474 Video Views·Mar 1, 2025
🔵 Try Epoch Times now: https://ept.ms/3Uu1JA5
John Eastman: “Americans really need to understand this aggressive weaponization of our criminal justice system that the Democrats did to go after their political opponents… I hope Kash Patel, now the FBI director, is going to do is investigate the prosecutors, because in my view, what's been going on here is a nationwide conspiracy to go after people for the exercise of their constitutional rights, right to speech, right to assembly, right to petition the government for redress of grievances. And that's a federal felony, and I think Kash Patel can investigate it, and if he determines it's warranted, wrap it up with a bow and hand it over to Pam Bondi to prosecute.”
At the 2025 Conservative Political Action Conference, Jan Jekielek interviewed Trump’s former lawyer John Eastman. Eastman is the subject of the new documentary film “The Eastman Dilemma: Lawfare or Justice.”
Eastman about the documentary: “The question is, you know, did I have a dilemma? And when you see the film, you say, No, Eastman never had a dilemma. The dilemma is to my colleagues in the legal profession: Are they going to sit idly by and watch this lawfare go on without speaking up against it, or are they going to join with me and fight for justice?”
Five years ago, John Eastman urged President Donald Trump to challenge the legality of the 2020 elections. Today, he faces multiple legal cases and his license to practice law has been suspended in California. In this episode, he shares his story.
“You know, people said: Oh, it’s just vengeance. No, it's not vengeance. What went on here was unprecedented in American history, this distortion and overreach of federal criminal or state criminal statutes to go after the political opposition. The people that did that need to be held accountable for two things. One, if they violated people's constitutional rights, they should be brought to justice. But two, a very strong net message needs to be sent so that nobody will ever entertain doing that again.
CHAPTER TITLES
0:00:05 - Introduction to John Eastman
0:00:23 - The Lawfare documentary: The Eastman Dilemma
0:01:28 - Legal Challenges and Psychological Projection
0:03:14 - Advice to Vice President Pence and Court System Failure
0:06:18 - Alternate Electors and Constitutional Authority
0:08:44 - Ongoing Legal Battles and Federal Investigation
0:09:30 - Spending Power and Impoundment Control Act
0:11:43 - Birthright Citizenship and Originalist Scholarship
0:13:29 - Background and Competence
0:16:25 - Future Legal Battles and Supreme Court Involvement
0:17:36 - Reputation and Originalist Briefs
John Eastman: “One of the greatest examples of psychological projection I've ever seen was when the Democrats said, if Trump wins, he'll weaponize the Department of Justice. And I was sitting there saying, What? What have I been dealing with? The last four years. I was an unindicted co-conspirator in Jack Smith's criminal indictment against President Trump. I'm indicted in Georgia and Arizona. They've suspended my bar license out in California or made it inactive while we're appealing that decision.”
John Eastman about the 2020 election: “The thing was we got to bring challenges in the courts to talk about the illegality, because Article Two of the Constitution quite clearly gives the sole power to the state legislatures to choose the rules, to check the manner for choosing electors. And in each of those swing states, the election officials refused to follow the rules that made it a fraudulent or filed election, and I said, with a failed election, the legislatures need to weigh back in and try and ascertain what would have happened if the rules had been followed. And my advice to Vice President Pence, or my urging to friends, was to accept requests from those state legislators to let them decide what the impact of that illegality was.”
“And I think the American people deserve to have an answer and, win or lose, they would feel more comfortable with the result. But when you refuse to let people raise those questions, and just pretend that what the government has spoken is true, George Orwell wrote this in his famous book ‘1984’: The government has said two plus two is five, and you got to not only repeat the lie, but you got to come to believe it. Well, Americans are not too keen on being, you know, spoon fed lies, and have to repeat them. And unfortunately, we didn't get a chance to actually vet those claims to see whether they were true or false. And there are way too many people, myself included, that think the government's claims this was the most secure election in our history is just laughably false.”
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
💛 Support us 👉https://donorbox.org/american-thought-leaders
-------------------------------------------------
© All Rights Reserved.
