-control and awareness. Kali, who completely
freaked out Westerners when they first arrived in India, he's this semi-naked wild woman,
hair flowing, dark skinned, which was very shocking to them. We've all seen Indiana Jones,
the Temple of Doom. Yeah, which is, Hindus are rightly extremely insulted by, exactly. But Kali
represents something very wonderful. There are wonderful texts, Devi Mahatmya is a text in which
Kali gives a speech to a king who's been abandoned by his people, to a merchant who's been
betrayed by his family. And she says, what you have to do is understand the darkness of the world.
If you understand it, if you can get your hands dirty, if you can see it and not be destroyed,
if you can accept death, the one thing that no one can accept, you become strong, you become
virtuous, you become knowing and robust in a way that is holistic. And so this is also a virtue
that Kali represents. And of course, you've got Krishna, the virtue of the lover, who can give
completely to love, who can maximise beauty, passion, and the pleasurable goods of life.
You've got all these figures who represent, Saraswati represents the virtues of civilisation,
of art, of knowledge, of learning, of music. Hanuman, the monkey god, is glorious. He represents
strength, strength not only of body, but also of heart, which is a really nice corrective to
the Western idea that you need to be physically strong but emotionally restrained. The Western
hero, you know, never cries. This is no, no, no, you are strong physically, and you're strong in
your feelings and your loves and your commitments. And when you hurt, you cry, and when you love,
you shout with joy. So exactly that, you get a plurality of virtues all expressed through these
very different deities. And it's a sense that you sort of pick and choose, as in, you know,
if you were in that tradition, you go, you know, this god's my guy. Yeah, I mean, it's interesting
because you may, your region may have a preferred deity, your family may have a preferred deity,
but everyone in Hinduism gets to choose what's called their Ishta Devata, their desire, their
personal preferred deity, who they give their hearts to, and who, in a sense, becomes a kind
of a guiding light in their life. But I think it is a recognition of that plurality. When a Hindu
goes to the temple, almost every temple across the range of Hinduism may have one god at the front,
but all the deities are there. And at certain times in your life, you need Shiva for that
strength and clarity. Sometimes you need Kali to help you face the dark. And other times you'll
need Rama, who represents sovereign goodness and virtue for his community. All of these characters
are there because humanity and human life is super complex. You do, as you've hinted earlier,
discuss that there's a political as well as a spiritual valency to this concept of Dharma.
Isn't how that's played out, I mean, we think also in terms of the sort of intellectual history,
I mean, does this tradition have, as we do in kind of Western Christianity, you know,
church fathers, historical theologians, gurus and authorities, I mean, gurus maybe you do, but
you know, has it changed and has it been affected by, if you like, political facts on the ground
and co-opted by those things? In the West, I guess, the Christian tradition has as well.
Yeah, I think it's right to say that the language of Dharma, for instance, just that discourse
starts off as something that's coming out of this Vedic Brahminical tradition associated
with priestly caste. And to some extent, it has the character of a certain kind of propaganda. I
mean, the people writing the system put themselves at the top of the hierarchy. And so the Brahmins
do use this in a sense to shore up a structure, which is going to keep people under control.
The great Buddhist emperor Ashoka, around 300 BC, propagates the term Dharma. And he calls himself
the Dharmic emperor. And he puts the wheel of Dharma as a symbol everywhere. It's still part
of the Indian kind of flag symbolism. But it's partly to keep people quiet and calm and doing
their duty. So it is in some ways linked to a kind of political control. Interestingly,
in India, the good thing is, because there's no organ of orthodoxy, there's no inquisition,
there's no one who gets to say, burn that book. There's always a subversive message that emerges
somewhere in Indian history. Even in the Mahabharata, the great epic, you get characters
going, too much Dharma can be a bad thing, or too obvious and strict a Dharma, never lie.
Well, when a man comes, when the thief says, hey, where are the family hiding from you? He says,
oh, they're hiding in that cupboard from you. And he says, thanks, and he goes and he
slits their throats. That was the wrong application of over-strict Dharma.
Yeah, bad Dharma, bad Dharma, right. And just the last thing on that, there's also,
one of the biggest things that happens in India is there's, at some point with the rise of
devotional spirituality, there's a huge affirmation of passion, a huge affirmation of throwing caution
to the winds. When it's right, particularly in spiritual matters, and completely giving your
heart to something and letting Dharma fall behind, when it matters to love, God or whatever,
then you have to let Dharma dissolve, at least temporarily.
Well, that does lead on to something that I think is an interesting distinction you make between
the communitarian understanding of virtue and this sort of rather enclosed, hermetic,
sort of yogic idea that virtue consists not in your place in society, but in withdrawing from
society and mastering yourself. Obviously, in ordinary life, these two things rub along,
but they seem to be quite distinct traditions in Hindu spirituality. How do they kind of
rub along, and do they lead in completely different directions?
Yeah, I think it's a very good question, and the answer's always going to be complicated,
but I think in some ways, they are a fruitful tension. They're, in a way, two different
traditions. And you can see early on, scholars like Patrick Olivelle have written a lot about
this, where the Brahmins are saying, oh, we've got to do our Dharma, be a good householder,
make children, support society in the social fabric. And then you see evidence of an increasingly
large number of ascetics, yogis—this happens all over the world—leaving behind society,
saying, if you don't agree with this, leave it behind. Come and join an alternative community
of yogis and ascetics who are living in the forest and pursuing spiritual goals.
And there's a friction between them. There's a certain amount of rhetoric we can see from
both sides saying, God, you don't want to be one of those banal householder, domestic
Dharma doers. And they're saying, you don't want to be one of these irresponsible,
homeless, feckless yogis prioritizing liberation over the group. So there's a little tension there.
And a lot of what happens in the whole of the history is to try and bring them together. Rama,
the great king, is shown as spending years in the forest as an ascetic, so he unites the two.
And again and again, texts keep suggesting to us that we can bring the two together.
It's the genius of the Bhagavad Gita, which many Hindus still read.
Very cleverly, it says, you can do your Dharma and be a yogi on the inside. Good
citizen on the outside, spiritual yogi on the inside. And so it's trying to give both to
everybody. And the two traditions always do. There's a sort of sense that that's a kind of
slightly panicky, you know, if everyone goes off and becomes a sannyasin, you know, society is
screwed. Let's find a way of encouraging people to be, you know, you can be a sannyasin without
going anywhere. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And that's a political move rather than a theological one.
I think it's both. I think it's both. Like, I love the Bhagavad Gita's beautiful text,
but it's definitely partly trying to persuade people not to leave home. You know, in a way,
it's the 50s saying, you know, I know you want to become a yogi and go to California and sit
around the fire and play, you know, find yourself, but please don't do that. Please stay home.
You can listen to the records at home and find yourself at home, right? So it is trying to
head off the more extreme side of things. The virtue, again, of South Asia is that it's too
large to be controlled. So actually, even contemporary India still has one of the
world's largest communities of active ascetics living outside the normal social kind of structure
so that they didn't succeed fully, you know. And one of those groups went off and became Buddhism
and took over half the rest of Asia. So it's not that they fully succeeded. You know, but maybe
this is also something that humans are always struggling with, that there is, you know, every
young person who thinks, oh, I would like to go and choose the harder path, strike out towards
virtue of a profound spiritual kind that will elevate myself and my soul and make me perhaps
reach a higher level of human experience and becoming. But what am I going to do about
family, about home? Do I really want to give up having a house, a job, going to college?
You know, I think I had that moment at 18. I'm like, oh, I could go to college
or I could go sit in a cave somewhere. Which will I do? And you're, you know, most of us think,
oh, I'll go to college first and I'll go to the cave later. And then you never get to the cave.
Yeah, exactly. Right. So, you know, India tries to create conduits for both and kind of succeeds
more than almost any culture I know. Other cultures come up with monastic systems to create a place
for those who want to devote themselves to more radical forms of virtue. And that works as an
institution. But even that's a struggle. You know, Francis of Assisi has to struggle not to become a
property owning institution within the church. He wants to keep that purity. It's always hard,
I think, in every culture. Yeah. And that struggle goes on today in a way.