[Music]
well John Eastman such a pleasure to
have you on American thought leaders
well thank you for having me on it's a
real pleasure to be with
you so you're one of the few people I
think to have an actual dilemma named
after you the Eastman dilemma okay tell
me about the Eastman dilemma well you
know it was a somebody wanted to
Hollywood wanted to do a documentary
about all the law I've been dealing with
and um I was happy to oblige because I
think the story needs to be told and
Americans really need to understand this
aggressive weaponization of our criminal
justice system that the Democrats did to
go after their political opponents and
so the eastan Dilemma lawfare or Justice
I think does a fabulous job exposing
that and when we premiered it at
maralago president Trump came and
watched it with us and that was just
great fun but so but but what is the
dilemma I mean I guess is the question
yeah the question is uh you know did I
have a dilemma and when when you see the
film you say no Eastman never had a
dilemma The Dilemma is to my colleagues
in the legal profession are they going
to sit idly by and watch this lawfare go
on without speaking up against it or are
they going to join with me and fight for
justice you're also involved in a whole
bunch of legal challenges as we speak
like working on them so I want to get
into that before we go there but just
kind of give me a picture of what you
faced well you know one of the Great
greatest examples of psychological
projection I've ever seen was when the
Democrats said if Trump wins he'll
weaponize the Department of Justice and
I was sitting there saying what have
what have I been dealing with the last
four years I was an unindicted
co-conspirator in Jack Smith's criminal
indictment against President Trump I'm
indicted in Georgia and Arizona they've
suspended my bar license out in
California or made it inactive while
we're appealing that decision uh it's an
outrage because I gave advice to the
president of the United States um to
challeng illegality in the 2020 election
uh the the Georgia prosecutors and the
Arizona prosecutors don't seem to have
gotten the message from the last
election and they're doubling down and
they're still fighting hard to keep
those prosecutions
alive so what was the advice that you
gave well first thing was we got to
bring challenges in the courts to talk
about the illegality because article two
of the Constitution quite clearly gives
the sole power to the state legislators
to choose the rules to direct the manner
for choosing electors and in each of
those swing States the election
officials refused to follow the rules
that made it a f fraudulent or a filed
election and I said with a failed
election the legislators need to weigh
back in and try and assertain what would
have happened if the rules had been
followed and my advice to vice president
Pence or my urging to P was to accept
request from those state legislators to
let them decide what the impact of that
illegality was and by by the way I I
specifically wrote If the impact is
smaller than b Biden's margin then that
would be useful to know as well and then
we could be more confident that Biden
had actually won but Pence said I'm not
doing
anything and so you know ultimately
these are all questions that you were
expecting to be answered in the courts
right right and the courts they just
took a pass in the movie um Larry leig
prominent Harvard Law School professor
says he just don't think the courts did
the work that was required they didn't
look at the evidence they didn't look at
the legal arguments they just thought
and he kind of gives them a bone and say
well I think they just didn't think they
had enough time I think it was worse
than that they didn't want to address
the significant illegality that occurred
but the problem is by leaving that stuff
unaddressed you've got this open soar on
the American Body politic that will
never heal because too many people knew
there was stuff that went on that was
that was fraudulent that was illegal and
nobody did anything about it right and
it's and so you can't even have the
discussion of whether it was enough to
shift things or not because you didn't
address the core questions that's kind
of what you're arguing here that's was
you know and I think the American people
deserve to have an answer and and win or
lose they would feel more comfortable
with the result but when you refuse to
let people raise those questions and
just pretend that the what the
government has spoken is true I mean you
know George Orwell wrote this in his
famous book 1984 you you know the
government has said 2 plus 2 is five and
you got to not only repeat the lie but
you got to come to believe it well
Americans are not too keen on being you
know spoonfed lies and have to repeat
them and unfortunately we didn't get a
chance to actually vet those claims to
see whether they were true or false and
there are way too many people myself
included that think the government's
claims this was the most secure election
in our history it's just laughably
false Lawrence leig is not someone I
necessarily expected to see in the film
yeah right well he's he's an honest
scholar on the left uh but he thinks the
importance of the alternate electors
meeting and voting was critical the
reason Congress doesn't have any
authority over the choosing of a
president the founders did that by
Design because if Congress got to pick
the president you would destroy
separation of powers but the one
Authority they do have is to set the
date that the electors meet and vote and
the Constitution requires that that date
the same throughout the United States so
if you've got pending challenges to
elections that go your way and your
electors have not met on Election
elector day quite arguably they can't
those votes can't be considered this is
why John Kennedy's electors in Hawaii in
1960 met and voted even though Nixon had
been certified as the winner because
there was an election challenge pending
and when the election challenge went
Kennedy's way those electoral votes were
there to be certified if they hadn't
voted there wouldn't be anything to
certify and leig is on honest enough to
say that's what's required under the
Constitution and that's what Eastman was
advising and I you know I really
appreciate him standing up I'm sure he
got some heat from his colleagues on the
Harvard faculty but it it was it was an
honest thing to do and I applaud him for
it what is the status of you you you
suggested that there's still some of
these cases that are being played out
what is what is your sit General
situation so we we've got an appeal uh
Hearing in March in the California bar
proceeding and I have no idea what the
appell court or the California Supreme
Court is going to do but the criminal
matters in Georgia and Arizona are still
very much alive fonnie Willis in Georgia
has been disqualified but she continues
to prosecute the case filing appeals on
other counts that have already been
dismissed and she's still acting as if
she's the in charge even though she's
been disqualified so we're challenging
that but even if the
disqualification is upheld there are
other County Das that are just chomping
at the bit to get this case and continue
it to make their name on the Democrat
base side of the of the aisle so it's
not going away anytime soon what I hope
cash Patel now the FBI director is going
to do is investigate the prosecutors
because in my view what's been going on
here is a nationwide conspiracy to go
after people for the exercise of their
constitutional rights right to speech
right to assembly right to petition the
government for redress of grievances and
that's a federal felony and I think cash
Patel can investigate it and if he
determines it's warranted rrap it up
with a bow and hand it over to Pam Bondi
to
prosecute fascinating and what and what
would be the determining Factor whether
a case like this would go ahead would be
would become legitimate the terms of a
conspiracy would have a predicate I
guess is the term right yes did did you
was there a meeting of the minds to
violate people's constitutional rights
through the exercise of this conspiracy
and I think cash is going to be able to
prove that particularly if he gets all
the email and the text message traffic
back and forth I'll give you one example
the the the special prosecutor that
Fanny Willis hired down in Georgia
Nathan Wade he met a whole day with the
White House and I believe under oath he
said I didn't talk about the Georgia
case but it was reported down in Georgia
that in fact he build the Georgia case
for that meeting so so if that's
true then then we've at the White House
coordinating with a state prosecutor to
bring charges against the White House's
political opponent this is an egregious
abuse of our criminal justice system and
it's a deprivation of constitutional
rights and that's a federal felony and
they and and that could be addressed
earnestly and honestly in the courts I
mean that's it could and you know people
said oh you're just it's Vengeance no
it's not Vengeance what went on here was
unprecedented in American history this
Distortion and overreach of federal
criminal or state criminal statutes to
go after the political opposition the
people that did that need to be held
accountable for two things one if they
violated people's constitutional rights
they should be brought to justice but
two a very strong net message needs to
be sent so that nobody will ever
entertain doing that
again well I guess we'll see what
happens right um let's talk about the
work you're doing now so there's some uh
challenges around spending Nancy Pelosi
famously said in response to a question
uh years ago uh she said well Congress
can spend for whatever it wants well
anybody can look at the Constitution
it's Article 1 Section 8 first Clause
gives Congress the power to raise
taxes for only two purposes to pay the
debts of the United States and to
provide for the common defense and
general welfare and the people that
wrote that language meant things in the
National interest not in the local
interest so common defense is the US
Army local defense is the Long Beach
police force right and the Constitution
doesn't authorize us to tax the folks of
Rhode Island to pay for the Long Beach
California police force and uh a lot of
the spending that we've grown accustomed
to over the last century has been in
violation of that limitation on the
spending power Congress passed in 1974
against a weakened Richard Nixon the
impoundment Control Act right anytime a
president wants to not spend money that
Congress has authorized he has to ask
congress's permission and if they don't
give it the money has to be spent and
I've taken the position article in the
Federalist a couple months ago saying
the president has an independent
obligation uphold the Constitution and
if the spending that he's trying to cut
violates that limit on on spending in
the Constitution then he has an
independent obligation not to make those
expenditures not to allow that money to
be spent and he doesn't need to ask
congress's permission to do so I mean
fascinating right I mean all the things
in the last few weeks that I've learned
about spending how it works you know
just the idea that some of that in the
treasury there was isn't really like
credible audits happening so I mean this
is your legal argument like someone
presumably is coming from the other side
and saying no John we should we should
be able to spend you know whatever
whatever we need that's right and I just
say look at the language of the
Constitution it's very clear I often
joke the Constitution is written so
clearly even lawyers should be able to
understand it oh that's I think a lot of
people appreciate that that one joke
okay tell me about Birthright
citizenship so Birthright citizenship
this is another major area of my
scholarship over the last 20 years and
and I'll give you a good example of the
how simplistic the other side has made
it uh senator hono from Hawaii couple
weeks ago after the president signed his
executive order
she she found it to be an egregious
unconstitutional action she says because
the Constitution is clear anybody born
in the United States dot dot dot is a
citizen that's what she posted on her
Twitter account well the dot dot dot is
the key language that she just wrote out
of the Constitution it's all persons
born here and subject to the
jurisdiction thereof and for those that
wrote it it didn't mean just being here
and subject to our laws while you're
here they called that partial or
territorial jurisdiction it the complete