And how well, I mean, you know, as you say, if we've got some, one of these traditions takes
off and becomes Buddhism, you know, India is huge. It's got, you know, it is the prevailing,
melting pot of a number of different religious traditions. Given the sort of incipient pluralism
and, you know, multivalent qualities, how well do all these traditions rub along? I mean,
is the Hindu tradition something that's amenable to secularism, if you like? Does it just find it
easy to accommodate multiple religious traditions within its territory?
Yeah. And it raises questions about, interesting questions about what we mean by secularism,
right? So traditionally, India was one of the best cultures in the world, I think,
at accepting multiple traditions. I think Asia actually generally is very good at this. If you
go to Japan, Shinto and elements of Taoism and elements of Buddhism live very happily.
If you go to even to Indonesia or Malaysia, if you spend time there, traditionally,
the Chinese, the local indigenous religions, Christian, Muslim, they all kind of mix in quite
well together. So I think the Western idea that there's one creed, you've got to follow one God
with his morality and virtues is a particular, it's almost like actually a cul-de-sac of history.
The majority of cultures don't expect everyone to do the same thing. And that's worked very well.
Of course, politics can change things. India is, in some ways, I think that Hindu virtues,
as they're being framed in the current world, are being promoted as national virtues.
Throughout Modi's attempt to kind of remake India as a Hindu nationalist.
I think that there's a kind of, you know, the BJP, and there's a lot of discourse about trying
to turn those kind of religious virtues. And this goes into a longer history of debate. Gandhi
caught a lot of flack, as well as doing a lot of good from people like Rabindranath Tagore and so
on. But in saying that, you know, we can use these Hindu ideas, Satyagraha, virtue, etc.,
to help create a better India. It opens the door potentially to one religion and its values and
virtues becoming the dominant discourse. And that's complicated because India, as you said,
is too big for that. There's going to be Muslim culture, which has always been an important part
of Indian culture. Buddhist culture is still there. Jainism, Christianity, so many different
groups. And Hinduism itself is more than one thing, that in order to create a single kind of
text of what is the proper Hindu way of doing things, they've had to kind of constrain and,
to some extent, make an artificial version of Hinduism. Interesting project, but with complicated
implications, I think, for the society. What has, you know, you've said that they are
separate traditions, but in the last 100 or 200 years, what has Indian contact with the West done
to modify the Hindu ideas of vice and virtue, as you understand it? Yeah, interesting. I think
there was a lot of impact from the arrival of the kind of colonial world into South Asia,
particularly on the intelligentsia, shall we say. You know, you can see the everyday people at a
certain level, the Hinduism and the Indian culture of the village, if you like, stays relatively
intact. But the intelligentsia, if you like, the middle classes, the educated classes,
did start to try and generate a version of Hinduism that would look good to the West in
the Western university and to the Western missionary. And there's a huge apologetic
project which comes out, which, you know, produced some positive things. It got Hindus to think
about their own values, virtues, and how they should be socially implemented. And there's a
huge group, what's called the Bengal Renaissance, the Brahmo Samaj groups, who decided to try and
reform Hinduism. And some of that was very important. It made them think in a new way about
caste, for instance, and about gender. On the other hand, it was an apologetic project where
they ended up saying, oh, yeah, well, you know, all the gods are really just one God. And so it's
really just Christianity. Really, we can feel the Gita is just like the Bible. There was a sort of
conforming of Hinduism to what they saw as the proper pucker, quite Protestant, particularly,
model that they should match. And that was, in some ways, it was part of the organic change
in response to a new culture. And again, important thinkers came out of that. Vivekananda, Swami
Vivekananda, who went to the Chicago Parliament of World Religions in the 1890s and helped to
promote an understanding of Hinduism, was in some ways involved in that. But it is true, it created
a certain kind of sanitized version of Hinduism. And characters like Kali, the more complex,
but in some ways more interesting, more novel insights got pushed aside. So I think there's
still a project that we have now of trying to make sense of this Hindu picture to the university
establishment, to the contemporary global media, and show what insights it has to bring to our own
thinking about virtue today. Well, you're the person to do that. Jessica Fraser, thank you very much indeed.