jurisdiction do you owe allegiance to
this country have you become part of our
political Community with our consent and
people that are temporary visitors they
specifically said are not covered by
that mandatory automatic citizenship and
if temporary legal visitors are not
covered then clearly temporary illegal
visitors are not covered either and
that's all president Trump's order does
it says those two character those two
categories of people were never
understood to be granted automatic
citizenship by the 14th Amendment and so
we need to restore the original meaning
of that of that citizenship Clause okay
that's fascinating I mean so this is
you've been working on this for 20 years
yeah yeah so H H how does that work and
so before we continue actually tell me
about your background because this is
the other thing you know um you were
really you know there's a lot of really
negative things said about you including
that you're not competent so I want to
give you a chance to tell me what you've
done over these last 20 years or or and
of course much longer so if they don't
think I'm confident why do they avoid
debating me on these issues so I was at
University of Chicago last Monday to
talk about Birthright citizenship and
they were so outraged The Faculty held
another meeting to have their two
experts who don't know anything about
this issue talk about all the ways that
I was wrong but they wouldn't actually
say it in front of me where I could
challenge them um look uh I have a PhD
in in the political philosophy of the
American founding I have a law degree
from one of the top law schools in the
country the University of Chicago I
clerked at the Supreme Court of the
United States with Justice Clarence
Thomas probably the greatest originalist
judge on the court today and um and I've
been doing this uh for 25 years I
created my own public interest law firm
to advance the originalist understanding
of the constitution in major
constitutional cases before The Supreme
Court and I've been involved in over 200
cases there um the Obamacare cases the
the the takings case the kilo casee that
um the property rights cases the
separation of powers cases the
federalism cases the limits on the
Commerce Clause cases I was even hired
by the state of South Dakota to press
this argument on the spending Clause 15
years ago so you know the state
legislators the state governments are
recognizing I'm the expert to go-to
person on this um and I think that's one
of the reasons why I'm so targeted by
the lawfare they want to keep me on my
heels so that I can't weigh in
with with these originalist
constitutional arguments that are
persuading the courts you know that it's
so fascinating because well for for
starters you you you know a little bit
about the
Constitution I think we could I think
hopefully no one would no one would
dispute that the other thing that's
coming to my mind you know as you
describe this Birthright citizenship
reality it it actually
changes changes how I think about it
because it's not it's it's not that
there is no Birthright it's that there's
it's it's very it's a very specific
thing the birthright is a very specific
thing that's what I hear yes right well
and you know look the the the people
that are on the other side of this
battle say we've had what's called you
solely the old English common law rule
if you're born on the king's soil you
were the king's subject um and and they
said well we've had that our whole
history well the youth solely ruled if
you were born on the king soil you owed
the you owed allegiance to the king
forever you could never renounce it look
at the closing paragraph of our
Declaration of Independence these United
Colonies are and of right ought to be
free and independent states and we
hereby renounce all allegiance to the
king that was the most eloquent
repudiation of that old common law rule
ever written and that was at the moment
of our founding that we repudiated that
Doctrine so what's next for you well I'm
still fighting Georgia and Arizona I
hope we win the appeal on the California
bar thing right now my license is in
inactive status so I'm not allowed to
practice in the state courts in
California and several of the federal
district courts have followed suit but
happily the Supreme Court has not they
sent me a letter after the original
recommendation for disbarment and said
we know that's just an interim step
thank you for advising us let us know if
they actually take that action but in
the meantime I'm still allowed to
practice before The Supreme Court of the
United States not in the Superior Court
in Los Angeles but I could practice
before The Supreme Court of the United
States cuz they understand what a farce
that bar proceeding has been and uh
hopefully the the appell at courts will
fix fix it I mean I I won't attribute
Kangaroo Court to that uh proceeding but
everybody that watched it was calling it
a kangaroo court and coming up with
memes and all that stuff and I I you
know I think uh if one were to look at
it that might be the conclusion one
would
draw well and and with the Supreme Court
one would think that you know 200
arguments odd arguments being done
probably contribute to your reputation
there yeah now just so I've not argued
200 times but I've been involved in 200
of the cases I just want to correct that
so nobody says fact check oh but uh but
I have argued there uh and uh uh but our
briefs became known for being the best
originalist briefs that the court would
look at I've had several justices tell
me when I see Justice Alo gave a big
speech and said when I see a brief come
in from John Ean and his center for the
Constitutional jurist Prudence it's the
first one I look at because if they want
to understand the history and the
political philosophy that led to those
Clauses to give them meaning um we're
the ones that are are putting that
information before the court well John
Eastman it's such a pleasure to have had
you on thank you thank you so much for
having me and thanks to your audience
for all all that you do by the way if
they can want to watch the the film it's
still available for free streaming at
eastand dilemma. comom
and they can go read more about it at
gend
go.com where we post a lot of
information fantastic thank you thank
you so much
[Music]